User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > GLB Notes > CPL > Interesting topic of the Week: Evolutionism versus Creationism
Page:
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
<Gturtle> but ultimately, I'm not going to support that decision, because the invisible lion theory is just as much a theory as the slanted surface + gravity theory
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

It just seems that the perfectness of all the things that came about as we understand more and more leads me to believe it was all a master plan....and not just random.


The complexity and delicate balance of life is hardly compelling evidence. Creationism is certainly an elegant and beautiful story, I'll give you that, but not much more than that.



Maybe we define Creationism differently also? I simply definite it that there was a higher force which planned out everything.

When people want to talk about teaching Creationism in schools, I don't think they are talking about about "what God did on day 1". I think they are talking about a different view than "everything evolved from single celled organisms by pure chance".
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
I'm having trouble understanding how any thoughts/beliefs you have could fall outside of those three choices.


Because they do? You are only accounting for three philosophies/belief systems in your choices. Let me show you:


[ ]There is a god (theistic choice)
[ ]There may or may not be a god (agnostic choice, among others)
[ ]There is no god (strong atheistic choice)

Again, that certainly doesn't cover what I would be classified which is a weak atheist which is basically the equivalent of "I can't answer this question because I didn't bring a sharpened #2 pencil".
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
I'm having trouble understanding how any thoughts/beliefs you have could fall outside of those three choices.


 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

I'm having trouble understanding how any thoughts/beliefs you have could fall outside of those three choices.


Because they do? You are only accounting for three philosophies/belief systems in your choices. Let me show you:


[ ]There is a god (theistic choice)
[ ]There may or may not be a god (agnostic choice, among others)
[ ]There is no god (strong atheistic choice)

Again, that certainly doesn't cover what I would be classified which is a weak atheist which is basically the equivalent of "I can't answer this question because I didn't bring a sharpened #2 pencil".


You're being a nit here, either you're 100% God, 100% no God, or some 99-1/1-99% inbetween. THat's the point. I fail to see what numbers you could possibly believe that wouldn't qualify.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
Forum Jesus needs his questions answered
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Strong atheism, yes. Weak atheism, not so much. Which is why I made the distinction is atheistic philosophy.

What I'm saying is, strictly from a literal/etymological standpoint, the word means to deny the existence of a god/supreme being. It's semantics, yes, and I understand that language evolves with use, but it's just a pet peeve of mine.

Especially because the word itself is pejorative by nature, and defining one's self/position by the terms of another (consciously or unconscious) is inherently limiting.
 
Cuivienen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
We know so little in comparison of the universe, saying you know for certain there's no god is arrogant like mad.

Just say, "It's much bigger then me, I don't know".



Not really. Let me explain, with some very heavy paraphrasing to keep it light.

René Descartes is famous for basically establishing the correct way to think, for lack of a better phrase. From Wikipedia:

Originally posted by
He has been dubbed the "Father of Modern Philosophy," and much of subsequent Western philosophy is a response to his writings which continue to be studied closely to this day.
...
Descartes was also one of the key figures in the Scientific Revolution.


The reason I am bringing Descartes up is because he basically says that you should assume nothing exists. You have to prove something exists before you can consider it to exist.

All science is based on this principle. All of it. If you assumed things existed before you proved them, science simply couldn't work. One false assumption and every single scientific principle that comes after it will be wrong as well. This is why you have to categorically prove everything before you can assume it exists.

Now, you might say that is science and this is philosophy. That is why I quoted Wikipedia. Descartes is primarily a philosopher, not a scientist. I wrote about the scientific method because people are more familiar with that.

The question of whether god(s) exist(s) or not is a philosophical one. According to Descartes, you should assume that god(s) doesn't/don't exist until you can prove that it/they do(es). Therefore, unless you have sufficient proof (which some people think they do), the correct point of view is an atheistic one.

Now, you can say you disagree with Descartes, which is also a valid argument. That was another reason I brought up the scientific method. All that science has accomplished since Descartes was alive is pretty compelling evidence that his method of thinking is the correct one.

"Just say[ing], 'It's much bigger then me, I don't know'." is a cop out really. In my opinion, that makes it the least respectable opinion. At least theists are taking a stand and saying they have sufficient evidence to prove to themselves that god(s) exist(s). An intelligent agnostic would say there is some evidence that leads me to believe that god(s) might exist but not enough for me to be certain, not this question is too complicated for me and I don't want to think about it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by Deathblade
<Gturtle> Someone ask VT if I need to believe in the invisible lion that might be in my room right now. I've got no way of telling one way or the other, but I'm pretty sure that might've been why that pencil fell off my desk.


