User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by datongw

Hey Bort, it's pretty obvious that the changes are really a step backward, can we just revert to last season's off tackle and inside run code? Trying to fix it now on the fly will probably cause a lot of other issues which means that the first few games of this season will be guess work for everyone.


How about my idea of creating the advanced tactical option for HB's as I stated earlier in the thread of no delay, just hit the hole as fast as possible (essentially last season's code), delay to make sure you follow the FB (this season's code) or, in between, no delay if there's a good hole, but otherwise wait for the hole to develop and FB help?

Why that instead of a complete reversion? Because Bort might eventually get his changes fixed so it's better all around, and this season's system might actually be better even now if a team has a slow FB.

There's also the stutter-stepping fix, which may have helped things (if by itself) or may have hurt them. If there were still problems that didn't exist last season with the "no delay" option engaged, then another option of "be decisive and don't change course easily" (new system) or "change course whenever it seems to make sense" (last season's) with a middle option, could also be added.

Bort put in some new options for QB's pretty quickly last season, so I think it can be done and done quickly.


Whenever fixes are put in without adequate testing, new problems will surface. This is pretty much a given, how many times has that happened in GLB in the past, too many. One fix exposes something else. Thus I think it's best to just roll back, make sure the changes are tested before implementing it, maybe implement it next season. Having to deal with constant changing of the sim on a game to game basis is just not fun for players.

The change you recommended and the QB change from last season are different. That change is much easier. All Bort needed to do was add in the option interface and add in the velocity difference for 2 additional pass speed.

This change is a bit more complicated. The options of having the HB hit the hole quickly would need Bort to "roll back" or add in the old code for running anyways. If we had two more preseason games, I'd go for the change and see how it works, but with regular season a few hours away, it's best to get back to whatever works.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Ken1

Originally posted by datongw


Hey Bort, it's pretty obvious that the changes are really a step backward, can we just revert to last season's off tackle and inside run code? Trying to fix it now on the fly will probably cause a lot of other issues which means that the first few games of this season will be guess work for everyone.


How about my idea of creating the advanced tactical option for HB's as I stated earlier in the thread of no delay, just hit the hole as fast as possible (essentially last season's code), delay to make sure you follow the FB (this season's code) or, in between, no delay if there's a good hole, but otherwise wait for the hole to develop and FB help?

Why that instead of a complete reversion? Because Bort might eventually get his changes fixed so it's better all around, and this season's system might actually be better even now if a team has a slow FB.

There's also the stutter-stepping fix, which may have helped things (if by itself) or may have hurt them. If there were still problems that didn't exist last season with the "no delay" option engaged, then another option of "be decisive and don't change course easily" (new system) or "change course whenever it seems to make sense" (last season's) with a middle option, could also be added.

Bort put in some new options for QB's pretty quickly last season, so I think it can be done and done quickly.


Whenever fixes are put in without adequate testing, new problems will surface. This is pretty much a given, how many times has that happened in GLB in the past, too many. One fix exposes something else. Thus I think it's best to just roll back, make sure the changes are tested before implementing it, maybe implement it next season. Having to deal with constant changing of the sim on a game to game basis is just not fun for players.

The change you recommended and the QB change from last season are different. That change is much easier. All Bort needed to do was add in the option interface and add in the velocity difference for 2 additional pass speed.

This change is a bit more complicated. The options of having the HB hit the hole quickly would need Bort to "roll back" or add in the old code for running anyways. If we had two more preseason games, I'd go for the change and see how it works, but with regular season a few hours away, it's best to get back to whatever works.


It won't bother me if he rolls it back for running plays, as I do recognize that running plays aren't working right and I very much want them to work right, too.

On the other hand, I also want the game to progress. Things were much worse early in Season 4 but they were soon corrected and we had a much better sim than anything before it.

But I do realize things are broken now, and I also know Season 4's sim worked well enough; so if he rolls the running changes back, I won't be too bothered (I'd have been very bothered if things had been rolled back to Season 3 in Season 4, as Season 3's sim was pure crap; but Season 4's was fine, so I wouldn't be upset if he brought some of it back).
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Yeah, I just hope Bort does something about it, our first game is only hours away.

Testing the codes in off season or scrimmages are fine, but I'd hate to test them in regular season.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I could roll it back with some work, but then people will complain that it changed on them from preseason.

