User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Why the hell should I HAVE to remember to have my Punter return kicks against gutjobs?!?
Page:
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
To add to this,

Right after playoffs and off season, definitely definitely definitely get rid of all the gutted teams, force promotion, all that, 100% in favor of it,

BUT, give me a realistic measure to say that on Day -8 or Day 1, that I can't gut Medellin in someway



1) You can't sell the team between team Re-Org and Day 40.
2) you can hit 'Sell' during the season and it will sell the next avail. time.
3) On Team re-org, Deduct 40 days from team ownership.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
It is not impossible, it is just something that Bort has no desire to address with a penalty for doing it. Big difference.


Like I said, give me some measures as to how to prevent teams from gutting.
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
Originally posted by r87

It's very easy to tell. A full roster of slow built 45+ is about the lowest you can be and have a chance to stay competitive in the pros. By the end of the season they will be 50.

Alternatively, add a "flagging" system. Team owners can flag gutted teams in their leagues, and support will check it out and drop them to an appropriate cap. God help you if you report someone that isn't gutted.


When does this happen? Day 41, when teams just lost their free agents? Day -X, when promotions have been done for a while and everyone is planning out how the league will fall?

Or does it happen after the team has ruined the league for a season, and would request a drop down anyway?


This problem is in relation to teams that refuse to request demotions, and just drift through the pro/AAA/AA caps season after season.

A team average would not fall because they lost players to free agency. This would likely have to be done after promotions/demotions and before the end of the season...
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Adderfist

1) You can't sell the team between team Re-Org and Day 40.
2) you can hit 'Sell' during the season and it will sell the next avail. time.
3) On Team re-org, Deduct 40 days from team ownership.


Not a problem,

TRADE PLAYERS FOR CASH, RELEASE PLAYERS AS WE GO ALONG FROM DAY 1,

Gonna prevent that too?
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
Originally posted by r87

As sjmay just pointed out, it is impossible to do anything about mid-season guts.


It is not impossible, it is just something that Bort has no desire to address with a penalty for doing it. Big difference.


It's impossible.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Not a problem,

TRADE PLAYERS FOR CASH, RELEASE PLAYERS AS WE GO ALONG FROM DAY 1,

Gonna prevent that too?


You also forgot "play offense on defense and vice versa" for lulz
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
As sjmay just pointed out, it is impossible to do anything about mid-season guts.


Very true. But it should be possible to do something about END-season guts and PRE-season guts.

It should DEFINITELY be possible to do something about TWO-season guts.

Right now, all of those are being ignored. A team owner can intentionally gut his team the INSTANT he gets promoted to Pro, keep it gutted, and slowly glide back down to AAA, then down to AA, then finally back down to minors over the next 3 seasons, cashing in on 3 seasons' worth of high-league cash along the way. That's clearly what the Winnipeg Wrath are doing.

Hell, add World League to the top of that, and a team owner could do this for *4* seasons.

That should not be allowed. Period.

And yet it is.

Why is that?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
You also forgot "play offense on defense and vice versa" for lulz


LOL true, but not really a component of a true gut job I thought.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Novus
Very true. But it should be possible to do something about END-season guts and PRE-season guts.

It should DEFINITELY be possible to do something about TWO-season guts.

Right now, all of those are being ignored. A team owner can intentionally gut his team the INSTANT he gets promoted to Pro, keep it gutted, and slowly glide back down to AAA, then down to AA, then finally back down to minors over the next 3 seasons, cashing in on 3 seasons' worth of high-league cash along the way. That's clearly what the Winnipeg Wrath are doing.

Hell, add World League to the top of that, and a team owner could do this for *4* seasons.

That should not be allowed. Period.

And yet it is.

Why is that?


Like I said, I definitely agree with that, the problem is, you will still have some major asshat, that wants to screw with everyone, so he waits until Day 1, and starts a slow gut
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by foofighter24

It is not impossible, it is just something that Bort has no desire to address with a penalty for doing it. Big difference.


Like I said, give me some measures as to how to prevent teams from gutting.


In season, you can certainly limit player movement to 10 players. Allowing somone to gut their roster via cuts or cash trades is easily preventable.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
In season, you can certainly limit player movement to 10 players. Allowing somone to gut their roster via cuts or cash trades is easily preventable.


Only if you severely hamper player movement,

You really want to prevent player movement in a football sim where recruiting/teams are a MAJOR part of the game?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by foofighter24
In season, you can certainly limit player movement to 10 players. Allowing somone to gut their roster via cuts or cash trades is easily preventable.


By the way, it doesn't have to be cash trades,


I trade my LVL 70 QB for your LVL 30 QB, and LVL 26 WR

I trade my LVL 65 HB for your LVL 34 HB and LVL 25 OG,

etc, so on and so forth.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Smaller roster limit + everyone gets max xp IMO. If you have 45 players and you don't play backups you're fucked, but I do think you can get away with it with 55 guys.
 
Novus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Like I said, I definitely agree with that, the problem is, you will still have some major asshat, that wants to screw with everyone, so he waits until Day 1, and starts a slow gut


But at least he can only do it for 1 season. Right now, he can do it for 4 seasons. That's an improvement.




Also, keep in mind that it's also impossible for the police to stop me from going to my next door neighbor's house and killing him with a butcher knife right now. But the police CAN arrest me for it afterward and punish me for my crime... which makes me think twice about committing that murder in the first place.

If you knew that gutting your team on Day 1 could mean getting banned from the game with no refund, would you still do it? A few people still would: we call them "assholes." But a lot of the other people who are doing Day-1 gutjobs right now would think twice about it, and you'd cut way down on the number of Day-1 gutjobs.

You can't prevent Day-1 gutjobs entirely. But there are plenty of feasible ways to cut WAY down on the number of them.
Edited by Novus on Dec 13, 2009 17:09:47
 
foofighter24
jumpin da snark
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by foofighter24

In season, you can certainly limit player movement to 10 players. Allowing somone to gut their roster via cuts or cash trades is easily preventable.


By the way, it doesn't have to be cash trades,


I trade my LVL 70 QB for your LVL 30 QB, and LVL 26 WR

I trade my LVL 65 HB for your LVL 34 HB and LVL 25 OG,

etc, so on and so forth.


And that is easily handled by using league minimums for trades.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.