User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Opponent Scouting Page - need ideas
Page:
 
Saris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by pottsman

Right now, picking TE1 and TE2 is obvious. No thought is needed on which one to use on a play. Do you really want any depth chart decision to be that obvious?


I see what you're saying and to a degree I agree. But my concern is that we'd just be replacing one type of obvious with another. Under this system there would only be two viable TE builds. Receiving TE's built to break tackles who also have decent blocking around the first cap, and Receiving Speed/agility TE's who also have decent strength/blocking around the first cap. While any TE who has very high natural blocking may as well retire.
Edited by Saris on Aug 12, 2009 00:06:42
Edited by Saris on Aug 12, 2009 00:05:25
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I've never been in favor of any numbers being known, outside of attributes by the owner. I really wish there were no specific numbers included in VAs. The more numbers you know the more of the formulas you can figure out and the less mystery there is to the game. I don't like there being a set way to do things and the more we know the more a clear cut best way becomes evident and the more cookie cutter builds and all of that stuff you get. I just prefer not to know the specifics.


Knowing that someones speed is over 75 is not going to unlock the mysteries of the simulation for you.

Trust me.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

Closed builds are just that. Closed. They should stay strictly off limits. If Bort wanted us to know the numbers or felt that we needed to know the numbers, then closing builds would of never been a option.
TBH, I don't even check for open builds when I do any scouting. I get a good idea of everything from watching game tape.


If God Had Meant for us to Fly.....

Yeah, Bort has never changed the game. Why this OP was made by an imposter.

There is a far cry between someones build being opened and using a scouting position in your coaching staff to get a hint at roughly how large one stat is on one opposing player.



If only you spent as much time recruiting as you did this.
Builds are off limits. Watch your gametape, look at your lolbars, compare notes, but stop trying to see into someones build, no matter how small YOU think it is.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by driftinggrifter
If only you spent as much time recruiting as you did this.
Builds are off limits. Watch your gametape, look at your lolbars, compare notes, but stop trying to see into someones build, no matter how small YOU think it is.


Your Obstructionist Opinion is duly noted.

My suggestion stands as a good way to expand scouting into a playable interesting position and to give coaches something more to consider when planning their tactics.

And this is infinitely preferred to going click click click click click to add one contract offer.to the mix.
Edited by yello1 on Aug 12, 2009 00:07:11
 
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Originally posted by driftinggrifter

And suggestion that you get to see a vague glimpse at a players build when it's closed is not one of those times.

Gametape will tell you all you need to know tbh.


Dont you mean TBR, as in To Be Repetitive.

How do I use game film to tell me how strong a player is?

And you think its unrealistic to know what someones strength and speed is when every single NFL Player goes to a combine and has that all measured by every team?


Yes, it is to unrealistic to know that...............in a MMORPG game, this isn't the NFL nor the NCAA. This is a game, a sim. there is no combine here. there are only builds. Some of which are open some of which are closed. Stop trying to get closed build info. It won't happen.

And on that note, since we are both being repetitive. I'm gonna drop it since there is no more to debate on the matter.


 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Its not a Rollerball game. Its not World of Warcraft.

Its a football sim.

Not knowing when the opponents lineman is a 400 pound bench pressing beast etc is idiotic in a football sim because you can SEE THAT just by looking at the guy.

Purely and simply idiotic to think that knowing something like that would detract from a sim.

Seriously LOL Think about it. If you knew the precise stats of every single opposing player, its not like it would somehow let you game the game and win out. We dont know what the numbers even flipping DO!!!!! So what harm is there in knowing the guys speed is over a certain vague range?

Using the rough numbers to tell us the other guy is big or speedy is immersive and would add depth to the gameplanning. Thats ALL. It sure as heck would not hurt the game play.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Incorporate the concept of the Monsterkill V2 script into the page for each game.


Take away the advantage that script users have over non-script users (And I have Firefox myself, and use plenty of GM scripts).
 
pottsman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Saris
Originally posted by pottsman


Right now, picking TE1 and TE2 is obvious. No thought is needed on which one to use on a play. Do you really want any depth chart decision to be that obvious?


I see what you're saying and to a degree I agree. But my concern is that we'd just be replacing one type of obvious with another. Under this system there would only be two viable TE builds. Receiving TE's built to break tackles who also have decent blocking around the first cap, and Receiving Speed/agility TE's who also have decent strength/blocking around the first cap. While any TE who has very high natural blocking may as well retire.


