User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Demotion Ideas for the WPL
Page:
 
AngryDragon
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jamz
Originally posted by AngryDragon

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by kwankwan



The relegation of teams is a VERY big deal... The WL will make GLB a "one league game" .... so it is a big deal.. so to distribute demoted teams randomly, could go against Bort's wishes.


It would actually probably be best for the overall health of pro league competition, tbh, to demote the teams to wherever they are needed, but it is not an easy pill for quite a few owners to swallow.


This could backfire. Consider that you could end up with 12 USA pro teams in a few seasons if they are demoted to other regions and then get back to the WPL on another regions ticket.


Then that region will have to get better, or never make it to the WPL.


I totally agree. I was just playing a little devil's advocate.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zoblefu
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Zoblefu


Keep it simple

Top 1 from each conference goes up each year. Top 2 this season only.

Keep always 2 teams per conference in pro league. This means one gets demoted every year, even if it was 2nd place and the other was first.

This way you ALWAYS promote the winners, and you just really compete against the others from your conference to "stay" in the world league. You can request demotion if you want however (if you would normally stay) and get another team to come up from your league.


Why, in a World League, would you just want teams to compete with only teams from their old region to stay? It's a World League, no?


You're still competing against everyone for bragging rights about who is best, but the world league (this way) will always contain the best 2 teams a league has to offer. It gives fair representation to all leagues, and has no problems with promotion/demotion, so it seems like the easiest way.

But as you bolded and pointed out, if you want to STAY in the world league you need to be the best team from your league, period. If you aren't the best from your league, then the next season the pro champion will get a chance to see if they're the best from their league, etc.


Same problem as discussed in the other one above. Say OPL's 4 teams dominate in the first season of the WL, all four make the Final Four of the WL. Two of them have to leave? When all four of the USAPL's failed to even make the playoffs and only two of them have to leave?
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Bort u havent commented on LOL Soccer idea

do u not like it


This is all going to fast...! Probably many good ideas left on the floor... I guess the mods will have to do some reading tomorrow..
 
smallbugger
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Here's how it should work!

1. This season WL is the top 4 from each pro league. 32 teams as planned. Allow a few teams to switch in if they can find owners to want out. MEM for Oceania team for example.

2. At the end of the season the top 16 teams in WL stay.

3. The bottom 16 are demoted to where they came from and the top 2 in each league are promoted to WL.

4. To handle the demotions send them back like this:

If there is room from the natural promotion, add them.

If there is room from a gut/CPU job, add them. Process these first. (These 2 steps handle 90% of the cases I bet)

If there isn't any room just demote the worse pro teams to AAA until you have room.

Why?

Easy 2 up / 2 down promotion/demotion
Everyone always goes back to where they came from
If your the bottom Pro Teams you likely won't care about your demotion.

Everyone's problem is solved. Such a simple answer.



I like this idea...
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Hikariu
Here's how it should work!

1. This season WL is the top 4 from each pro league. 32 teams as planned. Allow a few teams to switch in if they can find owners to want out. MEM for Oceania team for example.

2. At the end of the season the top 16 teams in WL stay.

3. The bottom 16 are demoted to where they came from and the top 2 in each league are promoted to WL.

4. To handle the demotions send them back like this:

If there is room from the natural promotion, add them.

If there is room from a gut/CPU job, add them. Process these first. (These 2 steps handle 90% of the cases I bet)

If there isn't any room just demote the worse pro teams to AAA until you have room.

Why?

Easy 2 up / 2 down promotion/demotion
Everyone always goes back to where they came from
If your the bottom Pro Teams you likely won't care about your demotion.

Everyone's problem is solved. Such a simple answer.



This'd work (and it's been suggested before pretty much) but it would definitely suck to get demoted when you didn't want to.

Let's say the following happens:

We end up with 16 teams from one region in the WPL. For whatever reason, they all start to suck suck, or most of them suck at the same time, and they all miss the playoffs. Now we have to send down 16 teams to the same region, and demote an additional 14 teams. Unlikely scenario, but it would suck.
 
Ubasstards
offline
Link
 
just set up games on day 42+ for teams that won their conferences to try and unseat the bottom two World league teams that came from that region
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kwankwan
Originally posted by the man of doom

Bort u havent commented on LOL Soccer idea

do u not like it


This is all going to fast...! Probably many good ideas left on the floor... I guess the mods will have to do some reading tomorrow..


haha
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galkuris
Originally posted by FairForever

Originally posted by Galkuris




Originally posted by FairForever



Originally posted by Bort




Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My solution fits all of them to be honest.


