User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > South America A Leagues > South America A #3 > The Committee's League Wide Pro Bowl Team
Page:
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Man you try hard, I will give you props for that.

But I thought you were after the BETTER HB, not the more consistent one.

But I guess if you really wanted to compare them, you would have to compare, oh I don't know, the offensive line, unless you really think Dragon was the only player out there.

Let's assume these are good builds because they arent open to me.

Punata

LOT - LVL 28
ROT - LVL 28
ROG - LVL 33
LOG - LVL 28
C - LVL 27

Cape Horn

LOT - LVL 34
ROT - LVL 30
LOG - LVL 39
ROG - LVL 32
C - LVL 32

All things being equal, Tails would have gotten your numbers running behind that line, if you don't understand that, you are completely lost.

 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Please don't let it die, I am bored at work again lol
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MGood030
Originally posted by oakland360

You do realize how stupid your argument is. So let me get this right. You'd rather take the less consistent RB who on 5 separate occasions this season failed to gain 100yds on the ground or score a Td? Over the 1 RB in the league that put up a 100yds and a Td on pretty much everyone no matter the opponent? The only time he came close to being held short was against Fisher where he had 99yds and 3 touchdowns. So is that the logic you people are trying to throw my way. If so than it's flawed. It's a safe bet that you'll never be a head football coach or GM anytime soon.

Tell me this, who would you take as your QB, Manning or Brady? Please say you'd rather have Brady so I can laugh at you. You always take the more consistent player. It's a no brainer, Hands down. People that take the flashy new toy over old reliable crack me up every time. If that's really how you approach things than you need to be in my Fantasy football league so I can dominate you. Your the type of person that I said thank you to for letting me draft Peyton Manning in the 2nd round. Ya you go ahead and go with that philosophy right there. See how far it gets ya.

Oh and just so you know. Not even your fumble argement holds any weight when talking about "Tails" Prowler Vs. McDragon. Sure he fumbled 10 times, but only lost 8 of them. Putting the ball on the ground and still retaining possession doesn't count bro. Ask any football player. So two of those can be swept under the rug and forgotten about. The ones lost are what matters. So in that aspect, we're really only only talking about 8 fumbles here. Which is only 4 more than "Tails" P(who fumbled 4 times this season, all of them turnovers). Two of the games "Tails" fumbled in, his team lost. So you can also argue that none of McDragons fumbles hurt his team. Opponents only scored 1 time off of any of those 8 fumbles, which was a late, 4th quarter meaningless touchdown scored by Rio. A game that was already a blowout. How many yards did Tails put up against Rio by the way? Which happens to the team with the best rushing defense in the league. Was it 100yds. Nope not even close. But guess what? McDragon put up well over 100 on them.

And why everyone keeps trying to discredit the Broken tackles stat is beyond me. Not one back in this league that isn't already on my team had more broken tackles than McDragon. Meaning that most of McDragons 3609yds came with defenders trying to bring him down. That's the whole Shaq thing. You can slow him down, but you can't stop him. He's gonna get his regardless. Teams have found a way to either shutdown, shut-out or contain Prowler this year. Plus besides the top 2-3 teams in Zeta, Alpha is a way harder conference. Would Prowler put up those numbers vs. Rio... nope he already failed at that. How bout against Port Royal. I doubt it, and would love to see him try. How bout against ShortBus? Doubt it. How bout against Fisher before they gutted themselves. Not likely. Trujillo. Maybee, but unlikely. He might have a chance vs. Israel, but I'd bet he comes up short there. Against the Jags. Ya, I'll give him that. But his team would probably still lose. Plus McDragon is a lower level player. Prowler is playing with more SP than McDragon is, this I guarantee. Just wait until I put my level 32 upgrades on. Oh ya didn't know. I haven't purchased those yet. LOL... McDragon is the better RB by far. Fuck the fumbles. It's only a difference of 4 fumbles we're talking about here. It's only a difference of maybe 1 yard per carry.

Tell me this, since you like to live in the land of what-ifs, just who's stats end up higher outta these two comparisons I'm about to give you. Which is basically your argument vs. mine.

