User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Combine some threads: the G-OT Gap "Exploit"
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Personal attacks. Nice. You must be a very angry person.

The vast majority of plays I see have the LT getting in on the action too. And the ones where he's not are very often because the LT doesn't have any coding to move over and block the DE. He either moves very ineffectively or does nothing useful at all, and is basically out of the play... Even though there's a huge pass rusher standing right next to him. That's called an exploit.


I called you stupid for completely mangling what I've been saying in a very clear manner. Although, typically, your arguements are pretty stupid. Here's some more examples:

First, it's not an exploit for the linemen that is closest to the RDE to take him (the LG) and for linemen further away to *gasp* look for other guys to block FIRST before going to help double someone.

Second, generally when the LT gets in on the action, there is no sack, or at least the RDE is now force to go end around for the sack.


People have posted dozens of plays where the LT gets in on the action and there's still a sack? Where have you been?

PS - hostile much?
Edited by fallingmercury on Jul 17, 2009 12:00:53
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by kurieg

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Personal attacks. Nice. You must be a very angry person.

The vast majority of plays I see have the LT getting in on the action too. And the ones where he's not are very often because the LT doesn't have any coding to move over and block the DE. He either moves very ineffectively or does nothing useful at all, and is basically out of the play... Even though there's a huge pass rusher standing right next to him. That's called an exploit.


I called you stupid for completely mangling what I've been saying in a very clear manner. Although, typically, your arguements are pretty stupid. Here's some more examples:

First, it's not an exploit for the linemen that is closest to the RDE to take him (the LG) and for linemen further away to *gasp* look for other guys to block FIRST before going to help double someone.

Second, generally when the LT gets in on the action, there is no sack, or at least the RDE is now force to go end around for the sack.


People have posted dozens of plays where the LT gets in on the action and there's still a sack? Where have you been?

PS - hostile much?


Doesn't require hostility to see how bad of a poster you are, FM.

The vast bulk of those replays involve the RDE shedding the LG and shooting through before the LOT does a damn thing.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Originally posted by kurieg


Originally posted by fallingmercury



Personal attacks. Nice. You must be a very angry person.

The vast majority of plays I see have the LT getting in on the action too. And the ones where he's not are very often because the LT doesn't have any coding to move over and block the DE. He either moves very ineffectively or does nothing useful at all, and is basically out of the play... Even though there's a huge pass rusher standing right next to him. That's called an exploit.


I called you stupid for completely mangling what I've been saying in a very clear manner. Although, typically, your arguements are pretty stupid. Here's some more examples:

First, it's not an exploit for the linemen that is closest to the RDE to take him (the LG) and for linemen further away to *gasp* look for other guys to block FIRST before going to help double someone.

Second, generally when the LT gets in on the action, there is no sack, or at least the RDE is now force to go end around for the sack.


People have posted dozens of plays where the LT gets in on the action and there's still a sack? Where have you been?

PS - hostile much?


Doesn't require hostility to see how bad of a poster you are, FM.

The vast bulk of those replays involve the RDE shedding the LG and shooting through before the LOT does a damn thing.


Not the ones I'm looking at.

And seriously, grow the fuck up.
 
mwoods07
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Out of simple curiousity, can anyone post plays where this particular alignment doesn't work? Or specific DEs who don't do well with this alignment?


I'm not in a mood to go digging for plays...also, jdbolick did a pretty good job of it. But just looking at my own games and getting an assessment, I would say I could post 5 FAILED plays for every 1 PASSED play you can post. It just doesn't happen that often...and that is with the very specific DE's. I can show you where it has been used 100% during a game with 100% failure if you like as well...which is my main argument that it is not a bug, with not "perfect" DE's you can't do it...With the perfect DE's you have a success rate of about 10% or less...and in reality that same DE will get sacks at about a normal 7-8% rate anyway. It just gives him an extra sack or two simply because he is close to the QB when he beats his man...
 
kurieg
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by kurieg

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Originally posted by kurieg



Originally posted by fallingmercury




Personal attacks. Nice. You must be a very angry person.

The vast majority of plays I see have the LT getting in on the action too. And the ones where he's not are very often because the LT doesn't have any coding to move over and block the DE. He either moves very ineffectively or does nothing useful at all, and is basically out of the play... Even though there's a huge pass rusher standing right next to him. That's called an exploit.


