User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Endorsements - What I am thinking
Page:
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
considering stats are skewed and not every team gets to play the same schedule , I do not see how you can determine a fair MVP in each league.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Capaneus
Originally posted by Bort


You're probably right, actually. I could do a MVP list based on last season stats per league from the live site, output in in a text file or something, and post results until it looks good?


Sounds great, and I'd love to see the results.


I'll have to set something up. I doubt it will be hard to set up. The formula will be the hard part.
 
gobolts33
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by gobolts33

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by tautology



Bort:

Regarding MVPs

The biggest difficulty in determing these sorts of things has to do with palying gutted teams, and the fact some players may face 4 gutted teams while others might face one one (or none).

Does the differential in fame make up for this level of disparity?

For instance-

A level 40 HB can easily pick up 800+ yards and 20 TDs vs a gutted teams. If they play three more gutted teams than an opponent, that is perhaps an 1800 yard and 50 TD "lead" that thye establish against the rest of the league in their primary stat lines.


Solution: In order to prevent this from causing inequities, throw away the 4 best games from each player. That goes a long ways towards making things a bit more even.


With the right weight balance I think fame could actually work pretty well to filter down the gut job masters.

It is also quite possible to go back through and re-calculate the stats that "count" for the purposes of an MVP calculation. Perhaps we could multiply the stats by a percentage, based on the level difference in the teams or the score differential, etc.



This idea dont work for me....What if the player who loses his 4 top games did not play against gutted teams. SO a great build is penalized for no reason...The success of a well built player against a good team is just as much how the teams game plan and AIs work. Sometimes a good team can dominate another good team with a wise game plan and AI. So this would not be fair. If you keep the endorsements within the conference then its an even playing field because all the teams play the same opponents and get to play weak and strong teams...


I heare you and sympathize, but it is very difficult to come up with an alogrithmic method for weeding out gut jobs.

Scounting Bar/ratings? no
Score? no
Level difference? weak, but maybe




I agree with your point aswell.......I really think that some of this stuff just gets overcomplicated. The solution is to simplify it. If the endorsements are "conference" related then its black and white. The conference or league leaders get endorsements and a few other top performers in the conference...The gut jobs are all conference related, so each team in that conference has the same opportunity to stat pad....The best builds and smartest teams win. Thats how it works for league leading trophy's and championships. Keep endorsements in line with everything else.....If you dont build a good player and your on a team that is not ran well then just like all the other perks in the game, you dont get none..lol

 
odg62
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Rezlov
Sounds like a disaster waiting to happen. If the BCS can't decide the top team correctly, how is GLB going to decide the top player?

Not to mention there are FAR more factors and such.


yeah i like the vote idea but i think it opens up a door to people conspiring to see the vote go favorably for them
 
MeatBomb
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kurieg
Originally posted by MeatBomb

Originally posted by Bort


Originally posted by kurieg



To calculate MVP stats:

1 - Throw out interconference games.
2 - Select the 9 highest average score differential teams. Only count stats against these teams. Throw one of them out randomly, and use the remaining 8 to compare stats with the 7 that don't make this list. Explanation -
Teams 1-9 have the best score differentials. Team 1 gains fame based on games vs. 2-9. Team 2 vs. 1 and 3-9. Etc.
Roll 1-9 and throw that team out. Team 10-16 are compared to the remaining 8 to gain fame.

Oh ya, don't bother calculating fame until the end of the season so you can weed out the terrible teams/gutjobs.


Like judging figure skating?

Throw out the highs and lows, take the average?


Would be basically the same as comparing stats against teams in your division that made the playoffs.



Gutjobs have made the playoffs.


And teams have also had high score differentials, sold mid-season, and still finished in the top ha;f of a division in score differential. It's apples and apples. The likelyhood of either though is rare enough to be dismissed. Gutting and mid-season team folds are always going to mess up any calculation.

I think the best idea yet might be the stats accumulated without "cruise control" being in effect.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I think it would be a good time to introduce a MNF game for each league and link the game in each league forum...fame would be doubled for performance in that game...every team would get at least one MNF game a season and they would be based on even-leveled matchups. This would further reward teams that are playing in the right league as they would see more MNF games. As well, it would be a great opportunity to build the game and level of interest for players.

I made the thread a while ago about how to work it, but it is ultimately not my call. I am just suggesting that the game add this for more of a business feel to owning a team/players on top of the extra benefits of getting people more involved.
 
ChuckTaylor
offline
Link
 
- strip the old ones away
- compensate the guys who have been stripped of the ones they got
- rerun the script to double the amount of endorsements per league ( 32 per conference , 64 per league)
- limit the teams to 5 Endorsements per team ( 2-offensive, 2 defensive,1 ST)
- limit it to 5 endorsements can be active at once
- Minimum of 2 endorsements per team ( Random)
- No player can get endorsements in back2back seasons
- You can't trade/ release a player with an endorsement unless he is willing to waive his endorsement

Instead of making things more complicated Bort, why not just simplify it and make more of them?
 