Your arguement...
Give "Tails" P the extra 41 carries at 10.6 yards a carry. Making his total rushing yards only 41 more yards than what McDragon currently has. Yup that's the math on that one my friend. And that's still a big what if. Cause there's no guarantee he would keep his average up with those extra carries.

My arguement...
Give McDragon an equal amount of plays per game, which in turn would make the favored RB in almost every offensive situation. Who's numbers end up better? Ya sure you'll want to argue ypc. But the end result is what matters. Not the what-ifs, cause if that's what mattered here. Just how many yards and Touchdowns would he have ended up with if I had him being the only RB on the team to get any love? Remember... I have another 2566yds and 51 TD's that I can bring into this conversation. Cause the carries to Fu Su Lu could've easily been given to McDragon instead. And another thing to add to this point. While 10.6ypc and 9.6 really aren't that much of a difference. 9.6ypc is a big difference over 7.7ypc. So there for McDragon could've easily had another 3000 yards if your doing the math right. So you see, your what if's don't matter. All that matters is the end result. And the end result is that McDragon is the Better RB. We're not talking about WR's here. For you to have to bring in a whole different stat category to validate your argument is laughable. Cause once again. Prowler had way more drops than McDragon and not that many more catches. Prowler only had 14 more catches, but 6 more drops. Was tackled for a loss more than McDragon. Broke way less tackles than McDragon(93 to 244). Had a lower yards per game average even though he saw the field more often. Plus you have to bring in a new stat category for him, to make him nearly as productive. Your point is illogical and stupid.


Did you honestly just say "Give McDragon Equal Playing Time"

Dude, when your a running back plays per game do not matter. They are insignificant if your not running the ball. You ran the ball more than Prowler. He's the only one your allowed to what-if about as far as playing time. Again, your arguement is still ruined by plain as day, black and white statistics that don't favor McDragon. Not in rushing or recieving, and then you get to the fact that he put the ball on the ground double of the other. This is a simple case of WHO IS BETTER. These things I'm telling you are all that matter. Not how it affected Cape Horn, not how many there actually were, nobody cares about that. It's the fact they happened and if has to factor into the arguement or I'd have down Miles a disservice.

Also, everyone here knows your arguement. We went through it yesterday. Nobody here believes the crap your selling, and for good reason. None of it makes any damn sense. Why don't you just let it die, for all of our sanity.


Actually Mgood, if you weren't so blinded by your stubborness to admit your wrong you'd see the error in your statement. Giving them equal playing time would mean alot, since Cape Horn obviously runs alot more frequently than Punata. Meaning that alot more of the carries and touchdowns that went to Fu Su Lu, would've ended up going to McDragon. Giving him better numbers than he currently owns. Don't be blind to your own argument. You used this same point when trying to explain why you picked an offensive line man over another in the OP of this very thread I do believe. And when I use it back against you... you throw the fumbles at me... 4 fumbles doesn't match/make up for the difference of 4 more rushing touchdowns. Cause we're only talking about rushing stats here. For you to have to bring in the receiving category when besides the touchdowns, isn't much of a difference either. Only weakens your own stance on the subject. Ypc doesn't mean as much as Ypg does. 65 rushing touchdowns is more impressive than 61. 225.6ypg is more impressive than 219.8ypg.
244 broken tackles is far more impressive than 93(more than double). And your going to try to use 4 fumbles and 1 more ypc as your reason? That's straight stupid and is very biased. Don't care what you say. It is what it is. You've made so many biased opinions concerning my team this year it's not even funny. Putting players from your own team in from your version of the pro-bowl when there's others more deserving. Man you didn't even get the name of the title correct. A pro Bowl... concerns two seperate conferences. McDragon should have been in his own conference all by him self with the argument in Zeta being between Paul Thorn, "Tails" P and Noel Devine(who also deserves to be rated higher than "Tails" P). Get real bro. I respect you... but your bias on the topic of Alpha vs. Zeta is showing and your not even big enough to admit it. That at least I openly do. I don't hide it. Your even biased on who the best TE in the league is. You'll say Tight Goodman all day, won't ya? I'm sure both Hans Solo and Broodemore Escalade would disagree with you. Hans Solo put up numbers comparable to, if not better than those nof Tight. While Escalade did something unheard of. Put up O-lineman type numbers with a crap load of pancakes... over 100 actually. And this is a TE we're talking about. Plus he didn't drop not 1 pass thrown his way all season. That's right. No drops.
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Man you try hard, I will give you props for that.

