User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by maz621

wrong let me explain why... SI youre from nevada and i dont know who you are voting for but for arguments sake ill say mccain you vote for mccain and obama wins your state your vote now under the current system is null it means nothing to the election because your state is obama... now without the electoral college your vote still counts regardless who gets the most votes out of your state because your vote counts toward a compiled total tally yea?


You think a vote only "matters" if cast for the guy who wins?

A national popular vote also means someone can theoretically cheat in one city and and rack up millions of votes to swing an election. Or perhaps a less paranoid fault, it would allow someone to run on a campaign that caters only to large cities.

The founding fathers put this system in place for the same reason they created the Senate - to prevent 51% of the public from getting its way, if that 51% were not evenly distributed nationwide.
 
mattshwink
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by maz621

say it with me now vermont i said vermont what are you reading? anyways think of it this way... texas had 34 ellectoral votes its almost always republican mccain doesnt try too hard because he basically has it in the bag 34 points no negative to not trying now say electoral is gone a scaled down population votes just for example mccain wins 55 people to 45 he would have to worry about those 45 voters because it hurts him in the whole election where as with the electoral system those 45 votes disappear and dont matter to him at all... now same goes for vermont and every other state this makes EVERY vote count at this time with the system we have this much is not true if you win a state the votes for your opponent in that state NO LONGER MATTER IN ANY WAY get it? see how its out of date?


This isn't entirely true. Two states (Nebraska and Maine) can split their electors. Colorado defeated a measure (handily, in 2004) to do something similar. States decide how their electors are apportioned and chosen.

So if you want change, not only should you lobby your senators and congressional representatives, you should also lobby your state representatives and governor.

Last edited Nov 4, 2008 11:25:37
 
mikelj
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by maz621
Originally posted by mikelj

Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Originally posted by maz621



Originally posted by mikelj




Originally posted by maz621





"Gore was the Democratic nominee for president in the 2000 presidential election. He won the popular vote by approximately 500,000, but ultimately lost the electoral vote to Republican candidate George W. Bush; the legal controversy over the Florida election recount was eventually settled in favor of Bush by the Supreme Court."

thats all i need to know to not vote... when the nation picks one person and the system picks a different person you know at that point your vote means nothing


Someone who once again doesnt understand presidential elections. HMM not like that was the first time the popular vote didnt win out. This is so states BESIDES CA, TX, NY, IL, FL matter. Why would someone campaign in Missouri if it was JUST the popular vote.

REMEMBER AL GORE DIDNT WIN HIS HOME STATE. THINK ABOUT THAT. WHO KNOWS YOU BETTER THAN YOUR HOME STATE?


oh i get it i somewhere secretly said this was the first time this happened and you found my hidden encoded message congratulations! anyways... how does the electoral college make other states matter? do tell! why would they campaign missouri? really? because you would need every vote not just the big states? compare how many times mccain and obama visit vermont to how many times they visit california hows the system helping the small states at all anymore? its out of date



I'm living in Vegas now and both guys have been here MANY times and have been flooding the state with TV ads. Why does NV get so much more attention than Texas or New York if only big states matter?

Nevada is pretty barren except for Las Vegas and even Las Vegas is pretty small. There is only 20 minutes of civilization around the strip in any direction. the rest is sand.



My point exactly. NEVADA wouldnt matter if it was just popular vote.


wrong let me explain why... SI youre from nevada and i dont know who you are voting for but for arguments sake ill say mccain you vote for mccain and obama wins your state your vote now under the current system is null it means nothing to the election because your state is obama... now without the electoral college your vote still counts regardless who gets the most votes out of your state because your vote counts toward a compiled total tally yea?


But with just popular vote, the candidates would visit the most populus places, I dont know why I would argue with someone that is so closed minded...OPEN your eyes.

I am not saying that the Electoral College is the way, but I see it since I live in a smaller state population wise.
 
blazzinken
offline
Link
 
Voted
 
Bomber085
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by F8n4tune
As for the $250,000 argument you guys do realize that it's NOT the whole $250,000 that will be taxed but anything over it ?

Now how many REAL people make over $250,000 ? *shakes head* at what people argue about.


What are you talking about? They aren't going to tax anyone who makes under $250k? Really?

That's about the dumbest comment I have EVER heard!

VOTE MCCAIN!

Also, the presidential election asside.. there are 435 seats for the House open.. 11 governors.. 35 Senate seats..

And more importantly.. Local measures that are just as much likely to impact your lives as the national.. It's not just about the president people..
Last edited Nov 4, 2008 11:34:50
 
Swiftus
offline
Link
 
I voted
 
Sarg01
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bomber085

What are you talking about? They aren't going to tax anyone who makes under $250k? Really?


No, under 200k, according to Obama. Or 150k according to Joe Biden. Or 120k according to Bill Richardson. Or 97k according to Obama (much earlier in the campaign).

Of course, he's called for the elimination of tax cuts that apply to people making as little as 42k - but of course, that's not a "tax increase" as far as the media is concerned.

