User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > New Plays/Playbooks
Page:
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by ron2288

I just logged on and looked at the new stuff....it looks awesome

I have a question. I have not read thru this whole thread so if it has been discussed forgive me.

If I want my back HB to run a sweep I would set it to run the sweep then set it for HB2?
I have only 2 HB's on the roster. Again I just saw the title of this thread and posted this so if this has been discussed sorry to bring it back up


Check your Depth Chart page and it should make sense.


thank you Bort
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Football Genius

If a GM try's to run that play more than dozen times they will get shut down by a run defense.


How so? The team will also have a pure passer throwing the ball. Not to mention that the QB sweeps have an extra blocker compared to HB sweeps. Even if the QB is 70-80% as effective as a HB at the sweep, the extra lead blocker will make a huge difference, while the team still maintains a 100% ability to pass.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
I can think of another possible 'problem' in the future.

If there ever comes in HB/WR trick plays where they throw the ball...you could then feasibly put a QB in the WR3 or RB2 spot and cheese this way as well.

Something to think about in conjunction with the QB1 dilemma here. These extra slots were meant to give depth in the spirit of the game...where the RB slots are for RBs, people who carry the ball expressly. Or QB slots for people who throw the ball expressly. But having added plays like QB rush plays and WR/HB trick plays (passing), will mean cheese.

Last edited Nov 2, 2008 03:29:37
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG


This would be a good idea. I guess if/when Bort expands the defensive options to allow for personnel settings then the QB-QB1 thing could be brought in then??


The way I see it, this is Beta right? We all know what Beta means. Putting in running QB plays with no way to determine which QB runs the play, is like having the peanut butter and no Jelly.

Everyone has been asking for a way to determine which HB runs the ball on which play, and Qb running play's.

Now we have the running play's but we are left to chance between a guy who is a pocket passer and very little ability to run, and a guy that can do both ok but not great with either, or guy who can run and absolutely no ability to throw.

Just have to Close your eyes and hope the right QB is in on the right play?
I think if Bort add's a restricted QB1 slot and it looks like its unbalanced then Nerf it, or take it out completely but let's at least try it.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
What I think should happen is totally restricting all depth chart slots.

QB-only QB.
HB/FB-only HB/FB.
WR-only WR/TE.
TE-only TE/FB.
MLB/ILB-only LB.
OLB-only LB/DE.
SS-only SS/FS.
FS-only FS/SS.
CB-only CB/SS/FS.
DT-only DT.
DE-only DT/DE/LB.
K-only K/P.
P-only P/K.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
I can think of another possible 'problem' in the future.

If there ever comes in HB/WR trick plays where they throw the ball...you could then feasibly put a QB in the WR3 or RB2 spot and cheese this way as well.

Something to think about in conjunction with the QB1 dilemma here. These extra slots were meant to give depth in the spirit of the game...where the RB slots are for RBs, people who carry the ball expressly. Or QB slots for people who throw the ball expressly. But having added plays like QB rush plays and WR/HB trick plays (passing), will mean cheese.



OK man, Now you are just trying to take out trick plays all together, If you want to compare to NFL there are a ton of players who have done it,

Randle El, Randal Cunn., Cordell Stewart, Hines Ward, LT Throws Td's, the Wild cat formation Miami is running now and the Jets copied. The list goes on and on.

Anyone that try's to run these on a regular basis with high frequency will get burnt by a Good DC.
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by GG

I mean right now, I could transfer all my EQT into one of my RBs throwing, and with their high vision and throwing up to about 30 now, that would do them well enough to throw when needed (short/med passes) and just run the ball all game from QB rush plays. That kind of thing is too cheesey but will be done by some GMs out there.


OOP penalty is fairly high for HB -> QB tho. QB is really the only position that can play QB without at least a 30-40% OOP penalty.


I think the issue here is that passing relies too much on strength and vision, and not enough on throwing.

This is why we see people toss in their punter at QB for fun, and the punter does OK. The punter already has high strength and vision. His lack of throwing doesn't seem to impede his throwing skills... if a punter has 80 strength and 50 vision, a 40% penalty still leaves him with decent STR/VIS for a QB, and he doesn't have any throwing to penalize.

On the "QBs built like HBs" thing... that's the player's prerogative. However, this will be rare IMO. If he's the starting QB it makes the opponent's DC happy to have an easy matchup. If he's only in on certain plays... well, not many people will take a consistent 15 plays a game and not have a problem with it. It would be a gimmick player.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
What I think should happen is totally restricting all depth chart slots.

