User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Relocation Spin-Off Idea (Long)
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Alright, this is more pissing into the wind than anything, but here is what I was thinking...

Team money is only used to pay for player salaries/equipment upgrades (at the same time that owners are trying to build the largest possible stadium). The financial aspect of building a team is kind of weak, imo. Once you max your stadium, you are waiting on unknown, future upgrades to the game. You can spend a lot of money on signing players that are also waiting for future upgrades before money really means anything to them...but money becomes moot at a certain point (yeah, equipment upgrades become rape-ish, but at your team's prime they will come every 2 seasons).

Here is my thought. It would take a lot of work, but might be worth it in the long-run. They should fill in the leagues so that there is a set of A teams in every league first, though.

-Drastically increase income based on league/ league level – American Pro would net more income than Africa Pro, which would net more income than America A
-Adjust ticket sales so that shit teams make less than they currently do in their league (decrease the disparity as leagues go down...so no team is eternally stuck in a hole).
-Forget relegation based on record/playoffs...but make playoff appearances result in more income (a little more in A leagues; consider some sort of profit sharing for the away teams)
-Teams can sell/buy their league spot to other teams and move down/up.
-If you flex out of ownership, a new owner takes over for the rest of the season but can only sell league position "officially" at the end of the season.
-Team stadiums stay - but should be incorporated in the sales price (complete with automated suggested prices)
-Perhaps even make certain city locations be mandatory in each league with slight adjustments to income - a team in New York would cost more, but net more if you won. A team in Kansas City would cost less, but losses would be less if you had a losing team.

Okay, again, a lot of work, but a more economics-based model of the game would be a huge boost to how it currently operates. Here are some reasons why I think this would work:

1) Without the current relegation measures, no one would "throw" the championship or playoffs.

2) The HUGE gutting problem could be solved...new owners of a gutted team could move down in the hierarchy before their first official season and get a decent additional cash boost and be competitive. Teams that finished 3rd or 4th could afford the price tag of moving up and basically make more money or not, based on how well their team plays.

3) In addition to #2, more parity; as gutted teams will end up in a league where they can be immediately competitive. The allowance of more team moves per season would expedite the process. It should be set so that no team could move down just to dominate and still earn more money than they would be getting being mediocre in their current league.

4) Teams that want to be in a certain region can build up to that, as it would be harder to take over a gutted team in their desired league and be successful without moving down. At the same time, you could follow a logical progression and move from a low league Africa team to a Pro Canadian or American team.

5) Owners that make unintelligent moves will be penalized (i.e. from SE Asia AA to East Europe Pro would fail and lose enough money in the first year that they might have to move back down to a lesser league).

6) Clear delineation of which league is “better” based on average income

Here are some problems that I can foresee:

1) Cheating…always a problem…minimum sale of a league spot would have to be set and have to be strict and accurate

2) The percentage of dumb new owners will continue to be the same as it is in the current system. Teams would still end up in leagues they do not belong in.

3) International players would be pissed that this league/level does not get the same income as that league/level

4) These financial changes would inhibit the eventual World League.

5) A lot of work needs to be done to figure out how income should be adjusted to make the game fair.

What are your thoughts? I am all for the economics of running a team mean more. You are essentially owning a “pro” franchise and winning should not always mean making more money.
Last edited Sep 3, 2008 11:33:22
 
Jackula
offline
Link
 
tl;dr



*waits for kretch to throw something at him*
 
Guppy, Inc
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
.....and winning should not always mean making more money.


o_o
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc
Originally posted by kretchfoop

.....and winning should not always mean making more money.


o_O


If you win in a shit league, when your team belongs in a better league...you should not be able to continue to field a powerhouse team, imo. The point being, fix the economics of the league and the parity will take care of itself...a tall order, but the best soultion for the future of the game, imo.

Jackula, all I have avaliable is my remote. Will that do?
 
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Guppy, Inc

Originally posted by kretchfoop


.....and winning should not always mean making more money.


o_O


If you win in a shit league, when your team belongs in a better league...you should not be able to continue to field a powerhouse team, imo. The point being, fix the economics of the league and the parity will take care of itself...a tall order, but the best soultion for the future of the game, imo.

Jackula, all I have avaliable is my remote. Will that do?



+1 I agree with this statement.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Bump
 
Cedo
offline
Link
 
Your topic contain too much things. Some good and a lot more bad.

