User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Exploiting the Kicking Positions for Multiple level gains
Page:
 
jamz
offline
Link
 
I'm pretty sure this isn't an intended feature.

Owners are using slow build and gutted teams to 'power level' their players.

In extreme cases abusing advanced AI, and how the kicker positions gain XP to kick on first down, every time to get maximum experience for their player.

See this thread/game as an example of the extremes people are now taking it to:

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=95249
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=883393

1) The kicker position should be made kicker or punter only so people can't stick a WR there to gain 4 levels a game.

2) The people exploiting the way kickers earn experience seriously need to be punished. Any other MMO if you take advantage of a design flaw, and exploit it, there are repercussions.

3) Teams need to be taken away, player levels reversed, and out of positional XP penalties strengthened to discourage this sort of activity that is clearly against the 'Spirit of the Game'

Players / Agents should not be able to keep their ill be gotten gains.
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 10:34:00
 
CoachSherman
offline
Link
 
I don't understand why you guys think he gained 4 levels naturally in 1 game. You are aware that people are allowed to boost 3 levels per season right? He gained 4 levels in a couple days. It's called training, max XP from a game and 3 boosts.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CoachSherman
I don't understand why you guys think he gained 4 levels naturally in 1 game. You are aware that people are allowed to boost 3 levels per season right? He gained 4 levels in a couple days. It's called training, max XP from a game and 3 boosts.


I agree that he probably boosted -- I've never seen anyone get over 3,000 XP from a game, but I'm not sure what the XP cap is in terms of Kicks for a player. I know it is higher than at other positions -- I have a punter on a slow build team that is a full 3 levels higher than others created at the same time and getting max plays.

The XP for kickers/punters is, and has always been, broken. If they don't get in the game, they get nothing. But if they kick ridiculous amounts, they get ridiculous amounts of XP. This leads punters to want to play their early seasons on the worst possible teams, and kickers looking for the best possible teams they can land on.

There has to be a better way. I know I've suggested that the kicker/punter follow the exact same max XP guidelines as all other positions, but give them a 50% of max XP guarantee every game, so it doesn't matter if they get in or not. And they can earn up to max XP through actually getting into the game.

I have not seen a better or easier solution to the potential exploit listed above.

----

To CoachSherman -- you obviously don't understand the idea of power leveling a player through the K or P spot, so its best you leave the conversation until you grasp the concept.
 
thehazyone
NFL Replacement Refs SUCK
offline
Link
 
Definitely there is a significant difference. My level 28 kicker got 212 points in a 152-0 blowout and in his previous game he received 95 in a 45-20 win. Same thing when he was level 27, 269 points in a 191-0 blowout and an average of 106 in the other five games he played at that level (all a minimum of 34 points scored).

I have my punter on our team as well but I have an extra punter that I looked for a bad team so I could get max XP. Punter on bad team has earned 1,550 XP in 10 games. Punter on good team has earned 558 XP in 10 games. That's nearly a whole level difference and these are level 27 punters, not level 10.

That being said, no way a guy got 4 levels in one game without boosting. Not possible as their is an XP cap (like Scace said, I think it's higher for kickers/punters).
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 11:30:55
 
Intimnasc
offline
Link
 
You can't gain 4 levels in a game. Max XP is reached at 50 plays anything above the 50 does little but make for nice stats.
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
He probably got around a thousand for that game; I know that's what my kicker got the one time he doubled up on K & P.

Most likely murdered his energy, unless he's trying a stamina build for kickers or something.

SCACE's point needs reiterating: K/P need to get at least 50% of max every game, and I'd go so far as to say players need to have like, 40 kicking/punting if they aren't natural kickers/punters to be put on that depth chart. That way you can still build a hybrid but you have to actually build it (not just take some random with 7 kicking and put him as the kicker), thereby negating the XP bonus from playing the position.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by oldskool
He probably got around a thousand for that game; I know that's what my kicker got the one time he doubled up on K & P.

Most likely murdered his energy, unless he's trying a stamina build for kickers or something.

SCACE's point needs reiterating: K/P need to get at least 50% of max every game, and I'd go so far as to say players need to have like, 40 kicking/punting if they aren't natural kickers/punters to be put on that depth chart. That way you can still build a hybrid but you have to actually build it (not just take some random with 7 kicking and put him as the kicker), thereby negating the XP bonus from playing the position.


Yes, 50% guaranteed, but the max should be inline with the rest of the positions...none of this 1,000+ XP nonsense.

And I'd agree with there needing to be a minimum in kicking or punting to go on the DC for that position. Should be very easy to code, same as removing a guy from the trade page who has a no trade contract.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
The highest XP I've ever received was for my newest punter @ 926 XP. I know that you can get over 1,000 though with a P or K at level 1 with max plays.

As mentioned, my P, TE and two OG's are on the same team. TE/OG/OG getting max plays. P getting over 20 plays per game.

The P is already a full 3 levels ahead of the others, despite being created on the same day.
 
