god damnit this whole thread made me stupider
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Tackling: The most useless attribute?
jaxinthebox
offline
offline
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
god damnit this whole thread made me stupider
more stupidest
god damnit this whole thread made me stupider
more stupidest
boondocksaint
offline
offline
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
thanks for your proof.
Dude, there is no "proof". As I mentioned previously, talking about vision/agility/etc. is beyond the point. And that still doesn't change that "superior vision" the SA is not working as it's described. I've had players w/ ~20 in the SA (not even worth it by admin's admission) that still bite on pump fakes/catch fakes regularly. And I'm not talking 50ish base vision, I'm talking 80ish. More relevant to the thread: these players regularly get faked out when trailing the ball carrier, which just blows my mind.
thanks for your proof.
Dude, there is no "proof". As I mentioned previously, talking about vision/agility/etc. is beyond the point. And that still doesn't change that "superior vision" the SA is not working as it's described. I've had players w/ ~20 in the SA (not even worth it by admin's admission) that still bite on pump fakes/catch fakes regularly. And I'm not talking 50ish base vision, I'm talking 80ish. More relevant to the thread: these players regularly get faked out when trailing the ball carrier, which just blows my mind.
jaxinthebox
offline
offline
Originally posted by boondocksaint
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
thanks for your proof.
Dude, there is no "proof". As I mentioned previously, talking about vision/agility/etc. is beyond the point. And that still doesn't change that "superior vision" the SA is not working as it's described. I've had players w/ ~20 in the SA (not even worth it by admin's admission) that still bite on pump fakes/catch fakes regularly. And I'm not talking 50ish base vision, I'm talking 80ish. More relevant to the thread: these players regularly get faked out when trailing the ball carrier, which just blows my mind.
This conversation has nothing to do with the superior vision SA, or fakes. I 'm trying to make a point that a player should not need a ton of strength to tackle a RB with a ton of strength.
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
thanks for your proof.
Dude, there is no "proof". As I mentioned previously, talking about vision/agility/etc. is beyond the point. And that still doesn't change that "superior vision" the SA is not working as it's described. I've had players w/ ~20 in the SA (not even worth it by admin's admission) that still bite on pump fakes/catch fakes regularly. And I'm not talking 50ish base vision, I'm talking 80ish. More relevant to the thread: these players regularly get faked out when trailing the ball carrier, which just blows my mind.
This conversation has nothing to do with the superior vision SA, or fakes. I 'm trying to make a point that a player should not need a ton of strength to tackle a RB with a ton of strength.
Edited by jaxinthebox on May 6, 2010 00:22:40
Veg
offline
offline
Well my CB has missed i think 1 tackle to a non spin this season with 62 str 51 tackle and 2 wrap up tackle. The rest were all spins.
Str/Tkl vs Str/Carry
Thats how i pretty much see it. While not always but in most cases.
Str/Tkl vs Str/Carry
Thats how i pretty much see it. While not always but in most cases.
boondocksaint
offline
offline
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
This conversation has nothing to do with the superior vision SA, or fakes. I 'm trying to make a point that a play should not need a ton of strength to tackle a RB with a ton of strength.
Sorry, you're right. It's not about those things mentioned, though they were brought up. I had the itch to address 'em as I saw 'em
That said, I completely agree with you. My FS comes to mind... better than 60 capped strength, better than 70 capped tackling, and I still can't "count on him" tk make the play. Oh, and he's got 3 different tackling VA's to boot
This conversation has nothing to do with the superior vision SA, or fakes. I 'm trying to make a point that a play should not need a ton of strength to tackle a RB with a ton of strength.
Sorry, you're right. It's not about those things mentioned, though they were brought up. I had the itch to address 'em as I saw 'em

That said, I completely agree with you. My FS comes to mind... better than 60 capped strength, better than 70 capped tackling, and I still can't "count on him" tk make the play. Oh, and he's got 3 different tackling VA's to boot