But I thought you were after the BETTER HB, not the more consistent one.

But I guess if you really wanted to compare them, you would have to compare, oh I don't know, the offensive line, unless you really think Dragon was the only player out there.

Let's assume these are good builds because they arent open to me.

Punata

LOT - LVL 28
ROT - LVL 28
ROG - LVL 33
LOG - LVL 28
C - LVL 27

Cape Horn

LOT - LVL 34
ROT - LVL 30
LOG - LVL 39
ROG - LVL 32
C - LVL 32

All things being equal, Tails would have gotten your numbers running behind that line, if you don't understand that, you are completely lost.



There you go switching the argument to suit your needs. Back to the world of what if's. What if Barry Sanders played for Dallas? Blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

Dude leave the land of what-ifs already. The facts are that he doesn't play for my team. And there's no way to know or will never be anyway to know what he could do behind my O-line. But guess what he didn't play behind my line. I did. I have the better numbers by far. Consistency is a factor when talking All-Pro and Pro Bowl. You show me 1 player who went to the hall of fame that wasn't consistent. You show me one player that made the pro bowl(NFL) this year that isn't considered consistent.
This is a game that's based off of the rules of real football. So if someone is going to attempt to put together a Pro Bowl and say he's unbiased. When it comes down to two players who's numbers are similar in ypc but where McDragons are better in every other category except for fumbles. Which he only really lost 4 more. Than you have to go with the more consistent player. Those 5 games alone, with out any other stat show that Tails doesn't belong in the convo. Even Noel Divine was more consistent than him, and put up what could be a better stat line. If you honestly can't see that and want to stay in your land of what ifs... than there's no point in wasting my time. Come at me with a real/valid arguement. Not this what if shit. Go look at the game logs. Proof is in the pudding.
 
oakland360
offline
Link
 
oh and for the record I did let it die... Smjay brought it back up this morning.

And I'm spitting facts and stats your direction...

It's you that's using opinions. But opinions are like assholes, everyones got 1. Stats and facts on the other hand... Everyone must use the same. You've yet to explain how you overlooked the fact that Tails had 5 bad games while McDragon had none. It's consistency baby. No other back was more consistent. And wasn't that also your point in giving Agent X the Defensive MVP... It's your crap that no one should be buying. At least I can admit when I'm wrong. Read your own words, than go look at the game logs.

The one common opponent the two shared that truly mattered(another of your points used against Cape Horn, when talking about games against opponents that matter) is against Rio, were counting scrimmage games in which case you have to throw in my games against your Dreads and Valencia. You do that and my point is proven even further. But were only going to talk about regular season games here. "Tails" P fell flat on his face against the Titans, While McDragon shined.

Stop being a homer....
 
DaStick88
offline
Link
 
Here is a stat for you

Votes for McDragon - Oak
Votes against - SA #3

SA #3 > Oak

you must be so angry because you root for the Radiers out there.... I guess I would be angry too when the only football I could win is dots on a simulation.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
LMFAO are you kidding me,

Dragon is now an hall of fame back? You are seriously stuck on stupid.

BTW if you want to get out of the "what if" scenarios, then FFS stop using the " but if Dragon got more playing time" routine, you can't have it both ways cupcake.

I love how the fact that 65 TD is MUCH MORE impressive than 61, a difference of FOUR. Yet, your EIGHT fumbles lost to his FOUR, a difference of FOUR, isn't impressive on his side, funny how that works.
 
