User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Yes, we are aware the I slam play is frequntly cheesy and many teams are running it over and over. No, we are not updating things in-season.
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
A team should still have the ability to hide the plays its calling via formation though.

If i call 30 singleback plays all game, and they're all singleback slam, the defense should have a good idea what's coming on the 31st time we line up in singleback.

But if we go with 45 singleback plays, 30 slam, and 15 some sort of passing play, the defense shouldn't have as good of an idea of what we're about to do.

I appreciate that this will be quite difficult to code.


Agreed, it is much more complex than what people think, and will be more difficult to code correctly.
 
joemiken
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gyuri1
If 1000 vision won't help, then I'm not sure how a vision penalty/bonus would do it (as I'm not sure a vision reduction on the offense would solve the problem either). I'd think, though, that applying a percent reduction to each roll (with the penalty increasing the more times a play is run in a game over a certain threshold) similar to in-game energy/morale multipliers would work.


True, but if a penalty is assessed to the offense and a bonus assessed to the defense, it's a two-fold gain. On top of that, making it an exponential gain will make a difference pretty quickly. Let's say a 2% vision & confidence bonus/penalty is applied once a team runs one play 10 times. 11 times, now it's a 4%. 12 times, 16%, etc etc. After running the play 20 times, the vision & confidence bonuses/penalties will be so severe (for JUST that play), the offense will be blind and suicidal while the defense will be able to see the future. lol
 
Dpride59
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Gart888

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by Gart888



Bort,

Any immediate plans to implement some sort of code that punishes offenses for making repetitive play calls? I get the sinking feeling that whatever you do to fix SI Slam will work to balance that one play, but eventually another 'god' play will make itself known and we'll have the exact same thing happen all over again.

Something to encourage diverse play calling would not only solve the current issue, but go a long way in preventing this from happening again, in the future, with different play.s


I have tested it and it doesn't do a whole lot unless you buff a lot of defenses' abilities. You could have 1000 vision, but if you can't make it past a blocker, you're still screwed.


Well then how about instead of buffing the defenses abilities, you penalize the offenses abilities? Something like out of position penalties, but for the entire offense?


Sounds counter-intuitive. Why would the offense play worse when they run the play over and over? A more intuitive idea would maybe be an increasing stamina usage every time the same play is called or something, but it still doesn't make that much sense.

Also, do you buff the defense/nerf the offense to the point where a crap team can shut down a really good team if the good team runs the same play over and over? Just because I run up the gut every play, should I get shut down by lv 1's when I'm level 60?

There's also the issue that some formations don't really have that many plays. We've added a couple more, but sometimes you're forced to run certain plays many times. Some HS and college teams literally run 3 plays.


+1. Teams who run the same play over and over get better at it dont they? All day running dive left vs chargers? Cornhuskers option right. If anything mb a defensive vision buff if they see the same play 4 times in a row or something.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Sorry, got a phone call I had to take.
 
Link
 
Thanks

Hooty Hoo
Last edited Mar 31, 2009 18:07:06
 
Skanker irl
offline
Link
 
Thanks Bort. Appreciate it.
 
reddogrw
HOOD
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Sorry, got a phone call I had to take.


tell DD to put TWO coats of wax on the car, not just one





(j/k DD - had to do it)
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Gart888
A team should still have the ability to hide the plays its calling via formation though.

If i call 30 singleback plays all game, and they're all singleback slam, the defense should have a good idea what's coming on the 31st time we line up in singleback.

But if we go with 45 singleback plays, 30 slam, and 15 some sort of passing play, the defense shouldn't have as good of an idea of what we're about to do.

I appreciate that this will be quite difficult to code.


It can be done by checking the percentage of each play in a formation and setting a threshold like 80%. This checking can only be activated after there are 10 plays in a certain formation.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
[Off-Topic]
Last edited Mar 31, 2009 18:07:11
 
Procrustes
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Sounds counter-intuitive. Why would the offense play worse when they run the play over and over? A more intuitive idea would maybe be an increasing stamina usage every time the same play is called or something, but it still doesn't make that much sense.

Also, do you buff the defense/nerf the offense to the point where a crap team can shut down a really good team if the good team runs the same play over and over? Just because I run up the gut every play, should I get shut down by lv 1's when I'm level 60?

There's also the issue that some formations don't really have that many plays. We've added a couple more, but sometimes you're forced to run certain plays many times. Some HS and college teams literally run 3 plays.


that's the tricky part, but it still seems doable.

a dominant offense should still be able to waltz all over a crappy defense... even if they only run one play and the defense gets max vision/confidence/etc because of it.

for one thing, the effects of morale gain/loss would still exist.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
Epic.


 
Gyuri1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by joemiken
Originally posted by Gyuri1

If 1000 vision won't help, then I'm not sure how a vision penalty/bonus would do it (as I'm not sure a vision reduction on the offense would solve the problem either). I'd think, though, that applying a percent reduction to each roll (with the penalty increasing the more times a play is run in a game over a certain threshold) similar to in-game energy/morale multipliers would work.


True, but if a penalty is assessed to the offense and a bonus assessed to the defense, it's a two-fold gain. On top of that, making it an exponential gain will make a difference pretty quickly. Let's say a 2% vision & confidence bonus/penalty is applied once a team runs one play 10 times. 11 times, now it's a 4%. 12 times, 16%, etc etc. After running the play 20 times, the vision & confidence bonuses/penalties will be so severe (for JUST that play), the offense will be blind and suicidal while the defense will be able to see the future. lol


I'm not even sure seeing the future would stop the Strong I Slam this season. Still, I think the addition of confidence to a vision penalty is a good idea, as it should have a wider impact on the player attributes.
 
Weather
offline
Link
 
Bort, just pretend that the servers are infected with Conficker, tomorrow. Then say it will take like 2 weeks for them to get games simming again.

That delay can get you to fix the problem. Who cares if it's inseason.
 
Cerneo
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cerneo
[Off-Topic]


Good god man! How was that off topic?
 
firehazard
offline
Link
 
Look, a "beta" game should be modified immediately when a bug/exploit is found. It's in the game's best interest to retain members.

Oh but wait, this really isn't a beta. No one charges to play a true beta.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.