I called you stupid for completely mangling what I've been saying in a very clear manner. Although, typically, your arguements are pretty stupid. Here's some more examples:

First, it's not an exploit for the linemen that is closest to the RDE to take him (the LG) and for linemen further away to *gasp* look for other guys to block FIRST before going to help double someone.

Second, generally when the LT gets in on the action, there is no sack, or at least the RDE is now force to go end around for the sack.


People have posted dozens of plays where the LT gets in on the action and there's still a sack? Where have you been?

PS - hostile much?


Doesn't require hostility to see how bad of a poster you are, FM.

The vast bulk of those replays involve the RDE shedding the LG and shooting through before the LOT does a damn thing.


Not the ones I'm looking at.

And seriously, grow the fuck up.


Oh, hey, look, grow the fuck up. No u.

I looked at the replays you posted at least in one spot in this thread. It's just RDE owns LG at word go.
 
Link
 
Some of the coolest replays are the ones where the LG moves to block the DT, while the LT does nothing or tries to block the DE from the side, which doesn't work....

Edited by fallingmercury on Jul 17, 2009 12:32:06
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Some of the coolest replays are the ones where the LG moves to block the DT, while the LT does nothing or tries to block the DE from the side, which doesn't work....



Kurieg,

You should probably give up trying to show this guy reason, his moronic posts have given everyone notice, that he just doesn't get it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Originally posted by fallingmercury

Some of the coolest replays are the ones where the LG moves to block the DT, while the LT does nothing or tries to block the DE from the side, which doesn't work....



Kurieg,

You should probably give up trying to show this guy reason, his moronic posts have given everyone notice, that he just doesn't get it.


Oh shit, smay is here?!?

Inb4 FIX UR BUILDS!
Inb4 OMG WHAAA DONT NERF MY PLAYEH
Inb4 Smay's angry emotional outburst starts
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Thanks jd - always appreciate that kind of effort

I looked through a bunch of Pa Dong's games, and then a few of the Pro teams I'm associated with, so that I could see builds. Then, I tried to look through competitive Pro teams who don't use this particular formation, in order to compare.

It was damn difficult to find someone who isn't using this, I have to say.

I think the main crux of the argument has been this: how successful is it? Well, it all depends on how one defines success.

If someone is defining success as a registered hurry or sack, then it's not very successful. I'd say 10-20% for the better DEs.

However, if someone else is defining success as getting into the backfield very quickly passed two blockers, then I'd say the success rate is MUCH higher. More like 80-90% for the better DEs, such as WD or PE.

What's interesting is to use DB's script and to check out their max acceleration. When successful, the max acceleration is between 20-25. When it's not successful (or it's not being used), the max acceleration is between 10-15. However, a DE can *sometimes* get around a 20 acceleration rushing around the outside if he encounters a blocker and quickly sheds that block, but it's much more rare and much, much less effective.

Compare the acceleration to WRs, who usually clock in at around 15 or so, with Jericho Brooks hitting 17ish. So, I guess the question is, should a player gain that much more acceleration from a shed block?

Personally, I think there's some kind of slingshot/pinball effect going on where the DE bounces between the LG and LOT, gaining acceleration/speed as he goes, and it produces a "shot out of a gun" issue.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by sjmay

Originally posted by fallingmercury


Some of the coolest replays are the ones where the LG moves to block the DT, while the LT does nothing or tries to block the DE from the side, which doesn't work....



Kurieg,

You should probably give up trying to show this guy reason, his moronic posts have given everyone notice, that he just doesn't get it.


Oh shit, smay is here?!?

Inb4 FIX UR BUILDS!
Inb4 OMG WHAAA DONT NERF MY PLAYEH
Inb4 Smay's angry emotional outburst starts


Kurieg,

Did he make my point for me, or what?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Thanks jd - always appreciate that kind of effort

I looked through a bunch of Pa Dong's games, and then a few of the Pro teams I'm associated with, so that I could see builds. Then, I tried to look through competitive Pro teams who don't use this particular formation, in order to compare.

It was damn difficult to find someone who isn't using this, I have to say.

I think the main crux of the argument has been this: how successful is it? Well, it all depends on how one defines success.

If someone is defining success as a registered hurry or sack, then it's not very successful. I'd say 10-20% for the better DEs.

However, if someone else is defining success as getting into the backfield very quickly passed two blockers, then I'd say the success rate is MUCH higher. More like 80-90% for the better DEs, such as WD or PE.

