Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by datongw
Hey Bort, it's pretty obvious that the changes are really a step backward, can we just revert to last season's off tackle and inside run code? Trying to fix it now on the fly will probably cause a lot of other issues which means that the first few games of this season will be guess work for everyone.
How about my idea of creating the advanced tactical option for HB's as I stated earlier in the thread of no delay, just hit the hole as fast as possible (essentially last season's code), delay to make sure you follow the FB (this season's code) or, in between, no delay if there's a good hole, but otherwise wait for the hole to develop and FB help?
Why that instead of a complete reversion? Because Bort might eventually get his changes fixed so it's better all around, and this season's system might actually be better even now if a team has a slow FB.
There's also the stutter-stepping fix, which may have helped things (if by itself) or may have hurt them. If there were still problems that didn't exist last season with the "no delay" option engaged, then another option of "be decisive and don't change course easily" (new system) or "change course whenever it seems to make sense" (last season's) with a middle option, could also be added.
Bort put in some new options for QB's pretty quickly last season, so I think it can be done and done quickly.
Whenever fixes are put in without adequate testing, new problems will surface. This is pretty much a given, how many times has that happened in GLB in the past, too many. One fix exposes something else. Thus I think it's best to just roll back, make sure the changes are tested before implementing it, maybe implement it next season. Having to deal with constant changing of the sim on a game to game basis is just not fun for players.
The change you recommended and the QB change from last season are different. That change is much easier. All Bort needed to do was add in the option interface and add in the velocity difference for 2 additional pass speed.
This change is a bit more complicated. The options of having the HB hit the hole quickly would need Bort to "roll back" or add in the old code for running anyways. If we had two more preseason games, I'd go for the change and see how it works, but with regular season a few hours away, it's best to get back to whatever works.
Originally posted by datongw
Hey Bort, it's pretty obvious that the changes are really a step backward, can we just revert to last season's off tackle and inside run code? Trying to fix it now on the fly will probably cause a lot of other issues which means that the first few games of this season will be guess work for everyone.
How about my idea of creating the advanced tactical option for HB's as I stated earlier in the thread of no delay, just hit the hole as fast as possible (essentially last season's code), delay to make sure you follow the FB (this season's code) or, in between, no delay if there's a good hole, but otherwise wait for the hole to develop and FB help?
Why that instead of a complete reversion? Because Bort might eventually get his changes fixed so it's better all around, and this season's system might actually be better even now if a team has a slow FB.
There's also the stutter-stepping fix, which may have helped things (if by itself) or may have hurt them. If there were still problems that didn't exist last season with the "no delay" option engaged, then another option of "be decisive and don't change course easily" (new system) or "change course whenever it seems to make sense" (last season's) with a middle option, could also be added.
Bort put in some new options for QB's pretty quickly last season, so I think it can be done and done quickly.
Whenever fixes are put in without adequate testing, new problems will surface. This is pretty much a given, how many times has that happened in GLB in the past, too many. One fix exposes something else. Thus I think it's best to just roll back, make sure the changes are tested before implementing it, maybe implement it next season. Having to deal with constant changing of the sim on a game to game basis is just not fun for players.
The change you recommended and the QB change from last season are different. That change is much easier. All Bort needed to do was add in the option interface and add in the velocity difference for 2 additional pass speed.
This change is a bit more complicated. The options of having the HB hit the hole quickly would need Bort to "roll back" or add in the old code for running anyways. If we had two more preseason games, I'd go for the change and see how it works, but with regular season a few hours away, it's best to get back to whatever works.






