Mr. Dumass
offline
Link
 
Who would win a pickled pig feet eating contest between "Tails" P, McDragon, Pissed Off Japanese Minnow Farmer and McRib?




 
brettlevy
offline
Link
 
Here would be my suggestion for Oakland. Get a job or go to class (depending on how old you are). Anyone who has this much time to argue for his RB for the Pro Bowl when he wasn't even the best RB on his own team, needs to get out of his mom's house and do something.
 
Mr. Dumass
offline
Link
 
This forum is going to be dead next season w/o oak. Which one of you midget haters is going to pick up the slack?
 
GMathiasf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oakland360
You do realize how stupid your argument is. So let me get this right. You'd rather take the less consistent RB who on 5 separate occasions this season failed to gain 100yds on the ground or score a Td? Over the 1 RB in the league that put up a 100yds and a Td on pretty much everyone no matter the opponent? The only time he came close to being held short was against Fisher where he had 99yds and 3 touchdowns. So is that the logic you people are trying to throw my way. If so than it's flawed. It's a safe bet that you'll never be a head football coach or GM anytime soon.


I agree with you that consistency is important, but you can't blame the guy for not getting carries in some of those games. Would I take a guy using your argument, all else being equal, that was more consistent, yes. Unfortunately, all else is not equal.

Originally posted by
Tell me this, who would you take as your QB, Manning or Brady? Please say you'd rather have Brady so I can laugh at you. You always take the more consistent player. It's a no brainer, Hands down. People that take the flashy new toy over old reliable crack me up every time. If that's really how you approach things than you need to be in my Fantasy football league so I can dominate you. Your the type of person that I said thank you to for letting me draft Peyton Manning in the 2nd round. Ya you go ahead and go with that philosophy right there. See how far it gets ya.


Though i would take Manning, there is definitely an argument for Brady. The guy has more rings with arguably less talent. But this really is pointless.

Originally posted by
Oh and just so you know. Not even your fumble argement holds any weight when talking about "Tails" Prowler Vs. McDragon. Sure he fumbled 10 times, but only lost 8 of them. Putting the ball on the ground and still retaining possession doesn't count bro. Ask any football player. So two of those can be swept under the rug and forgotten about. The ones lost are what matters. So in that aspect, we're really only only talking about 8 fumbles here. Which is only 4 more than "Tails" P(who fumbled 4 times this season, all of them turnovers). Two of the games "Tails" fumbled in, his team lost. So you can also argue that none of McDragons fumbles hurt his team. Opponents only scored 1 time off of any of those 8 fumbles, which was a late, 4th quarter meaningless touchdown scored by Rio. A game that was already a blowout. How many yards did Tails put up against Rio by the way? Which just so happens to be the team with the best rushing defense in the league. Was it 100yds. Nope not even close. But guess what? McDragon put up well over 100 on them.


Fumbles count no matter how you try to dismiss them. They are critically important and an HB doesn't get credit because his defense bails him out. Not to mention that I certainly wouldn't have the time and energy to look into fumble results for every player in every league that is consider prowbowl rosters. Bottom line is that for many people this is THE tiebreaker and your incessant dismissal of it shows how silly your bias is.

Originally posted by
And why everyone keeps trying to discredit the Broken tackles stat is beyond me. Not one back in this league that isn't already on my team had more broken tackles than McDragon. Meaning that most of McDragons 3609yds came with defenders trying to bring him down. That's the whole Shaq thing. You can slow him down, but you can't stop him. He's gonna get his regardless. Teams have found a way to either shutdown, shut-out or contain Prowler this year.


I'll reiterate that this is a game and to me, there is no difference between running around someone/juking them or breaking the tackle. Is there a stat for people head faked? No. Is there a stat for FS that couldn't match your speed to the edge? No. It's a meaningless stat that you're only harping on because it benefits your guy. Again, major bias in you logic

Originally posted by
Plus besides the top 2-3 teams in Zeta, Alpha is a way harder conference. Would Prowler put up those numbers vs. Rio... nope he already failed at that. How bout against Port Royal. I doubt it, and would love to see him try. How bout against ShortBus? Doubt it. How bout against Fisher before they gutted themselves. Not likely. Trujillo. Maybee, but unlikely. He might have a chance vs. Israel, but I'd bet he comes up short there. Against the Jags. Ya, I'll give him that.


