User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Goal Line Blitz > Interpreting the Polls
Page:
 
BullFrogOnNet
offline
Link
 
It still doesn't excuse the exception, I don't care what was verified. So do deployed service men and women need to send in some sort of document to verify that so someone can babysit there accont? That was an issue brought up by many people.
 
Tim Harper
offline
Link
 
Tim Harper has yet to see any concrete proof or breaking of rules when it comes to Tim Harper. All Tim Harper sees is false accusations so far.

Also Tpat, my second team wasn't taken away. That was given up to save face with the community here. I hadn't broken any rules with that team, so it wasn't taken away. I did give it away so I didn't have to read threads about people complaining about me "gaming" the game.

As for if I was fired or if I stepped down. I was planning on stepping down for a while, I had made that clear to Bort for a while. The game was no longer fun for me as a moderator. So I am still of the thought it was a mutual thing. I still somewhat work for them, just not as a moderator.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Originally posted by BullFrogOnNet

it is about the decision making process in who they made Mods then that reflect on Mods now, irregardless if any currently have done wrong now or not.The track record is clearly there.


The track record is what I am disputing. So far Tim Harper is the only specifics we can come up with. Satchmo is now either in a coma or has passed on due to a terminal illness and so an exception was made. He was really only a mod for about 2 weeks anyway before his condition deteriorated to the point that he is no longer here. I don't know what the timetable is for the situation to be resolved but I am guessing that at some point the guy sitting his account will have to give it up, and also if anyone else had a terminal illness who had contributed to the game the way Satchmo did then probably Bort would make the same exception even if he were not a mod.




For what it's worth, I don't think contibutuion had anything to do with it. In those regards, Bort and DD (through PMs during season #1) always impressed me as very understanding and wanting to work with players to keep their accounts active and players advancing. IMO, that's why Bort has never bothered with a vaction setting. If someone has something legit going on, I don't believe they'll never ban a player for having someone else sit their account until they get back.
 
superpunk
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tim Harper
Tim Harper has yet to see any concrete proof or breaking of rules when it comes to Tim Harper. All Tim Harper sees is false accusations so far.

Also Tpat, my second team wasn't taken away. That was given up to save face with the community here. I hadn't broken any rules with that team, so it wasn't taken away. I did give it away so I didn't have to read threads about people complaining about me "gaming" the game.

As for if I was fired or if I stepped down. I was planning on stepping down for a while, I had made that clear to Bort for a while. The game was no longer fun for me as a moderator. So I am still of the thought it was a mutual thing. I still somewhat work for them, just not as a moderator.


A mutual thing that you found out about while playing call of duty 4, of course.
 
karma99
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tim Harper
I still somewhat work for them, just not as a moderator.


Care to elaborate on that?
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tim Harper
Tim Harper has yet to see any concrete proof or breaking of rules when it comes to Tim Harper. All Tim Harper sees is false accusations so far.

Also Tpat, my second team wasn't taken away. That was given up to save face with the community here. I hadn't broken any rules with that team, so it wasn't taken away. I did give it away so I didn't have to read threads about people complaining about me "gaming" the game.

As for if I was fired or if I stepped down. I was planning on stepping down for a while, I had made that clear to Bort for a while. The game was no longer fun for me as a moderator. So I am still of the thought it was a mutual thing. I still somewhat work for them, just not as a moderator.



That is exceptionally sad...All of it, but particularly the "still somewhat work for them." One could make an extremely weak argument that rules weren't expressly broken (though the transferring of players certainly could be made out to be an extremely strong case for gutting and breaking "The Sooneer Rule"). It's a huge stretch, but I'll even give you that and just say that numerous rules were CREATED because of the stunts some unnamed former mod pulled:
1) Trade deadline (to stop unnamed players from making mass moves from their Canadian Pro team to their USA pro team for the POs)
2) Roster mins (see above, as well as to stop joke rosters, such as unnamed players having OTs start at LOT, RDE and play special teams all with no backup to max XP gain, for example)
3) A dramatic increase in the importance and need for stamina (to stop unnamed players having CBs start at CB, WR and play special teams all with no backup to max XP gain, for example)
4) The implementation of team chemistry (see #1)
5) Trade limits between teams (see #1)
6) Tpat's proposed limit of not allowing rosters to dip below 40 players (to stop copy cats of that unnamed player from showing other players how to strip a team of players before selling it through his fine example)

