Originally posted by Chief Bootnaka
Originally posted by Knightman
Seems like a lot of us are getting tripped up on what we DO agree on and what we DON'T agree on.
I think there's general consensus that 5-8 really should get MUCH better compensation for making the playoffs. The question we disagree on is HOW to get that money to them.
One group argues for revenue sharing, i.e. taking away money that in the past went to the 1-4 seeds in order to make things "fairer." This brings the playoff teams closer together in terms of revenue collected from the playoffs, but leaves the higher seeds with much less than they expected. The previous poster who cited a 10% share to the lower seeds is (IMO) a little naive. If $100k-$200k isn't a drop in the bucket, $500k (10% of $5M) isn't really a whole lot better in game terms when equipment upgrades are on the order of $800k/player. OTOH, a 25% drop in revenue is easily over $1M and quite possibly robs the higher seed of a stadium upgrade.
The flaw in this argument is the assumption that there is a finite pool of playoff money that has to be divvied up. That's not true. Bort has shown openness to the idea by having suggested the Jumbotron option himself (http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1141616&page=7).
I think a far fairer way to address the needs of the 5-8 teams is to give them an alternate revenue source to close the gap with the 1-4's, such as the Jumbotron. This way teams that are in the 1-4 seed that have been planning ahead (and yes, teams do plan 2-3 seasons ahead--I do it and I don't consider my team anywhere NEAR the upper echelon of GLB so I'm sure MANY others do it as well) don't get penalized--they get roughly the playoff revenue they estimated. The 5-8's don't get shafter because they can pick up quite a bit MORE money than a paltry 10-15% cut of $5M by concessions sales w/ or w/o reduced price ticket sales, depending on what Bort sees fit to allow tickets to be sold for. Now the best teams get the rewards they expected, the 5-8 have much more money than they would have with revenue sharing, and teams that are 9-16 have a MAJOR incentive to get that last playoff spot.
I just don't see what the objection is to this last proposal except that there are those who feel a need to PUNISH those evil higher seeds. We need to figure out if our priority is to hurt the teams at the top or get some help to the 5-8 teams. I'd vote for the latter.
I think you are right, and maybe the person/person's that suggested it, give revenue to the teams that are in the 5-8 out of general funds not out of the dedicated owner's pocket's who have striven to be more successful, but how and why are always going to come into question.
I like Bort's Jumbotron idea for a few reasons:
(1) It doesn't penalize the teams that have worked their butts off to get a higher seed. Not to say that 5-8 haven't worked hard as well, but the reward isn't for EFFORT, it's for RESULTS (kinda like real football) so 5-8 shouldn't expect rewards on the same scale as those who actually ACHIEVED a 1-4 seed. Without trying to sound pejorative, work harder to get that higher seed next year (if you don't get promoted!
)
(2) It encourages ALL teams to develop their OWN stadiums. This means that if you build your team at the expense of your stadium and get in the playoffs, your payoff (in GLB $$$) is going to be less, just as it would be if you were a 1-4 seed. This is entirely fair. Each owner makes a decision as to how he wants to get his team in position to compete for the Championship, and how much he wants to sacrifice stadium/revenue for contracts/talent.
(3) It removes a significant amount of dependency on people and factors out of your control with regard to playoff revenue. For example, if the #1 seed has a HUGE stadium but the #2 does not, then the #8 seed is going to get a LOT more than the #7 seed. This will happen despite the fact that there is nothing the #8 seed has done to justify such a discrepancy in compensation. This way, if an 8 seed makes more than a 7 seed, it's because the 8 seed invested more of his own money in his stadium. I like that reward follows investment & planning rather than pure luck.
Originally posted by Knightman
Seems like a lot of us are getting tripped up on what we DO agree on and what we DON'T agree on.
I think there's general consensus that 5-8 really should get MUCH better compensation for making the playoffs. The question we disagree on is HOW to get that money to them.
One group argues for revenue sharing, i.e. taking away money that in the past went to the 1-4 seeds in order to make things "fairer." This brings the playoff teams closer together in terms of revenue collected from the playoffs, but leaves the higher seeds with much less than they expected. The previous poster who cited a 10% share to the lower seeds is (IMO) a little naive. If $100k-$200k isn't a drop in the bucket, $500k (10% of $5M) isn't really a whole lot better in game terms when equipment upgrades are on the order of $800k/player. OTOH, a 25% drop in revenue is easily over $1M and quite possibly robs the higher seed of a stadium upgrade.
The flaw in this argument is the assumption that there is a finite pool of playoff money that has to be divvied up. That's not true. Bort has shown openness to the idea by having suggested the Jumbotron option himself (http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=1141616&page=7).
I think a far fairer way to address the needs of the 5-8 teams is to give them an alternate revenue source to close the gap with the 1-4's, such as the Jumbotron. This way teams that are in the 1-4 seed that have been planning ahead (and yes, teams do plan 2-3 seasons ahead--I do it and I don't consider my team anywhere NEAR the upper echelon of GLB so I'm sure MANY others do it as well) don't get penalized--they get roughly the playoff revenue they estimated. The 5-8's don't get shafter because they can pick up quite a bit MORE money than a paltry 10-15% cut of $5M by concessions sales w/ or w/o reduced price ticket sales, depending on what Bort sees fit to allow tickets to be sold for. Now the best teams get the rewards they expected, the 5-8 have much more money than they would have with revenue sharing, and teams that are 9-16 have a MAJOR incentive to get that last playoff spot.
I just don't see what the objection is to this last proposal except that there are those who feel a need to PUNISH those evil higher seeds. We need to figure out if our priority is to hurt the teams at the top or get some help to the 5-8 teams. I'd vote for the latter.
I think you are right, and maybe the person/person's that suggested it, give revenue to the teams that are in the 5-8 out of general funds not out of the dedicated owner's pocket's who have striven to be more successful, but how and why are always going to come into question.
I like Bort's Jumbotron idea for a few reasons:
(1) It doesn't penalize the teams that have worked their butts off to get a higher seed. Not to say that 5-8 haven't worked hard as well, but the reward isn't for EFFORT, it's for RESULTS (kinda like real football) so 5-8 shouldn't expect rewards on the same scale as those who actually ACHIEVED a 1-4 seed. Without trying to sound pejorative, work harder to get that higher seed next year (if you don't get promoted!
)(2) It encourages ALL teams to develop their OWN stadiums. This means that if you build your team at the expense of your stadium and get in the playoffs, your payoff (in GLB $$$) is going to be less, just as it would be if you were a 1-4 seed. This is entirely fair. Each owner makes a decision as to how he wants to get his team in position to compete for the Championship, and how much he wants to sacrifice stadium/revenue for contracts/talent.
(3) It removes a significant amount of dependency on people and factors out of your control with regard to playoff revenue. For example, if the #1 seed has a HUGE stadium but the #2 does not, then the #8 seed is going to get a LOT more than the #7 seed. This will happen despite the fact that there is nothing the #8 seed has done to justify such a discrepancy in compensation. This way, if an 8 seed makes more than a 7 seed, it's because the 8 seed invested more of his own money in his stadium. I like that reward follows investment & planning rather than pure luck.
Last edited Sep 30, 2008 10:59:09




, the proposed plan (which isn't even a plan yet) will merely force you and others to re-work your calculations. With just 4 or 5 games played, you've got more than enough time to adjust your plans without missing much of a beat.