 
Link
 
Originally posted by maz621


wrong let me explain why... SI youre from nevada and i dont know who you are voting for but for arguments sake ill say mccain you vote for mccain and obama wins your state your vote now under the current system is null it means nothing to the election because your state is obama... now without the electoral college your vote still counts regardless who gets the most votes out of your state because your vote counts toward a compiled total tally yea?


I hear your point, but alot of it comes down to funding from the Federal Government and how things were done in the past. If the whole US got to vote for everything we did in Nevada, then it would be fine, but they don't. So when Nevada gets a chunk of money from the government, it is spent as the locals here want it spent. After all, we know more than people of Vermont as to what is best for us here. Likewise, when we vote for President, we are voting for who we think will help us in Nevada the most. It really doesn't matter to us what Obama does for Washington or Vermont. That doesn't affect our lives at all. Presidents wouldn't have to take a stand on ethanol or answer to people of Michigan about what they are going to do to bail out the auto industry, they would simply ignore the issue (some consider this good, some consider that bad).

The other reason why we have to go state by state instead of individual votes is fraud. It is much harder to coordinate fraud when 50 different counties individually come up with votes and record those votes. If you could just declare that you are a citizen of the US, then you could go vote in OH, then walk over to PA, and it would be a nightmare coordinating everything. There would be much higher chance of fraud.

I agree with you though. It sucks when you live in a state that is strongly against your views. I lived in CA for a few years and there was no chance for Republicans. Silenced my vote.


Personally, I think the system sucks and should be changed. I think voting should be verified online with a place where people could check their vote was registered by their SS number. But people don't want that. They think their SS number (and credit card number) is magical.

I also think that catering to special interest groups is retarded and leads to wasteful spending. Promising farm and ethanol subsides to states to win votes is a HORRIBLE idea for the country. But it happens all the time.

Dems and Reps should work together to change the system. Let's get the federal government out of pork barrel spending and subsidies all together and only fund public works like roads, bridges and defense of the country like it is supposed to be.

No one wants to change the Constitution though, so it doesn't seem likely to happen any time soon. So I don't complain about elections because I know why it was set up the way it was and how to change it if we want to in the future. I also know if it isn't changed, then that is the way it is going to be. Crying after the fact about how something was robbed or stolen (as if it just changed recently or was done in order for one party to win an election) is the part that doesn't make sense to me when people complain.
 
itsme420
offline
Link
 
Libertarian Party Candidate Bob Barr

the lesser of the lesser of 2 evils
 
maz621
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Sarg01
Originally posted by maz621


wrong let me explain why... SI youre from nevada and i dont know who you are voting for but for arguments sake ill say mccain you vote for mccain and obama wins your state your vote now under the current system is null it means nothing to the election because your state is obama... now without the electoral college your vote still counts regardless who gets the most votes out of your state because your vote counts toward a compiled total tally yea?


You think a vote only "matters" if cast for the guy who wins?

A national popular vote also means someone can theoretically cheat in one city and and rack up millions of votes to swing an election. Or perhaps a less paranoid fault, it would allow someone to run on a campaign that caters only to large cities.

The founding fathers put this system in place for the same reason they created the Senate - to prevent 51% of the public from getting its way, if that 51% were not evenly distributed nationwide.


yes your vote only matters if your state picks who you voted for if your state doesnt go with who you voted for what is the difference in voting and not voting for you then?
 
maz621
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mikelj
Originally posted by maz621

Originally posted by mikelj


Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Originally posted by maz621




Originally posted by mikelj





Originally posted by maz621






"Gore was the Democratic nominee for president in the 2000 presidential election. He won the popular vote by approximately 500,000, but ultimately lost the electoral vote to Republican candidate George W. Bush; the legal controversy over the Florida election recount was eventually settled in favor of Bush by the Supreme Court."

thats all i need to know to not vote... when the nation picks one person and the system picks a different person you know at that point your vote means nothing


Someone who once again doesnt understand presidential elections. HMM not like that was the first time the popular vote didnt win out. This is so states BESIDES CA, TX, NY, IL, FL matter. Why would someone campaign in Missouri if it was JUST the popular vote.

REMEMBER AL GORE DIDNT WIN HIS HOME STATE. THINK ABOUT THAT. WHO KNOWS YOU BETTER THAN YOUR HOME STATE?


oh i get it i somewhere secretly said this was the first time this happened and you found my hidden encoded message congratulations! anyways... how does the electoral college make other states matter? do tell! why would they campaign missouri? really? because you would need every vote not just the big states? compare how many times mccain and obama visit vermont to how many times they visit california hows the system helping the small states at all anymore? its out of date



I'm living in Vegas now and both guys have been here MANY times and have been flooding the state with TV ads. Why does NV get so much more attention than Texas or New York if only big states matter?

Nevada is pretty barren except for Las Vegas and even Las Vegas is pretty small. There is only 20 minutes of civilization around the strip in any direction. the rest is sand.



