wrap should make a takcle but they get dragged dwon with the power back
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Serious Question: How much strength/tackling do you think SHOULD be required to stop a very strong power back?
Knicksfan20
offline
offline
Originally posted by Cryptotich
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
I think the HB'S speed and agility should also be a factor in breaking tackles
IF the HB/FB has low speed or agility...they shouldnt be able to break tackles as much....being pure strength shouldnt mean shit.
the faster you are moving...with your strength...the better you should be at breaking tackles.
a player with 80 speed and 80 strength should be harder to bring down then somone with 100 strength and 60 speed.
and agility play in the fact just for the acceleration....if you got a rb like Brandon Jacobs running full speed....and his size and strength...it is nearly impossible to stop him.
but if he doesnt get much of a chance to get going...it will be much easier to stop him.
So "momentum" should play a huge role in this...SO IMO to answer your question bort
50 strength and 60 tackling should be able to stop a big power back
once you start limiting players to HAVE TO LOAD str and tackle...and neglect speed/agility (opposite of what is going on now) then speed back will start to dominate and that will be the next problem.
a player with
60 str/60agility/60speed/60tackle should be like...the ultimate build in this game.
JMO
GREAT ADVICE!!!!!
Er.... What level of play are you talking about? Cause no one in my 13 cap league can hit that.
well taht would be like a 30-40 level player or so....was just coming upw ith numbers...
i could of also used the example
40 speed and 40 str should be better then 60 str and 20 speed
30sp/30str/40tackle/30agil for mlb
40sp/30str/30tackle/30 agily for safety
60spd/20str/20tackle/40 agility for cb
ect ect
like that....a player shouldnt be able to totally neglect one attribute and get away with it...Wrs and Cbs dont need to be too strong...but you cant have DTs with 90 speed and get away with it...or mlbs with 20 tackle...that is just crazy
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
I think the HB'S speed and agility should also be a factor in breaking tackles
IF the HB/FB has low speed or agility...they shouldnt be able to break tackles as much....being pure strength shouldnt mean shit.
the faster you are moving...with your strength...the better you should be at breaking tackles.
a player with 80 speed and 80 strength should be harder to bring down then somone with 100 strength and 60 speed.
and agility play in the fact just for the acceleration....if you got a rb like Brandon Jacobs running full speed....and his size and strength...it is nearly impossible to stop him.
but if he doesnt get much of a chance to get going...it will be much easier to stop him.
So "momentum" should play a huge role in this...SO IMO to answer your question bort
50 strength and 60 tackling should be able to stop a big power back
once you start limiting players to HAVE TO LOAD str and tackle...and neglect speed/agility (opposite of what is going on now) then speed back will start to dominate and that will be the next problem.
a player with
60 str/60agility/60speed/60tackle should be like...the ultimate build in this game.
JMO
GREAT ADVICE!!!!!
Er.... What level of play are you talking about? Cause no one in my 13 cap league can hit that.
well taht would be like a 30-40 level player or so....was just coming upw ith numbers...
i could of also used the example
40 speed and 40 str should be better then 60 str and 20 speed
30sp/30str/40tackle/30agil for mlb
40sp/30str/30tackle/30 agily for safety
60spd/20str/20tackle/40 agility for cb
ect ect
like that....a player shouldnt be able to totally neglect one attribute and get away with it...Wrs and Cbs dont need to be too strong...but you cant have DTs with 90 speed and get away with it...or mlbs with 20 tackle...that is just crazy
ken-in-rockwall
offline
offline
The difference between power versus elusive I would think be based on a table with Strength, Agility, and Vision. The higher the Strength parameter = more of a power back where as higher Agility and Vision = elusive.
maizenhops
offline
offline
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kalkmanc
the gang tackling is the main thing.its pretty fake when there are 8 defensive dots on top of 1 offensive dots and they all miss the tackle.
Maybe that's the next thing I need to look at adding - the ability to be dragged and slow down the guy when missing a tackle instead of just always bouncing off.
Seems like the HBs are already slowing quite a bit when they plow through guys...does it not?
they get slower, but they still don't get tackled.doesn't matter how fast you go if you can't get tackled.
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kalkmanc
the gang tackling is the main thing.its pretty fake when there are 8 defensive dots on top of 1 offensive dots and they all miss the tackle.
Maybe that's the next thing I need to look at adding - the ability to be dragged and slow down the guy when missing a tackle instead of just always bouncing off.
