User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > XP bonus for playing at or above your level
Page:
 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Instead of whole team v. whole team for averages, why not the higher of the sum levels of the top few offensive & defensive players (five, maybe)? Take the top five offensive players, the top five defensive players, add their levels together to get a number and that number's the one you use to determine average team quality.

Eliminates the ability to create & sign a bunch of level 1s to sit on the bench for minimum salaries to drop your average level to within tolerances.


Same problem again, as I just stated in my previous post.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, so here's a positive reinforcement idea instead of level caps, to "encourage" parity instead of force it. This has been brought up before, but I'm posting it here for further review:

(note this is in "suggestions," not "announcements")

Power gamers and those looking for loopholes to pwning n00bs care about one thing: XP. They want to be uber player, gain the max XP possible, and look at their pretty attributes.

1) For every game you play, the experience an individual player gains is modified based on the levels of your opponents (or of the league) compared to your own, with say, up to a 15% modifier.

2) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's around the same level as you, you get the same XP as you get now.

3) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's better than you, you get an XP bonus.

4) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's worse than you, you get less XP.

Levels could be based on:
1) The average level of the other team, weighted toward starters. A "better" team would be one that was, say, 3 levels higher than you on average. And worse, would be say, 3 levels lower (could be 4/5, dunno).
2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits?


You HAVE to blow up the leagues and realign by level if you do this. I shouldn't be forced to take less XP at a Pro or AAA level because there are too many crappy teams to be relegated in a single season.
 
drifter
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Originally posted by James1985

I dont like it you punish good team and reward bad ones.

After a few Seasons the best teams will be together threw moving up or down in Leagues.

It will take time just let it do its work.

All players no matter the level the competition or the league should earn XP the same way.

My Vote for XP based on level
100% no


It isn't punishing teams...just players that are completely out of their level. For example if a BBB league had an average level of 10, and signed a player who was level 18, that one player on the team would get less XP than if he'd just signed one level up where the average was 13 or 14.

It makes sense. The rest of his team still gets all their XP, it just lowers the incentive for a Lv18 to sign in a low level league. If he does, the rest of the league (including his teammates) will catch him quicker than they would've without this penalty.

If he wants to stay ahead of lower level players all he has to do is head to the appropriate league level.




THe problem is that there are bad teams at good levels. Based on the "highest level" leagues post the other day, AAA#2 is #4 IIRC with an average level of 14.xx The best teams in the league are more like 18.xx. Why should the best teams in the 4th hardest league in the game be punished because there's so many bad teams in ALL of the leagues that the average level is 14? Unless the leagues are blown up and realigned for more parity, this is an awful idea. If that happens it might have merit.
Last edited Jun 6, 2008 22:36:23
 
LithoMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
Also, maybe boost the minimum salary & signing bonus offers for the low level teams when they sign above the averages?

I hate using real-world analogies, but:
I don't think any top-tier NFL players will be playing Arena Football any time soon, but if the Arena leagues offered 2-3x as much money as the NFL was they'd change their tune pretty quickly, aye?


See, 1/3 the seating capacity * half the ticket price = 1/6 of NFL salaries for AFL. Seems about right.
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Option 1: because that's an oppoment related thing and not a league related bonus.

SO we must compare the 2 teams.

Being a low level team against better team, i agree. That will hurt a lot high level team and they surely will fight a lot to be promoted! It's a side effect very attractive! No more team who don't play the playoff because it's better crushing teams whole season long
 
TehKyou
offline
Link
 
What? Accusing me of liking this idea because my team moved into a league with an average 2 level advantage on us? NEVER!


Make it happen Bort!
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
10 seasons from now, all of the existing leagues are going to have same level players anyway.

If you are promoting and demoting teams, it doesn't make sense to force promotion and demotion of players as well. Especially not with the way chemistry works, and with the fact that teams want to stick together. Why punish a high-level team that doesn't win the championship and is stuck in a low league? They obviously weren't so much better than everyone that they dominated their way through the league. They didn't even WIN the league. Let the season play out naturally.

If the problem is simply that high-level players are dropping down to new leagues to dominate, then simply eliminate that. No players higher than level 10 can be signed to new leagues. Done. To hell with the whiners.

