Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
Originally posted by RyguyRB
I do agree that pump fake/juke is overpowered, though those may not be the best examples. I have no problem with a better built player effectively using a pump fake or a juke occasionally, but the problem is with the timing.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=127360&pbp_id=7070518
From the time the pump fake occurs, the WR gets 8 steps before the CB even takes a step. The pass was pretty underthrown, but because theres such a HUGE cushion anytime a pump fake/juke happens, he could juggle it around for a few seconds and do a little dance on an underthrown pass before the CB catches up.
No problem with an effective special ability, but they really need to limit it to giving the WR an extra step or 2, not 8.
This is probably the wrong forum for this discussion .. but I disagree.... or atleast here is my thinking - I've only seen 2 Pump fakes ever. Admittedly, I'm not always looking for them.. but I have a QB that is specialized in Pump Fake and I have only seen him fake a defender 1 time. You bet your ass I want it to be effective if it is going to happen so infrequently. If pump fake triggered every drive - then yea, 1-2 steps would be fine.. but if we are talking about getting 1 pump fake per game/season/career -- I want it to result in a completion or even TD every single time.
Yup.
And I'm sure it happens pretty often. The thing is, MOST of the time, the CB wins their "saving roll".

So we see a few replays of a CB biting on a pump fake, but we will never see the replays of when they don't bite. It happens, as you said, infrequently, and I think it's alright, as long as it really does happen.
Now, if the dots had little dot-arms that moved, or blinking colors to designate when a SA is used/triggered, it'd be different.
