***COMPLETE EDIT***
What about this, then...if the 200 attribute points to spread around and then work with SAs only is a no-go, why not set up leagues just teh way they are, but inside each pyramid, have:
PRO LEVEL - seasonal/playoff based (only one league with two conferences per area)
*NEW* ARENA LEVEL - seasonal/playoff based (two leagues with two conf's per area, for those not good enough to go Pro yet, or for old timers who don't want to retire)
*NEW* MINOR LEAGUE LEVEL - seasonal/playoff based (two leagues with two conf's per area, for those not good enough to go Pro yet, or for old timers who don't want to retire)
COLLEGE LEVEL - seasonal/bowl tournament based (many leagues with two conferences in each area - as it is set up right now)
H.S. LEVEL - seasonal/elimination tournament based (even a more vast amount of leagues with two conf's in each area, sort of like the D leagues are right now)
*NEW* Thanks to Bluejay for this concept: The different levels would have a promotion/relegation system within them, so there would constantly be movement up and down the various tiers within the tiers for H.S. and College teams. The various levels would be exactly the same as what we have now, being the best H.S. teams would be in the "A" bracket, the middle of the road teams in the "AA" and "AAA" brackets, and the worst/gutted would fall down to "BBB" bracket level within the various regions. Same for College teams, but the Pros would all be on the same level for each region, simply put, you'd have the best with the best records most likely, and the worst with the worst records. The higher schools get more attention from Pro Scouts and GMs which would put their players in a better position to get noticed and get that ever-elusive Pro contract when their 4 years are up. It's also been suggested that a player could move up one season early to the Pros if he's being recruited already, as an option.
Players would be able to play four seasons of game time in the H.S. and College Level before being forcibly moved upwards to the 'next level'. If they can't hack it when it's time to move up, then the agent would have to make the decision - keep their bench warmer with a lackluster career ahead of him, or retire and start anew. Players who've been 'bumped' would only be eligible to accept contracts and trade offers from teams in that level of play for the duration of the 4 seasons, whether they've played the entire time or not...so if a brand new player is created, he's a High School athlete, and must spend 4 seasons in that level. He can choose to not sign on to any team at all, and just wait it out (why? I don't know), or play as much as he can and get as good as he can for entering into College.
Once in the Pro level, which not very many players would actually get signed onto a team, since the Pro level would have a very few number of teams compared to the other two (this goes for the transition from H.S. to College as well, just as in reality, only a few H.S. kids play college ball, and only a few College guys get signed to the Pros), and forcibly make the Pros the elite class, and something to strive for.
With this idea, I think that if someone wanted to boost, they could...but not 3 times per season, perhaps just once. Or keep it the same. But personally I'd not want to boost until I found out if my player was going to be good enough to go to the College level at least...but again, not boosting would possibly make your player's chances of getting to the pros, and even College, that much more slim.
*NEW* Originally posted by Bluejays4ws
I really like the idea of having a High School, College, and Pro type structure. Where you have to spend a certain number of years at each location. Instead of having players last a certain number of seasons, how bout just have them have a "age".
E.g. you start out High School as a Freshman (so what, 14/15 years old). As you progress through the High School seasons your player gets older, 15, then, 16, then 17 and all during the senior season the College teams could send out scholarships (Here's where the recruiter for college teams come into play). So I guess your player could choose to accept the scholarship to a school or walk-on (As a penalty for walking on a player could have something happen like only can train every 2nd day).
How about having separate "minor" leagues (Like NFL Europe, CFL, Arena League, etc. Of course with different names but you get the point).