If the problem is that you want the talent levels in the leagues to match the pyramid system, the solutions are completely different from what we are considering now. And in none of these solutions will team promotion and relegation work. And all of these things will anger Owners and GMs. I personally don't like them:

1. Have ten tiers, with players joining each league for one season before getting drafted (or going into FA) into the next level. Or have 5 tiers with 2 seasons in each level. Or some other combination: 1 year in the "development" leagues, 4 years in the "college" leagues, and 6 years in the "pro" leagues. No team promotion or relegation.

2. Hard level limits on players. It's the most hated idea out there, but if you want a pyramid talent scheme, this is the best way. Player level freezes when they reach the cap of the league until they sign into a higher league. No promotion or relegation.

3. Reorganize the leagues every offseason based upon team level. Another horrible idea, but it will keep the pyramid illusion alive.

In reality, there is no good way to enforce a pyramid talent scheme, so just straight up block the new league abuse directly rather than designing a hundred more complex algorithms that will make the game worse.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Ok, so here's a positive reinforcement idea instead of level caps, to "encourage" parity instead of force it. This has been brought up before, but I'm posting it here for further review:

(note this is in "suggestions," not "announcements")

Power gamers and those looking for loopholes to pwning n00bs care about one thing: XP. They want to be uber player, gain the max XP possible, and look at their pretty attributes.

1) For every game you play, the experience an individual player gains is modified based on the levels of your opponents (or of the league) compared to your own, with say, up to a 15% modifier.

2) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's around the same level as you, you get the same XP as you get now.

3) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's better than you, you get an XP bonus.

4) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's worse than you, you get less XP.

Levels could be based on:
1) The average level of the other team, weighted toward starters. A "better" team would be one that was, say, 3 levels higher than you on average. And worse, would be say, 3 levels lower (could be 4/5, dunno).
2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits?


I've seen the arguments against this, and I think most of them are very weak.

"So I'm punished for being better than the other players because too many bad teams are in my league?" Yes! Go find a better league!

The one with some merit is that I hate to break teams up, plus you addressed another in your post, of having some flexibility.

So, for the "par" level, I'd suggest using the 70th percentile of the players who saw at least 20 snaps that game day among teams in the league. So you're comparing with the better players in the league, overall.

It's the higher of the two, so if one weak you face an unusually bad team, you don't get punished.

If your player is above that level, there's a 10% cushion (if the 70th percentile is 15, then up to 16.5 you'd be without penalty), but then for every extra level above that you get 1% less exp, maxed at a 15% penalty. So, a level 26 (they don't exist yet, but soon will) player sandbagging in that league would get 9.5% less experience, which is IMO too small a punishment for a pro playing college kids, but would likely be enough.

To help keep teams together, the "fudge factor" for higher levels could be tripled to 30% for players who have been with their team for at least one full season previously. The hypothetical level 15 league would then not punish until 19.5, and, say, Level 20's would only have a miniscule 0.5% punishment. Remember, that's 30% above the more than 2/3 of the used players in the league before any penalties.

If a player is more than 10% below the number, he gains an extra 1% experience for each additional level he's below the number (10% below 15 being 13.5, a Level 6 would get 7.5% more experience for the game).

I also think bonuses and penalties for league level (could be just bonuses for already-existing leagues, with penalties as lower leagues are added) could work, but ideally as an addition, not the whole thing, and must be strong to stratify the levels:

Pro: +12%
AAA: +9%
AA: +6%
A: +3%
BBB: +0%

When BB and B exist, they'd be -3% and -6% respectively.

Yes, this is meant to bring about some intra-divisional parity. Combining these ideas, you'd get it. And Bort, to people who want to play in too-low divisions to dominate them, you have to put your foot down and say, "No, you will be penalized, for the sake of fairness."
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
10 seasons from now, all of the existing leagues are going to have same level players anyway.

If you are promoting and demoting teams, it doesn't make sense to force promotion and demotion of players as well. Especially not with the way chemistry works, and with the fact that teams want to stick together. Why punish a high-level team that doesn't win the championship and is stuck in a low league? They obviously weren't so much better than everyone that they dominated their way through the league. They didn't even WIN the league. Let the season play out naturally.

If the problem is simply that high-level players are dropping down to new leagues to dominate, then simply eliminate that. No players higher than level 10 can be signed to new leagues. Done. To hell with the whiners.