What if the top two teams both make it to the WL conference championship? Why should they be punished? Drygerian/Marblehead could very easily pull that off and it would not be fair to demote one of them. This is one part of the solution I would absolutely not agree on.


That's why we included the play-in game after. So if Marblehead beat Dryden in the WPL Conference Championship Game, Dryden would face off against CPL East's champion. If Dryden was good enough to make WPL Conference Finals, they should have no problem dispatching the CPL team and staying in WPL.


idk, even yet I think it would mean the best teams are not always going to be in the WPL. A solution should have the Pro League champions always moving up. Teams should not get free passes to stay in the WL when they are worse then other teams that should be there.

It may not be the best now, but in 4-5 seasons that should be the goal. To do that teams that make the playoffs should never get demoted. And teams that earn their way up by winning the Pro Conferences should be in.

Finally, what if CPL East's champion wins CPL and they lose to Dryden. However, the CPL West's champion wins and beats North Delta. How is it fair that the true CPL champion has to keep rotting in CPL while the team they beat moves up?


They don't get free passes, they have to face a play-in game against the Pro League champions. It's going to be rare to have both teams in WPL from a conference be undeserving of staying there compared to teams in their respective Pro Leagues.

As for your last part, if CPL East's champion can't get past Dryden/Marblehead, then maybe there's another issue that they're not one of the two best teams in their Conference (including teams currently in WPL).
 
lukin83
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by turnit643
Originally posted by Zoblefu

Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by Zoblefu



Keep it simple

Top 1 from each conference goes up each year. Top 2 this season only.

Keep always 2 teams per conference in pro league. This means one gets demoted every year, even if it was 2nd place and the other was first.

This way you ALWAYS promote the winners, and you just really compete against the others from your conference to "stay" in the world league. You can request demotion if you want however (if you would normally stay) and get another team to come up from your league.


Why, in a World League, would you just want teams to compete with only teams from their old region to stay? It's a World League, no?


You're still competing against everyone for bragging rights about who is best, but the world league (this way) will always contain the best 2 teams a league has to offer. It gives fair representation to all leagues, and has no problems with promotion/demotion, so it seems like the easiest way.

But as you bolded and pointed out, if you want to STAY in the world league you need to be the best team from your league, period. If you aren't the best from your league, then the next season the pro champion will get a chance to see if they're the best from their league, etc.


Same problem as discussed in the other one above. Say OPL's 4 teams dominate in the first season of the WL, all four make the Final Four of the WL. Two of them have to leave? When all four of the USAPL's failed to even make the playoffs and only two of them have to leave?


Set it up like the NFL and all four teams from one region will never make the playoffs.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist

To create parity you need to have a limit on teams from regions & they all need to be even. Sure it hurts some teams this season but it will only help out in the future.

Wouldn't allowing the deserving teams to continue to promote into the WL also create parity? Skimming the cream continually into the WL.
 
Galkuris
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ImTheScientist
Originally posted by turnit643

Originally posted by FairForever


Originally posted by turnit643


Originally posted by Galkuris


Originally posted by FairForever


Originally posted by Bort




Added to OP.

Caveats:

- Special treatment cannot be given to a certain region or regions, just because some people think that region is better. Biases should be determined by stats, wins, losses alone.
- Think long term. Encouraging the regions to even out as far as talent is a GOOD thing.
- Team owners would prefer to go back to the region they came from. If we can make that happen, it is best.


My solution fits all of them to be honest.


What if the top two teams both make it to the WL conference championship? Why should they be punished? Drygerian/Marblehead could very easily pull that off and it would not be fair to demote one of them. This is one part of the solution I would absolutely not agree on.


Agreed. This is the problem with all regional quote demotion ideas, even if all WL teams from one region succeed while in the WL, they can't all stay. Have four teams there and all finish int he final four? Too bad, two are getting the boot. Makes no sense in what is supposed to be the best league in the game.


In the long run this would mean better teams going to OPL, EEPL and APL (to try and get easier entrance into WPL), making the Pro Leagues more equal.


That would be the case for most of the ideas mentioned. The easier paths would be ID'd in no time. My question is ... why limit the number of teams that can stay in the WL from one region if they are all deserving of staying and others clearly are not?


To create parity you need to have a limit on teams from regions & they all need to be even. Sure it hurts some teams this season but it will only help out in the future.


How are better teams supposed to just move to the other conferences? Who decides who gets to move? Who decides that the AAA teams in that League don't deserve to move up?

