User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Special Teams Pro
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Alright, everyone knows that special teams are currently a side-note in this game. I am sure it will be in-depth in the future. Before this happens, I suggest they roll out a new position for players to create a special teams pro. This player would have strength/vision/speed/agility as major attributes and blocking/tackling/carrying/catching.

Their SAs would be return specialist (cover up, quick cut, head fake, super vision, return specialist - boosted a bit over the CB skill) and bullet (wrap up tackle, diving tackle, shed block, monster hit, closing speed).

Their XP would be more like kickers/punters (as they would see less plays). They would see a big out-of position hit for playing anywhere else and cost 150 or 200 FP to create.

Teams that spent the money to get a few of these players would see a solid improvement in their special teams. There would be 3 return spots in the depth chart (2 short and one deep returner) and 2 bullets (one on each side).

Thoughts? Would anyone create a special teams pro? Would teams use this?

I see people complaining about their CB having spent a lot on the return specialist SA...but this should be a benefit to running back interceptions and they would still have the option of being the return man.
Last edited Sep 4, 2008 04:10:37
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
...if I am correct the primary motivation behind this is to eliminate the use of linemen as returners?!

My first inclination is that who would want to create a player that would only get 8-10 plays per game...but then I figured you came up with the idea, so lets work from the foundation that enough of these 'return specialists' would be created.

Here's the problem, it is very rare that a player actually is just a KR/PR in real football (at any level). Taking the NFL because the names are recognizable, lets think of the Kick returners throughout the league...

Arizona-Steve Breaston (WR)
Atlanta- Jerious Norwood (HB), Adam Jennings (WR)
Baltimore-Yamon Figurs (WR)
Buffalo- Terrence McGee (CB), Roscoe Parrish (WR)
Carolina-Ryne Robinson (WR)
Chicago- Devin Hester (WR)
Cincinnati- Glenn Holt (WR), Antonio Chatman (WR)
Cleveland- Joshua Cribbs (WR)
Dallas- Miles Austin (WR), Patrick Crayton (WR)
Denver- Eddie Royal (WR)
Detroit- Shaun McDonald (WR)
Green Bay- Will Blackmon (CB), Tramon Williams (CB)
Houston- Andre Davis (WR), Jacoby Jones (WR)
Indy- Pierre Garcon (WR)
Jacksonville- MJD (HB), Dennis Northcutt (WR)
Kansas City- BJ Sams (CB), Jamaal Charles (HB)
Miami- Ted Ginn Jr. (WR), Davone Bess (WR)
Minnesota- Maurice Hicks (HB), Aundrae Allison (WR)

Okay I'm tired of this drill, I think the point has been made...every single returner in the list so far off of NFL depth charts is actually a player at another position. Their profile is HB, WR, CB, etc. Not KR or PR...

I know at least one later on (Michael Lewis--SF) will be a safety, but no O-linemen

So why not have a very severe out of position penalty for returners based on the weight of the player. If the player weighs more than 230 a penalty starts to kick in...say 1% of his attributes for every pound...thus a FB or LB might do decently but a lineman would be worthless as a returner.



 
sam_acw
offline
Link
 
There are a few exceptions like Steve Smith, Ted Ginn but in general I doubt these guys are high up in the depth chart at their position
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sam_acw
There are a few exceptions like Steve Smith, Ted Ginn but in general I doubt these guys are high up in the depth chart at their position


I never said they were starters...but their primary position they've trained for throughout their lives is never KR/PR...even guys who make a career out of being returners (Dante Hall, Eric Metcalf, etc.) are primarily something else when they come into the NFL...however they don't make it at that position and fall back on returning.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Okay. Point taken. Suggestion failed. However, we will see what happens in the NFL in the next several years. There will be more Devin Hesters drafted that are primarily targeted as return men.

These players would still be able to play other positions (perhaps reduce the out of position penalty to the standard and make XP gains standard). However, they would not be as good since they would be missing some of the SAs of the other position players. They would basically be backups, but pretty versatile backups. Still, they would be a lot better at returning kicks and/or make some big tackles on special teams.
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Okay. Point taken. Suggestion failed. However, we will see what happens in the NFL in the next several years. There will be more Devin Hesters drafted that are primarily targeted as return men.

These players would still be able to play other positions (perhaps reduce the out of position penalty to the standard and make XP gains standard). However, they would not be as good since they would be missing some of the SAs of the other position players. They would basically be backups, but pretty versatile backups. Still, they would be a lot better at returning kicks and/or make some big tackles on special teams.


There are other players drafted as known threats in the return game (Ted Ginn Jr comes to mind), but they are primarily still WR, CB, HB, etc.

What do you think of the proposal to penalize based on weight of the player. This will address the 'lineman' issue without requiring specific positions.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
I think the weight penalty is a good route to go. There should never be centers returning kicks.

Part of this is also my love for special teams. They can make or break a game and often do. The way this game is going they are simply a cheap way for teams to get XP. Maybe with special teams advanced tactics, teams will start to utilize them more fully. Maybe not.
 
didymus
offline
Link
 
Everyone here seems well intentioned.

I have just not seen in the forums, games or anywhere in GLB a panic due to an epidemic of interior lineman returning kicks.

What is this about? Still scratching my head.

I do like the idea of more SA's aimed at special team performance. Heck, open field blocking is totally different than 'trench' blocking.
 
Tito716
offline
Link
 
Um.

What would be the position penalty for playing those special teamers at almost every position on my roster?

I'd love to give 5 or 6 defenders a nice balanced, tackle-focused SA tree, and put people with my favorite offensive SAs on the other side...

EDIT: Couldn't you already make players with those builds? Why don't you convince people to build SSs specially built for special teams? Or elusive backs that just return kicks?
Last edited Sep 4, 2008 08:32:17
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Tito716
Couldn't you already make players with those builds?


No. As I pointed out, the SA trees are different here and more geared towards special teams playes.

Now, let this stupid thead die, please. The idea is obviously stupid.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.