User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Offical Thread for Promotion System Changes (Enforcing Level Caps Etc)
Page:
 
VincentJG
offline
Link
 
+1
 
Smokey1913
offline
Link
 
Not Letting This DIE!
 
ilracefan
offline
Link
 
Obviously the powers that be do not agree with enforcing caps, how does a 38 cap team have 80%+ of it's roster at level 42 and above on day 4 of season?? If the Mods can't find teams like this they aren't looking, it took me viewing 1 38cap league to find a team with almost all lvl 42 starters, even with 3 boosts that would only make them level 41.

So will anything ever be done??
 
Myd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ilracefan
Obviously the powers that be do not agree with enforcing caps, how does a 38 cap team have 80%+ of it's roster at level 42 and above on day 4 of season?? If the Mods can't find teams like this they aren't looking, it took me viewing 1 38cap league to find a team with almost all lvl 42 starters, even with 3 boosts that would only make them level 41.

So will anything ever be done??


Some of these questionable teams are owned by the powers that be...
 
GosuPho
offline
Link
 
+1
 
MarBro456
Diamond Cutter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Chysil
the root of the problem is that you promote a certain level of caps irregardless of what your player's levels are. If you are in a 14 cap league, and you are all level 14 at the start, if you don't make the playoffs you are promoted 1 cap (level 18), even though if you boost, all your players will be level 22. That's just crazy to me.

We have elite, competitive and regular leagues now. Why are we still promoting a # of caps based on how well you did?

Why not simply have a team promote into the lowest cap that they fit into. If your highest level player is level 30 than you go to a 32 cap league etc. You still have day 41 to cut people off your roster if you have a few guys that are higher level and would pull you into another cap.

then based on where you finished last season (conf champs vs playoff teams vs bottom of the barrel etc etc) you are placed in whichever league style fits your team (elite, competitive or regular)

it doesn't seem that hard to me...


I like this idea.... it's alot like the one I had earlier:


Originally posted by MarBro456
I had a suggestion that was totaly different than, "Someone is cheating... enforce the rules.....................but it was locked due to this one being endorsed. But..... here was mine:

The current system allows for some leagues to have teams that can be 10+ levels higher than other teams in the league. While some think it is intentional, it isn't always. Some teams have no care about winning in the lower leagues and don't game plan, they just concentrate on building their dots, having losing seasons, and promoting once or not at all. After a few seasons, it leads to a big disadvantage and even not gameplanning they are still too powerful to beat.

System I propose:

Each season when teams move up, put them in the league where their levels fit. Let the promotion be where they go from there, depending on how they did the previous season....... ie...... regular, competitive, or elite..... top playoff teams go to elite, next tier (lower playoff teams and the ones just missing), go to competitive, the teams that do really bad, go to regular.......

From that point, all teams still start where they can be competitive...... Gameplanning, boosting etc. can determine how their season plays out. Also by the point when the teams want to get serious, they'll be at a level where they can truly test their mettle against others.



 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
The system is better, but it still needs some tweaks and I like this last idea.
 
charwh
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MarBro456
I like this idea.... it's alot like the one I had earlier:


Originally posted by MarBro456
I had a suggestion that was totaly different than, "Someone is cheating... enforce the rules.....................but it was locked due to this one being endorsed. But..... here was mine:

The current system allows for some leagues to have teams that can be 10+ levels higher than other teams in the league. While some think it is intentional, it isn't always. Some teams have no care about winning in the lower leagues and don't game plan, they just concentrate on building their dots, having losing seasons, and promoting once or not at all. After a few seasons, it leads to a big disadvantage and even not gameplanning they are still too powerful to beat.

System I propose:

Each season when teams move up, put them in the league where their levels fit. Let the promotion be where they go from there, depending on how they did the previous season....... ie...... regular, competitive, or elite..... top playoff teams go to elite, next tier (lower playoff teams and the ones just missing), go to competitive, the teams that do really bad, go to regular.......

From that point, all teams still start where they can be competitive...... Gameplanning, boosting etc. can determine how their season plays out. Also by the point when the teams want to get serious, they'll be at a level where they can truly test their mettle against others.





The concept is good, but in actual implementation, over 3,000 CPU teams and 120,000 CPU players to fill them, would need to be added to make sure there was always a spot for a team to move into, since you can't always predict if the players will boost or not.

That also means a large number (8-10) CPU teams in each Competitive and Elite league.

In other words, if 64 teams move out of a 32 cap, and 75 teams move into it, you have to add 21 extra CPU teams to make leagues of 32 teams again.

The reason team advancement doesn't care what level your players are, is that the computer needs to know that if 16 teams advance 2 caps out of a league, 16 other teams advance 2 caps back into it, and if 14 teams advance 1 cap out of it, 14 new teams advance 1 cap back into it.

Something needs to happen, but I also understand Admins problem, that it's going to be a tough system to fix. They've already got the simplest system that ensures leagues keep a constant 32 teams, without watering down the competition by making 1/3 of the teams CPU.
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
it may be the simplest way to do things, but it isn't fair to honest gamers. you think i enjoy paying for a game where my honest teams get trounced by a bunch of cheaters gaming the system? just make it a hard level cap and be done with it.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by Clarka3
it may be the simplest way to do things, but it isn't fair to honest gamers. you think i enjoy paying for a game where my honest teams get trounced by a bunch of cheaters gaming the system? just make it a hard level cap and be done with it.



Agreed. I think Chysil's suggestion that I've edited in to the OP is a fantastic way to do things.
 
Savitar
Ghost Recon
offline
Link
 
+3,897,432.53
 
Sprocket
offline
Link
 
What gets me, is right now, I think the Cap-Gaming teams are the majority. Im about ready to sell mine. There isnt any point trying anymore.
 
Clarka3
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sprocket
What gets me, is right now, I think the Cap-Gaming teams are the majority. Im about ready to sell mine. There isnt any point trying anymore.


yep- a sure-fire indicator that the current promotion system is broken. if i hadn't renewed my team ownership for the max i could pay at one time, i'd pack it in.
 
Dr. E
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sprocket
What gets me, is right now, I think the Cap-Gaming teams are the majority. Im about ready to sell mine. There isnt any point trying anymore.


From the leagues I'm associated with, there is less cap exploits this season and those teams that are still managing to play in a league with Dots over the cap are much closer to the cap than in the past. I think the more common exploits are done for and it will work itself out in another season or two.
 
Myd
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Dr. E
From the leagues I'm associated with, there is less cap exploits this season and those teams that are still managing to play in a league with Dots over the cap are much closer to the cap than in the past. I think the more common exploits are done for and it will work itself out in another season or two.


It only takes one or two teams per league to take away the fun for the rest of the teams that play legit.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.