User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > PATs effecting breath differently from FGs for Kickers
the7trumpets
offline
Link
 
For some time now, I have suspected that my kickoffs have been statistically different lengths in different situations (1st or 3rd quarter, after FG attempt, after PAT). Most notably, it has seemed shorter after PAT attempts. Now that i have almost a whole season of data to pull from where I've been close to the same level (24 now), I have compiled the data and I present it here:

Player in question:
http://goallineblitz.com/game/player.pl?player_id=65110

68.929 Yards - Average Kickoff length to begin the game or half.
69.469 Yards - Average Kickoff length after FG made
63.457 Yards - Average Kickoff length after PAT made
63.285 Yards - Average Kickoff length after PAT attempts (including misses)


As you can see, the difference between a plain kickoff and one after a FG being made is statistically insignificant. However, the drop after PAT attempts is 8.2%, which is statistically significant.

There are two possibilities:

1 - FG attempts are not taking any breath away from kickers and they SHOULD. This might be related to there not being a visual replay for these plays, but I have no way of knowing that.

2 - PAT attempts are taking too much breath away from kickers, and the effect should be reduced.

Both of these could be true, but my hunch is that the breath used in PATs is correct, by design, and there is no breath being taken away by FG attempts. This is purely based on anecdotal observation that after games with many TDs (PAT attempts and Kickoffs), my kickers stamina has been way down, but after games with many FG attempts (and kickoffs for the ones made), his stamina has not been quite as far down.


Any word on this from those in the know?
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
I've never understood in game breath...maybe Bort himself will give us an answer.
 
PackMan97
offline
Link
 
Season 3 PAT - 45/50
Season 4 PAT - 76/77

What's the problem?
 
mgse
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PackMan97
Season 3 PAT - 45/50
Season 4 PAT - 76/77

What's the problem?


His post is about kickoff length after PATs vs FGs. Has nothing to do with the success rate of PATs.

Anyway, good post by the OP. I'll have to gather some data for my kicker and see what I come up with.
 
bmedders
offline
Link
 
I checked my teams and can't find anything that confirms this.

Not saying it isn't true, but I don't see a correlation.

Maybe SAs such as automatic and big boot affect it?
 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
I may have to check the guy on my team to see that.
 
mgse
offline
Link
 
Went through 10 games and didn't see much difference so I stopped. Not saying it isn't true, but I think a lot of things could affect this. RNG, morale, in-game breath (lots of PATs in blowouts = shorter kickoffs)

Details on my kicker...

Kickoffs after FG: 64.42307692
Kickoffs after PAT: 64.68
 
the7trumpets
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by mgse
Went through 10 games and didn't see much difference so I stopped. Not saying it isn't true, but I think a lot of things could affect this. RNG, morale, in-game breath (lots of PATs in blowouts = shorter kickoffs)

Details on my kicker...

Kickoffs after FG: 64.42307692
Kickoffs after PAT: 64.68

Thanks for checking. I thought about that, but we've only had 3 games where we won by more than 30 points, and the most we've scored is 53. We also had one game where I attempted six FGs.

I'm trying to think what else could effect this, but I'm at a loss. My confidence is pretty high (61), but without knowing more about the sim, I really can't say anything for certain other than it makes no sense that a PAT would tire out my kicker more than a FGA. I just don't know why it didn't effect your kicker.
 
TurboBoxer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Firenze
I've never understood in game breath...maybe Bort himself will give us an answer.


a better more in depth explanation of "in game" energy/morale would be wonderful, especially the effects it has on players. (there is no way to tell since the replays dont show energy, and there is so many different factors to consider)
 
Firenze
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by TurboBoxer
Originally posted by Firenze

I've never understood in game breath...maybe Bort himself will give us an answer.


a better more in depth explanation of "in game" energy/morale would be wonderful, especially the effects it has on players. (there is no way to tell since the replays dont show energy, and there is so many different factors to consider)


Maybe replays should show energy?
 
GenoBong
offline
Link
 
For a fair comparison you should take compare kickoff lengths at the same junction in the game.

For example, if you kicked off first in a game, and happened to kick a PAT, presumably your breath will be lower on the next kickoff. As opposed to your team receiving the opening kickoff, then kicking a field goal, then kicking off.

What I'm trying to say here is that there's too much potential statistical deviance in taking entire games/seasons to take an entire data set. You need to compare apples to apples.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.