User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > I don't think slow build works as well as you think.
Page:
 
Rage Kinard
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade


Keeping knowledge to oneself = Personal gain in an internet dotball game.
Spreading knowledge around = Higher quality game in general.

I prefer the latter, because really, who cares if you win if 90% of the players on the game suck?


agreed.

Although no reason for most to worry. I would say about 2/3 of GLB community never looks for this type of stuff and 30-50% of those who do find it won't take advice of others even if they see it.

 
god056
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Octowned
Eh, I prefer to keep some advanced strategies to myself, but help out a lot in the OC and O-line forum. Some things bug me when people talk about. The fill bar to 90% then cap, etc., should never have been talked about. Let people spread their equip, etc. General game knowledge though, I'll talk about.




Why? Isn't it a bit helpful in sharing tips to fellow players, at the same time making the game more challenging, at least a bit
 
geal
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Your problem is you miss the fact that slowbuild spends points as soon as it can cap the currently targetted attribute. So you get the benefit of bigger training sessions without the downside of missing auto-level points past the cap.

If you're building say speed to 68, you generally train to somewhere around 25-28, before hitting level 4 (or even level 3 with good initial rolls, bonus tokens or super-slowbuild). Then BEFORE you hit level 4, you apply most of the skill points to get to 49 speed. Then you start saving the 20 or so skill points you'll need to get to 61. Rather than slow-building costing you auto-level points, it leverages them by hitting caps earlier that a more well-rounded player would.


Why would you save the 20 or so skill points? That makes no sense. The purpose of saving it before was to take advantage of training gains. Saving it after you reach first cap serves 0 purpose.
 
MrMoose
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma

Take a WR for instance. Their natural gains are .33 SP per level for a primary. So at level 3 he has enough to cap speed, say 23.66 speed with 25 SP. Two options: Cap or Wait to level 4:

Cap at level 3, spend all 25 SP: speed = 48.66
level 4 speed = 48.99, with 5 SP

Wait, train speed up another point, cap at level 4:
Level 3 speed: 23.66
Level 4 speed: 24.99 + 24 SP = 48.99 + 6 SP


This bugged me for awhile, but I finally figured out why this is not true. Lets take both theoretical WRs here:

WR A:

Level 3: 23.66 Speed, 25 SP
+25 Speed
Level 3: 48.66 Speed, 0 SP
+ XP, get level 4
Level 4: 48.99 Speed, 5 SP

WR B:

Level 3: 23.66 Speed, 25 SP
+1 Speed
Level 3: 24.66 Speed, 24 SP
+ XP, get level 4
Level 4: 24.99 Speed, 29 SP
+24 Points in Speed
Level 4: 48.99 Speed, 5 SP

You gain no extra SP by putting a single point into speed -- your math never subtracted the initial skill point when you took it from 23-24 at level 3. It assumed there were 25 points in your pool right before you levelled, and 30 when you did level, when there were actually 29.

Basically, if you can cap, you should cap. The only reason to wait is if you aren't about to level and can train the stat to 90% or higher. But if you can hit a softcap, and your build is focused on hitting the softcap ASAP, spending 1 point instead of blowing your wad makes zero difference.
 
Homsar16
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Nuge20

Originally posted by Deathblade


You explain it well...but you don't know how to slow build, so it isn't really much of an argument.






 
drakeborn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
You gain no extra SP by putting a single point into speed -- your math never subtracted the initial skill point when you took it from 23-24 at level 3.


Why would he subtract a SP for training? Training doesn't cost SPs. I think you read him wrong.

 
BuddyHorn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by BuddyHorn

I hate the fact that people that know how to build a team will discuss publicly with the clueless.


Keeping knowledge to oneself = Personal gain in an internet dotball game.
Spreading knowledge around = Higher quality game in general.

I prefer the latter, because really, who cares if you win if 90% of the players on the game suck?