Seems like the HBs are already slowing quite a bit when they plow through guys...does it not?
they get slower, but they still don't get tackled.doesn't matter how fast you go if you can't get tackled.
Nuge20
offline
offline
Originally posted by kalkmanc
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kalkmanc
the gang tackling is the main thing.its pretty fake when there are 8 defensive dots on top of 1 offensive dots and they all miss the tackle.
Maybe that's the next thing I need to look at adding - the ability to be dragged and slow down the guy when missing a tackle instead of just always bouncing off.
Seems like the HBs are already slowing quite a bit when they plow through guys...does it not?
they get slower, but they still don't get tackled.doesn't matter how fast you go if you can't get tackled.
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by kalkmanc
the gang tackling is the main thing.its pretty fake when there are 8 defensive dots on top of 1 offensive dots and they all miss the tackle.
Maybe that's the next thing I need to look at adding - the ability to be dragged and slow down the guy when missing a tackle instead of just always bouncing off.
Seems like the HBs are already slowing quite a bit when they plow through guys...does it not?
they get slower, but they still don't get tackled.doesn't matter how fast you go if you can't get tackled.
Knicksfan20
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort
How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?
Well, elusive broken tackles and power broken tackles are calculated differently ain't they? Maybe it should be "power moves" and "elusive moves" instead of "power/elusive back".
Elusive guys don't really break tackles except for spinning - they avoid contact entirely with fakes and such. Breaking tackles is a power back thing.
Maybe just
Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked
That is pretty stupid though....elusive guys should be able to break tackles too...
when you got somone who is quick and agile...it is hard to stay in front of him or anticipate his movements...thus...only being able to get like 2 hand on his leg or something....speed backs break tackles all the time....they may not run people over...but they will break tackles...something this game doesnt have for speed backs which kinda sucks
Originally posted by Deathblade
Originally posted by Bort
How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?
Well, elusive broken tackles and power broken tackles are calculated differently ain't they? Maybe it should be "power moves" and "elusive moves" instead of "power/elusive back".
Elusive guys don't really break tackles except for spinning - they avoid contact entirely with fakes and such. Breaking tackles is a power back thing.
Maybe just
Power: more likely to get fooled by head fake/juke/spin
Wrap: more likely to get trucked
That is pretty stupid though....elusive guys should be able to break tackles too...
when you got somone who is quick and agile...it is hard to stay in front of him or anticipate his movements...thus...only being able to get like 2 hand on his leg or something....speed backs break tackles all the time....they may not run people over...but they will break tackles...something this game doesnt have for speed backs which kinda sucks
Robbnva
offline
offline
Personally I think to stop a power back, an LB has to have a MINIMUM of 60 Strength AND Tackling
Korwin
offline
offline
if the running back breaks one tackle, does the chance to break a 2nd tackle go down? I'd figure that gang tackling would be best to stop the power backs. Then make more difficult to break the 3rd, 4th and 5th tackle in a play.
Deathblade
offline
offline
Originally posted by Knicksfan20
That is pretty stupid though....elusive guys should be able to break tackles too...
when you got somone who is quick and agile...it is hard to stay in front of him or anticipate his movements...thus...only being able to get like 2 hand on his leg or something....speed backs break tackles all the time....they may not run people over...but they will break tackles...something this game doesnt have for speed backs which kinda sucks
Faking someone out is basically an elusive backs broken tackle...
That is pretty stupid though....elusive guys should be able to break tackles too...
when you got somone who is quick and agile...it is hard to stay in front of him or anticipate his movements...thus...only being able to get like 2 hand on his leg or something....speed backs break tackles all the time....they may not run people over...but they will break tackles...something this game doesnt have for speed backs which kinda sucks
Faking someone out is basically an elusive backs broken tackle...
iMan
offline
offline
Originally posted by the man of doom
wrap should make a takcle but they get dragged dwon with the power back
that never happens on heads up tackling cuz it cant possibly occur
to be trucked you need to tackle from an angle
I think the question should be
"how much str + tackling should be required to an open field tackle?"
in the box, it doesnt take much tackling to bring a power back down if you have many heads around
wrap should make a takcle but they get dragged dwon with the power back
that never happens on heads up tackling cuz it cant possibly occur
to be trucked you need to tackle from an angle
I think the question should be
"how much str + tackling should be required to an open field tackle?"
in the box, it doesnt take much tackling to bring a power back down if you have many heads around
Polorl69
offline
offline
80+ strength
70+ Tackling
for D line and LB's
A bit less for the secondary but as stated earlier 4 yd dive and stiff arm should be more effective against the secondary
70+ Tackling
for D line and LB's
A bit less for the secondary but as stated earlier 4 yd dive and stiff arm should be more effective against the secondary
WestbrookFTW
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by Deathblade
Power Tackling
Pros:
Effective at stopping Powerbacks in their tracks.
