User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Someone give me cliffs on the weight fix
Page:
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
9 pages of cliffs, impressive.


compared to the original thread closing in on 90 pages...I guess it still kinda is.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by taurran
Yes, it's a vague word that doesn't explain much.

Exactly like 95% of the information on this website.


Oh shit, here's a baby to kill, I had an extra one.
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
R-Tick-Tock to the STOP, STOP,

Come inside, take off your clothes, I'll make you feel at home.
 
valakar
offline
Link
 
I normally do not comment a whole lot on the public boards but I am personally saying thank you to PT for bringing issues to light. I have invested a large sum of money into this game and have always wondered why some of my players perform better then others (built the same time and same way) and always believed in the x-factor or whatever is causing such differences. Glad to see fixes coming but like PT said should not take seasons and blatent discussion to get them implemented or addressed.
 
Link
 
My understanding:

- Bort has said that he has never intentionally coded a permanent attribute for players determining performance
- Essentially, it was proven that two players with completely equal attributes can perform very differently. Some players get a massive speed boost for no apparent reason
- You can have one receiver with lower overall attributes AND less stamina, and he can be faster than a receiver with full stamina and higher attributes
- It's been called the "x-factor" for several seasons, and now with speed scripts has been mathematically proven
- Bort's change today is apparently in response to the mounting pressure of this evidence
- It's not really known how long he's known about the error (some type of data transmission error), but he hasn't really been forthcoming about X-factor, what this bug is, what the fix actually did, etc.

THIS MEANS:

- Your good players may have been good because they were bugged
- Some of your under performing players may have sucked due to being bugged as well
- Successful players whose builds you've tried to emulate may have been successful primarily because of bugs and not because of build
- You don't know which of your players were affected unless you figure out a way to test a ton of replays, which takes a while
- Your players may not be who you think they are.
- Gameplanning, scouting, etc needs to be adjusted around these X-factor bug players, who are typically the stars of teams

QUESTIONS:

- How long has this bug been known for?
- Why is the changelog language vague and cryptic?
- Why has there been no public apology and thank you to the discoverers of the issue?
- We haven't been getting what we've paid for, apparently. A bug is a bug, sh!t happens. But be forthcoming.
- What players were affected? Should I expect different performance out of my players now?
- Didn't I pay for a game where I have complete control over my players, teams, and strategies?
- Why did it take so long for this issue to be addressed? Surely those behind the scenes could see the broken strings when those of us on the other side of the curtain noticed player performance issues for a long time AND pointed it out.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
pretty good ^^^^^
 
MikeJ
offline
Link
 
Nice summary, bovine.

"Why has there been no public apology and thank you to the discoverers of the issue?"

This is something I'd very much like to know, as well. Bort must be hoping that this will fly under the radar for most people - I can't see any other reason for the complete lack of transparency here. He's not doing much for his reputation.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MikeJ
Nice summary, bovine.

"Why has there been no public apology and thank you to the discoverers of the issue?"

This is something I'd very much like to know, as well. Bort must be hoping that this will fly under the radar for most people - I can't see any other reason for the complete lack of transparency here. He's not doing much for his reputation.


because IF there are hidden attributes/X-Factor so to speak (note I said IF) intentionally in the game, and Bort admitted to this....his flex sales would drop through the floor. He would be much better served (if it exists and he KNOWS it does) by stealth removing it and denying it ever existed.
Edited by islander1 on Sep 2, 2009 13:29:50
 
NiborRis
offline
Link
 
oddly enough, all the people who screamed "height/weight is the x-factor" were sort of right, too.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bovineblitzkrieg
QUESTIONS:

1) How long has this bug been known for?
2) Why is the changelog language vague and cryptic?
3) Why has there been no public apology and thank you to the discoverers of the issue?
3a) We haven't been getting what we've paid for, apparently. A bug is a bug, sh!t happens. But be forthcoming.
4) What players were affected? Should I expect different performance out of my players now?
5) Didn't I pay for a game where I have complete control over my players, teams, and strategies?
6) Why did it take so long for this issue to be addressed? Surely those behind the scenes could see the broken strings when those of us on the other side of the curtain noticed player performance issues for a long time AND pointed it out.


1) When Deathblade showed him the evidence yesterday, he seemed to not know of it being a bug till that point.
2) Because it's not necessarily a change which will fix anything, so he didn't want to focus attention on what it might solve, only what happened and what it might do.
3) Have you ever seen this for any bug fix, ever?
3a) Beta. You've been getting exactly what you paid for.
4) Don't know yet. Won't really know till the exact problem is definitively nailed down and fixed, which we won't know much more about until tomorrow's games (since the players who were used as testing to show this problem don't play till tomorrow)
5) There's been die rolls and randomness built into the sim since day 1. So if anything that varies even slightly from your stats vs the opponents' stats means you don't have completely control, then that's not something new. So no, you didn't.
6) Because it got lost in the sea of "WAAAAAAAAH MY PLAYER SUCKS AND IT'S NOT MY FAULT" that goes on around here. It took more solid evidence to pick that out of the crowd. Obviously, it wasn't noticed until now since nothing was even being looked at as a fix until now.
Edited by Jed on Sep 2, 2009 13:49:56
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jed

3a) Beta. You've been getting exactly what you paid for.


This is why we hate you so much.
 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Krunchy
This is why we hate you so much.


c[_]
 
firehazard
offline
Link
 
You don't pay for betas. This is not a true beta.
 
Krunchy
offline
Link
 
It would be a fun experiment to try and calculate how much business Bort has lost from its mouthy moderators.
 
Vagrant God
offline
Link
 
The Jed Vs, Voltron part of this thread was kind of fun....

Originally posted by Jed
3a) Beta. You've been getting exactly what you paid for.


I paid for a bug that made some players better and some worse than how they should be? I'm a monster!
Edited by Vagrant God on Sep 2, 2009 13:54:48
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.