User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Has there been any discussion of instituting NCAA overtime rules?
Page:
 
DrkSandman
Baseballs
offline
Link
 
I'm on board for this. Great idea.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
keepin the faith
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Was there any debate about this, and has Bort spoken on it? I definitely prefer the college rule because it is both more entertaining and a much better way of breaking a tie.

I'm sure this thread has been done before, but (insert salty comment about search function here).

Edited to be included in the initial post:

We all know this is GLB, not NFL, so there's no reason we should be married to every rule in the NFL rulebook. This is especially true of rules that actually detract from the game and have more to do with finishing on time than encouraging the highest quality of sport.

Re: the 2 point conversion issue. Until 2 point conversions are added to the game, we will leave out the portion of the rule forcing teams to go for 2 in 3OT. Once it's added, switch it over.

Thanks to any mods or admins who are willing to take this suggestion into consideration.



Once teams loses because of a missed XPAT the forums will erupt with kickers are broken.

The system is fine the way it is.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman

Once teams loses because of a missed XPAT the forums will erupt with kickers are broken.

The system is fine the way it is.


Where have you been? They've been screaming that forever.

The system sucks the way it is. IMO
 
Arcadic
offline
Link
 
Just rid of the 2pt/xp step of this until 3rd OT. At least till the 2pt conversion is added, then just do NO xp and after the 3rd OT do 2pt conversions.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by SwagOnLock

Was there any debate about this, and has Bort spoken on it? I definitely prefer the college rule because it is both more entertaining and a much better way of breaking a tie.

I'm sure this thread has been done before, but (insert salty comment about search function here).

Edited to be included in the initial post:

We all know this is GLB, not NFL, so there's no reason we should be married to every rule in the NFL rulebook. This is especially true of rules that actually detract from the game and have more to do with finishing on time than encouraging the highest quality of sport.

Re: the 2 point conversion issue. Until 2 point conversions are added to the game, we will leave out the portion of the rule forcing teams to go for 2 in 3OT. Once it's added, switch it over.

Thanks to any mods or admins who are willing to take this suggestion into consideration.



Once teams loses because of a missed XPAT the forums will erupt with kickers are broken.

The system is fine the way it is.


Not any more than they already do. Missed PATs have cost teams plenty of games, missing in OT hurts more but isn't any greater of an issue.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by czman


Once teams loses because of a missed XPAT the forums will erupt with kickers are broken.

The system is fine the way it is.


Where have you been? They've been screaming that forever.

The system sucks the way it is. IMO


There screams are mostly about non-factors though. I do not think it would be wise to give them an actual reason for their yelps.

"Let's face it - anger outweighs joy when it comes to this community" From an admin on another site but very true.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman

There screams are mostly about non-factors though. I do not think it would be wise to give them an actual reason for their yelps.

"Let's face it - anger outweighs joy when it comes to this community" From an admin on another site but very true.


Bort has said that there is only 1 make_kick function, so if they miss a PAT then its because of low stamina or bad build.

One guy has lost 2 playoff games because of a missed PAT. It happens.

This thread isn't about giving K something to cry about. Its trying to make games more suspenseful instead of it being decided (basically) on a coin flip.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by Knick

Originally posted by czman



Once teams loses because of a missed XPAT the forums will erupt with kickers are broken.

The system is fine the way it is.


Where have you been? They've been screaming that forever.

The system sucks the way it is. IMO


There screams are mostly about non-factors though. I do not think it would be wise to give them an actual reason for their yelps.

"Let's face it - anger outweighs joy when it comes to this community" From an admin on another site but very true.


How are their screams about non-factors? A point is a point is a point. Just because it happens in overtime doesn't make it any more valid or worthwhile (or any less).
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SwagOnLock
Originally posted by czman

Originally posted by SwagOnLock


Was there any debate about this, and has Bort spoken on it? I definitely prefer the college rule because it is both more entertaining and a much better way of breaking a tie.

I'm sure this thread has been done before, but (insert salty comment about search function here).

Edited to be included in the initial post:

We all know this is GLB, not NFL, so there's no reason we should be married to every rule in the NFL rulebook. This is especially true of rules that actually detract from the game and have more to do with finishing on time than encouraging the highest quality of sport.

Re: the 2 point conversion issue. Until 2 point conversions are added to the game, we will leave out the portion of the rule forcing teams to go for 2 in 3OT. Once it's added, switch it over.

Thanks to any mods or admins who are willing to take this suggestion into consideration.



Once teams loses because of a missed XPAT the forums will erupt with kickers are broken.

The system is fine the way it is.


Not any more than they already do. Missed PATs have cost teams plenty of games, missing in OT hurts more but isn't any greater of an issue.


When you compare the amount of XPAT that happen in regulation and compare it to the amount that matter in this game,I would say it is a very small %. All of the XPAT would matter in OT and kickers would be at their lowest energy at that point too.

 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick


Its trying to make games more suspenseful instead of it being decided (basically) on a coin flip.


We lost a playoff game in overtime.

We should have played better defense. If you lose the coin flip go out there are stop someone. If you cannot do that then you do not deserve to win that game.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by Knick



Its trying to make games more suspenseful instead of it being decided (basically) on a coin flip.


We lost a playoff game in overtime.

We should have played better defense. If you lose the coin flip go out there are stop someone. If you cannot do that then you do not deserve to win that game.


A GLB K has made a 67 yard FG.

Even with a touchback your defense only has to allow 30 yards.

And right now Offense >>>>> Defense

I'm just trying to say that even a GREAT defense can't stop the fact that K are ridiculous right now.
Last edited Nov 17, 2008 23:16:11
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Knick
Originally posted by czman

Originally posted by Knick




Its trying to make games more suspenseful instead of it being decided (basically) on a coin flip.


We lost a playoff game in overtime.

We should have played better defense. If you lose the coin flip go out there are stop someone. If you cannot do that then you do not deserve to win that game.


A GLB K has made a 67 yard FG.

Even with a touchback your defense only has to allow 30 yards.

And right now Offense >>>>> Defense

I'm just trying to say that even a GREAT defense can't stop the fact that K are ridiculous right now.


1 kicker who has made 1 FG does not make a tendency. Moreover, if the kicker missed that FG in overtime the defending team would get great field position.
 
SwagOnLock
offline
Link
 
I'm happy to see the dissent because 1) you're among the first to disagree with the idea and 2) the VERY first to give any substantial reason why.

I understand what you're saying about going out and stopping somebody. That's football, play defense, get it done, I get it. But a sudden death overtime makes absolutely no sense in a sport where there are specific defensive units, and specific offensive units. In hockey? Sure. Everyone on the ice has to play defense, and everyone on the ice has to play offense. In soccer? Same deal. Football isn't like that.

In football, you're only playing one half of a team against the other half of a team. It goes against the very spirit of the sport.
 
Knick
Sknickers
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman

1 kicker who has made 1 FG does not make a tendency. Moreover, if the kicker missed that FG in overtime the defending team would get great field position.


There was a thread in Game Replays the other day. I saw around 15+ K who hit a 60+ FG. This was not 'on occasion' this was like 4/5 accuracy. How many kickers do you think there are that don't visit the forums?

And how many MORE kickers will be able to do that sort of thing in a few seasons?

I don't even want to see how far back they'll be able to kick it by Season 10. Which is why I support this.

And yes I realize the Risk/Reward factor, but I would just like to see a little suspense added.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.