User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Defense AI occasionally not followed
Page:
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

...

Most of the "occasional" problems involve calling an offensive or defensive play that doesn't exist.

...


Sorry, but that's a BUG.

It is widespread known that there are limited offensive plays.

But Bort never announced that he just didn't code certain defensive plays - just like there's no pathing for a certain blitz combination vs. a certain offensive play - WHILE THE VERY SAME PLAY IS CODED VS. ALMOST ALL OTHER OFFENSIVE PLAYS.

So while I can understand somehow that you don't want to share your knowledge of the bug, you shouldn't deny that this is actually a bug.

Easiest fix: Bort should just tell people about it - or have a list announced of non-existing plays.


To point this out:

- knowing that a certain blitz has a different pathing vs. a certain play = secret to keep
- knowing that a certain blitz leads to a malfunction = bug = help to solve the issue




It is obviously not widespread enough known to the OP who was insisted that there was nothing wrong with him calling long passes to his TE.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

...

Most of the "occasional" problems involve calling an offensive or defensive play that doesn't exist.

...


Sorry, but that's a BUG.

It is widespread known that there are limited offensive plays.

But Bort never announced that he just didn't code certain defensive plays - just like there's no pathing for a certain blitz combination vs. a certain offensive play - WHILE THE VERY SAME PLAY IS CODED VS. ALMOST ALL OTHER OFFENSIVE PLAYS.

So while I can understand somehow that you don't want to share your knowledge of the bug, you shouldn't deny that this is actually a bug.

Easiest fix: Bort should just tell people about it - or have a list announced of non-existing plays.


To point this out:

- knowing that a certain blitz has a different pathing vs. a certain play = secret to keep
- knowing that a certain blitz leads to a malfunction = bug = help to solve the issue



Bort only recently listed the offensive plays. Before that only some teams had figured out what plays existed and which didn't. I don't recall anyone sharing a list with everyone of what plays existed and what plays would produce a "random CPU play". Do you?

If Bort wants to list all the defenses that work and don't, that is up to him. Very few people even realized that you couldn't blitz from the outside rush, pass defense. On after pulling my hair out and losing a few key games a couple seasons ago, he finally admitted it. Since then I realized he isn't going to give us everything and next time I found something, to keep it to myself.

There. I gave 2 nuggets of info to you now. Figure out the rest like I had to.

Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:00:02
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by RAPB

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=146243&pbp_id=6071961

This is the single back big. We play one of our single back plays (3-3-5 and MLB + ROLB blitzing) - instead of the single back big plays (3-4 and 4-3 + no blitzers).

The single back big - input is above the single back inputs, so it should have triggered. But it has not!


I just realized that it must even go as far as some basic packages are not coded (base formations, coverage shell, zone/man underneath, play type focus, LB shift). The plays not called didn't involve ANY blitzing.


I don't think it is related to blitz. In my case, I explicitly set 100 to players I want to blitz and set 0 to others. I also have max number of blitzers set properly. However, sometimes the same play is correctly called and sometimes isn't.

This is a legit bug after all.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Very few people even realized that you couldn't blitz from the outside rush, pass defense.


Not true, this happens all the time. For example: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141084&pbp_id=7689063
 
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Very few people even realized that you couldn't blitz from the outside rush, pass defense.


Not true, this happens all the time. For example: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141084&pbp_id=7689063



That is not a 4-3 defense which calls for the the defense to stop outside plays. This was back in season 2 before the new AI came in. Here is an example of the defense I'm talking about. Note the DE's dropping into coverage:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1967013


There was no way to blitz out of that defense and Bort did not make it known.

Just like he didn't make it known what would happen if you called a play that doesn't exist like pass to TE deep.


But it seems you already know everything, so I guess I'm wasting my time here.

Bort has let this thread sit here on the top of the Bugs pile for 2 weeks for a reason: He's not going to answer every detail of the game. He wants you to experiment and find stuff out on your own.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
...
Bort only recently listed the offensive plays. Before that only some teams had figured out what plays existed and which didn't. I don't recall anyone sharing a list with everyone of what plays existed and what plays would produce a "random CPU play". Do you?


Right. The long pass to the TE was tricky - for you could determine the general pathing. And before Bort announced the plays I always thought the primary receiver might change (so same plays called, but different primary receiver). Was hard to tell, because TEs don't get that open usually (and if they do, most likely a WR does even better).

No brainer was
- the long pass to the FB
- pitch/sweep FB / QB
- off-tackle FB / QB

Originally posted by SteelersInsider

If Bort wants to list all the defenses that work and don't, that is up to him. Very few people even realized that you couldn't blitz from the outside rush, pass defense. On after pulling my hair out and losing a few key games a couple seasons ago, he finally admitted it. Since then I realized he isn't going to give us everything and next time I found something, to keep it to myself.