Just 1 thing, there's 2 speed game:
- Home game playoff team
- the rest

Home game playoff team, gain too much money and the rest the opposite. There's a lot of teams which has already completed their stadium but there's a lot of teams fighting for survive.

I was on the 2nd class and this season is the first time i have some money to spend...
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
It's a novel idea.. I can't say that I'm an immediate supporter - but I'm willing to see where the discussion goes before making up my mind. I do have one question off hand:

When a team changes from one owner to another - does the new owner keep the stadium intact? If not, then how will a new owner in the PRO leagues be able to have a chance to compete, and will therefore be "forced" to sell his slot; and if so, then what will prevent the game from reaching a point where all teams have a completed stadium?
 
Yukon Don
offline
Link
 
Guys most regions are only 1-2 seasons into the promotion/relegation system. As such, it has not had a chance to work itself out for the parity issue. Gutted teams are really the bigger issue as they cause much of the strife regarding a lack of parity. Lets first deal with the motivations for and/or repercussions of gutting (not sure a great solution is out there and yes XY I've read yours)...

Then we can start reviewing the ability of promotion/relegation to create parity. No solution is going to work to create parity until the gutting issue has a solution.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
It's a novel idea.. I can't say that I'm an immediate supporter - but I'm willing to see where the discussion goes before making up my mind. I do have one question off hand:

When a team changes from one owner to another - does the new owner keep the stadium intact? If not, then how will a new owner in the PRO leagues be able to have a chance to compete, and will therefore be "forced" to sell his slot; and if so, then what will prevent the game from reaching a point where all teams have a completed stadium?


Yeah, I was thinking the stadiums stay (it is realistic) and are factored into the pricing...you can get a poorly built stadium in a better league for pretty cheap...and maybe allow teams that move up to build double the stadium upgrades their first season. A wise owner that wanted to move up would look at the deals on the table and decide if the move would be good for the team or if they should wait on it. An owner that wanted to move down could adjust the price lower and lower throughout the season until they can make the sale.

Of course there would be min and max dollar amounts based on the league/stadium level that was fair based on prjected sales.

Again, the numbers would really have to be crunched so that a medium built stadium in a better league still nets more money than a maxed stadium in a lower league. However, I kind of see most stadiums being maxed in a couple of seasons.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Guys most regions are only 1-2 seasons into the promotion/relegation system. As such, it has not had a chance to work itself out for the parity issue. Gutted teams are really the bigger issue as they cause much of the strife regarding a lack of parity. Lets first deal with the motivations for and/or repercussions of gutting (not sure a great solution is out there and yes XY I've read yours)...

Then we can start reviewing the ability of promotion/relegation to create parity. No solution is going to work to create parity until the gutting issue has a solution.


True. I basically am suggesting this be looked into so that for the future. If it is a go (probably not), it can be implemented once the leagues fill out and teams have a couple of seasons to build their stadiums. The reason I think this could help with parity is that an owner that gets a gutted team can sell their stadium/league spot and become immmediately competitive while getting another cash boost.

If you move down too far just to dominate, your sales will not be able to support your team. In fact, if there was a salary cap based on league/level...it would be impossible to screw up parity from that angle. I don't know, just throwing that out there.

Edit: And as long as there are these 1 or 2 seasons and out owners and new teams being added, parity will look about the same for a long, long time. If owners had more control over where they played, parity could be established more quickly. Just trying to stir conversation.

Does anyone want owning a team to have an equally important front-office aspect?
Last edited Sep 3, 2008 18:18:19
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by rbedgood
Lets first deal with the motivations for and/or repercussions of gutting...


I don't think you can solve this problem, tbh. It will always exist (without drastic and unreasonable changes). My idea attempts to fix this so that new owners on gutted teams can try to sell their leaue spot and get to the level they need to be at more quickly. A new owner on a gutted team may not reach a competitive level in 2 or 3 seasons. At that point, they will give up and gutting will happen again.
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by kretchfoop

Yeah, I was thinking the stadiums stay (it is realistic) and are factored into the pricing...


Might want to rethink this. Stadium building is an experience that Bort has said he wants future owners to have available. Your initial plan is still a novel idea - but I don't a point at which the Stadium could be reset.
 
kretchfoop
offline
Link
 
How does it work now? If you take over a gutted team, don't you inherit the stadium?
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.