Originally posted by Bort
Ok, so here's a positive reinforcement idea instead of level caps, to "encourage" parity instead of force it. This has been brought up before, but I'm posting it here for further review:
(note this is in "suggestions," not "announcements")
Power gamers and those looking for loopholes to pwning n00bs care about one thing: XP. They want to be uber player, gain the max XP possible, and look at their pretty attributes.
1) For every game you play, the experience an individual player gains is modified based on the levels of your opponents (or of the league) compared to your own, with say, up to a 15% modifier.
2) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's around the same level as you, you get the same XP as you get now.
3) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's better than you, you get an XP bonus.
4) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's worse than you, you get less XP.
Levels could be based on:
1) The average level of the other team, weighted toward starters. A "better" team would be one that was, say, 3 levels higher than you on average. And worse, would be say, 3 levels lower (could be 4/5, dunno).
2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg.
Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits?
I've seen the arguments against this, and I think most of them are very weak.
"So I'm punished for being better than the other players because too many bad teams are in my league?" Yes! Go find a better league!
The one with some merit is that I hate to break teams up, plus you addressed another in your post, of having some flexibility.
So, for the "par" level, I'd suggest using the 70th percentile of the players who saw at least 20 snaps that game day among teams in the league. So you're comparing with the better players in the league, overall.
It's the higher of the two, so if one weak you face an unusually bad team, you don't get punished.
If your player is above that level, there's a 10% cushion (if the 70th percentile is 15, then up to 16.5 you'd be without penalty), but then for every extra level above that you get 1% less exp, maxed at a 15% penalty. So, a level 26 (they don't exist yet, but soon will) player sandbagging in that league would get 9.5% less experience, which is IMO too small a punishment for a pro playing college kids, but would likely be enough.
To help keep teams together, the "fudge factor" for higher levels could be tripled to 30% for players who have been with their team for at least one full season previously. The hypothetical level 15 league would then not punish until 19.5, and, say, Level 20's would only have a miniscule 0.5% punishment. Remember, that's 30% above the more than 2/3 of the used players in the league before any penalties.
If a player is more than 10% below the number, he gains an extra 1% experience for each additional level he's below the number (10% below 15 being 13.5, a Level 6 would get 7.5% more experience for the game).
I also think bonuses and penalties for league level (could be just bonuses for already-existing leagues, with penalties as lower leagues are added) could work, but ideally as an addition, not the whole thing, and must be strong to stratify the levels:
Pro: +12%
AAA: +9%
AA: +6%
A: +3%
BBB: +0%
When BB and B exist, they'd be -3% and -6% respectively.
Yes, this is meant to bring about some intra-divisional parity. Combining these ideas, you'd get it. And Bort, to people who want to play in too-low divisions to dominate them, you have to put your foot down and say, "No, you will be penalized, for the sake of fairness."