User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Have "Superstars" and "All-Pros"
Page:
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by R.Williams34
Originally posted by Kira

I have one problem with this. No matter how much you think people understand that games are won in the trenches and positions like Safety and FB and TE are also very important, people are ALWAYS going to take the star QB/HB/WR and a few other key positions like DE and CB instead of your O-lineman/DT/FS. That kind of makes the game even less fun for us non-glamour guys. Even if you were to say ok 1 d-lineman, 1 secondary ect...people would just always take the DE and CB. I think you HAVE to find a way to make it unlimited for every team. I'm not certain how to do that and make it perfectly fair, but if you can think of something then + 1 billion


ok how about this, each team gets 2 superstars on defence and offense, but limit it to only 1 star player and one non-glamour position. and for defense one DB and one LB/D-line.??? hows that sound?


well maybe, but DTs and Safeties who are at the same level will still never get picked. I guess there's just nothing that could be done to make it perfectly fair so just limit it as much as possible like you said 1 offense star, 1 non-glamour offense player and 2 defenders I'd like the number bigger for higher level teams though like 12 for Pro, 8 for AAA-AA and 4 for A-BBB or even bigger like 20 Pro/16 AAA/12 AA/8 A/4 BBB
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
Or maybe we should just let Bort impliment it and then complain about what doesn't work so he can tweak it.
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
i kinda like the idea of the different numbers for different leagues, but how bout this, why not make it the lower the league the more guys you can have on a team. yes ive thought about how if you go up a league you may have more supers than aloud, well thats the whole fun, not every player always stays on the same team through his entire career and since each agent can only make 1-2 that would limit him to filling his team up with supers.
 
Lugnut
offline
Link
 
This is a really good idea. However, I enjoy the nuances of the game that allow persons to create their own player. I would like more emphasis on secondary attributes i.e. confidence and such.
 
iMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by John Waylon
Actually, the Superstar idea shoots itself in the foot...

Think about it... You create a SS QB. It's going to take 2700 FP to boost, which basic math tells us is about 27 dollars, and that is simply too much for one player in one season. That means the boosting of other players is going to fall by the wayside, because you naturally want to boost your stat maker, and not the FS who gets 3 tackles a game.

But with his SP and training advantage, you can still keep him unboosted, and be on par with other players in your league due to the bonuses.

It could actually lead to the game making LESS money, because like I said, if there is no penalty at all for me not boosting my SS QB at the end of the season, then I am NOT going to be buying 2700 FP to do it, and I am also going to be buying 900 LESS to boost my other players.


 
Llyranwyar
offline
Link
 
Superstars are just bad. Who would really want to make crap players? Everything that isn't a superstar will just be trash. Maybe there will be folks that will want to keep making players to have something else to do, but consider the player market. Even if you limit them per team and per account you will still have an issue with finding players for the teams.

Holding off the discovery of a superstar talent or ability will just crash the market for players above the superstar mark or level.

If people really need some sort of superstar ability, be it by attributes or or special abilities, it should be something that every player could theoretically obtain. An example would be getting rewarded with a point placed in an SA or perhaps awarded to a special group of SA's for being ranked int he top 5-10 players for a given position or stat within your league or conference. Say your WR, created and maintained just like everyone else's, ends up with an exceptional number of catches over the season. At the end of the season he gets awarded with a point to the superstar catching abilities or something.

I hate the superstar idea. Still think its a bad idea and not well thought through. It sounds like people wanting something for nothing and just plain 'cheese'. Its just bad logic to think that its acceptable to FORCE a player to be better than some else's. There are plenty of less than ideal builds out there. A poorly built superstar will still be junk. Its one more dimension to the game for people to complain about.

A star player needs to be so because he is the right fit for the right situation with the right people around him. Segregating the potential of players will cause less players to be made unless everyone can be a superstar. If you make limitations on the number of players that can be superstars, don't expect that people will want to settle for not being a superstar. In the end....It means less $$$$.

Last edited Dec 1, 2008 20:23:39
 
cowtesticles2001
udder pressure
offline
Link
 
I've seen good suggestions before....but this one is....FUCKING AMAZING!!!
 
britdevine316
offline
Link
 
I really like it with the

1. Randomness

2. Not knowing till level 29

3. Limiting it to 1-2 per agent

4. Limiting it to 3-5 per team

5. Not costing any more FP's.
 
islander1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by flames54
Originally posted by britdevine316

Originally posted by Bort


I would prefer something more along the lines of a "hidden talent" that unlocks after a certain level or something, than having people pay more to have a "super" player.