I don't think so. I think that your first two builds will definitely be around, as they're basically around now already. There are the power TEs and the speed ones already, both enjoy some success to my knowledge. And yes, they will need to cap blocking now to be competent. But I think that the high blocking TE will survive. He'll already have high strength and agility, along with decent speed (since I'm assuming that a successful blocking TE is built as a cross between an OT and a fullback, going with raw numbers of 70+ strength and agility, 68ish blocking, 60s speed, and capped vision). Add in capped catching to that build and well trained carrying (high 30s), and you don't think that will be a build capable of running a few routes, forcing coverage? You lose some of the points you planned to put into SAs or extra vision and put them into catching. He won't be pulling in 50 catches, he won't be something that the DCs will gameplan to stop...but he will be someone that they're forced to cover. If you as an OC see a team ignoring blocking TEs in coverage, you have the tool available to throw to him a few times against a defense completely unprepared.
 
Kblitz
offline
Link
 
I like it +1

Maybe it could also show open builds and provide links to them.

Also it could show replays involving their major players or the top threats. Maybe showing like the top running backs touchdown plays.

Also maybe it could show a random percentage(%) of how many times they ran or passed or blitzed.
 
timpjynx
offline
Link
 
long thread already ... don't know if posted or not.. but last "X" number of games should be last "X" number of NON gutted opponents?
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kblitz
I like it +1

Maybe it could also show open builds and provide links to them.

Also it could show replays involving their major players or the top threats. Maybe showing like the top running backs touchdown plays.

Also maybe it could show a random percentage(%) of how many times they ran or passed or blitzed.


Or how about replays of the play that the selected player has most often carried the ball? Say Joe HB is used to do HB Sweep 40% of the time and Slam 39%, Off Tackle 20% of the time 1% HB Screen, then next to his name would be Favorite Play and a link to a random HB Sweep of his (or the one he gained the most yards on etc).

Note I am not using specific play names but I do mean they should be specific play names.

Or alternatively you could just have a complete listing of the plays he has carried the ball on like his

Joe HB
Breakdown of Touches
40% HB Sweep
39% HB Slam
20% Off Tackle
1% HB Screen

Also you could have a choice to see Situational Touches

Joe HB
Touches by Situation
60% Normal Down (1-3)
10% 3rd and Short
10% 4th and Short
10% Goal Line
10% Red Zone, not Goal Line
0% 3rd and Long
5% Backed Into Goal

(Not adding up to 100, since Red Zone etc would overlap with Normal Down etc)

That would be percentage of plays the player touched the ball.

You could also break it down by percentage of plays in those situations that the player touched the ball (ie carried a run or caught a reception, if possible recoveries and interceptions should be excluded).


 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Or how about replays of the play that the selected player has most often carried the ball? Say Joe HB is used to do HB Sweep 40% of the time and Slam 39%, Off Tackle 20% of the time 1% HB Screen, then next to his name would be Favorite Play and a link to a random HB Sweep of his (or the one he gained the most yards on etc).

Note I am not using specific play names but I do mean they should be specific play names.

Or alternatively you could just have a complete listing of the plays he has carried the ball on like his

Joe HB
Breakdown of Touches
40% HB Sweep
39% HB Slam
20% Off Tackle
1% HB Screen

Also you could have a choice to see Situational Touches

Joe HB
Touches by Situation
60% Normal Down (1-3)
10% 3rd and Short
10% 4th and Short
10% Goal Line
10% Red Zone, not Goal Line
0% 3rd and Long
5% Backed Into Goal

(Not adding up to 100, since Red Zone etc would overlap with Normal Down etc)

That would be percentage of plays the player touched the ball.

You could also break it down by percentage of plays in those situations that the player touched the ball (ie carried a run or caught a reception, if possible recoveries and interceptions should be excluded).




I like this, but only if Bort makes it so that you can adjust your defensive gameplan based on which player is in the game. If he doesn't, there is really no need to break it down by player, just by position.
 
yello1
Preacher
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by butler312
I like this, but only if Bort makes it so that you can adjust your defensive gameplan based on which player is in the game. If he doesn't, there is really no need to break it down by player, just by position.


Hmm. No, because you can have a player at HB1 who touches the ball for all your short yardage situations and does up the middle dives, and yet another for your speed back that goes wide to get some yardage in the red zone or what have you. Therefore going by position (unless it lets you go by HB1 and HB2) would not help to divine tendencies nearly as much as by player.

I think....
 
feedy
offline
Link
 
any chance you could get it throw out the blowout games? I'd really hate to have skewed stats
 
butler312
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by yello1
Hmm. No, because you can have a player at HB1 who touches the ball for all your short yardage situations and does up the middle dives, and yet another for your speed back that goes wide to get some yardage in the red zone or what have you. Therefore going by position (unless it lets you go by HB1 and HB2) would not help to divine tendencies nearly as much as by player.

I think....


But why does it matter if you know the splits by player if you can't change your defense based on which player is in the game? On defense you have to gameplan around the HB position as whole. You kind of have to treat it as if both HBs are just 1 HB combined together. Unless you are going to gamble and hope that a specific HB is in the game at a specific time. Because if you set your defense up to defend one and the other is in the game you are just really screwed.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.