MentalMisfit
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Intimnasc
You can't gain 4 levels in a game. Max XP is reached at 50 plays anything above the 50 does little but make for nice stats.


this is wrong on so many levels. Punters/kickers don't follow that for xp not to mention the cap isnt 50 anymore it was lowered.

Most my punter has gotten was 954xp that was off about 20 punts at level 2. He kicked 80 field goals I'm guessing he got over 1000xp.

It does need to be fixed though surprised it took this long for someone to do that. I hate that if I put my punter on good team he gets punished for it. I've had a few games my lvl 27 punter got no xp or less xp then training xp. I made my SS and my punter at the same time. My punter is almost 2 full levels behind.
 
CoachSherman
offline
Link
 
nm
Last edited Aug 22, 2008 11:48:29
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by MentalMisfit
Originally posted by Intimnasc

You can't gain 4 levels in a game. Max XP is reached at 50 plays anything above the 50 does little but make for nice stats.


this is wrong on so many levels. Punters/kickers don't follow that for xp not to mention the cap isnt 50 anymore it was lowered.

Most my punter has gotten was 954xp that was off about 20 punts at level 2. He kicked 80 field goals I'm guessing he got over 1000xp.

It does need to be fixed though surprised it took this long for someone to do that. I hate that if I put my punter on good team he gets punished for it. I've had a few games my lvl 27 punter got no xp or less xp then training xp. I made my SS and my punter at the same time. My punter is almost 2 full levels behind.


Actually, the ultimate play cap is 50. 40 is where you get like 95% of possible XP or maybe a bit higher. You can still gain the rest (3-5%) from plays 41-50.
 
Aoiree
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=213802

havent updated this in a while but i'm fairly certain now that its the act of punting (and maybe kicking) that yields more exp than other positions.

I've had a Punter play games at CB and receive normal experience compared to similarly leveled non-punters.

Also i've never seen anyone get anywhere remotely near to 3k exp from a game.


But this is also from like two or 3 seasons ago and there have been some changes since i've updated information and I've heard experience methods have slightly changed.
Last edited Aug 23, 2008 02:46:55
 
Elias_5th
offline
Link
 
here is my punter's EXP log if this helps at all for you guys trying to figure out exp.

2008-08-23 02:41:02 42 training
2008-08-22 07:32:35 315 game
2008-08-22 02:43:09 42 training
2008-08-21 02:43:50 42 training
2008-08-20 07:34:11 445 game
2008-08-20 02:46:47 42 training
Level up!
2008-08-19 02:45:46 45 training
2008-08-18 07:49:33 498 game
2008-08-18 02:38:07 45 training
2008-08-17 02:37:58 45 training
Level up!
2008-08-16 07:47:01 418 game
2008-08-16 02:31:58 47 training
2008-08-15 02:29:39 47 training
2008-08-14 07:30:21 359 game
2008-08-14 02:27:20 47 training
2008-08-13 02:30:13 47 training
2008-08-12 07:48:00 358 game
2008-08-12 02:27:32 47 training
Level up!
2008-08-11 02:19:37 51 training
2008-08-10 07:50:30 455 game
2008-08-10 02:20:49 51 training
2008-08-09 02:11:39 51 training
Level up!
2008-08-08 07:49:52 440 game
2008-08-08 02:15:33 54 training
2008-08-07 02:05:17 54 training
2008-08-06 07:30:47 411 game
2008-08-06 02:11:57 54 training
2008-08-05 02:08:44 54 training
Level up!
2008-08-04 07:51:04 600 game
2008-08-04 02:09:56 57 training
2008-08-03 02:31:08 57 training
2008-08-02 07:51:11 455 game
2008-08-02 02:05:03 57 training
2008-07-21 01:54:57 57 training
2008-07-20 01:57:25 69 training
Level up!
2008-07-19 01:55:10 73 training
2008-07-18 01:53:48 73 training
2008-07-17 01:50:46 73 training
2008-07-16 01:55:26 73 training
2008-07-15 02:13:08 73 training
2008-07-14 02:31:54 73 training
2008-07-13 02:17:46 73 training
Level up!
2008-07-12 07:39:55 1065 game
2008-07-12 02:18:10 77 training
2008-07-11 02:20:12 77 training
Level up!
2008-07-10 07:41:12 1136 game
2008-07-10 02:24:34 82 training
Level up!
2008-07-09 02:17:07 87 training
2008-07-08 07:36:22 909 game
Level up!
2008-07-08 02:12:11 91 training
2008-07-07 02:05:11 91 training
Level up!
2008-07-06 07:54:47 1344 game
2008-07-06 02:33:23 96 training
2008-07-05 02:47:45 96 training
Level up!
2008-07-04 07:31:42 1150 game
2008-07-04 02:21:23 100 training
2008-07-03 02:10:34 100 training
 
Illig INC
offline
Link
 
you were the punter and kicker in same game that's how you got them xp's !
 
Buxx
offline
Link
 
"1) The kicker position should be made kicker or punter only so people can't stick a WR there to gain 4 levels a game."

There's a cure
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.