User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
I had assumed from the get-go that VISION would give a player an advantage toward reading plays, and reacting to the ball.

However, it seems that every defender on the feild reacts to a thrown ball immediately.

Players with VISION in the 20's react at the same rate of a player with VISION near 70.

It seems like a bug to me. But I imagine that I will get countless replies about how it is working as intended.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
well yes if you see a ball in the air you go and run for it

vision helps you get the jump on routes and on angles of pursuit
Last edited Sep 8, 2008 19:48:34
 
ssaints4ever
offline
Link
 
plz show examples of players w/ 20 vision reacting as players w/ 70 vision...

 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ssaints4ever
plz show examples of players w/ 20 vision reacting as players w/ 70 vision...



Agreed - I'd actually be very interested to see the difference in how each player reacts.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
I pumped my FS's vision from 25 to 34 mid-season and noticed quite an improvement in his reads, just from those few points.

It's not like 34 is a lot of vision for a lvl 17, either.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
It is pretty much every pass play of every game, but sure.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=131906&pbp_id=9541359

When the ball is thrown, all defenders react immediately. Noone continues to pass-rush, nor cover their reciever. Everyone who is unblocked starts toward the intended reciever.

The RDE has 31 VISION, DT has 32, SS has 67. All react immediately.

I'll find ya a play with some backups next.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Here is my d-league player, CB, Emmitt Thomas HOF.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=138785&pbp_id=9557580

Once the ball is in the air, he reacts immediately. His VISION is 13. He should be as lost as a Chicago Cubs playoff series, on about every single play.

My player isn't in on this play, but it is D-league players.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=138785&pbp_id=9557946

Every defender on the feild is after the intended reciever, while the ball is in the air.
 
Forbin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
Here is my d-league player, CB, Emmitt Thomas HOF.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=138785&pbp_id=9557580

Once the ball is in the air, he reacts immediately. His VISION is 13. He should be as lost as a Chicago Cubs playoff series, on about every single play.

My player isn't in on this play, but it is D-league players.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=138785&pbp_id=9557946

Every defender on the feild is after the intended reciever, while the ball is in the air.


Are you saying that someone with 13 vision should literally be blind, or what? How exactly would they NOT see a ball in the air?

That's not what vision does.

Vision is the attribute for pre-snap reads, and reads that allow a defender to get a jump on the play. Once the ball is in the air, you'd have to be a retard to not actually see the big brown flying thing. Really.
 
the man of doom
Miracles happen
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by chief31
It is pretty much every pass play of every game, but sure.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=131906&pbp_id=9541359

When the ball is thrown, all defenders react immediately. Noone continues to pass-rush, nor cover their reciever. Everyone who is unblocked starts toward the intended reciever.

The RDE has 31 VISION, DT has 32, SS has 67. All react immediately.

I'll find ya a play with some backups next.


like i said you run to the ball
 
Onions
offline
Link
 
Who has vision in the 70's? Most positions that need a nice amount of vision stop around the 50's.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Onions
Who has vision in the 70's? Most positions that need a nice amount of vision stop around the 50's.


my level 13 LB has 63 vision. so, he'll be there eventually. he's sort of an experiment. seems to be working well.
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Forbin

Are you saying that someone with 13 vision should literally be blind, or what? How exactly would they NOT see a ball in the air?

That's not what vision does.

Vision is the attribute for pre-snap reads, and reads that allow a defender to get a jump on the play. Once the ball is in the air, you'd have to be a retard to not actually see the big brown flying thing. Really.



Well, then there are a whloe lot of retards playing in the NFL. When a CB is in coverage, they tend to be concentrating on the receiver that they are covering, and if the ball gets thrown another direction, they often don't get to see that for a few seconds after it is thrown, due to the fact that they have to keep an eye on their receiver.

Pass-rushers are often unable to see when the QB has thrown the ball, because they don't get to keep their eyes focused on the ball, when they are trying to avoid a 300 lb+ offensive lineman.

Remember the Kiwanuka/Vince Young play? Kiwanuka didn't realize that Young sstill had the ball, so he let him go.

Is Mathias Kiwnuka retarded, just because he couldn't see the ball?

If yes, then maybe VISION should make my D-League CB retarded.

If no, then maybe VISION should just make him unable to see the ball thrown most of the time.

How does a QB "pump-fake" work, if you would have to be retarded to be unable to see that the ball wasn't thrown?
 
o5prey
offline
Link
 
This is an interesting discussion.

I think vision has really hurt my LBers actually. With vision they re-act to running plays sooner and run themselves right into the blockers. before they were more effective with high speed and cut down the ball carriers even for losses by not re-acting so quickly.
 
Takary240
offline
Link
 
the difference is the fore sight. with higher vision you can *read the eyes* of a QB as he goes through his check down or know which way the HB will try to juke or recognise which way the run play is going. players with lower vision only react to the ball and who they defend
Last edited Sep 8, 2008 21:38:49
 
chief31
offline
Link
 
I have yet to see a play where my SS, with 67+ VISION, jumps a route, before the pass is thrown.

That seems like the kind of thing that high VISION would help with. Yet he is no quicker to react to the pass than the next guy, regardless of the VISION attribute.

SPEED and AGILITY make some appear to react quicker than others. But that is just the SPEED and AGILITY getting them moving sooner.

A player with 13 STRENGTH gets run over by stronger players regularly.

A player with 13 SPEED rarely gets anywhere.

But a player with 13 VISION reacts every bit as quickly as the players with 67+ VISION.

I am not questioning VISION, as it pertains to a QB or RB. Although, I am not entirely sold on the effects there either.

I am suggeting that low VISION should cause a slow reaction to the ball in the air, or even knowing when the QB has handed the ball off.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.