User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Multifaceted solution to some of GLB issues
Page:
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Many people have brought up problems that exist in GLB.
-Gutting
-Recruiting
-Non-competitive leagues/teams

I think many of the problems are interrelated. I believe the problems can be cured with a change in the structure/team ownership rules of GLB. I tend to right in long paragraphs but realize that is harder to read so I am going to do my best to use bullet points and shorter paragraphs.

Gutting:
There has been a lot of talk about moving gutted teams down to the bottom tier. The inherent problem there is what if 8-15 teams get gutted in one league in the same season. If that many teams promote to fill the void, it will just force more teams up into a situation that they cannot compete in? Will this cause more gutting?

I believe if the entire league structure is reorganized, it may help with the ease of moving sold teams down.

I think there are two ways to reorganize the leagues and I am going to lay them out now.

1) Create one giant pyramid. Take the top 4 teams from each of the pro leagues and put them in the top. Fill in from their down by team level.

2) Create a Bow tie structure. Where the one pro leagues has pyramids jetting away from it. Each side would be working towards one conference in the highest league. Use the same method above to fill in the teams.

Why this will help? First, it will level the recruiting field because it will make all of the leagues worth nearly the same. Second, the structure will be very large; therefore, if one league takes a huge hit there will be more than just a few leagues to pull teams from. Normal regulation will happen the same, but filling the hole left by gutted teams will fall onto the duty of all of the next level down leagues. This will help keep the balance of league play intact.


I also think ownership rules need to be updated. This may be harder to sell.
-teams have minimum player requirements.
Once you reach 20 players you cannot go below 15 unless their contracts expire. Once at 25 players you cannot go below 20, at 30 you cannot go below 35 and so on an so forth. This way the only way a team can get rid of its players is sign them all to end of season contracts and let them expire.

This will solve the gutting problem and will keep teams relatively competitive.

Team ownership will run until the end of the season. No more selling your team mid season. No more purchasing teams mid season. Yes, I understand Bort will have to take a loss extending some owners teams out until the end of a season, but it will only be those that’s ownership expires after the season has begun. It is a very small price to pay to cure some of the problems. This along with the team minimum rule will make sure teams are as competitive as they were going to be all the way to the end of the season. An inactive owner is better than a gutted team for the league and the game.

When teams are sold back, this will happen at the end of the season. .
-Owners will no longer get flex points back for selling their teams.
-A team can be earmarked for sale at any point
-Once a team is earmarked for sale the owner cannot make any signings, re-signings, and releasing of players.
-Owners can change their mind at any point until the team actually gets sold back
-All team extensions have to be done before the season ends. People who wait to extend their team ownership are SOL.

With all teams changing hands at the same time, it allows teams to be moved in a controlled way.

How to move the teams?
At the conclusion of the season, end of day 40 the game will do a few things.
-All of the teams earmarked for sale or teams that have not been renewed will be stripped of everything.
-All of the players will be released
-The stadium will be brought back to base
-the money will be moved to a standard point
-the team will be moved out of its league
-Teams from one of the leagues right below it will be moved up to take its place

All of the teams moving up will create opening in the lowest leagues.

How to implement new teams and deal with sold teams
There will still be capped leagues but they will not be directly under any league. When a cap league finishes the teams will take the place of the teams that moved up to fill the void let behind by the gutted teams.

There will probably not be a perfect fit between gutted teams and capped teams. Therefore, the rest of the spaces needed to fill the leagues will be sold to people who want uncapped leagues.

New capped leagues will be generated. They will not be under anyone league again.

I am sure I have missed some of my ideas and convoluted others.

I really hope this does not fall on blind eyes.

Edit: increase the cost of teams to 600 a season and 1500 upfront. That will not do much to effect current owners, but it will hopefully make owners who are unprepared to do the job well-and likely to gut--pull their name off the list for a team or not even put it on. Especially, if you do not allow people to get their flex points back. Good owners who are in it for the long haul should not mind. People are going to sell the team back over the increase are probably going to sell it back anyway.
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 22:51:24
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
wow...my one and only concern about this is that leagues and regions have, for better or worse (mainly for the better) taken on identities that adds to the GLB experience. That would be lost being in League ABC in tier 4 of the Zeta track of the lefthand side of the bowtie.

But that having been said....who cares. I think we'd deal with it. Your ideas make a lot of sense.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
wow...my one and only concern about this is that leagues and regions have, for better or worse (mainly for the better) taken on identities that adds to the GLB experience. That would be lost being in League ABC in tier 4 of the Zeta track of the lefthand side of the bowtie.