boondocksaint
offline
offline
Originally posted by Veg
Well my CB has missed i think 1 tackle to a non spin this season with 62 str 51 tackle and 2 wrap up tackle. The rest were all spins.
Str/Tkl vs Str/Carry
Thats how i pretty much see it. While not always but in most cases.
Don't even open the Spin box o_O
Well my CB has missed i think 1 tackle to a non spin this season with 62 str 51 tackle and 2 wrap up tackle. The rest were all spins.
Str/Tkl vs Str/Carry
Thats how i pretty much see it. While not always but in most cases.
Don't even open the Spin box o_O
Veg
offline
offline
Originally posted by boondocksaint
Don't even open the Spin box o_O
lol just saying im not having an issue with tackling other than spins -=P
Don't even open the Spin box o_O
lol just saying im not having an issue with tackling other than spins -=P
Bladnach
offline
offline
Wait. People realize that by the time HBs most often get to CBs, SYM is no longer active, sometimes bruiser not active, CBs are not fighting off blocks as much as Dlineman and LBs, they usually are fresh in terms of stamina/morale for that play while the HB often broke one tackle or spun or something reducing morale/energy, CBs are pretty much always on wrap up while many dlineman/LBs are on power/balanced and usually have a good angle as they're just standing there waiting for the HB instead of havving to take a weird angle.
You can experiment if you want and throw the DTs in the CB slots and then run pitches and see how well the DTs perform out there without SYM-Bruiser-2breaktackle%aeq all stacking together against them. Or more easily accesible if you just put a LB out at the CB spot for a scrim test game (since the LBs are probably fast enough). Then put the CBs on the dline and see how good their tackling skills are. I'd like to see a corner fighting off a OG and C at the same time trying to tackle an HB who is stacking 2aeq, sym and bruiser with the stamina/morale loss that comes from the oline/dline battles
You can experiment if you want and throw the DTs in the CB slots and then run pitches and see how well the DTs perform out there without SYM-Bruiser-2breaktackle%aeq all stacking together against them. Or more easily accesible if you just put a LB out at the CB spot for a scrim test game (since the LBs are probably fast enough). Then put the CBs on the dline and see how good their tackling skills are. I'd like to see a corner fighting off a OG and C at the same time trying to tackle an HB who is stacking 2aeq, sym and bruiser with the stamina/morale loss that comes from the oline/dline battles
Edited by chronoaug on May 6, 2010 01:04:48
Edited by chronoaug on May 6, 2010 01:04:21
shield.bearer
offline
offline
Originally posted by xsujx
Umm, no.
absolutely yes. Anything that increases the tackling radius will also increase missed tackles. It's just simple common sense. If you attempt more tackles at the extreme edge of a larger radius, you will miss more.
Umm, no.
absolutely yes. Anything that increases the tackling radius will also increase missed tackles. It's just simple common sense. If you attempt more tackles at the extreme edge of a larger radius, you will miss more.
Bladnach
offline
offline
Originally posted by shield.bearer
Originally posted by xsujx
Umm, no.
absolutely yes. Anything that increases the tackling radius will also increase missed tackles. It's just simple common sense. If you attempt more tackles at the extreme edge of a larger radius, you will miss more.
Yea, i've thought this for awhile too. I would hope that there are multiple rings in the big radius with each one going away from the center decreasing the % to attempt the tackle and the % to make it. It's probably a bit more crude and simple than that though
Originally posted by xsujx
Umm, no.
absolutely yes. Anything that increases the tackling radius will also increase missed tackles. It's just simple common sense. If you attempt more tackles at the extreme edge of a larger radius, you will miss more.
Yea, i've thought this for awhile too. I would hope that there are multiple rings in the big radius with each one going away from the center decreasing the % to attempt the tackle and the % to make it. It's probably a bit more crude and simple than that though
shield.bearer
offline
offline
Originally posted by jaxinthebox
Well, that's the easy way to end a conversation I guess....
Status quo...as is.
A Well-built DB with superior Vision/Tackling should be able to tackle a Strength/Carrying Powerback at least 50% of the time.
well, 3 out of 7 is 1 less than 50%. Maybe if his incredible Vision had put in position one more time you would have gotten your wish...
Well, that's the easy way to end a conversation I guess....
Status quo...as is.
A Well-built DB with superior Vision/Tackling should be able to tackle a Strength/Carrying Powerback at least 50% of the time.
well, 3 out of 7 is 1 less than 50%. Maybe if his incredible Vision had put in position one more time you would have gotten your wish...
Rage Kinard
offline
offline
My DT in a Pro league with 42 tackling has made 45 tackles (after subtracting the 10 sacks from 55) and missed 16. He also has 16 TFLs.
2 games were against non competitive teams and he had 11 of his non sack tackles and 5 of his TFLs in those games
So in other games
34 tackles, 16 missed, 11 TFLs
Another DT on the same team with 80 tackling has 38 tackles, 16 missed, and 9 TFLs. In competitive games it is 29 tackles, 15 missed, 6 TFLs.
Why in the world would I want to invest heavily in tackling for a DT?
2 games were against non competitive teams and he had 11 of his non sack tackles and 5 of his TFLs in those games
So in other games
34 tackles, 16 missed, 11 TFLs
Another DT on the same team with 80 tackling has 38 tackles, 16 missed, and 9 TFLs. In competitive games it is 29 tackles, 15 missed, 6 TFLs.
Why in the world would I want to invest heavily in tackling for a DT?
5STAR
offline
offline
Originally posted by 5STAR
tackling is worthless...48 is the most anyone needs
this is the bible...live by it

tackling is worthless...48 is the most anyone needs
this is the bible...live by it

j10er
offline
offline
Tackling is useful for making tackles, forcing fumbles and for knocking loose passes.
Unless you'll be doing 2 out of those 3 on a regular basis (3 out of 3 would be ideal), Tackling is fairly worthless.
It's useful for some LBs, hard-hitting SSes and STOP players that are FF machines. That's really about it, isn't it?
Seems like a poorly designed attribute.
It's much better to increase Vision, which helps with all of the same things Tackling does (PDs more than KLs, though) and even more, to boot.
Unless you'll be doing 2 out of those 3 on a regular basis (3 out of 3 would be ideal), Tackling is fairly worthless.
It's useful for some LBs, hard-hitting SSes and STOP players that are FF machines. That's really about it, isn't it?
Seems like a poorly designed attribute.
It's much better to increase Vision, which helps with all of the same things Tackling does (PDs more than KLs, though) and even more, to boot.
Edited by j10er on May 6, 2010 06:01:47
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.



























