User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Announcements > Customer Support & Vet Abilities
Page:
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Originally posted by YardRat

I have yet to apply any VA pts for any of my players, but...

1)A complete 'wipe' or 'do-over' isn't fair to those who have used them and are satisfied with their choices.

2)I wouldn't be opposed to a mechanism that works similar to equipment...The ability to 'sell back' VA's and be re-imbursed half of their value for re-use.


everyone's entitled to their opinion i suppose. but what exactly is unfair about it, care to elaborate?



Let's put this another way. Constantly bailing people out of their own mistakes is a dis-incentive to be responsible and try to get things right the first time........

Or put yet another way........ suppose everybody is taking a test at school. Group A studies for the test, thinks over their answers, and go figure they get an A. Group B studies for the test, thinks over their answers, but they all got D's.

Group B whines at the teacher about how the questions were poorly worded, they were tricked because the teacher wants them to fail, etc,etc. The teacher changes some of the questions, decides to give out the answers to a lot of them too, and forces everyone to retake the test. Can you seriously not see how Group A would be upset?

 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Such fine examples of good sportsmanship! And keeping the thread fresh! Thank you!


Any owner or GM worth their salt would have advised their team to hold off on assigning VXP until things had a chance to settle down and to let the herd make their mistakes and to learn from it. We've been down this path soooooooooo many times, and you know since you've been here since April!

Surely, I'm not the only parent here who sees the life lesson to be learned from this?
 
Rot
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sbuck143


Let's put this another way. Constantly bailing people out of their own mistakes is a dis-incentive to be responsible and try to get things right the first time........

Or put yet another way........ suppose everybody is taking a test at school. Group A studies for the test, thinks over their answers, and go figure they get an A. Group B studies for the test, thinks over their answers, but they all got D's.

Group B whines at the teacher about how the questions were poorly worded, they were tricked because the teacher wants them to fail, etc,etc. The teacher changes some of the questions, decides to give out the answers to a lot of them too, and forces everyone to retake the test. Can you seriously not see how Group A would be upset?



Congratulations- an analogy SO flawed that it not worth my time (which, believe you me, is not worth much) to correct it. A superb job, sir.
 
Havoc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sbuck143


Any owner or GM worth their salt would have advised their team to hold off on assigning VXP until things had a chance to settle down and to let the herd make their mistakes and to learn from it.


Bort comes out and says directly that Special Teamer doesnt apply to the KR/PR. I suggested to my KR to go ahead and spend his points elsewhere. A couple days later Bort changes the VA.

I must be the worst owner ever.

Add on top of that the confusion about Mr. Reliable because of the unclear wording.

I think the life lesson is one about good customer service.

 
atom871
offline
Link
 
We aren't talking about 'life lessons' here. This isn't school and it certainly isn't parenting. Bort rolled out a cool new system which allowed us to allocate some interesting, yet vague, player modifications. It's a game, it's beta and the majority of us are paying towards this work-in-progress, which i am thoroughly enjoying. It's more a of a customer service issue at this point and also a lesson learned for GLB coders and players alike.

This retro-fit was released with poor descriptions and points were applied that, as a player cannot be adjusted. Now, a great number of paying customers are asking for a simple re-allocation. It is not just me. If you have not allocated your points, then this will not affect you at all. Perhaps you should spend your time helping those school kids study or show your children what good sportsmanship is rather than argue against something that is inconsequential to you.

If you have allocated your points and are happy about it, a wipe gives you an opportunity to reconsider where your points went. I would imagine that just about every agent out there would do something just a bit different with his points if admin did a VA point wipe.
 
Eli Blanton
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Havoc


Bort comes out and says directly that Special Teamer doesnt apply to the KR/PR. I suggested to my KR to go ahead and spend his points elsewhere. A couple days later Bort changes the VA.

I must be the worst owner ever.

Add on top of that the confusion about Mr. Reliable because of the unclear wording.

I think the life lesson is one about good customer service.



I agree with everything except the life-lesson. It could just as easily be in poor customer service. That's for Bort to decide.
 
Sain621
offline
Link
 
Atom871, Havoc, and Rot just owned the entire anti-wipe argument in this page alone. There is no reason, not a single one except this one:

Originally posted by Ubasstards
i say leave vet abilities as is. I havent assigned mine yet and i like to see my competition assigning them incorrectly


And even though I assigned mine right, I think a wipe is only fair, seeing as it wasn't completely the users' fault. Management made a mistake, if they have the power to unmake it, they should. And seeing as the Season starts in as little as a dozen hours, a wipe won't happen. Management basically stuck a huge middle finger at all its agents and said deal with it.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
And how many times has Bort said one thing, then been convinced by a loud faction to give them what they want and do the exact opposite? You've been here from day 1 season 1 Havoc. The answer to that question is about a billion. It happened here, and it burned you / your kick returner.

You are obviously not the worst owner ever, but you made a mistake here. One that your prior 9 months in GLB had given you countless examples from which to learn.

Here is a very valuable piece of advice to everyone reading this thread from here on out

................whenever a major change happens in GLB, and involves you doing something permanent to your character, wait for at least 14 days before doing ANYTHING related to that change. No matter what Bort says, and this goes double if you've spent any money on the game at all. The part of you that says "OMG my player is goin to suck while everyone else will be uber" needs to listen to the part of you that says "But i don't want to be the guy whining on page 78 of the 'Bort *MUST* fix this thread' "

2nd very valuable piece of advice

When Bort gives you all the re-wipe you so desparately need (and I have a feeling he will)......................FOLLOW the FIRST PIECE OF ADVICE. Don't spend those newly freed VXP, and wait for the fallout.

