User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Medium Coverage pushes me over the edge
Page:
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
The old medium setting was actually buggy - it ended up being the same as "aggressive."

The old broken "if" clause was like:

"If ball has been thrown and coverage style is not loose, go for the ball"

See the problem there?

Now it is:

"if ball has been thrown and coverage style is aggressive or coverage style is medium and there's help over the top, go for the ball"

If you want the same exact thing as medium did before, just choose "aggressive." It's the same code block.


No.. If you pick Medium, then the CB just lets the WR catch the ball.

The CB even backs up when the ball is thrown.

That can't be correct.

The change was supposed to be, that when the CB didn't have help over the top, he wouldn't try to INT the pass, but he should still be able to make a play on the ball, meaning try to knock it down.

We should be able to pick something that allows the CB to knock the pass down if he doesn't have help over the top, but try to INT the ball, if he does have help.

That used to be what Medium did.

You overly-fixed Medium

All you needed to do, was correct the CB from going for the INT, when no one was behind him. Now he NEVER goes for the INT, he just sits back there waiting for the ball to be completed.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 20:40:18
 
Link
 
He has spoken!
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 20:44:59
 
Yung1King
offline
Link
 
Hi, Bort.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Bort,

Did you somehow weaken tight coverage? Because all of my CBs on teams I GM (and yes, they're built w/high agility and vision and not speed heavy) that were shutting receivers down with tight coverage now cannot cover anyone. Would like to know if I should now have them play medium coverage because tight has been nerfed.

Thanks.



Last edited Nov 28, 2008 20:46:29
 
Link
 
Why does the WR have a much faster reaction time then the CB?
If the WR can adjust I think the CB should be able to as well.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.


We all know this Bukowski is a serial whiner. Appreciate you posting an explanation.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by vrshah
Bort,

Did you somehow weaken tight coverage? Because all of my CBs on teams I GM (and yes, they're built w/high agility and vision and not speed heavy) that were shutting receivers down with tight coverage now cannot cover anyone. Would like to know if I should now have them play medium coverage because tight has been nerfed.

Thanks.





Nope, just that fix for the one-liner bug.
 
vrshah
offline
Link
 
Ok thanks. I'll look at some other coverage options because it was weird what happened today.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by islander1
Originally posted by Bort

Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.


We all know this Bukowski is a serial whiner. Appreciate you posting an explanation.


I read in the other thread about an idea for a possible 4th setting - that might be a reasonable idea. Maybe it could make the player head for a point near but still outside the player, or something of the like, so he has a better chance of getting the PD?

What would it be called?
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 20:49:10
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Bort


Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.


We all know this Bukowski is a serial whiner. Appreciate you posting an explanation.


I read in the other thread about an idea for a possible 4th setting - that might be a reasonable idea. Maybe it could make the player head for a point near but still outside the player, or something of the like, so he has a better chance of getting the PD?


This would be a welcome addition.

Along with bump and run coverage for my strong CBs
 
Link
 
I heard blanket coverage
Think that would work out fine.

But what is the difference between medium and loose right now?
Last edited Nov 28, 2008 20:51:51
 
Bukowski
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.


There is no Cornerback on any level of football, that just watches a WR catch the ball, then react to it.

That would be considered Loose, if anything.

Besides, isn't Play Coverage Distance supposed to dictate how tight a CB plays the WR, not the Coverage Style?

If I set my CB to Stick to WR Like Glue, I would expect him to stay on top of the WR, no matter what the Coverage style is set to. There seems to be some kind of mix up as to which does what.

Or if this is how you intended it to work, then we should get another option, as it's not allowing people to keep their CBs as what Medium was supposed to do.

I would still want my CB to make a play on the ball, no matter what. But going for the deflection is supposed to be a lot less riskier than going for the pick, which should be reflected in one of the choices, but it's not.

There is no middle ground here.

We either pick the choice that's going to let our CB get beaten all day long, without even reacting.

Or we choose the one that will have our CB jumping every single route, while allowing the WR to beat them long.

There needs to be some kind of medium ground, between the two. And if you look through the threads, I'm far from the only one that feels this way.

 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Haha, bump may be coming soon. I think it's needed for sure.
 
Dacolts
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by islander1

Originally posted by Bort


Buk, I know what I changed. It was one line of an if statement.

If the defender doesn't go right for the ball, he continues to play as if he were playing coverage on the player, which includes having to have reaction time, etc.

Going for the ball is the same no matter if you're going for a PD or int - he still has to turn and head right at the receiver, which means if he doesn't knock it down he'll likely get beat since he would then have to turn around again as the receiver catches it behind him. Thus the "help over the top" part for medium.


We all know this Bukowski is a serial whiner. Appreciate you posting an explanation.


I read in the other thread about an idea for a possible 4th setting - that might be a reasonable idea. Maybe it could make the player head for a point near but still outside the player, or something of the like, so he has a better chance of getting the PD?

What would it be called?


Deflection Focus
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.