If the problem is that you want the talent levels in the leagues to match the pyramid system, the solutions are completely different from what we are considering now. And in none of these solutions will team promotion and relegation work. And all of these things will anger Owners and GMs. I personally don't like them:

1. Have ten tiers, with players joining each league for one season before getting drafted (or going into FA) into the next level. Or have 5 tiers with 2 seasons in each level. Or some other combination: 1 year in the "development" leagues, 4 years in the "college" leagues, and 6 years in the "pro" leagues. No team promotion or relegation.

2. Hard level limits on players. It's the most hated idea out there, but if you want a pyramid talent scheme, this is the best way. Player level freezes when they reach the cap of the league until they sign into a higher league. No promotion or relegation.

3. Reorganize the leagues every offseason based upon team level. Another horrible idea, but it will keep the pyramid illusion alive.

In reality, there is no good way to enforce a pyramid talent scheme, so just straight up block the new league abuse directly rather than designing a hundred more complex algorithms that will make the game worse.


Some awful ideas here. We need incentives, and some incentives to keep teams together.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drifter
Originally posted by Bort

Ok, so here's a positive reinforcement idea instead of level caps, to "encourage" parity instead of force it. This has been brought up before, but I'm posting it here for further review:

(note this is in "suggestions," not "announcements")

Power gamers and those looking for loopholes to pwning n00bs care about one thing: XP. They want to be uber player, gain the max XP possible, and look at their pretty attributes.

1) For every game you play, the experience an individual player gains is modified based on the levels of your opponents (or of the league) compared to your own, with say, up to a 15% modifier.

2) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's around the same level as you, you get the same XP as you get now.

3) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's better than you, you get an XP bonus.

4) If you play a team or at a level (see two options below) that's worse than you, you get less XP.

Levels could be based on:
1) The average level of the other team, weighted toward starters. A "better" team would be one that was, say, 3 levels higher than you on average. And worse, would be say, 3 levels lower (could be 4/5, dunno).
2) Or, the average level of the league, weighted towards the top. You get a bonus for being below the avg.

Shoot holes in it! What are the exploits?


You HAVE to blow up the leagues and realign by level if you do this. I shouldn't be forced to take less XP at a Pro or AAA level because there are too many crappy teams to be relegated in a single season.


Okay, so use the 70th percentile of used (>20 snaps players) in a league, rather than the individual team. So if you're in a talented league, it won't hurt you if you play a crappy team a given week.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by James1985
I dont like it you punish good team and reward bad ones.

After a few Seasons the best teams will be together threw moving up or down in Leagues.

It will take time just let it do its work.

100% no


No, because they'll eventually add BB leagues and someone will bring in his Level 25 (then) players and get his friends to bring them in and destroy the competition.

Penalize those players. Hard.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by James1985

I dont like it you punish good team and reward bad ones.

After a few Seasons the best teams will be together threw moving up or down in Leagues.

It will take time just let it do its work.

100% no


No, because they'll eventually add BB leagues and someone will bring in his Level 25 (then) players and get his friends to bring them in and destroy the competition.

Penalize those players. Hard.


No. Don't penalize these players by creating an algorithm that effects EVERYONE.

Simply block this from happening to begin with.

Problem solved.

All of these stupid parity algorithms will ruin the game.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by thunderdoozer
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by James1985


I dont like it you punish good team and reward bad ones.

After a few Seasons the best teams will be together threw moving up or down in Leagues.

It will take time just let it do its work.

100% no


No, because they'll eventually add BB leagues and someone will bring in his Level 25 (then) players and get his friends to bring them in and destroy the competition.

Penalize those players. Hard.


No. Don't penalize these players by creating an algorithm that effects EVERYONE.

Simply block this from happening to begin with.

Problem solved.

All of these stupid parity algorithms will ruin the game.


No, all the ringers and 118-0 games would ruin it first.

Parity should be a goal, without forcing people to play where they don't want to but incentivizing them to play where it's fair for them to play.
 
ozzfan1317
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by madet0rder
Yeah i definitely like those, except 5 and 6. I think for doing that, it should be based on the individual you are facing. However, if you are someone that doesnt have a set opponent, then base it on the average of the guys that you are going against.


I agree I think That would be the best way of doing it.

 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
This would be viable if there were more than 1 team per conference promoted.

The way it is now, you're stuck with menial competition? Get a menial team.

Ideally, as Serenity said, a small XP boost for playing better opponents with no XP penalty for playing worse ones would be good.

The fact is that the Silverymoon Elves had two players leave, and two players join (or something to that extent). Continuity should be rewarded, not punished.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.