User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=121513&pbp_id=7280206

So... the reciever 'catches' the ball, someone misses a tackle, then the ball is deflected out of his hands. Statistically, something is clearly wrong here.
 
rangeroak
offline
Link
 
He tryed tackling the receiver as he was catching it, but wasn't able to. Then the other guy deflected the ball, swat the ball out of his hands before it was considered a catch.
 
Link
 
This is a bug.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
I don't think so. Imagine this play. You are a WR, catch a pass, but you haven't secured the ball completely and you haven't made a football move. A guy tries to hit you, but slips off the side because his angle was wrong. You turn to head up field and POW, the ball comes out. You hadn't completed your football move, so the pass is incomplete.

The first guy gets a missed tackle, the second guy gets a deflection.
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
you can't get credit for a tackle on a guy who doesn't have possession.
 
Jose Bagg
offline
Link
 
Of course not. If you hit a WR just as he touches the ball and he drops the ball, it is not a tackle. If you you hit a WR just as he touches the ball and he does not drop the ball it is a tackle. If you hit a WR just as he touches the ball and you whiff, it is a missed tackle. He hasn't caught it or dropped it yet. He has his hands on the ball and has yet to make a football move so that it can be a completion. The safety comes up right behind you and drills him and the ball flies out. Incomplete. But at the time that you missed him, you missed a tackle. I suppose they could call it a missed deflection or tackle, but that is too wordy.
 
Revel8
offline
Link
 
Yeah this has been going on for a little while now.
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
I don't think so. Imagine this play. You are a WR, catch a pass, but you haven't secured the ball completely and you haven't made a football move. A guy tries to hit you, but slips off the side because his angle was wrong. You turn to head up field and POW, the ball comes out. You hadn't completed your football move, so the pass is incomplete.

The first guy gets a missed tackle, the second guy gets a deflection.


Football move doesn't exist anymore. The NFL recently changed it to simply having two feet down and control, just like a sideline catch.
 
chapnis
offline
Link
 
Im baffled
Last edited Aug 31, 2008 22:56:26
 
Ratphlegm
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Jose Bagg
Of course not. If you hit a WR just as he touches the ball and he drops the ball, it is not a tackle. If you you hit a WR just as he touches the ball and he does not drop the ball it is a tackle. If you hit a WR just as he touches the ball and you whiff, it is a missed tackle. He hasn't caught it or dropped it yet. He has his hands on the ball and has yet to make a football move so that it can be a completion. The safety comes up right behind you and drills him and the ball flies out. Incomplete. But at the time that you missed him, you missed a tackle. I suppose they could call it a missed deflection or tackle, but that is too wordy.


I understand all that, I'm just saying, how can you fail to get something if you didn't have the chance to get it in the first place? Either the missed tackle should be nothing (since the deflection implies the reciever didn't have possession), or the deflection should be a forced fumble (since the missed tackle implies he did). In the grand scheme of GLB issues, though, this should be way down the priority list.
 
ssaints4ever
offline
Link
 
bug imo
 
ssaints4ever
offline
Link
 
shuldda been a fumble
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.