There. I gave 2 nuggets of info to you now. Figure out the rest like I had to.


Thanks for sure. But why couldn't you admit that it's actually a bug? I'm not asking for all impossible combinations (since I wouldn't try to call a 3-1-7 and blitz all CBs anyway). But it's still a malfunction i.m.h.o.

And the play I provided was without any blitzer - so just an impossible combination of shell, underneath coverage setting, distance, focus and shift. Just tell me real quick (yes or no): did YOU know that for some offensive plays some of these BASIC settings don't work?

Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
Originally posted by SteelersInsider


Very few people even realized that you couldn't blitz from the outside rush, pass defense.


Not true, this happens all the time. For example: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141084&pbp_id=7689063


That's an MLB blitz. SI is probably talking about a blitz of both OLBs out of a run or pass focus + coverage distance long in some shell (maybe cover 2 or 3). That's just something you come up with when you set up a play, then alter it because you like to improve it a bit. Suddenly it doesn't work anymore and all you did was change one single setting...
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Very few people even realized that you couldn't blitz from the outside rush, pass defense.


Not true, this happens all the time. For example: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141084&pbp_id=7689063



That is not a 4-3 defense which calls for the the defense to stop outside plays. This was back in season 2 before the new AI came in. Here is an example of the defense I'm talking about. Note the DE's dropping into coverage:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1967013


There was no way to blitz out of that defense and Bort did not make it known.

Just like he didn't make it known what would happen if you called a play that doesn't exist like pass to TE deep.


But it seems you already know everything, so I guess I'm wasting my time here.

Bort has let this thread sit here on the top of the Bugs pile for 2 weeks for a reason: He's not going to answer every detail of the game. He wants you to experiment and find stuff out on your own.


Then you will need to be more specific, what player blitz would make this play calling skipped? Anyway, now you say it only applies to 4-3. Then this has nothing to do with OP's case since the play defense AI tester showed was 3-4 cover 0.

You still fail to answer what blitz package makes 3-4 cover 0 illegal? I have a scrimmage today and can test whatever you said. I still think you don't know what caused the bug because you would have said it loud already and acted like you are superior to everyone.

Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:49:35
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB

Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Very few people even realized that you couldn't blitz from the outside rush, pass defense.


Not true, this happens all the time. For example: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141084&pbp_id=7689063


That's an MLB blitz. SI is probably talking about a blitz of both OLBs out of a run or pass focus + coverage distance long in some shell (maybe cover 2 or 3). That's just something you come up with when you set up a play, then alter it because you like to improve it a bit. Suddenly it doesn't work anymore and all you did was change one single setting...


I can test whatever SI said if he could be specific. He simply said "outside rush, pass defense" and it has been proved untrue. If he wants to insist this is not a bug, he needs to be more specific, like what player can't blitz in what formation with what coverage shell, and so on.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

Originally posted by SteelersInsider



Very few people even realized that you couldn't blitz from the outside rush, pass defense.


Not true, this happens all the time. For example: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=141084&pbp_id=7689063



That is not a 4-3 defense which calls for the the defense to stop outside plays. This was back in season 2 before the new AI came in. Here is an example of the defense I'm talking about. Note the DE's dropping into coverage:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?pbp_id=1967013


There was no way to blitz out of that defense and Bort did not make it known.

Just like he didn't make it known what would happen if you called a play that doesn't exist (like pass to TE deep).


But it seems you already know everything, so I guess I'm wasting my time here.

Bort has let this thread sit here on the top of the Bugs pile for 2 weeks for a reason: He's not going to answer every detail of the game. He wants you to experiment and find stuff out on your own.



Here is my example (link above) again. I gave you an OLD example because like I said.....


I'm not giving away any info that my opponents can use.

Do you understand that yet??


Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:49:59
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider

Here is my example (link above) again. I gave you an OLD example because like I said.....


I'm not giving away any info that my opponents can use.

Do you understand that yet??


The only thing I understand is that you don't know what blitz package would cause 3-4 cover 0 be skipped. If you knew it, you would already said it loud and acted like you are superior to everyone.

It is also interesting you bring up a 4-3 case while the OP case is 3-4. This further proves you don't know. Besides, you didn't give the detail on the 4-3 case. Since you already give out 4-3 case, let's be specific on blitzing what player in 4-3 against outside run would cause the play being skipped.
Last edited Oct 15, 2008 15:54:47
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw
...
You still fail to answer what blitz package makes 3-4 cover 0 illegal? I have a scrimmage today and can test whatever you said.