My point exactly. NEVADA wouldnt matter if it was just popular vote.


wrong let me explain why... SI youre from nevada and i dont know who you are voting for but for arguments sake ill say mccain you vote for mccain and obama wins your state your vote now under the current system is null it means nothing to the election because your state is obama... now without the electoral college your vote still counts regardless who gets the most votes out of your state because your vote counts toward a compiled total tally yea?


But with just popular vote, the candidates would visit the most populus places, I dont know why I would argue with someone that is so closed minded...OPEN your eyes.

I am not saying that the Electoral College is the way, but I see it since I live in a smaller state population wise.


close minded to what? all ive been saying is electoral college is not the way and you just agreed with me... the hell are you arguing then?
 
maz621
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by maz621



wrong let me explain why... SI youre from nevada and i dont know who you are voting for but for arguments sake ill say mccain you vote for mccain and obama wins your state your vote now under the current system is null it means nothing to the election because your state is obama... now without the electoral college your vote still counts regardless who gets the most votes out of your state because your vote counts toward a compiled total tally yea?


I hear your point, but alot of it comes down to funding from the Federal Government and how things were done in the past. If the whole US got to vote for everything we did in Nevada, then it would be fine, but they don't. So when Nevada gets a chunk of money from the government, it is spent as the locals here want it spent. After all, we know more than people of Vermont as to what is best for us here. Likewise, when we vote for President, we are voting for who we think will help us in Nevada the most. It really doesn't matter to us what Obama does for Washington or Vermont. That doesn't affect our lives at all. Presidents wouldn't have to take a stand on ethanol or answer to people of Michigan about what they are going to do to bail out the auto industry, they would simply ignore the issue (some consider this good, some consider that bad).

The other reason why we have to go state by state instead of individual votes is fraud. It is much harder to coordinate fraud when 50 different counties individually come up with votes and record those votes. If you could just declare that you are a citizen of the US, then you could go vote in OH, then walk over to PA, and it would be a nightmare coordinating everything. There would be much higher chance of fraud.

I agree with you though. It sucks when you live in a state that is strongly against your views. I lived in CA for a few years and there was no chance for Republicans. Silenced my vote.


Personally, I think the system sucks and should be changed. I think voting should be verified online with a place where people could check their vote was registered by their SS number. But people don't want that. They think their SS number (and credit card number) is magical.

I also think that catering to special interest groups is retarded and leads to wasteful spending. Promising farm and ethanol subsides to states to win votes is a HORRIBLE idea for the country. But it happens all the time.

Dems and Reps should work together to change the system. Let's get the federal government out of pork barrel spending and subsidies all together and only fund public works like roads, bridges and defense of the country like it is supposed to be.

No one wants to change the Constitution though, so it doesn't seem likely to happen any time soon. So I don't complain about elections because I know why it was set up the way it was and how to change it if we want to in the future. I also know if it isn't changed, then that is the way it is going to be. Crying after the fact about how something was robbed or stolen (as if it just changed recently or was done in order for one party to win an election) is the part that doesn't make sense to me when people complain.


i wasnt old enough to vote for gore so it wasnt meant to be crying after the fact i only used that merely as an example as to the system being flawed
 
maz621
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mattshwink
Originally posted by maz621


say it with me now vermont i said vermont what are you reading? anyways think of it this way... texas had 34 ellectoral votes its almost always republican mccain doesnt try too hard because he basically has it in the bag 34 points no negative to not trying now say electoral is gone a scaled down population votes just for example mccain wins 55 people to 45 he would have to worry about those 45 voters because it hurts him in the whole election where as with the electoral system those 45 votes disappear and dont matter to him at all... now same goes for vermont and every other state this makes EVERY vote count at this time with the system we have this much is not true if you win a state the votes for your opponent in that state NO LONGER MATTER IN ANY WAY get it? see how its out of date?


This isn't entirely true. Two states (Nebraska and Maine) can split their electors. Colorado defeated a measure (handily, in 2004) to do something similar. States decide how their electors are apportioned and chosen.

So if you want change, not only should you lobby your senators and congressional representatives, you should also lobby your state representatives and governor.



i do
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Bomber085
Originally posted by F8n4tune

As for the $250,000 argument you guys do realize that it's NOT the whole $250,000 that will be taxed but anything over it ?

Now how many REAL people make over $250,000 ? *shakes head* at what people argue about.


What are you talking about? They aren't going to tax anyone who makes under $250k? Really?

That's about the dumbest comment I have EVER heard!

VOTE MCCAIN!



You are correct. I was a personal financial advisor for a couple years and it is amazing how little people understand about their own taxes.

Tax deduction is the most misunderstood phrase about taxes for Americans.

Many think $1,000 tax deduction = $1,000 cash to them.

Many think tax deductible dinner of $50 = $50 they get back at the end of the year.


I almost pulled my hair out several times trying to explain this to people and I'm not even a CPA. Poor accountants.
 
mikelj
offline
Link
 
I said that the Electoral college isnt necessarily the best way, BUT it is better since it gives EVERY state a chance to matter. Or else just a few states would matter.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.