Notice I said publicly. There is nothing wrong with helping a few guys out through PM or private forum. Teh game needs diversity in builds and strategy to be fun.
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MrMoose
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma


Take a WR for instance. Their natural gains are .33 SP per level for a primary. So at level 3 he has enough to cap speed, say 23.66 speed with 25 SP. Two options: Cap or Wait to level 4:

Cap at level 3, spend all 25 SP: speed = 48.66
level 4 speed = 48.99, with 5 SP

Wait, train speed up another point, cap at level 4:
Level 3 speed: 23.66
Level 4 speed: 24.99 + 24 SP = 48.99 + 6 SP


This bugged me for awhile, but I finally figured out why this is not true. Lets take both theoretical WRs here:

WR A:

Level 3: 23.66 Speed, 25 SP
+25 Speed
Level 3: 48.66 Speed, 0 SP
+ XP, get level 4
Level 4: 48.99 Speed, 5 SP

WR B:

Level 3: 23.66 Speed, 25 SP
+1 Speed
Level 3: 24.66 Speed, 24 SP
+ XP, get level 4
Level 4: 24.99 Speed, 29 SP
+24 Points in Speed
Level 4: 48.99 Speed, 5 SP

You gain no extra SP by putting a single point into speed -- your math never subtracted the initial skill point when you took it from 23-24 at level 3. It assumed there were 25 points in your pool right before you levelled, and 30 when you did level, when there were actually 29.

Basically, if you can cap, you should cap. The only reason to wait is if you aren't about to level and can train the stat to 90% or higher. But if you can hit a softcap, and your build is focused on hitting the softcap ASAP, spending 1 point instead of blowing your wad makes zero difference.


Read the bolded part of my post above. The logic is sound. Like I said, the only thing it doesn't take into account is that training on speed could have been spent on a third attribute.
Last edited Jan 8, 2009 08:15:46
 
TheGreatPuma
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by geal
Originally posted by Sarg01

Your problem is you miss the fact that slowbuild spends points as soon as it can cap the currently targetted attribute. So you get the benefit of bigger training sessions without the downside of missing auto-level points past the cap.

If you're building say speed to 68, you generally train to somewhere around 25-28, before hitting level 4 (or even level 3 with good initial rolls, bonus tokens or super-slowbuild). Then BEFORE you hit level 4, you apply most of the skill points to get to 49 speed. Then you start saving the 20 or so skill points you'll need to get to 61. Rather than slow-building costing you auto-level points, it leverages them by hitting caps earlier that a more well-rounded player would.


Why would you save the 20 or so skill points? That makes no sense. The purpose of saving it before was to take advantage of training gains. Saving it after you reach first cap serves 0 purpose.


UNless of course you intend to continue to train it.
 
michoool123
offline
Link
 
I just save my points until I can cap my sub-goal (if it aint soft cap), let the auto level help a little and then take it to my goal. Like if i want 68 in a stat i take it to 61 while saving points and training.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by michoool123
I just save my points until I can cap my sub-goal (if it aint soft cap), let the auto level help a little and then take it to my goal. Like if i want 68 in a stat i take it to 61 while saving points and training.


you have not built a slow build yet. And if you have it's an alt account and you should probably be reported.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TheGreatPuma

UNless of course you intend to continue to train it.


Or you could train the next attribute, and reap the benefits of the level up gains and the training gains, rather than choosing one or the other.
 
saltman241
offline
Link
 
This thread should be stickied and title changed to Simple guide to slow build. It really is amazing how many people have no clue how, why, or what to do to slow build.
 
Underdawg08
offline
Link
 
Slow building is better than you think. A player has a chance to get a certain number of sp's. Every single level 32 player has access to 170 sp's( if my math is right.) And that is IT. once they are spent they are gone FOREVER. If you spend less points because you have trained an attribute up, first it will give you more sp's to work with in the long run. And really it does make you an over all better player.
 
Club America
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by saltman241
Originally posted by Deathblade

You explain it well...but you don't know how to slow build, so it isn't really much of an argument.


This.


This


(man, this isnt even debatable anymore. The earth aint flat)
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.