SI wants you to find out yourself... so go like

- split up the inputs like 900 - 600 seconds, 599 - 300 seconds and 299 - 0 seconds
- so per quarter you'd get 3 inputs most likely to be called
- make to each input an output 3-4, cover 0, man under, pass focus, weak side shift and a different combination of blitzers

combinations:
- you know that LILB + SS + FS + ROLB works; the OP posts this plays himself
- he'd probably wanted to call something like LILB+FS+ROLB+LOLB (so the SS would cover the TE)
- try to blitz all 4 LBs too
- try to blitz both ILBs and both safeties
- try both OLBs and both safeties
- don't forget to add an additional blitzer to the LILB + SS + FS + ROLB - combination. Maybe the RILB, the LOLB or one of the CBs.

(just get 12 different combinations)

Then below all, you set an input all blank and the only output "goalline"

There you go! Whenever it shows the goalline defense, you hit a forbidden play.

...

(not funny... isn't it?)
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

...
You still fail to answer what blitz package makes 3-4 cover 0 illegal? I have a scrimmage today and can test whatever you said.


SI wants you to find out yourself... so go like

- split up the inputs like 900 - 600 seconds, 599 - 300 seconds and 299 - 0 seconds
- so per quarter you'd get 3 inputs most likely to be called
- make to each input an output 3-4, cover 0, man under, pass focus, weak side shift and a different combination of blitzers

combinations:
- you know that LILB + SS + FS + ROLB works; the OP posts this plays himself
- he'd probably wanted to call something like LILB+FS+ROLB+LOLB (so the SS would cover the TE)
- try to blitz all 4 LBs too
- try to blitz both ILBs and both safeties
- try both OLBs and both safeties
- don't forget to add an additional blitzer to the LILB + SS + FS + ROLB - combination. Maybe the RILB, the LOLB or one of the CBs.

(just get 12 different combinations)

Then below all, you set an input all blank and the only output "goalline"

There you go! Whenever it shows the goalline defense, you hit a forbidden play.

...

(not funny... isn't it?)


There are 924 combinations since SI may spin and say setting blitz percentage to players not in the lineup, for example, MLB in 3-4. Besides, I'm pretty sure he doesn't know, otherwise, he would have said it already and laughed at everyone not agree with him.
 
Link
 
The defense I showed was from season 2 and is no longer valid. It was meant to show a point that Bort doesn't tell us everything about all the defenses, not to solve the OP's problems.

I said I would help solve the OP's problems if he let us know what the settings were for that particular defense that is having problems (not his whole defense).

But he wants to keep it a secret. So nothing we can do.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by SteelersInsider
The defense I showed was from season 2 and is no longer valid. It was meant to show a point that Bort doesn't tell us everything about all the defenses, not to solve the OP's problems.

I said I would help solve the OP's problems if he let us know what the settings were for that particular defense that is having problems (not his whole defense).

But he wants to keep it a secret. So nothing we can do.


Then show a valid case before you insist it is not a bug. OP doesn't need to give you access to his AI. Since you claim you know what the problem is, you can simply tell him what blitz package cause 3-4 cover 0 being skipped.

Both ways will result him knowing what the problem is anyway.

Again, stop the I-want-to-keep-it-as-secret nosense. If you knew, you would have already said it out loud and acted like you are superior to everyone.
 
Link
 
Originally posted by RAPB
Originally posted by buffalobills_tw

...
You still fail to answer what blitz package makes 3-4 cover 0 illegal? I have a scrimmage today and can test whatever you said.


SI wants you to find out yourself... so go like

- split up the inputs like 900 - 600 seconds, 599 - 300 seconds and 299 - 0 seconds
- so per quarter you'd get 3 inputs most likely to be called
- make to each input an output 3-4, cover 0, man under, pass focus, weak side shift and a different combination of blitzers

combinations:
- you know that LILB + SS + FS + ROLB works; the OP posts this plays himself
- he'd probably wanted to call something like LILB+FS+ROLB+LOLB (so the SS would cover the TE)
- try to blitz all 4 LBs too
- try to blitz both ILBs and both safeties
- try both OLBs and both safeties
- don't forget to add an additional blitzer to the LILB + SS + FS + ROLB - combination. Maybe the RILB, the LOLB or one of the CBs.

(just get 12 different combinations)

Then below all, you set an input all blank and the only output "goalline"

There you go! Whenever it shows the goalline defense, you hit a forbidden play.

...

(not funny... isn't it?)



This guy is smart. And then when you find the answer, keep it to yourself though. Or only share with a few select people.

Or you can waste all that time narrowing down stuff and give it to all of your competitors like BB_tw wants me to do.

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.