I'm sure there's more that can be linked back to the crap that unnamed player pulled, but that's a pretty impressive list to begin with. BTW, I'd think that unnamed player would realize that his going on about how he was never punished and that he still works for GLB only makes the case stronger for those thinking the mods are cheaters and that Bort doesn't care, don't you? That person may want to pause and think about how exceptionally unfair he is being to the good mods, by making them all look like they can get away with virtually anything, without any negative consequences.

Last edited Sep 25, 2008 14:02:24
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by karma99
Originally posted by Tim Harper

I still somewhat work for them, just not as a moderator.


Care to elaborate on that?


He's soon to be announced to be one of the new Admins.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
Tim does not work with the mods in any capacity. If he still communcates with Bort and helps with finding bugs and exploits and things of that nature then I am not aware of that but I won't rule it out.

People like to bash on Tim, but consider this. When at the beginning of Season 1 everyone was trying to always hide their builds and when newbies had nothing to even know what the most basic things about how to make different positions, Tim was the FIRST person to start a thread which still exists where he would answer questions for hours helping people build their players. He was one of the first to open up one of his players, and he helped countless people who PMed him - to my knowledge he never refused to help anyone who PMed him and asked him a question about GLB. Finally, when he transferred those players, the outrage really came from without. The people most affected by the move (those in USA Pro) didn't really even have a problem with it. I am not saying that Tim is a saint or that you should think he is the greatest guy ever, but he definitely is not the all evil horrible person he is painted as being.

When he did all of the things that he did, there were no hard and fast rules that were being enforced about roster sizes and there was nothing that he did that was technically against the rules as they existed and as they were being enforced when he did what he did. That is why he was not really punished for what he did although it "seemed wrong" to the majority of the people on GLB. What about him losing/giving up. He and Bort agreed on what needed to happen, so did Tim give it up? Did Bort take it away? I understand why that is important to you guys but to them it was not, and the same when he stepped down. Was he "fired"? Did he resign? Tim and Bort agreed on what needed to happen and it happened. They were more worried about the result of the action, while you guys understandably are more concerned with the significance behind it.
 
mzsleeper02
offline
Link
 
Whether Tim broke the explicit rules or not, he's always been someone with little to no integrity. He was NEVER qualified to perform a moderating function and act as a face for GLB. From how he treated people in most threads to how he was/is so willing to go against the spirit of the game, he made this abundantly clear over and over again. Helping an old lady cross the street doesn't erase all the times you beat up handicapped children and steal their lunch money.
 
PP
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tpaterniti
Tim does not work with the mods in any capacity. If he still communcates with Bort and helps with finding bugs and exploits and things of that nature then I am not aware of that but I won't rule it out.

People like to bash on Tim, but consider this. When at the beginning of Season 1 everyone was trying to always hide their builds and when newbies had nothing to even know what the most basic things about how to make different positions, Tim was the FIRST person to start a thread which still exists where he would answer questions for hours helping people build their players. He was one of the first to open up one of his players, and he helped countless people who PMed him - to my knowledge he never refused to help anyone who PMed him and asked him a question about GLB. Finally, when he transferred those players, the outrage really came from without. The people most affected by the move (those in USA Pro) didn't really even have a problem with it. I am not saying that Tim is a saint or that you should think he is the greatest guy ever, but he definitely is not the all evil horrible person he is painted as being.

When he did all of the things that he did, there were no hard and fast rules that were being enforced about roster sizes and there was nothing that he did that was technically against the rules as they existed and as they were being enforced when he did what he did. That is why he was not really punished for what he did although it "seemed wrong" to the majority of the people on GLB. What about him losing/giving up. He and Bort agreed on what needed to happen, so did Tim give it up? Did Bort take it away? I understand why that is important to you guys but to them it was not, and the same when he stepped down. Was he "fired"? Did he resign? Tim and Bort agreed on what needed to happen and it happened. They were more worried about the result of the action, while you guys understandably are more concerned with the significance behind it.


