User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > World Pro Championship Tournament
Page:
 
Voltron
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by letan24
big surprise here. bort and co caved in to the people who were bitching. would be great one day if they didnt cave into crying and whining all the time. we already have plenty of tournaments. what's the point in doing what everyones already been doing.


Is that why everyone's crying in this thread? Hoping for a WPL that will be broken and people will bitch about(Aka CV's thread about OFG and MM not getting in).
 
SpreadThePink
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc




Hasn't stopped you before.
 
Octowned
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc



1) If it is already happening everywhere, what's an extra 3-4 teams? Plus, recruiting should be even easier for these teams even if they can't hang
2) Tell them to STFU, the point isn't for the top 32 but for all regions. In 2-3 seasons it will be balanced anyway
3) 2 teams gone? So what. This is a chance for other teams to win for a change, and extra motivation.
4) Extra teams promoted? Well, that's just for THIS SEASON. And it only amounts to one extra advancement from each AA league, which really isn't a big deal.
5) Extra dropdowns from WPL? Aren't they just replacing who is moving UP to WPL? Just don't put people back where they came from, only give priority to the highest seed from a given conference, and put the rest back randomly



I fail to see a major issue here
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
DOWN WITH THE TOURNEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc


You've done polls in the past? Why not do one now but limit it to just team owners? (sorry, for something like this it shouldn't be a general public decision as it is the owners who are the ones that quit, gut, and generally cause the ripple effect)
 
Laggo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc


- You don't change an entire structure because some owners might cry a bit more, especially a structure that was generally preferred by most all involved and alot that weren't
- Then fix the promotion system. There were a ton of ideas floating around that solved these kind of solutions properly. Even so, whats wrong with debate?
- Alot of the pro league teams wanted this to happen so the 16-0 teams wouldn't be in their division so they could get a chance at doing well in pro (which would bring its share of FA's trying to get into the world league)
- If adding another tier to your pyramid scheme breaks the system - theres something wrong with the system
- Media Revenue is easily fixed by having a slight bonus to ticket sales for playing in pro, enough to make up for the possibly offset later. Rich get richer is a weak argument in this case because the best teams need the help to succeed.

Lets get fixing this.
 
letan24
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jxgator33
Originally posted by henne

Don't we already have a PWT that is incredibly run?


Probably better then this will be


guaranteed to be better run imo
 
WinkYouOut
offline
Link
 
]Originally posted by WinkYouOut

If we are going to give a prize for winning this pro-league tournament, shouldn't there be tournaments with the same prize set up at every level? As stated above a bunch, this is going to make recruiting for uncapped minors, AA, and AAA impossible to recruit for.


I want to keep this bumped, because I think it needs to be addressed.
 
robponce
offline
Link
 
Wow.

Gart's idea was well liked and well respected among all the top teams.

This...

Was just stupid. Hell I'm in the PWT committee, and this is an absolute let down. WL was an opportunity to better GLB, and it didn't get better.


Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc


Please explain how this is different than swapping WSI over to USA.
 
James128
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).
- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league
- Dilution of Pro league talent
- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN
- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc


I agree 100% with this. World league was a nice thought but implementing it now wasn't the best idea with the season 1 guys soon to retire....
 
.spider.
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by rmiller517

WPL wouldn't have been balanced at all.


And likely would cause:

- Some owners to get promoted and quit after getting beat more than they are used to (can't handle losing syndrome - I've seen it over and over).

jbleich - Then freaking let em....More FA's for the owners that dont punk out like pussies, and more teams more than ready to take their spot

- Continued endless debate about how the wrong teams made it because we'd go with equal rep from each league

jbleich - There needs to be a system for promo/releg...that could be ironed out in the next 10 days...the first season would NOT have the right teams in there, hence a lot of the minors leagues...but the right plan will iron it out in the longer run 2-3 seasons.

- Dilution of Pro league talent

jbleich - So you are saying AAA leagues suck?

- Extra teams to get promoted who aren't ready, with a ripple effect ALL THE WAY DOWN

jbleich - If they are at the top of their league currently, HOW ARE THEY NOT READY?

- Extra teams to be demoted even if they didn't come in last place (due to dropdowns from WPL) which sucks for them, gives them less media revenue, etc

jbleich - If they are 13th/14th they would probobly welcome the shift down, would lessen the 13th and 14th ranked CPU teams at the end of the season that you are so worried about.



Edited by jbleich on Jul 27, 2009 16:09:23
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort's Announcement
I've been talking with our tournaments moderator, DrkSandman, and he is planning that the new official tournament will take the place of one of the unofficial ones, so those who've been participating in those won't have more games to play


I will bold where you went wrong...
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Nothing proposed with seeding, ranking, or membership in a league will come out with parity if all 8 Pro leagues are given equal footing in the script. It doesn't matter if it's a tourney or a league. The leagues are not balanced.

You haven't solved anything, Bort. Pro talent will still dilute, as other Pro leagues offer the easiest route in to the Tourney. People will still suffer from loser syndrome and gut.

You're fighting the wrong battles imo.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
Just don't put people back where they came from, only give priority to the highest seed from a given conference, and put the rest back randomly



I fail to see a major issue here


No. Teams would HAVE to go back to where they came from. That was the entire dealbreaker of the world league idea in the first place, and one of the main reasons why the world league is problematic.
 
RiverRat2
offline
Link
 
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
POLL
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.