User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Weight Classes
Page:
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
I would just like to take a minute to post another way to make weight matter...and it has been suggested before.

Include the weight classes...even allow players to adjust their weight (the whole normal training + gain/lose weight option). However, it would be decent if weight class determined two things: Autopoints and training gains. For example, a heavier player would gain a greater amount of strength and tackling/blocking per level and in their training bar when training any of those. Similarly, the same would go for lighter players in terms of speed and agility.

Of course, this would be for the new players as soon as the change is made. This would further make building a player more interesting. You can slow build a light player to be fast and then bulk him up and make him a harder hitter, or vice versa. You can also have a balanced player and enjoy the extra SPs that come with advanced training without shifting weight.

Your thoughts?


Very good idea..
 
TheInfinity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by TheInfinity

Introducing this system would probably take a lot of work and since its not going to add much something else can be focused on.


It would actually probably only take a day or so. The code's already there. I'd just have to replace constants in the formulas with variables based on the player's weight class.


... you're good.. didn't think it'd be that easy, then again I'm not a programmer but still it seems impressive.

My vote is still that its going to cause problems more than anything else. Speed guys get faster and if Power guys get big enough to break tackles you'll be back where you were when strength was too powerful. Its not going to make people realize strength, carrying, catching are valuable, or even make them valuable. (And thats the main core problem).
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jack Del Rio
For this to not piss people off tremendously the training for altering weight has to be completely independent of the attribute training. I'd leave it as a "Gain Weight/Lose Weight/Do Nothing" option that you set and it gets proccessed overnight. Maybe just have the weight change cost some money, how about the $ difference between 5x(daily salary) - 2x(cost to train on intense)?


I had this idea pretty well fleshed out on the old training regime...it was an eating option in junction with your training option. If you chose "massive coloric intake" with relaxed training, you would gain weight. If you chose "just a side salad" with intense training, you would lose weight.

That was back when I thought weight did/should matter.
Last edited Nov 23, 2008 21:20:39
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Long thread - didnt read past page 7 or so, just have one bit of instant feedback:

Please don't do it at all unless you're going to do it well - including sophistication (elegant integration so it doesn't "break" any current builds but has the potential to enhance most), gameplay balance (so more than one height/weight can be useful at a given position), and intuitive sense (effects are what hardcore football fans would expect). This is definitely an advanced concept for the simulation imo. Would be top-notch if done well.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
I think this just makes everyone faster.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Long thread - didnt read past page 7 or so, just have one bit of instant feedback:

Please don't do it at all unless you're going to do it well - including sophistication (elegant integration so it doesn't "break" any current builds but has the potential to enhance most), gameplay balance (so more than one height/weight can be useful at a given position), and intuitive sense (effects are what hardcore football fans would expect). This is definitely an advanced concept for the simulation imo. Would be top-notch if done well.


Basically, this would only be for new players once it was introduced...
 
The Avenger
Hulk Smash
offline
Link
 
Would a 6'6", 160 lb WR gazelle be as fast as a 5'4", 160 lb munchkin?

They both have this "Weight" issue equal so speed would be equal? right? Or are we going to ignore height?

Why did we random roll our new guy in the first place if the height and weight attibutes aren't effective in our builds right now??
 
Link
 
Originally posted by The Avenger
Would a 6'6", 160 lb WR gazelle be as fast as a 5'4", 160 lb munchkin?

They both have this "Weight" issue equal so speed would be equal? right? Or are we going to ignore height?

Why did we random roll our new guy in the first place if the height and weight attibutes aren't effective in our builds right now??


To get better skill/attribute bases?
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Avenger
Would a 6'6", 160 lb WR gazelle be as fast as a 5'4", 160 lb munchkin?

They both have this "Weight" issue equal so speed would be equal? right? Or are we going to ignore height?

Why did we random roll our new guy in the first place if the height and weight attibutes aren't effective in our builds right now??


Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Iruleall15

IMO i think Height and Weight should have an effect. 7 ft guy with 100 speed is slower than a 5ft 8 guy with 100 speed


Not really. Taking out you extreme example...taller sprinters can't accelerate as well but, generally, have longer strides and take less steps in their natural stride pattern. Considering the fact that agility is acceleration...I think that acceleration should be related to height and not speed.

There is actually a statistically insignificant correlation between height and 100-meter dash times. Sprinters come in all shapes and sizes. Trust me.
 
youngHOOD
offline
Link
 
this is a good one I like it.
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
I would love to see more than just the weight/height determine your 40yd dash or maximum speed.