No win situation.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
I could roll it back with some work, but then people will complain that it changed on them from preseason.

No win situation.


I totally understand, but at least it would be working.
 
StoutOne
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Hey Bort, it's pretty obvious that the changes are really a step backward, can we just revert to last season's off tackle and inside run code? Trying to fix it now on the fly will probably cause a lot of other issues which means that the first few games of this season will be guess work for everyone.


Says the guy that dominates with this play...lol

Originally posted by Bort
I could roll it back with some work, but then people will complain that it changed on them from preseason.

No win situation.


Seriously, let us know because I have some defense AI to change up if it gets rolled back.
Last edited Sep 20, 2008 23:56:48
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by datongw
Originally posted by Bort

I could roll it back with some work, but then people will complain that it changed on them from preseason.

No win situation.


I totally understand, but at least it would be working.


I dunno, pitches were a mess at the end of last season.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Wow this thread kinda exploded a bit

In regards the FB speed, most if not every team I am involved with preaches the importances of matching up attributes between related positions.
We work hard to match the speeds and agility of the HBs, FBs, OGs, OTs and TEs to support the Off Tackle/Sweep plays.

Thats not the Only issue, although I am sure it is part of the issue.

I really like Ken's idea of being able to choose if the Backs hit the Gap at speed, or wait for a lead block.

I would have to question how the HB would react on the plays where the FB is running a mis direct?
As long as that tests out fine then the choice would certainly be welcomed.

My one big fear is that you would probably need to be able to select a different style for inside, off tackle and outside plays.

The whole point of the outside running game (Sweeps) is that the defense is over pursuing, and you let them get out of their 'lanes', while you bring in more numbers to lead block.

By 'Hitting the Gap hard' on a Sweep, I would expect the HB to get thier before his pulling OLs, making it a Naked Far Right play, rather than a true Sweep.

Thats not neccessarily a bad thing, as long as OCs are aware that when they asked for a Sweep, they will likely not going to be getting any pulling OLs involved.

If Bort had the time to test it all out, I suspect that the all or nothing approach is not needed here.
If you could test the Off Tackle play with the current 'HB pause', then again with it at 2/3 and 1/3 the length, I think that the results should be promising.

Then test the same team with the same 'HB Pause' intervals on Inside and Sweep/Pitch plays.

I expect you will find that each of the three intervals is very good for one type of run, and pretty bad for another, while being ok at the third.

This would seem to fit the 'Natural order of GLB', its a pretty fair stament that +/- is almost a mantra around here.

So to sum up, I think a roll back would at the very least allow teams to Understand what to expect from the sim and their play calling, and thats the key to keeping everyone happy.

But for the future, the specific issues will be the same.

Pitch plays are avoided only because of the limited playbook, not because they are in themselves broken, although they suffer the same issues of hesitant HBs.

The increased playbook, for example adding the HB draw to Shotgun, and a couple more plays to Weak I and Proset, and a pass from Goal Line, will do more to solve many issues than any tweaking ever will acomplish.

This is because defenses can key in on limited formations and destroy any play with a small problem in the pathing/design or execution right now.
 
Mike Rogers
Lead Tester
offline
Link
 
Ooops that post got away from me a bit

Suggested fix.

1) Roll Back to last season, and announce in alerts section.

2) Test possibliity and effectiveness of Ken's 'Hit the Gap' option.

3) When ready to roll out, post examples of the differences.

4) Begin to expand the playbook using the following philosophy, "All formations must have at least one run to the left, the right, the middle and a short med and long pass.

This should not only fix a few of the obvious problems in the short term, but give a solid head start to avoiding Defenses exposing 'buggy plays' which multiply the issues currently.
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 01:34:49
 
MonkeyMan
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers
Wow this thread kinda exploded a bit

In regards the FB speed, most if not every team I am involved with preaches the importances of matching up attributes between related positions.
We work hard to match the speeds and agility of the HBs, FBs, OGs, OTs and TEs to support the Off Tackle/Sweep plays.

Thats not the Only issue, although I am sure it is part of the issue.

I really like Ken's idea of being able to choose if the Backs hit the Gap at speed, or wait for a lead block.

I would have to question how the HB would react on the plays where the FB is running a mis direct?
As long as that tests out fine then the choice would certainly be welcomed.