These are all very vague ideas, but it's fun just throwing out random ideas
*NEW* Originally posted by kretchfoop
I would say make the cost and structure for Owning look something like this (the numbers can be changed, of course)
-Pro team: base = 1000 FP
-College team: base = 500 FP
-HS: base = 250 FP
Another possible way is to have each team owned by a computer, and each person who wants to be a GM submit their 'application' which could simply be 500 flex points and a button to click on which position they'd like to apply for. General Manager (handles contract negotiations with FAs, re-signings, recruitment, releases, and trades), Offensive Coach (handles offensive tactics and offensive depth), Defensive Coach (handles defensive tactics and defensive depth), Special Teams Coach (handles special teams depth), Financial Advisor (handles all things money), etc etc...then if you were good at your job you'd basically get to keep it. If your team went on a losing streak, the CPU owner would be moe likely to fire some of it's staff, such as if the offense of the team wasn't putting up very good numbers, the Offensive Coach would be fired, and a position would open up (the CPU owner handling basic tactics until it's filled) as an example.
*NEW* Originally posted by kretchfoop
General Manager: base price
OC: base price x .75
DC: base price x .75
Special Teams Coordinator: base price x .25
Financial Advisor: base price x .50
Scout (Talent and Game Plan): base x .25
Of course, with these positions there would need to be clear distinctions/records kept. For example, a financial advisor should have a handful of stats such as team profit/ticket sales/concession sales total and trends, stadium progress, total salary paid out/average level of players, etc.
The way things are right now would still need to be reworked so that losing teams see a bigger hit to ticket sales. This way, everyone has to work together to net a profit. If the GM decides not to spend the money on a big time player, they will save some money but lose fan support and ultimately their job.
IDK, there are still a lot of holes in this system - the CPU-owned teams part, at least.
Originally posted by demonicangel
Most of the pro leagues are full of gutted teams anyways. I agree a huge restruction needs to be done. I think the op has a good idea, but it maybe a bit overboard.
Until GLB can come up with a way that can keep the high level guys up in the pro leagues, it will always be full of gut jobs. And that problems comes from people that want to play with friends and the over abundance of teams out there.
Every idea Bort has come up with people shot it down, and now every league is starting to pay for it. Pretty soon, it will be empty, because it will be to difficult for level 1-4's to find anything out there. Who the hell wants to play the game if they dont get play time. I know that when I finally retire my guys, I have no intentions of creating more, and just sitting their watching them get 10 plays a game, so when the 10th season comes, for them to retire again they will be at like a level 30? If I decide I want to boost them or not.
Its so easy to sit and think about the now, but what happens with the future rolls around and all your high guys are gone, and your forced to compete with a level 30 in a basement league, and your not getting any play time.
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Yes, something needs to be done. Here is my problem with the lack of systems thinking going on here:
We don't even know what is going to really happen to players when they hit their 11th season. Will they decline drastically? Will they be able to play several more years? Who will take their place? Most likely a season 9 or 10 (as they will be the highest level). Then they will be replaced by a season 9 or 10 guy. Ultimately, if you are lucky enough, you will get 2 seasons in the pros. Even then, the odds are against you. I know adding more teams is not the way to go. It has entirely become a watered-down version of the football experience.
That is why I support the OP's idea (with arena leagues). You basically would have season caps for leagues. If you end your highschool career without boosting, you will end up in a low-end, shitty college division. Then, after 4 seasons there, you will end up going to some crappy arena league team. You still get to play, but you don't get the rewards associated with paying to play (making it to the Pros for the big money and the limelight).
To take it a step further, add a short attention grabber at the top of each player's page for pro-league highlights. Click on the link and see the day's results. Give them a reason to try and make it to that level.
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by demonicangel
Sounds like your talking about a non booster team and leagues. That wont happen. But Bort needs to grow a set of balls, and say ya know what this friend thing is killing the game. WE NEED TO MAKE SURE WE KEEP A ABUNDANT SUPPLY OF LEVEL1-4'S. Without them this game will be tanked very very very fast. If there is a cap, people will bitch and cry, but I doubt that they will have invested so much money, and then just turn around and leave. I say call their bluff.