You base this on what? 7 teams gave up less than 1000 yards on the ground this season. 4 were in Zeta AND Tails played Rio in the inter-conference which means he played 5 of those 7 teams while McDragon played only 3. McDragon got the #16 ranked rush defense in his inter-conference match up. So can you stop with this argument?

Originally posted by
But his team would probably still lose. Plus McDragon is a lower level player. Prowler is playing with more SP than McDragon is, this I guarantee. Just wait until I put my level 32 upgrades on. Oh ya didn't know. I haven't purchased those yet. LOL... McDragon is the better RB by far. Fuck the fumbles. It's only a difference of 4 fumbles we're talking about here. It's only a difference of maybe 1 yard per carry.


What do levels matter anyways? Your HB is a higher level than either of my team's HBs and the same as my personal HB. The only difference is I'm not laming it up with a level 33 in A ball like you are so I can get e-hard off my stats. And arguing that you haven't put on level 32 equipment is amazingly lame and meaningless. 4 fumbles is 100% more than Tails and 1 ypc is 10% more. That's A LOT.

Originally posted by
Tell me this, since you like to live in the land of what-ifs, just who's stats end up higher outta these two comparisons I'm about to give you. Which is basically your argument vs. mine.

Your arguement...
Give "Tails" P the extra 41 carries at 10.6 yards a carry. Making his total rushing yards only 41 more yards than what McDragon currently has. Yup that's the math on that one my friend. And that's still a big what if. Cause there's no guarantee he would keep his average up with those extra carries.


Obviously they don't teach math in your high school, but 41 carries at 10.6 ypc is 434.6 yards, not 41. That's the math on that one genius.

Originally posted by
My arguement...
Give McDragon an equal amount of plays per game, which in turn would make him the favored RB in almost every offensive situation. Who's numbers end up better there? Especially since I already have the better rushing numbers. Ya sure you'll want to argue ypc. But the end result is what matters. Not the what-ifs, cause if that's what mattered here. Than just how many yards and touchdowns would he have ended up with if I had him being the only RB on the team to get any love like Punata did with Tails? Remember... I have another 2566yds and 51 TD's that I can bring into this conversation. Cause the carries to Fu Su Lu could've easily been given to McDragon instead. And another thing to add to this point. While 10.6ypc and 9.6 really aren't that much of a difference. 9.6ypc is a big difference over 7.7ypc. So there for McDragon could've easily had another 3000 yards if your doing the math right. So you see, your what if's don't matter.


This argument is amazing. I can't even respond to the ludacrisy of it..wow.

Originally posted by
All that matters is the end result. And the end result is that McDragon is the better RB this year outta the two. We're not talking about WR's here. For you to have to bring in a whole different stat category to validate your argument is laughable. Cause once again. Prowler had way more drops than McDragon and not that many more catches. Prowler only had 14 more catches, but 6 more drops. Was tackled for a loss more than McDragon. Broke way less tackles than McDragon(93 to 244). Had a lower yards per game average even though he saw the field more often. Plus you have to bring in a new stat category for him, to make him nearly as productive. Your point is illogical and stupid.


So HBs catching passes out of the backfield doesn't matter? Again, if the shoe were on the other foot, I have no doubt that you'd all of a sudden find the value of total yards vs. just rushing yards. Your guy dropped 3, caught 8. That's 37.5% Tails dropped 10, Caught 22. Thats 45.5%. Both are absurd amounts of dropped balls for the amount of attempts, but it's really not very significant. I can't even explain to you how biased your attempt to discredit the value of receiving yards for an HB sounds.

Originally posted by
You act like I'm trying to make the case for him to be considered the best RB this year. I'm absolutely not doing that. Paul Thorn won that honor fare and square. All I'm saying is there's no way "Tails" Prowler should be given the nod over McDragon based off of 4 fumbles and a 1 yard a carry difference. Not when Prowler was on the field an average of 6.8 more yards a game. The telling difference here is with us talking about RB's here. You have to bring in receiving numbers to bring Prowlers offensive production anywhere near that of McDragon. I don't have to do that to make my case.