For what it's worth, I don't think he's an evil person. I just think he repeatedly pimped the system and that mods should be above that. That was really never my point anyway.

My point was that the way mods are viewed today has a lot to do with that, how Bort dealt/didn't deal with it and the banning rage that occurred. Toss in the perception that some mods talk shit to other players and don't get banned and players have been banned for saying less and I believe you have the explanation for why many believe that mods can cheat and that Bort treats them differently. I'm not saying that any of that is right (and think most mods have been screwed by it), but one can sure understand why some would see it that way, if one were to look at it with an impartial view.

However, I do think it’s wrong to try to make those ppl look like they’re nuts for thinking that mods are cheats and Bort doesn't care. It’s simply the cost of those events unfolding the way they did and how they weren’t dealt with. To expect that VB’s view wouldn’t occur in many users after that is simply naïve.
 
Colin Mochrie
offline
Link
 
The wording of the Poll options suck. This is why the "total overhaul" option is leading.
 
tpaterniti
Lead Mod
offline
Link
 
One thing Bort is getting better at is communicating with the common man on GLB (hence the announcements), but even in a company setting, if someone underwent disciplinary action, it is highly unlikely that the CEO would come out and make a statement. That is just what happened with Tim. He and bort communicated about what was happening but it was considered an internal matter.

All I am trying to say is I hope we can change the perception that exists about mods as being cheaters and I think that by identifying what specifically makes people think badly of mods (especially the fact that 95% of it centers on a person who is no longer a mod) is a good first step.
 
Gott
offline
Link
 
I say get more penalties and tactic options in the game this season.

After the season ends, retire all players, returning 100% of flex, declare end of beta and start over with one huge pyramid.
 
panther17
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Gott
I say get more penalties and tactic options in the game this season.

After the season ends, retire all players, returning 100% of flex, declare end of beta and start over with one huge pyramid.


I could see mass rioting after the retire of all players.
 
IamJack
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by 1VBChaos
Originally posted by nano4288

There are a lot of votes for playing teams at their own level no matter what region they are in, but if you add up all of the other votes you get 4335 who want to play at own level no matter what region they are in, and 4456 who didn't vote that way. So if Bort makes it that we all play in different regions then thats pissing off slightly more than 50% of the game's population. If he takes the option to have teams play at their own level within regions, then he's appeasing the 4335 who don't care where they play (note: they didn't say that they vote to NOT play in their region, they simply voted they don't care where they play meaning if they stay in their own region they don't care) as well as the 1854 people who have so far voted that they want a shuffle but only within regions. That means that if Bort decides on a shuffle within regions, it will be making 6189/8791 (70%) of voters happy... thats most likely the correct choice for Bort to make.

Just wanted to point this out, because a lot of people so far seem to be freaking out and assuming that since over 4,000 people voted that they wanted a shuffle and didn't care which region, and not even 2,000 voted that they want to remain in their own region, that the first group would win. Not only would be it a bad decision for Bort to appease that group simply because they had the most votes (this would be comporable to a minority government... most votes out of any option but still not 50%+1), but it would in fact be a good decision for Bort to take the second option which would appease both the 4000+ and the ~2000 who want some parity in terms of level of teams.


LOL - talk about massaging figures.

I'm getting rather tired of hearing people try to counter the pending result of the poll by spouting shit about majorities and governments.

The fact is, more people have chosen option 1 than any other option. Fine, all the other options combined may be slightly more than 50%, but that doesn't alter the fact that option one ON IT'S OWN is tht most popular choice.

If you want my opinion, then I think no matter how the vote goes, the final decision will be made to cater for the minority of alpha testers, mods and sundry arse kissers and hangers on in the Pro leagues who just want to keep their monopoly on this game.

The rest of us are just here to provide those 'got here first' teams with someone to beat - and Bort and Co with an income.



You're saying that 70% is only slightly more than 50%? Have you ever gone to school and taken statistics? How familiar are you with basic math?

Also, I assume you're not a U.S. resident based on your spelling of "favorite", so you are'nt in contact with the intricacies of democracy in your daily lifestyle. Just to catch you up on that, the majority usually wins...and yes, the majority would be the larger group of people voting for a common cause, not just one option.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.