Buck out.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sain621
Atom871, Havoc, and Rot just owned the entire anti-wipe argument in this page alone. There is no reason, not a single one except this one:

Originally posted by Ubasstards

i say leave vet abilities as is. I havent assigned mine yet and i like to see my competition assigning them incorrectly


And even though I assigned mine right, I think a wipe is only fair, seeing as it wasn't completely the users' fault. Management made a mistake, if they have the power to unmake it, they should. And seeing as the Season starts in as little as a dozen hours, a wipe won't happen. Management basically stuck a huge middle finger at all its agents and said deal with it.


c/s
 
Sain621
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by atom871
Originally posted by Sain621

Atom871, Havoc, and Rot just owned the entire anti-wipe argument in this page alone. There is no reason, not a single one except this one:

Originally posted by Ubasstards


i say leave vet abilities as is. I havent assigned mine yet and i like to see my competition assigning them incorrectly


And even though I assigned mine right, I think a wipe is only fair, seeing as it wasn't completely the users' fault. Management made a mistake, if they have the power to unmake it, they should. And seeing as the Season starts in as little as a dozen hours, a wipe won't happen. Management basically stuck a huge middle finger at all its agents and said deal with it.


c/s


What does c/s mean?
 
Razorthorns
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by Razorthorns


Actually you don't get it. Many people thought they understodd it just fine but due to bad wording were simply wrong. Bort has admitted this but just refuses to give the points back which is wrong.

I am not blasting Bort for trying to improve the game. I applaud him for it and think its great! But reguardless when things are implemented poorly then he needs to take the proper steps to reeducate the gamers and do the logical reset and start over before the games count.

A buisiness that fails to listen to it's customers is doomed to fail. That is not soemthing I want for Bort as then the hundreds of dollars I've spent on this game will be really wasted. Do the right thing Bort.


So then you support the complete rerolls for the people who had their players neutered due to the speed, or agility, or blocking, or any number of changes?

They not only read the documentation, but followed the game rules to develop players which were suddenly neutered because they were too good. They have just as much right, in fact more right to complain about the game improvements impinging on their fun.

Right now there are significant problems with the new Sim, power backs may need looking at, Safety blitzing definitely needs looking at, the relationship between the offensive and defensive line needs to be looked at.

If people cry every time he puts something new into the game, this simply will never become a product and will perpetually be in Beta, and No, sorry, this is not a releasable product yet.

PinTBC


Well since I for one don't think Speed was nerfed to begin with i'd say no. I'd also say no for a game mechanics reason as you would have to reset their player to level 1 for it to be worth anything. The cost of reputting points into attributes say at level 40 after all those free attribute points from leveling up would be impossible to restore. For instance a level 40 player who softcapped speed at say 60 by level 8 by level 40 would have almost 66 to 70 speed without gear. those 6 to 10 points are worth a ton of SP and there is no way to refund them without resetting you player to level 1.

VA's don't have that problem and the easy solution was asked for well before the very first game so no impact would have taken place. There are also no bonus points in VA that would be effected as there are in attributes.

In my opinion if you have the chance to fix a simple mistake it should be done. or hell about this? each season you can spend 100 flexpoints to redisbute you VA points. Bort gives us 100 flexpoints each season so even a free player can do this at no cost and it is completely fair.
 
Joe Buck
offline
Link
 
Sain

That reason essentially boils down to a slippery slope debate.

If you roll back the VXP mistakes, I'd really love to get back all the pts in Return Specialist I spent back in Season 2 for my now lvl 43 CB. Back then Bort essentially admitted it wasn't working and was broken. I dont think it works right to this day and thats like 7 months later.

That wasn't an unclearly worded item, or something missing a key descriptor, it just wasnt turned on! But this is the first time I've mentioned it. Never asked for my pts back. 16 of them.

Really, doing a wipe of VXP will unleash a TORRENT of threads asking for a re-do of this SA or that ability. The precedent will be set. And while you all might have a perfectly, rationally worded logical defense for why YOUR re-wipe is justified and THEIRS is not..........don't expect Bort to stand tall against it.
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
c/s = co-signed (i agree)
 
Sain621
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Razorthorns

Well since I for one don't think Speed was nerfed to begin with i'd say no. I'd also say no for a game mechanics reason as you would have to reset their player to level 1 for it to be worth anything. The cost of reputting points into attributes say at level 40 after all those free attribute points from leveling up would be impossible to restore. For instance a level 40 player who softcapped speed at say 60 by level 8 by level 40 would have almost 66 to 70 speed without gear. those 6 to 10 points are worth a ton of SP and there is no way to refund them without resetting you player to level 1.

VA's don't have that problem and the easy solution was asked for well before the very first game so no impact would have taken place. There are also no bonus points in VA that would be effected as there are in attributes.

In my opinion if you have the chance to fix a simple mistake it should be done. or hell about this? each season you can spend 100 flexpoints to redisbute you VA points. Bort gives us 100 flexpoints each season so even a free player can do this at no cost and it is completely fair.


Beautiful.
Last edited Jan 1, 2009 21:45:47
 
atom871
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sbuck143
Sain

That reason essentially boils down to a slippery slope debate.

If you roll back the VXP mistakes, I'd really love to get back all the pts in Return Specialist I spent back in Season 2 for my now lvl 43 CB. Back then Bort essentially admitted it wasn't working and was broken. I dont think it works right to this day and thats like 7 months later.

That wasn't an unclearly worded item, or something missing a key descriptor, it just wasnt turned on! But this is the first time I've mentioned it. Never asked for my pts back. 16 of them.

Really, doing a wipe of VXP will unleash a TORRENT of threads asking for a re-do of this SA or that ability. The precedent will be set. And while you all might have a perfectly, rationally worded logical defense for why YOUR re-wipe is justified and THEIRS is not..........don't expect Bort to stand tall against it.


Here's the thing, i wouldn't argue against it..............................
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.