Being on the field matters to you, even if he's not running the ball (since McDragon has more carries), but he doesn't get credit for what he does when on the field not running the ball (catching the ball!). Amazing logic there man.

Originally posted by
And to further defeat your yards per carry average argument. What stat matters more in the end. Yards per carry(ypc) or yards per game(ypg). I'll give ya'll a hint. It's yards per game all day, every day. Consistency my friends. Consistency. But I'm sure you guys can't fathom this. So I'm just talking to a brick wall. You're to blind to see that your any point you can make for "Tails" Prowler was canceled out by his failure to produce in those 5 bad games, and in their one shared opponent that mattered. That being Rio. Ask Rio who's the better RB. Ask them which one hurt them more. If they'd be polite enough to answer honestly and without bias. It's McDragon all day.


I completely disagree. I look at YPC over yards every single time, in both real football and GLB. When you played Rio, McDragon ran for 4.4 ypc while Tails ran for 4.2. Almost the same and you have no idea what he could have done because he was held back by his teams play calling.

Originally posted by
So run and play with your delusions. You want to live in that biased world and don't even have the guts to admit when your being biased. That's funny. Of course your going to vote for the Zeta RB. Especially after the Alpha RB destroyed your team, and there's a documented history of arguments and disagreements between you and the owner of said player. Don't be a tool man. I'm not stupid in any way shape or form. Don't try to treat me like I am. Cause chances are I'm smarter than you. Not saying it's the case. But it's more than possible.


You're the one being so unbelievably biased. I've looked at the arguments and personally don't give a fuck who is better. The best argument you have, you haven't used. It's one that completely negates the YPC advantage. I'm not going to explain it to you because it's probably over your intellectual ability to grasp. The bottom line is that both players are VERY close. In the end, for me, the fumbles are the difference, but I could see someone going with the consistency being the difference and choosing McDragon. Anyways, there's no need to respond or post any more as it appears you cannot form a coherent argument because you love your dot too much.
 
MGood030
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oakland360
Originally posted by MGood030

Originally posted by oakland360


You do realize how stupid your argument is. So let me get this right. You'd rather take the less consistent RB who on 5 separate occasions this season failed to gain 100yds on the ground or score a Td? Over the 1 RB in the league that put up a 100yds and a Td on pretty much everyone no matter the opponent? The only time he came close to being held short was against Fisher where he had 99yds and 3 touchdowns. So is that the logic you people are trying to throw my way. If so than it's flawed. It's a safe bet that you'll never be a head football coach or GM anytime soon.

Tell me this, who would you take as your QB, Manning or Brady? Please say you'd rather have Brady so I can laugh at you. You always take the more consistent player. It's a no brainer, Hands down. People that take the flashy new toy over old reliable crack me up every time. If that's really how you approach things than you need to be in my Fantasy football league so I can dominate you. Your the type of person that I said thank you to for letting me draft Peyton Manning in the 2nd round. Ya you go ahead and go with that philosophy right there. See how far it gets ya.

Oh and just so you know. Not even your fumble argement holds any weight when talking about "Tails" Prowler Vs. McDragon. Sure he fumbled 10 times, but only lost 8 of them. Putting the ball on the ground and still retaining possession doesn't count bro. Ask any football player. So two of those can be swept under the rug and forgotten about. The ones lost are what matters. So in that aspect, we're really only only talking about 8 fumbles here. Which is only 4 more than "Tails" P(who fumbled 4 times this season, all of them turnovers). Two of the games "Tails" fumbled in, his team lost. So you can also argue that none of McDragons fumbles hurt his team. Opponents only scored 1 time off of any of those 8 fumbles, which was a late, 4th quarter meaningless touchdown scored by Rio. A game that was already a blowout. How many yards did Tails put up against Rio by the way? Which happens to the team with the best rushing defense in the league. Was it 100yds. Nope not even close. But guess what? McDragon put up well over 100 on them.