I initially disliked the WL as the best teams would not be in it now. I understand at this point why that has to be...but with this suggestion there is a good chance there will be a couple leagues where new teams never get to move up since their two reps are some of the best in ALL of GLB (see MEM/HHW and Dry/Marble)
 
FairForever
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Hikariu

Here's how it should work!

1. This season WL is the top 4 from each pro league. 32 teams as planned. Allow a few teams to switch in if they can find owners to want out. MEM for Oceania team for example.

2. At the end of the season the top 16 teams in WL stay.

3. The bottom 16 are demoted to where they came from and the top 2 in each league are promoted to WL.

4. To handle the demotions send them back like this:

If there is room from the natural promotion, add them.

If there is room from a gut/CPU job, add them. Process these first. (These 2 steps handle 90% of the cases I bet)

If there isn't any room just demote the worse pro teams to AAA until you have room.

Why?

Easy 2 up / 2 down promotion/demotion
Everyone always goes back to where they came from
If your the bottom Pro Teams you likely won't care about your demotion.

Everyone's problem is solved. Such a simple answer.



This'd work (and it's been suggested before pretty much) but it would definitely suck to get demoted when you didn't want to.

Let's say the following happens:

We end up with 16 teams from one region in the WPL. For whatever reason, they all start to suck suck, or most of them suck at the same time, and they all miss the playoffs. Now we have to send down 16 teams to the same region, and demote an additional 14 teams. Unlikely scenario, but it would suck.


It's not as unlikely as you think. If in season 11/12 USA Pro dominates, then retirement comes up.
 
kwankwan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Hikariu

Here's how it should work!

1. This season WL is the top 4 from each pro league. 32 teams as planned. Allow a few teams to switch in if they can find owners to want out. MEM for Oceania team for example.

2. At the end of the season the top 16 teams in WL stay.

3. The bottom 16 are demoted to where they came from and the top 2 in each league are promoted to WL.

4. To handle the demotions send them back like this:

If there is room from the natural promotion, add them.

If there is room from a gut/CPU job, add them. Process these first. (These 2 steps handle 90% of the cases I bet)

If there isn't any room just demote the worse pro teams to AAA until you have room.

Why?

Easy 2 up / 2 down promotion/demotion
Everyone always goes back to where they came from
If your the bottom Pro Teams you likely won't care about your demotion.

Everyone's problem is solved. Such a simple answer.



This'd work (and it's been suggested before pretty much) but it would definitely suck to get demoted when you didn't want to.

Let's say the following happens:

We end up with 16 teams from one region in the WPL. For whatever reason, they all start to suck suck, or most of them suck at the same time, and they all miss the playoffs. Now we have to send down 16 teams to the same region, and demote an additional 14 teams. Unlikely scenario, but it would suck.


This, and its not the only problem... can there be any solution that fixes all..? Not sure. Hiks idea is alright.. getting there at least.
 
turnit643
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Hikariu

Here's how it should work!

1. This season WL is the top 4 from each pro league. 32 teams as planned. Allow a few teams to switch in if they can find owners to want out. MEM for Oceania team for example.

2. At the end of the season the top 16 teams in WL stay.

3. The bottom 16 are demoted to where they came from and the top 2 in each league are promoted to WL.

4. To handle the demotions send them back like this:

If there is room from the natural promotion, add them.

If there is room from a gut/CPU job, add them. Process these first. (These 2 steps handle 90% of the cases I bet)

If there isn't any room just demote the worse pro teams to AAA until you have room.

Why?

Easy 2 up / 2 down promotion/demotion
Everyone always goes back to where they came from
If your the bottom Pro Teams you likely won't care about your demotion.

Everyone's problem is solved. Such a simple answer.



This'd work (and it's been suggested before pretty much) but it would definitely suck to get demoted when you didn't want to.

Let's say the following happens:

We end up with 16 teams from one region in the WPL. For whatever reason, they all start to suck suck, or most of them suck at the same time, and they all miss the playoffs. Now we have to send down 16 teams to the same region, and demote an additional 14 teams. Unlikely scenario, but it would suck.


But no one would have a problem with the pile of un-earned AAA-to-Pro promotions that came before that unlikely scenario.
 
shield.bearer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by the man of doom
Originally posted by crazy454

Originally posted by Joebarber


Originally posted by Havoc



[

If you promote 2 teams from each Pro league you will have to demote half of the WPL each season (dont you think that is a lot?)... why not just promote the league champion from each region and demote only 8 of the 32 teams...


Do it like European soccer.

8 Pro champs auto promote and replace the bottom 8 WPL teams.

8 Pro runner ups play an additional playoff game against WPL teams #17-24. Winner plays in WPL the next season.

I really like this plan tbh


+1


+1

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.