QB-only QB.
HB/FB-only HB/FB.
WR-only WR/TE.
TE-only TE/FB.
MLB/ILB-only LB.
OLB-only LB/DE.
SS-only SS/FS.
FS-only FS/SS.
CB-only CB/SS/FS.
DT-only DT.
DE-only DT/DE/LB.
K-only K/P.
P-only P/K.


I agree with that too, but lets ride one horse at a time.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Football Genius

Just have to Close your eyes and hope the right QB is in on the right play?


Or run what your QB can handle. If he is a scrambler, meaning he can throw a bit, and has running abilities, then by all means, throw in some running plays.

If your QB is a pure pocket passer, then it is well-advised to NOT try many running plays. Maybe a QB sneak every once in awhile...but nothing drastic.

If your QB is a pure running QB, then try to avoid passing, but feel free to dominate with the new QB running plays.

The problem is, with a QB1 position, teams could dominate with a running QB, AND still have a great passing game.
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
What I think should happen is totally restricting all depth chart slots.

QB-only QB.
HB/FB-only HB/FB.
WR-only WR/TE.
TE-only TE/FB.
MLB/ILB-only LB.
OLB-only LB/DE.
SS-only SS/FS.
FS-only FS/SS.
CB-only CB/SS/FS.
DT-only DT.
DE-only DT/DE/LB.
K-only K/P.
P-only P/K.


As always...the offensive line is forgot about...
 
Deathblade
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin

On the "QBs built like HBs" thing... that's the player's prerogative. However, this will be rare IMO. If he's the starting QB it makes the opponent's DC happy to have an easy matchup. If he's only in on certain plays... well, not many people will take a consistent 15 plays a game and not have a problem with it. It would be a gimmick player.


He could play HB...

Or is the OOP penalty for QB playing HB also around 40%?

Edit:
Triple post...wow.
Last edited Nov 2, 2008 03:38:09
 
ron2288
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
What I think should happen is totally restricting all depth chart slots.

QB-only QB.
HB/FB-only HB/FB.
WR-only WR/TE.
TE-only TE/FB.
MLB/ILB-only LB.
OLB-only LB/DE.
SS-only SS/FS.
FS-only FS/SS.
CB-only CB/SS/FS.
DT-only DT.
DE-only DT/DE/LB.
K-only K/P.
P-only P/K.


I agree with you on most..but you do you see CB's play WR every now then
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
Or is the OOP penalty for QB playing HB also around 40%?


Yeah, QB's don't really do well doing much else other than playing QB.

I think GG might be on the right track with general restrictions on playing OOP. Nobody's really abused it yet, but the more options we add, the more likely they will.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Amyrlin

I think the issue here is that passing relies too much on strength and vision, and not enough on throwing.

This is why we see people toss in their punter at QB for fun, and the punter does OK. The punter already has high strength and vision. His lack of throwing doesn't seem to impede his throwing skills... if a punter has 80 strength and 50 vision, a 40% penalty still leaves him with decent STR/VIS for a QB, and he doesn't have any throwing to penalize.


This is something I've often mentioned in my posts about fixing the player attributes system. See, you're touching on an area here that is key imo. If you look at d-league players, their FOOTBALL SKILLS all down at 12, they STILL block, tackle, carry, catch, throw, kick and punt very very well. Too well. If these level 1 d-leaguers PHYSICAL ATTRIBUTES are so child-like with 12 strenght, speed, etc, and you can SEE it in the replays, then these football skills should be also child-like---where RBs do stupid stuff like trip over themselves, run backwards, QBs who have 30% comp rate, WRs who drop 50 balls a game, LBs who miss 50 tackles a game, and linemen who totally blow all their blocking assignments.

This is kinda the problem here, because Bort has programmed the football skills very HIGH by default to allow low level players to actually play a good standard of football that makes it as realistic as the pros in terms of completions, catches, etc.

This is why people can exploit the player building system where they have WRs with 100 speed, agility 50, and they can leave everything else at 20 and they get away with it. Their players have 16 TDs, 1000 yards etc, even tho they have 20 catching, 20 vision, etc.

Last edited Nov 2, 2008 03:49:06
 
GG
offline
Link
 
EDIT....

CBs and WRs could play WR and CB as well.

And OL is simple enough...all OL can play in the OL. Dont allow anyone else.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.