False analogy. You can test to see if an invisible lion is in your room. A better comparision might be an inter-diminsional lion, and I can't prove whether it is or isn't.
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by X

Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder


I'm having trouble understanding how any thoughts/beliefs you have could fall outside of those three choices.


Because they do? You are only accounting for three philosophies/belief systems in your choices. Let me show you:


[ ]There is a god (theistic choice)
[ ]There may or may not be a god (agnostic choice, among others)
[ ]There is no god (strong atheistic choice)

Again, that certainly doesn't cover what I would be classified which is a weak atheist which is basically the equivalent of "I can't answer this question because I didn't bring a sharpened #2 pencil".


You're being a nit here, either you're 100% God, 100% no God, or some 99-1/1-99% inbetween. THat's the point. I fail to see what numbers you could possibly believe that wouldn't qualify.


Sorry, but you are asking me to characterize myself as something that I am not. I'm not 100% God or 100% Not God or anything in between. I'm 100% that I don't have a God-belief. Doesn't mean I believe that God doesn't exist.

I'm not really trying to be contentious here. I just don't know any other way to describe it.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder

Originally posted by X


Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder



I'm having trouble understanding how any thoughts/beliefs you have could fall outside of those three choices.


Because they do? You are only accounting for three philosophies/belief systems in your choices. Let me show you:


[ ]There is a god (theistic choice)
[ ]There may or may not be a god (agnostic choice, among others)
[ ]There is no god (strong atheistic choice)

Again, that certainly doesn't cover what I would be classified which is a weak atheist which is basically the equivalent of "I can't answer this question because I didn't bring a sharpened #2 pencil".


You're being a nit here, either you're 100% God, 100% no God, or some 99-1/1-99% inbetween. THat's the point. I fail to see what numbers you could possibly believe that wouldn't qualify.


Sorry, but you are asking me to characterize myself as something that I am not. I'm not 100% God or 100% Not God or anything in between. I'm 100% that I don't have a God-belief. Doesn't mean I believe that God doesn't exist.

I'm not really trying to be contentious here. I just don't know any other way to describe it.


This seems like a largely semantic difference
 
X
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Asheme
Originally posted by X

Strong atheism, yes. Weak atheism, not so much. Which is why I made the distinction is atheistic philosophy.

What I'm saying is, strictly from a literal/etymological standpoint, the word means to deny the existence of a god/supreme being. It's semantics, yes, and I understand that language evolves with use, but it's just a pet peeve of mine.

Especially because the word itself is pejorative by nature, and defining one's self/position by the terms of another (consciously or unconscious) is inherently limiting.


*shrug* I get you. Well, from an etymological standpoint, maybe not. But from a practical standpoint, yes, I am an atheist. If I walked into an atheist/agnostic/humanist/non-theist organizational meeting and said "I lack a belief in a god" then they'd say, "You are an atheist" or maybe more specifically "You are a weak atheist".
Last edited Oct 12, 2008 19:56:21
 
Asheme
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Cuivienen
Therefore, unless you have sufficient proof (which some people think they do), the correct point of view is an atheistic one.

You're forgetting Descartes also provides an ontological proof for God's existence.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by X
Originally posted by Asheme

Originally posted by X


Strong atheism, yes. Weak atheism, not so much. Which is why I made the distinction is atheistic philosophy.

What I'm saying is, strictly from a literal/etymological standpoint, the word means to deny the existence of a god/supreme being. It's semantics, yes, and I understand that language evolves with use, but it's just a pet peeve of mine.

Especially because the word itself is pejorative by nature, and defining one's self/position by the terms of another (consciously or unconscious) is inherently limiting.


*shrug* I get you. Well, from an etymological standpoint, maybe not. But from a practical standpoint, yes, I am an atheist. If I walked into an atheist/agnostic/humanist/non-theist organizational method and said "I lack a belief in a god" then they'd say, "You are an atheist" or maybe more specifically "You are a weak atheist".


I just got off. I love answers.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Vanilla Thunder
Originally posted by Deathblade

<Gturtle> Someone ask VT if I need to believe in the invisible lion that might be in my room right now. I've got no way of telling one way or the other, but I'm pretty sure that might've been why that pencil fell off my desk.


False analogy. You can test to see if an invisible lion is in your room. A better comparision might be an inter-diminsional lion, and I can't prove whether it is or isn't.


<Gturtle> "whether or not I test to exist, is the invisible, interdimensional lion worth praying to? what has invisible lion done for me?"
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.