I think each player should have a combine link which automatically calculates things like:

40-Yd Dash (sec)
Vertical Jump (in)
225 lb Bench Press Reps
Broad Jump (ft)
3-Cone Drill (sec)
60-Yd Shuttle Run (sec)

This link has been floating around:
http://cid-ddbf160d1575d830.skydrive.live.com/self.aspx/Public/GLB|_Player|_Spreadsheet.xls

And we have used it just for fun on our team forum. But I would love to see Bort use this so that we could truly manipulate our combine numbers. It would be a great way to scout guys because I think the combine numbers should be public data... That any GM/Coach/Agent could see... And it would be a great recruiting tool too during the off season.

Again, I like Borts idea... But think using height/weight and position should effect more than just max speed. It should effect all things related to that position based on NFL combine averages.
 
tuba_samurai
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt
I would love to see more than just the weight/height determine your 40yd dash or maximum speed.

I think each player should have a combine link which automatically calculates things like:

40-Yd Dash (sec)
Vertical Jump (in)
225 lb Bench Press Reps
Broad Jump (ft)
3-Cone Drill (sec)
60-Yd Shuttle Run (sec)

This link has been floating around:
http://cid-ddbf160d1575d830.skydrive.live.com/self.aspx/Public/GLB|_Player|_Spreadsheet.xls

And we have used it just for fun on our team forum. But I would love to see Bort use this so that we could truly manipulate our combine numbers. It would be a great way to scout guys because I think the combine numbers should be public data... That any GM/Coach/Agent could see... And it would be a great recruiting tool too during the off season.

Again, I like Borts idea... But think using height/weight and position should effect more than just max speed. It should effect all things related to that position based on NFL combine averages.


broken link?
 
TyrannyVaunt
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tuba_samurai
Originally posted by TyrannyVaunt

I would love to see more than just the weight/height determine your 40yd dash or maximum speed.

I think each player should have a combine link which automatically calculates things like:

40-Yd Dash (sec)
Vertical Jump (in)
225 lb Bench Press Reps
Broad Jump (ft)
3-Cone Drill (sec)
60-Yd Shuttle Run (sec)

This link has been floating around:
http://cid-ddbf160d1575d830.skydrive.live.com/self.aspx/Public/GLB|_Player|_Spreadsheet.xls

And we have used it just for fun on our team forum. But I would love to see Bort use this so that we could truly manipulate our combine numbers. It would be a great way to scout guys because I think the combine numbers should be public data... That any GM/Coach/Agent could see... And it would be a great recruiting tool too during the off season.

Again, I like Borts idea... But think using height/weight and position should effect more than just max speed. It should effect all things related to that position based on NFL combine averages.


broken link?


Sorry... That link worked during the off season (before season 6). I will find that file on my HDD and publish it on Google Docs. Give me 10mins and I will update this post.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
I'm not entirely sure I like this.

Why it would be somewhat more realistic, it would also be a burden to certain positions. Like FB's will suddenly need MORE speed and agility to lead block, along with vision, strength, blocking, and the other secondary attributes.

It also "normalizes" all builds, and seems to me like it would make it more cookie-cutter. For example, an OL that would normally have 70str/70blk/35spd/40agl, after this change, 50str/50blk/50spd/50agl would be the same thing. It emphasizes every position soft capping their abilities instead of building logically. Some positions that only need one thing, like WR's, gain a huge benefit, since strength and blocking are more or less useless to them and it just makes their speed even more crazy, while positions that need to be fast and strong are encouraged, or even required to soft cap everything.

It basically makes a "balanced" build into a specialized build, and makes a specialized build into an extremely lopsided build, based on weight. Granted...it has been suggested that it can be changed via training or veteran skills, but it just seems to me that it adds an unneeded barrier against customization.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by BlackRobLikeWhoa
Originally posted by kretchfoop

I would just like to take a minute to post another way to make weight matter...and it has been suggested before.

Include the weight classes...even allow players to adjust their weight (the whole normal training + gain/lose weight option). However, it would be decent if weight class determined two things: Autopoints and training gains. For example, a heavier player would gain a greater amount of strength and tackling/blocking per level and in their training bar when training any of those. Similarly, the same would go for lighter players in terms of speed and agility.

Of course, this would be for the new players as soon as the change is made. This would further make building a player more interesting. You can slow build a light player to be fast and then bulk him up and make him a harder hitter, or vice versa. You can also have a balanced player and enjoy the extra SPs that come with advanced training without shifting weight.

Your thoughts?


Very good idea..


Bleh? No hate, one love?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.