User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > The new promotion system
Page:
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
If there is a method, that sounds fine.. Random would be a disaster...
 
Nats Kule
offline
Link
 
Pretty certain this is how it works.

Step 1. Normal promotion/relegation, 1 up 2 down.

Step 2. All CPU and flagged teams are removed. Gaps are then filled in according to Bort's Rules of Promotion. Pro teams are filled by their two AAA, then the 2 AAA by the 4 AA on down the chain. Regular relationships apply (AA#3 Zeta and AA#4 Zeta fill AAA#2 Zeta, etc.)

Step 3. Teams that have been removed are then reset and added to the open spots in the lowest level in the region.

Don't like the use of the scrimmages to count, but it is what it is.

Question that needs answered: What is the criteria to flag a team to move them down and how does that process work.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by nfratami

A lot of people argue that college sports (basketball, football) are more exciting because of the importance of every last game. To me it seems like GLB is taking a route that would be like the NIT (virtually a consolation bracket) meaning more than the regular season in college basketball.


I'm actually in the camp of opposing a college football playoff system because it takes away from that importance of "every last game," but it seems like there are an awful lot of people who want to see teams who have lost 8-16% of their regular season games still be able to be selected for an 8-team playoff. Support for a playoff system takes away from the incredible importance of each regular season football game.

For basketball it's already there -- no one remembers who finishes second in the ACC, but everyone knows the Sweet Sixteen teams. Rather than comparing promotions from postseason scrimmages to the NIT, I expect it will be more like the main tourney's #3/#4 consolation game during the Final Four. Teams that didn't make it to the playoffs (and probably at least to the second round, if not the conference championship games) aren't realistically going to promote.

But I'm not particularly in favor of one way or the other - was just describing how I see it working with the mechanics Bort has provided.
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by scottyxWINx
Originally posted by nfratami


Also, you know there will be those juggernaut teams that will lose in the playoffs, and then attempt to stay in the lower league by throwing scrimmage games, either so they can stick around and try to get a trophy, or play against lesser competition.


Exactly, it will happen all the time.


That would be crap. I'm sure it could happen to some extent but I'm hoping not a whole lot. That's another reason I'd like to see a bigger difference in income between league levels.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 22:54:11
 
tautology
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tigerbait22
Originally posted by itsme4

Originally posted by tigerbait22


How will the scrimmages be determined is my question... Who plays who, and on what basis?


Bort and a dartboard


Can't be luck of the draw..... Where you play a scrub team from the other division.. makes no sense..


Post season scrimmages attempt to pair teams based on parity of standing within the conference, I believe.
 
tigerbait22
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tautology
Originally posted by tigerbait22

Originally posted by itsme4


Originally posted by tigerbait22



How will the scrimmages be determined is my question... Who plays who, and on what basis?


Bort and a dartboard


Can't be luck of the draw..... Where you play a scrub team from the other division.. makes no sense..


Post season scrimmages attempt to pair teams based on parity of standing within the conference, I believe.


In my recollection that tends to be true.. Can't remember anything other than a close match up.. so I think you are right
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
So without reading this entire thing, riddle me this Batman:

There are 5 gutted or previously gutted teams in a conference. Only one of them is a CPU team but the others are not competitive at all. Are all 5 teams going to be relegated this off-season? I know there is talk of a team being flagged but I do not know if that is active yet.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=38&conference_id=75&playoffs=0

Take that league for example. Austin is CPU owned but Dallas, LA, KC, SA (still has CPU starters) are not competitive. What happens?
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 23:56:18
 
Nats Kule
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Modok
So without reading this entire thing, riddle me this Batman:

There are 5 gutted or previously gutted teams in a conference. Only one of them is a CPU team but the others are not competitive at all. Are all 5 teams going to be relegated this off-season? I know there is talk of a team being flagged but I do not know if that is active yet.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/league.pl?league_id=38&conference_id=75&playoffs=0

Take that league for example. Austin is CPU owned but Dallas, LA, KC, SA (still has CPU starters) are not competitive. What happens?


They should be flagged, no one currently knows how that is done, or if an Admin just says bam you're flagged.

In your example 2 would be relegated down to BBB then the other 3 would be removed to BBB along with any gutted flag teams that were relegated down from AA #4.

We do need an answer on the requirements and process for flagging noncompetitive teams.
 
Bigmo6967
offline
Link
 
First I read a couple of days ago that GLB has too many meaningless games. Now it seems everyone thinks there are too many games that mean too much. Your either gonna gameplan for your scrimmages or not and save the "Which O-line guy wants to be a punt returner" for your preseason.
 
Galactus
offline
Link
 
The whole scrimmage debate is a discussion about semantics. Rename the post season scrimmage games (something like consolation games), post how they will be scheduled and it won't feel like such an issue.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Painmaker
Originally posted by scottyxWINx

Originally posted by nfratami



Also, you know there will be those juggernaut teams that will lose in the playoffs, and then attempt to stay in the lower league by throwing scrimmage games, either so they can stick around and try to get a trophy, or play against lesser competition.


Exactly, it will happen all the time.


That would be crap. I'm sure it could happen to some extent but I'm hoping not a whole lot. That's another reason I'd like to see a bigger difference in income between league levels.


Agree, league income level difference should be a lot greater. Also, scrimmage records should not be used. They are as meaningless as team scouting bars.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Galactus
The whole scrimmage debate is a discussion about semantics. Rename the post season scrimmage games (something like consolation games), post how they will be scheduled and it won't feel like such an issue.


I don't think change the name will change the nature of these games. The bottom line is that these games are meaningless, there are no reward attached to winning these games, heck, the stats don't even count. So most teams use them to try different stuff that they wouldn't normally do in the season, like putting WR at QB position etc.
 
Modok
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Galactus

The whole scrimmage debate is a discussion about semantics. Rename the post season scrimmage games (something like consolation games), post how they will be scheduled and it won't feel like such an issue.


I don't think change the name will change the nature of these games. The bottom line is that these games are meaningless, there are no reward attached to winning these games, heck, the stats don't even count. So most teams use them to try different stuff that they wouldn't normally do in the season, like putting WR at QB position etc.


They are no longer meaningless unless you want to not promote. Then throw the game.
 
Arya Stark
offline
Link
 
Just to get this right, is it total team career playoff victories or just this year?

This is important. Picture this:

A team in our conf has 3 career playoff losses. If they get to the final this year and lose it they will be 2-4 in p/o wins and losses. (0-3 from previous years and 2-1 this year)

Compare them with my team in the same league who have been to the playoffs twice, 3-0 (not counting the Div game win) and 2-1 for a total record of 5-1. Even if we lose the first round, we'd be at 5-2 at worst.

In that case, we'd have a free card for the Pros if the other team got to & lost the final. Not sure that's fair. (and this excludes the results & records of other teams of course)

And does the playoffs count the Div final?
 
Painmaker
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Arya Stark
Just to get this right, is it total team career playoff victories or just this year?


I'm positive they're "current season" victories.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.