If something like this is implemented the extra SP's need to be given out at Lvl 24 at the very least, more likley Lvl 32.

Having the SP's released early will just create a mass of players being retired at that level and people starting over. You don't want that.

I would say Lvl 29-32..Leaning more towards 29 as that's when leveling up becomes stagnant and could give us something to look forward to, while 29 being a high enough level that those playing the game would probably not retire their player if they only got 1 extra SP or something as they would be pretty invested into them by now.


Problem with Borts idea. You could stack a team with "breakthrough" players, and it would probably just end up with the exact same system we have now anyway, just with a few more sp's in it.

At least my idea would limit the number of superstars a team can field, in Bort's porposition it would be easy for owners to farm 3 or 400 players on various teams to create a completely stacked and 100% unbeatable team. Don't say it isn't possible to get that many players created to get breakthroughts for the top 40 to be on a real team, because I could do that in a second with just the people I know and many others would be able to as well.

Randomness will make this game lean much more towards an RPG than a football sim and that would make me quit for "real".


oh noes! please flames! don't hold GLB for ransom or you might quit?

for fucks sakes. What a drama whore.
 
walkom30
offline
Link
 
this a great idea would be great to have

would make owners think about who they would recu
 
flames54
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by walkom30
this a great idea would be great to have

would make owners think about who they would recu


It needs refinement for sure, but it would add a lot more towards building a team.

As for Pro teams having as many as they want, no way in hell. That would just mean that "friends" would stack the hell out of a team and make them totally unbeatable, there needs to be a cap.

As far as per agent goes, I agree now that there needs to be an all-pro cap but I'd really like to have an offensive and defensive guy as superstars. I'd prefer to see the limit imposed more on how many the team can have than the agents just because as an agent if I want to pay for superstars and all-pros then why not? it's not like everybody will do it and it's not like you can just stack a team up with them.

Perhaps 50% training bonus is a bit much as well, but 8sp in the current system will be huge early and later in life allow the superstar to separate a bit from the good well built players, which lets face it are far, far more common these days than they used to be.
 
Strokke
offline
Link
 
If teams are limited to a small amount of these players...when would a low impact position ever get signed by a team?

 
Jed
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Kira
I have one problem with this. No matter how much you think people understand that games are won in the trenches and positions like Safety and FB and TE are also very important, people are ALWAYS going to take the star QB/HB/WR and a few other key positions like DE and CB instead of your O-lineman/DT/FS. That kind of makes the game even less fun for us non-glamour guys. Even if you were to say ok 1 d-lineman, 1 secondary ect...people would just always take the DE and CB. I think you HAVE to find a way to make it unlimited for every team. I'm not certain how to do that and make it perfectly fair, but if you can think of something then + 1 billion


I don't think that's true. I know it's a long time ago, but when Alpha first rolled out, the biggest problem was finding QBs and RBs for teams because everyone wanted to try out other positions.

And I think, just like now, you'll find that most of the better Agents out there will realize what positions really are important to a team and have those be their superstars/all-stars. And on the flip-side, you'll see just as many people who make nothing but QB/RBs into those (kind of like how there is a huge glut of QB/RBs right now by Agents who don't know any better/care about what's important to a team).

Natural selection will get people to start making positions which matter, just like people were driven to make more linemen a few seasons ago and are more driven to make CB/WRs now due to demand.
 
superman8456
offline
Link
 
With the superstar idea, they should make it that a superstar can only line up at their respective positions. Lets say a team has a superstar CB, and is going up against a run heavy team. They move him to LB and he would still be pretty dominant imo. We should make it so that CB can only be on the depth chart for CB, SS, or FS. A LB can only be a LB or DE. A DE can be a LB, DE, or DT. And keep it like that.

But imo teams will all just end up putting superstars at the same position. People are going to make superstar DE's that are "unstoppable" and then to counteract that you will see superstar OT's or something along those lines.
 
R.Williams 34
offline
Link
 
if a team was only aloud 2 superstars, personaly i would have them both on defense, 1 DE and 1 MLB or both OLB. ive played defence most of my life, in real life, so i like it more lol. if i did get an offensive super, it would be a WR because thats what i played.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.