My one big fear is that you would probably need to be able to select a different style for inside, off tackle and outside plays.

The whole point of the outside running game (Sweeps) is that the defense is over pursuing, and you let them get out of their 'lanes', while you bring in more numbers to lead block.

By 'Hitting the Gap hard' on a Sweep, I would expect the HB to get thier before his pulling OLs, making it a Naked Far Right play, rather than a true Sweep.

Thats not neccessarily a bad thing, as long as OCs are aware that when they asked for a Sweep, they will likely not going to be getting any pulling OLs involved.

If Bort had the time to test it all out, I suspect that the all or nothing approach is not needed here.
If you could test the Off Tackle play with the current 'HB pause', then again with it at 2/3 and 1/3 the length, I think that the results should be promising.

Then test the same team with the same 'HB Pause' intervals on Inside and Sweep/Pitch plays.

I expect you will find that each of the three intervals is very good for one type of run, and pretty bad for another, while being ok at the third.

This would seem to fit the 'Natural order of GLB', its a pretty fair stament that +/- is almost a mantra around here.

So to sum up, I think a roll back would at the very least allow teams to Understand what to expect from the sim and their play calling, and thats the key to keeping everyone happy.

But for the future, the specific issues will be the same.

Pitch plays are avoided only because of the limited playbook, not because they are in themselves broken, although they suffer the same issues of hesitant HBs.

The increased playbook, for example adding the HB draw to Shotgun, and a couple more plays to Weak I and Proset, and a pass from Goal Line, will do more to solve many issues than any tweaking ever will acomplish.

This is because defenses can key in on limited formations and destroy any play with a small problem in the pathing/design or execution right now.


I TOTALLY AGREE WITH EVERYTHING YOU ARE SAYING.. AND I THINK THIS ISNT WRONG..

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189444&pbp_id=870484
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=191316&pbp_id=919057
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=191316&pbp_id=919126
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189444&pbp_id=867449
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189444&pbp_id=867822
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=189444&pbp_id=867855

EVERY SINGLE TIME MY RB RAN THIS PLAY SAME THING HAPPENED.. THE BACK UP HB NEVER HAD A PROBLEM. PEOPLE SAID ITS BECAUSE THE DT PUSHES THEM BACK(OL) BUT A RB WITH GOOD VISION SPEED AND AGILITY SHOULDN'T HAVE THIS PROBLEM MIKE RODGERS I WOULD LOVE YOUR OPINION ON THIS.. PM ME IF POSSIBLE
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
I've seen this a couple times in most of the preseason games I've watched:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=187457&pbp_id=985579

That's not a FB following bug, that's a HB with 5-10 yards in front of him if he stays on his current path cutting right back into a defender. I'm going to guess that a defender being blocked isn't treated as a threat so the deep safety is the nearest threat causing the cut-back? If so maybe it's an easy change and players being blocked need to be treated as threats but of a lower priority?
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 02:15:47
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Originally posted by datongw

Originally posted by Bort


I could roll it back with some work, but then people will complain that it changed on them from preseason.

No win situation.


I totally understand, but at least it would be working.


I dunno, pitches were a mess at the end of last season.


The pitch play is really not working much better this season either.
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by StoutOne
Originally posted by datongw

Hey Bort, it's pretty obvious that the changes are really a step backward, can we just revert to last season's off tackle and inside run code? Trying to fix it now on the fly will probably cause a lot of other issues which means that the first few games of this season will be guess work for everyone.


Says the guy that dominates with this play...lol



It's domination with the running game minus pitch play. Really, had we ran the inside run or goal line run, the results would have been very similar. It's about power running.
Last edited Sep 21, 2008 02:37:06
 
datongw
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Mike Rogers


Pitch plays are avoided only because of the limited playbook, not because they are in themselves broken, although they suffer the same issues of hesitant HBs.



+1. The -2 yards on a pitch play just kills drives. And thus the inconsistency of the play will turn a lot of GMs away from calling the pitching plays, or at least tune down its frequency.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Ok, I've made a small adjustment to the off-tackle play and tested it with about 20 or so different HB's of differing levels and styles.

The QB will now hand the ball off a little to the right instead of going straight back to hand the ball off, which helps get the HB going in the right direction towards the hole a bit quicker, and the delay at the start of the play is gone.

Next will be fixing some of the blocking assignments.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.