But that having been said....who cares. I think we'd deal with it. Your ideas make a lot of sense.


Thanks man, I have been thinking about it in my free time for awhile. Just a lot to put down on paper and organize.
 
osutuba
offline
Link
 
I with you on that part, Ottawa. Otherwise, the ideas RE: what to do when a team is sold is an excellent one!
 
mpatt75
offline
Link
 
Sounds good. +1
 
Optachrisprim
offline
Link
 
+1

Freaking awesome!
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
wow...my one and only concern about this is that leagues and regions have, for better or worse (mainly for the better) taken on identities that adds to the GLB experience. That would be lost being in League ABC in tier 4 of the Zeta track of the lefthand side of the bowtie.

But that having been said....who cares. I think we'd deal with it. Your ideas make a lot of sense.


I am sure there is a way to break it down so that regions can be given out. If the bow tie method is used one side could be Europe/Asia and the other North/South America.
 
UTBEARFAN
offline
Link
 
Nice idea, I think that it may alleviate some of the problems but there is no way to fully prevent the issues discussed. I think it would also be better if it was easier to sell teams to specific people rather than a rando on the list
 
OttawaShane
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
Originally posted by OttawaShane

wow...my one and only concern about this is that leagues and regions have, for better or worse (mainly for the better) taken on identities that adds to the GLB experience. That would be lost being in League ABC in tier 4 of the Zeta track of the lefthand side of the bowtie.

But that having been said....who cares. I think we'd deal with it. Your ideas make a lot of sense.


I am sure there is a way to break it down so that regions can be given out. If the bow tie method is used one side could be Europe/Asia and the other North/South America.


Oh for sure...my one limited concern has so many fixes to it its hardly worth mentioning. Either way, existing leagues/structures will likely be upset in some small way, but we'll all get over it.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by czman
-Owners will no longer get flex points back for selling their teams.


Have thought of that one - could be a detterent, but I don't know if losing out on 500 pts is really enough of a deterrent.

Other ideas:

My main worry with not letting owners sell in the middle of the season is that it not only means an inactive owner, but it means a bunch of players who now feel "stuck" and will probably quit as well. It's a good way to drive away up to 50 customers at a time.

Also, there is already a minimum roster size of 40, and limited cuts based on that. It could probably be extended to trading as well, I guess.

I do want to find a way to be able to reset teams when they are sold, so new owners get to play the stadium building game. Whether that's a bottom tier "gutted" league or something else, I don't know.

I'm not a big fan of the "giant pyramid" structure. I prefer the "identities" of separate leagues, and it plays into a world cup idea.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by UTBEARFAN
Nice idea, I think that it may alleviate some of the problems but there is no way to fully prevent the issues discussed. I think it would also be better if it was easier to sell teams to specific people rather than a rando on the list


So you can sell your team on ebay for 50 bucks? Uh uh.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


Also, there is already a minimum roster size of 40, and limited cuts based on that. It could probably be extended to trading as well, I guess.



I a not sure if roster size has been changed but I thought the game just gave you CPUs if you sold off your players. The roster size I am referring too is the human controlled players only. Once a team gets to a multiple of 5 human agents it will not be able to dip below -5 of that multiple. Hence, eliminating gutting.
Last edited Sep 9, 2008 17:05:15
 
czman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort


My main worry with not letting owners sell in the middle of the season is that it not only means an inactive owner, but it means a bunch of players who now feel "stuck" and will probably quit as well. It's a good way to drive away up to 50 customers at a time.



This idea does not at all deal with bad or inactive owners. I have no clue how to deal with them other than charging more for teams and not refunding flex when they are sold. That may at lease stop some non serious owners from buying teams on a lark. Will not help the current situation. This plan is solely trying to create a level playing field that can be automated and last for many seasons.
 
czman
offline
Link
 
The main reason for the one larger league is at this point the structure is not large enough to replace the mass amount of teams that are sold without furthering the talent gab between teams which will just perpetuate the problem.

Having, many completely non competitive leagues is a serious detriment to the game.
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by OttawaShane
wow...my one and only concern about this is that leagues and regions have, for better or worse (mainly for the better) taken on identities that adds to the GLB experience. That would be lost being in League ABC in tier 4 of the Zeta track of the lefthand side of the bowtie.

But that having been said....who cares. I think we'd deal with it. Your ideas make a lot of sense.


I know! I know!

Adding in a World Pro League that takes in the winner of each regional Pro league playoff makes it into a bow-tie without removing the regional identities.

It's been suggested a bazillion times of course, just throwing it out there.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.