User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Coaches - Item Crafting
Page:
 
Cronus6
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Troymk1
We are in complete agreement there.

So why would they need a shot in the arm to artificially keep them in place?

I really think you should read what YOU YOURSELF write before answering my posts. It seems to me you're making better points for my own argument than I do myself.



I'm fully aware that we agree on some issues.

But "one coach per team in the first season" is a BAD idea. At that rate it will take 10 seasons before we see coaches on lower tier teams.

Look it's like this, my first coach is either going to the team he's currently on, or I'll wait until there's an opening.
Don't think that your idea of capping the the number of coaches will force me to go to some random team.
I don't sign players to random teams and I won't sign coaches either. I'll just create him and let him sit until I can put him on the team I want. And yes, that team is USAPro.
 
MTDewJoe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
One of the ideas brought up last night was the ability to have coaches create items.


Uh no. This is one of the strangest ideas for a football "sim" I've run across. Maybe players can have mana points so they can cast spells too
 
madmal
Prez SWO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
I love this idea since it gives the coach something to do. I have a feeling the coaches will be very popular for a couple seasons just because they are new and we all have to play with the new toys. I am not sure how many coaches will grow old as I bet they might become boring fast without some kind of personal payoff.

I know there are lots of team players in GLB who will gladly make coaches. Still I wonder if that will be enough to keep a steady flow of coaches every season.


+1,000
 
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
Link
 
I'd think every type of coach should have its own thread in suggestions that should be stickied to open the floor up to us...It would give us a better idea of the coaching idea that is going to be implemented as well as allow us, the users, to give input and feedback on the ideas...
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by AngryDragon
I think it would be cool if all coaches could craft items but the ones who specialize in crafting should make the best items. That way all coaches would have something fun to do. They may also decide to change directions or career paths if that is even possible.

I guess I cannot see the big picture yet so there may be other fun things for the coaches to do that I am not aware of.


All coaches could craft items if they choose the skills to do so. Seriously, read drifter's suggestion. There lots of gameplanning type stuff they can do also based on his idea. Coaches will also be able to give temp bonuses to players, improve their morale, and other stuff.
 
SikoraP13 DTD
offline
Link
 
Bort, can you give us a list of the confirmed coaching archetypes and what they do/what bonuses they will have?
Edited by SikoraP13 on Sep 5, 2009 15:51:48
 
Troymk1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cronus6

I'm fully aware that we agree on some issues.

But "one coach per team in the first season" is a BAD idea. At that rate it will take 10 seasons before we see coaches on lower tier teams.

Look it's like this, my first coach is either going to the team he's currently on, or I'll wait until there's an opening.
Don't think that your idea of capping the the number of coaches will force me to go to some random team.
I don't sign players to random teams and I won't sign coaches either. I'll just create him and let him sit until I can put him on the team I want. And yes, that team is USAPro.


Ugh!!

First season of implementation of almost any new THING needs a limited roll out.

There will be bugs.

Who knows that better than GLB eh?

And your own predisposition towards an advanced Team you GM seemingly invalidates everything you've posted here.

Informed debate is usually not conducted by those with vested interests. Sorry but that's true, and obviously so.

Edited by Troymk1 on Sep 5, 2009 15:55:16
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman
An idea I had for coaching in general, posting it here because Bort will read it...

A few pages back, there was a minor controversy about coaches needing a minimum level, proving that they boosted during their career, and others disagreed. Why not make it so that player level at retirement corresponds to beginning coaching level? If someone plays 11 seasons and retires but is somehow only level 37, they start out at level 1. Someone else retires their coach at level 64, their coach starts out at level 4. You can't have the bonus levels be too large (since that will make the first gen coaches who used early XP bugs a big advantage), but having something there rewards boosting throughout your entire career, creates a bit of stratification between the first generation coaches, and punishes super slowbuilders while not being completely oppressive.


Hm. That is an interesting idea to reward boosters. Basically the coach would have 2 or 3 free boosts if he were high enough level?
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SikoraP13
Bort, can you give us a list of the confirmed coaching archetypes and what they do/what bonuses they will have?


I will create another thread in a bit with sort of a compiled coach thing.
 
madmal
Prez SWO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by DAWG
What actually benefits will a player get for keeping his player alive and will he be able to boost his coaching abilities?Can he be a player/coach for 1-2 seasons and will that negate his decline?


Player/Coach is a great idea. Otherwise what fun is it for an agent to have a player as a Coach????????????????
 
r87
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by madmal
Originally posted by DAWG

What actually benefits will a player get for keeping his player alive and will he be able to boost his coaching abilities?Can he be a player/coach for 1-2 seasons and will that negate his decline?


Player/Coach is a great idea. Otherwise what fun is it for an agent to have a player as a Coach????????????????


Helping your team 0_o
 
madmal
Prez SWO
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Helping your team o_O


Not very tangible.
 
Troymk1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by r87
Helping your team o_O


A ton of people will do this for the right owner.

OR for the prestige of being a coach on a PRO franchise
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I will create another thread in a bit with sort of a compiled coach thing.


Created. Very tl;dr:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=3229435
 
BP
offline
Link
 
I'm personally not a big fan of the concept. I understand it'll give season 1 players yet another reason to not retire their players...and that it will give them some value other then just the Mentor VA.

I think it's going to be a fairly closed system, especially if there is a limit to how many pieces a EQ manager or coach can make.

Basically people are going to bring their own lvl 70 players onto teams with their own dots and make themselves equipment...that's how I'd honestly see that going.

I think a better concept would be to have Coaches be able to modify training %'s for his group of players. Based on his personal attributes and what he worked on..it could be a modifier when the group of players that he is coaching trains on them.

Your Coach for the WR is a burner with 96 natural speed...so when your WR train speed they get an extra 9.6% bump every time they train. Your DE mentor is a Strength guy...with 85 natural strength..so when your DE's train strength they get an extra 8.5% training gain.

That makes much more sense to me, BP, as a value add the coaches can bring with them..much simpler and helps out every player in the group that coach is working with. Otherwise..yeah,

Dude -"Hey buddy, come over and mentor my WR's and make my WR a sick piece"
Buddy - "Ok dude, only if you bring your DE over to my squad and make my DE a piece"
Dude - "damn buddy, can't do..I'm brining my lvl 70 DE over to another squad to make my personal 50 DE a piece..sorry"

That's what you'll see Bort. Just a way for vets to make their younger dots pieces...
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.