Causes more fumbles.
Cons:
More likely to get faked out by elusive backs
More likely to miss tackles against elusive backs
Wrap-Up
Pros:
Effective against elusive backs
High tackle rate
Cons:
More likely to get plowed over by power backs, giving them an extra yard or two
More likely to miss tackles against power backs
How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?
Well, based upon how they approach you. If you're on Power Tackling in the open field against a RB and that RB tries to plow through me, the power tackling will kind of off set it. If they try to do some sort of spin or juke, the ability to "wrap up" and just get him down is more important.
Think of it like the Hit Stick on Madden. If you want to tackle The Bus in the open field, you better use the Hit Stick (or Power Tackling) if you want to bring him down. Otherwise, he'll either drag you for 5 yards and go down, or break the tackle and keep going. However, if you try to use the Hit Stick on a small, Maurice Jones-Drew type of back, you will find you'll miss a lot more often due to them being so quick and agile. However, if you do land a Hit Stick type of hit on these backs, due to their low strength, you should have a great chance of creating a fumble.
Originally posted by Deathblade
Power Tackling
Pros:
Effective at stopping Powerbacks in their tracks.
Causes more fumbles.
Cons:
More likely to get faked out by elusive backs
More likely to miss tackles against elusive backs
Wrap-Up
Pros:
Effective against elusive backs
High tackle rate
Cons:
More likely to get plowed over by power backs, giving them an extra yard or two
More likely to miss tackles against power backs
How do you define "elusive" or "power" back for this, though? Just based on their running style?
Well, based upon how they approach you. If you're on Power Tackling in the open field against a RB and that RB tries to plow through me, the power tackling will kind of off set it. If they try to do some sort of spin or juke, the ability to "wrap up" and just get him down is more important.
Think of it like the Hit Stick on Madden. If you want to tackle The Bus in the open field, you better use the Hit Stick (or Power Tackling) if you want to bring him down. Otherwise, he'll either drag you for 5 yards and go down, or break the tackle and keep going. However, if you try to use the Hit Stick on a small, Maurice Jones-Drew type of back, you will find you'll miss a lot more often due to them being so quick and agile. However, if you do land a Hit Stick type of hit on these backs, due to their low strength, you should have a great chance of creating a fumble.
n:iceman:16
offline
offline
Originally posted by Korwin
if the running back breaks one tackle, does the chance to break a 2nd tackle go down? I'd figure that gang tackling would be best to stop the power backs. Then make more difficult to break the 3rd, 4th and 5th tackle in a play.
Should go up. Should be like in Madden imo. Even the strongest guys should be able to break 1 tackle if they get the chance to truck a guy, and should get tired and having difficulty doing so again.
if the running back breaks one tackle, does the chance to break a 2nd tackle go down? I'd figure that gang tackling would be best to stop the power backs. Then make more difficult to break the 3rd, 4th and 5th tackle in a play.
Should go up. Should be like in Madden imo. Even the strongest guys should be able to break 1 tackle if they get the chance to truck a guy, and should get tired and having difficulty doing so again.
Saris
offline
offline
Originally posted by Bort
Maybe that's the next thing I need to look at adding - the ability to be dragged and slow down the guy when missing a tackle instead of just always bouncing off.
This should be a major part of the strength and tackling attributes, even if a player who has poor values in these stats makes a tackle they should be dragged if they don't have a ton of momentum built up (ie a head on collision). And even if a player with high values in these stats misses a tackle they should be able to slow down the back considerably.
Maybe that's the next thing I need to look at adding - the ability to be dragged and slow down the guy when missing a tackle instead of just always bouncing off.
This should be a major part of the strength and tackling attributes, even if a player who has poor values in these stats makes a tackle they should be dragged if they don't have a ton of momentum built up (ie a head on collision). And even if a player with high values in these stats misses a tackle they should be able to slow down the back considerably.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