What's interesting is to use DB's script and to check out their max acceleration. When successful, the max acceleration is between 20-25. When it's not successful (or it's not being used), the max acceleration is between 10-15. However, a DE can *sometimes* get around a 20 acceleration rushing around the outside if he encounters a blocker and quickly sheds that block, but it's much more rare and much, much less effective.

Compare the acceleration to WRs, who usually clock in at around 15 or so, with Jericho Brooks hitting 17ish. So, I guess the question is, should a player gain that much more acceleration from a shed block?

Personally, I think there's some kind of slingshot/pinball effect going on where the DE bounces between the LG and LOT, gaining acceleration/speed as he goes, and it produces a "shot out of a gun" issue.


Bingo.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by j10er
Thanks jd - always appreciate that kind of effort

I looked through a bunch of Pa Dong's games, and then a few of the Pro teams I'm associated with, so that I could see builds. Then, I tried to look through competitive Pro teams who don't use this particular formation, in order to compare.

It was damn difficult to find someone who isn't using this, I have to say.

I think the main crux of the argument has been this: how successful is it? Well, it all depends on how one defines success.

If someone is defining success as a registered hurry or sack, then it's not very successful. I'd say 10-20% for the better DEs.

However, if someone else is defining success as getting into the backfield very quickly passed two blockers, then I'd say the success rate is MUCH higher. More like 80-90% for the better DEs, such as WD or PE.

What's interesting is to use DB's script and to check out their max acceleration. When successful, the max acceleration is between 20-25. When it's not successful (or it's not being used), the max acceleration is between 10-15. However, a DE can *sometimes* get around a 20 acceleration rushing around the outside if he encounters a blocker and quickly sheds that block, but it's much more rare and much, much less effective.

Compare the acceleration to WRs, who usually clock in at around 15 or so, with Jericho Brooks hitting 17ish. So, I guess the question is, should a player gain that much more acceleration from a shed block?

Personally, I think there's some kind of slingshot/pinball effect going on where the DE bounces between the LG and LOT, gaining acceleration/speed as he goes, and it produces a "shot out of a gun" issue.


Good point, though I am curious why would you get a speed acceleration from shedding a block, or maybe max acceleration from shedding a block, thinking it out, DLine engages Oline, Dline is blocked, DLine sheds block, Dline has to accelerate again, sounds like he should be starting again from zero, is that what is happening? Or is he still maintaining some kind of momentum while being blocked that would account for a speed burst?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay


Did he make my point for me, or what?


You call me a moronic piece of shit on another thread then go around accusing people of making moronic posts?

Huh? Hypocrite much?

Go away, troll-larva.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by j10er

Thanks jd - always appreciate that kind of effort

I looked through a bunch of Pa Dong's games, and then a few of the Pro teams I'm associated with, so that I could see builds. Then, I tried to look through competitive Pro teams who don't use this particular formation, in order to compare.

It was damn difficult to find someone who isn't using this, I have to say.

I think the main crux of the argument has been this: how successful is it? Well, it all depends on how one defines success.

If someone is defining success as a registered hurry or sack, then it's not very successful. I'd say 10-20% for the better DEs.

However, if someone else is defining success as getting into the backfield very quickly passed two blockers, then I'd say the success rate is MUCH higher. More like 80-90% for the better DEs, such as WD or PE.

What's interesting is to use DB's script and to check out their max acceleration. When successful, the max acceleration is between 20-25. When it's not successful (or it's not being used), the max acceleration is between 10-15. However, a DE can *sometimes* get around a 20 acceleration rushing around the outside if he encounters a blocker and quickly sheds that block, but it's much more rare and much, much less effective.

Compare the acceleration to WRs, who usually clock in at around 15 or so, with Jericho Brooks hitting 17ish. So, I guess the question is, should a player gain that much more acceleration from a shed block?

Personally, I think there's some kind of slingshot/pinball effect going on where the DE bounces between the LG and LOT, gaining acceleration/speed as he goes, and it produces a "shot out of a gun" issue.


Bingo.


LOL Bingo what exactly? I guess you are the 1% that says this is successful because the DE gets into the backfield, right?
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by fallingmercury
Originally posted by sjmay



Did he make my point for me, or what?


You call me a moronic piece of shit on another thread then go around accusing people of making moronic posts?

Huh? Hypocrite much?

Go away, troll-larva.


LOL Think about what you just typed their sparky,

IF I called you a moronic piece of shit, AND I accuse you of making moronic posts,

HOW IN THE WORLD is that being a hyprocrite? Wouldn't you consider that being, consistent????
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.