And why everyone keeps trying to discredit the Broken tackles stat is beyond me. Not one back in this league that isn't already on my team had more broken tackles than McDragon. Meaning that most of McDragons 3609yds came with defenders trying to bring him down. That's the whole Shaq thing. You can slow him down, but you can't stop him. He's gonna get his regardless. Teams have found a way to either shutdown, shut-out or contain Prowler this year. Plus besides the top 2-3 teams in Zeta, Alpha is a way harder conference. Would Prowler put up those numbers vs. Rio... nope he already failed at that. How bout against Port Royal. I doubt it, and would love to see him try. How bout against ShortBus? Doubt it. How bout against Fisher before they gutted themselves. Not likely. Trujillo. Maybee, but unlikely. He might have a chance vs. Israel, but I'd bet he comes up short there. Against the Jags. Ya, I'll give him that. But his team would probably still lose. Plus McDragon is a lower level player. Prowler is playing with more SP than McDragon is, this I guarantee. Just wait until I put my level 32 upgrades on. Oh ya didn't know. I haven't purchased those yet. LOL... McDragon is the better RB by far. Fuck the fumbles. It's only a difference of 4 fumbles we're talking about here. It's only a difference of maybe 1 yard per carry.

Tell me this, since you like to live in the land of what-ifs, just who's stats end up higher outta these two comparisons I'm about to give you. Which is basically your argument vs. mine.

Your arguement...
Give "Tails" P the extra 41 carries at 10.6 yards a carry. Making his total rushing yards only 41 more yards than what McDragon currently has. Yup that's the math on that one my friend. And that's still a big what if. Cause there's no guarantee he would keep his average up with those extra carries.

My arguement...
Give McDragon an equal amount of plays per game, which in turn would make the favored RB in almost every offensive situation. Who's numbers end up better? Ya sure you'll want to argue ypc. But the end result is what matters. Not the what-ifs, cause if that's what mattered here. Just how many yards and Touchdowns would he have ended up with if I had him being the only RB on the team to get any love? Remember... I have another 2566yds and 51 TD's that I can bring into this conversation. Cause the carries to Fu Su Lu could've easily been given to McDragon instead. And another thing to add to this point. While 10.6ypc and 9.6 really aren't that much of a difference. 9.6ypc is a big difference over 7.7ypc. So there for McDragon could've easily had another 3000 yards if your doing the math right. So you see, your what if's don't matter. All that matters is the end result. And the end result is that McDragon is the Better RB. We're not talking about WR's here. For you to have to bring in a whole different stat category to validate your argument is laughable. Cause once again. Prowler had way more drops than McDragon and not that many more catches. Prowler only had 14 more catches, but 6 more drops. Was tackled for a loss more than McDragon. Broke way less tackles than McDragon(93 to 244). Had a lower yards per game average even though he saw the field more often. Plus you have to bring in a new stat category for him, to make him nearly as productive. Your point is illogical and stupid.


Did you honestly just say "Give McDragon Equal Playing Time"

Dude, when your a running back plays per game do not matter. They are insignificant if your not running the ball. You ran the ball more than Prowler. He's the only one your allowed to what-if about as far as playing time. Again, your arguement is still ruined by plain as day, black and white statistics that don't favor McDragon. Not in rushing or recieving, and then you get to the fact that he put the ball on the ground double of the other. This is a simple case of WHO IS BETTER. These things I'm telling you are all that matter. Not how it affected Cape Horn, not how many there actually were, nobody cares about that. It's the fact they happened and if has to factor into the arguement or I'd have down Miles a disservice.

Also, everyone here knows your arguement. We went through it yesterday. Nobody here believes the crap your selling, and for good reason. None of it makes any damn sense. Why don't you just let it die, for all of our sanity.