Rodion
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
I think you should do an MVP calculation for each position and give the same thing you give now for each position with the top 10 "MVP candidates" getting some chance to win the endorsement then add an MVP endorsement that adds even more than the regular endorsement EQ except the MVPs of the league cannot get their position endorsements


+1

Actually, I'd sort endorsements to the top 5 or so (or maybe simply give them to positional MVP).
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 20:42:44
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Nuge20
I think you should do an MVP calculation for each position and give the same thing you give now for each position with the top 10 "MVP candidates" getting some chance to win the endorsement then add an MVP endorsement that adds even more than the regular endorsement EQ except the MVPs of the league cannot get their position endorsements


Hm...so a tier of endorsments between the "corporate" and "national" level, based on MVP calculations per position.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by odg62
Originally posted by Rezlov

Sounds like a disaster waiting to happen. If the BCS can't decide the top team correctly, how is GLB going to decide the top player?

Not to mention there are FAR more factors and such.


yeah i like the vote idea but i think it opens up a door to people conspiring to see the vote go favorably for them


Its true but I dont think there is no sure way, by voting you may not effect the game as much by forcing starters to run up stats, instead it gives equal opportunity for everyone to be involved.. What do you think Bort?
 
Capaneus
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


I'll have to set something up. I doubt it will be hard to set up. The formula will be the hard part.


Yeah, I realize you likely won't want to release the exact formula, but if you want user input, a sense of how you're thinking about calculating would help us give good feedback.
 
Nuge20
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Nuge20

I think you should do an MVP calculation for each position and give the same thing you give now for each position with the top 10 "MVP candidates" getting some chance to win the endorsement then add an MVP endorsement that adds even more than the regular endorsement EQ except the MVPs of the league cannot get their position endorsements


Hm...so a tier of endorsments between the "corporate" and "national" level, based on MVP calculations per position.


yeah and then a better endorsement for the O MVP/D MVP/ST MVP
 
Hikariu
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by smizzy
I can see 400 threads now " My owner won't play me because he's trying to get his player the MVP award"


Yea. I can't figure out how to award an MVP award by conference.

If you do it random it's bad. If you do it by stats it causes major problems running a team, depth, drama, I want to be the only starter, etc more headaches.

Could the MVP awards be done by playoff team voting? Only players on playoff team are eligible. Would there be to much campaigning or collusion? Maybe voted on by only the playoff team owners? That would be a nice solution in my opinion. Better then some silly MVP calc. One MVP award for Offense, Defense and ST.
Last edited Feb 26, 2009 20:43:54
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by gobolts33
Originally posted by tautology

Originally posted by gobolts33


Originally posted by Bort



Originally posted by tautology




Bort:

Regarding MVPs

The biggest difficulty in determing these sorts of things has to do with palying gutted teams, and the fact some players may face 4 gutted teams while others might face one one (or none).

Does the differential in fame make up for this level of disparity?

For instance-

A level 40 HB can easily pick up 800+ yards and 20 TDs vs a gutted teams. If they play three more gutted teams than an opponent, that is perhaps an 1800 yard and 50 TD "lead" that thye establish against the rest of the league in their primary stat lines.


Solution: In order to prevent this from causing inequities, throw away the 4 best games from each player. That goes a long ways towards making things a bit more even.


With the right weight balance I think fame could actually work pretty well to filter down the gut job masters.

It is also quite possible to go back through and re-calculate the stats that "count" for the purposes of an MVP calculation. Perhaps we could multiply the stats by a percentage, based on the level difference in the teams or the score differential, etc.



This idea dont work for me....What if the player who loses his 4 top games did not play against gutted teams. SO a great build is penalized for no reason...The success of a well built player against a good team is just as much how the teams game plan and AIs work. Sometimes a good team can dominate another good team with a wise game plan and AI. So this would not be fair. If you keep the endorsements within the conference then its an even playing field because all the teams play the same opponents and get to play weak and strong teams...


I heare you and sympathize, but it is very difficult to come up with an alogrithmic method for weeding out gut jobs.

Scounting Bar/ratings? no
Score? no
Level difference? weak, but maybe




I agree with your point aswell.......I really think that some of this stuff just gets overcomplicated. The solution is to simplify it. If the endorsements are "conference" related then its black and white. The conference or league leaders get endorsements and a few other top performers in the conference...The gut jobs are all conference related, so each team in that conference has the same opportunity to stat pad....The best builds and smartest teams win. Thats how it works for league leading trophy's and championships. Keep endorsements in line with everything else.....If you dont build a good player and your on a team that is not ran well then just like all the other perks in the game, you dont get none..lol



Keeping things in confrence helps a lot, but there are still teams that gut mid-season that throw a wrench in the works. This happens pretty often, actually, so it is worth some consideration.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
I think it would be a good time to introduce a MNF game for each league and link the game in each league forum...fame would be doubled for performance in that game...every team would get at least one MNF game a season and they would be based on even-leveled matchups. This would further reward teams that are playing in the right league as they would see more MNF games. As well, it would be a great opportunity to build the game and level of interest for players.

I made the thread a while ago about how to work it, but it is ultimately not my call. I am just suggesting that the game add this for more of a business feel to owning a team/players on top of the extra benefits of getting people more involved.


Like a "starred" game for the season?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.