Actually Mgood, if you weren't so blinded by your stubborness to admit your wrong you'd see the error in your statement. Giving them equal playing time would mean alot, since Cape Horn obviously runs alot more frequently than Punata. Meaning that alot more of the carries and touchdowns that went to Fu Su Lu, would've ended up going to McDragon. Giving him better numbers than he currently owns. Don't be blind to your own argument. You used this same point when trying to explain why you picked an offensive line man over another in the OP of this very thread I do believe. And when I use it back against you... you throw the fumbles at me... 4 fumbles doesn't match/make up for the difference of 4 more rushing touchdowns. Cause we're only talking about rushing stats here. For you to have to bring in the receiving category when besides the touchdowns, isn't much of a difference either. Only weakens your own stance on the subject. Ypc doesn't mean as much as Ypg does. 65 rushing touchdowns is more impressive than 61. 225.6ypg is more impressive than 219.8ypg.
244 broken tackles is far more impressive than 93(more than double). And your going to try to use 4 fumbles and 1 more ypc as your reason? That's straight stupid and is very biased. Don't care what you say. It is what it is. You've made so many biased opinions concerning my team this year it's not even funny. Putting players from your own team in from your version of the pro-bowl when there's others more deserving. Man you didn't even get the name of the title correct. A pro Bowl... concerns two seperate conferences. McDragon should have been in his own conference all by him self with the argument in Zeta being between Paul Thorn, "Tails" P and Noel Devine(who also deserves to be rated higher than "Tails" P). Get real bro. I respect you... but your bias on the topic of Alpha vs. Zeta is showing and your not even big enough to admit it. That at least I openly do. I don't hide it. Your even biased on who the best TE in the league is. You'll say Tight Goodman all day, won't ya? I'm sure both Hans Solo and Broodemore Escalade would disagree with you. Hans Solo put up numbers comparable to, if not better than those nof Tight. While Escalade did something unheard of. Put up O-lineman type numbers with a crap load of pancakes... over 100 actually. And this is a TE we're talking about. Plus he didn't drop not 1 pass thrown his way all season. That's right. No drops.


Oakland..seriously...

If you gave McDragon more playing time, he would still be running the ball at a 9.6 Yards Per Rush clip, if not less. Running the ball more at a 9.6 yards per clip and running at a 10.6 yards per clip is a BIG difference. This is not stubborness, this is not bias (seriously, do you think I have any affiliation to Punata?), this...is...fact. Your using hypotheticals and second rate stats and word twisting to make your point while everyone else here is giving you black and white stats, and your simply responding with more things that don't make your point whatsoever, and just make you seem whiny and dumb. I don't think your necessarily dumb, as you do build good players, but this has certainly done you no favors in the eyes of many.

EVERYONE here knows your wrong. It's a plain as day as it can get. You have no point to make. Stop trying to. Let..it..go. Go to AA with the others and talk up McDragon there.

And for the record, I never said Tight was better than Solo, and I'm tempted to bring up the thread to shut you up, once again, for being wrong. I said he's "In the discussion." This is a proveable point, so I'd advise you to watch your response and not make me dig it up.
 
jfischer75
offline
Link
 
WOW

my eyes are bleeding


yeah my guy made the pro-bowl!!! thanks for the votes guys
 
jfischer75
offline
Link
 
is it in Hawaii?


just some shout out thanks i'd like to convey

i'd like to thank god, jesus, big bird, the chef from the muppets, thurman thomas, T.O., mom, dad, the asian dude from the grocery store i shop at, david hasslehoff, gizmo, my weed dealer and that hot hooters chick i took home one night when drunk and left a stain in my bed and was gone the next morning and for two days thought it was just a dream till she gave me funny looks next time i went to hooters and saw her there.

 
Mr. Dumass
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jfischer75
is it in Hawaii?


just some shout out thanks i'd like to convey

i'd like to thank god, jesus, big bird, the chef from the muppets, thurman thomas, T.O., mom, dad, the asian dude from the grocery store i shop at, david hasslehoff, gizmo, my weed dealer and that hot hooters chick i took home one night when drunk and left a stain in my bed and was gone the next morning and for two days thought it was just a dream till she gave me funny looks next time i went to hooters and saw her there.



Uhmm.... You do realize that Leslie fills in for a few shifts at Hooters on West Riverside? That might explain the stain.
Last edited Dec 17, 2008 11:21:10
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.