I see what you man about the non-booster leagues. Perhaps it needs to be set up so that the "arena" leagues do not have the same perks as the pro leagues. If there was a real drawback to being in the arean league, more people would be encouraged to boost. IDK what the drawback could be...that is where you guys could definately help out.
Originally posted by Schaffer05
I don't mind that so much, The one thing I don't think many will like is the owning of a team portion. Who gets what teams? How are new players delivered to the new teams (drafting or what?) You know what I mean, will it come down to a popularity contest, or will it come down to perfomance and stat wise? If that's the case what happens when an actually really good player ends up on a pretty good team but only gets decent stats because he plays against good competition as well. Same token, what happens when a mediocre player ends up on a shitty team in HS and college, but puts up great stats because he plays shitty players.
I am not too clear on what he meant by the CPU-owned teams with the different positions you could apply for and pay flex. I am still unsure if I like that. It would be next to impossible to implement fairly.
As far as players getting onto the pro teams, I think that is why turner wanted the CPU owned teams. Less BS of letting friends on their teams - if you lose too much, you get fired.
Perhaps, the owners that win the premier bowl games are put on a list to own a pro team. If they win 2 years in a row, they are bumped up the list. 3 years, etc. When a pro team opens, they can buy it and drop their old team. The same would be true for high school leagues. People could always decline the offer if they do not want to move up. They can then bring any of their good players up, if they want to. A sort of natural farming system bond would be built between certain teams in the different levels...like a team the favors drafting from a certain college.
I like the following post, and the thread linked within towards the end. It describes exactly WHY this is needed so badly:
Originally posted by rivergato
turnerhero---See it similar to you. Maybe you can take something from my dead thread to add to your ideas. BTW, I like a random degeneration beginning in 7th player season (maybe anywhere to 11th)...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=821914
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Yea I think the years in each league need to be adjusted, or the 10 season decline needs to be adjusted for this idea to work.
I was all about 12 years. This would give 4-5 seasons to play in the pros (before a decline...which we are still in the dark as to how long we could last). Keep in mind, the NFL career is 3.5 years on average. You must also realize that the journey would be fun...it is not just about the destination. Dominating in highschool or college would still be awesome. Right now, tearing up the D-Leagues is kind of lame. There is nothing to compare it to. Most people on here played in HS, and some in college. It is an MMORPG after all. It is a virtual way to re-live our lives or make projections about them, imo.
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by kretchfoop
OK, I think we are not on the same page, here. I have thrown out the whole CPU owned teams idea. I am for keeping teams together right now.
I guess the most plausible implementation of this idea is to implement it soon, but not force teams to break apart. Redistribute teams into pro/college/HS based on median level of players. Then, within those levels, break them further into tiers.
If you cut someone the season before it is implemented, you cannot sign them again for 2 seasons (to avoid teams trying to get around this and ruining parity)...or add a signing cap for each league/division until it all works out. Make only the gutted teams the HS teams and add some CPU controlled teams (if needed).
Eventually, it will all work out. The issue is, either address it soon and deal with bitching and moaning for a while, or have another reset. Either way, people are not going to be happy. But, you have to imagine that this game is going to grow if you do it right. If you keep it as is, it will die in a few seasons.
I agree with that portion of it... so if you own a HS or College team you'll never move up WITH your team, you'll have to get a new team in a different tier correct? Seems to make sense kind of like a real life Coach type thing. I'd say have it different costs for different levels of competition as well. Say HS is 200 a season to own, 500 to buy in. College is 300 a season to own, 750 to buy in, and Pros are the same as they are now.
So far these are the great debates going on in this thread, for those not willing to read through it all. PLEASE add your input!
What about this, then...if the 200 attribute points to spread around and then work with SAs only is a no-go, why not set up leagues just teh way they are, but inside each pyramid, have:
PRO LEVEL - seasonal/playoff based (only one league with two conferences per area)
*NEW* ARENA LEVEL - seasonal/playoff based (two leagues with two conf's per area, for those not good enough to go Pro yet, or for old timers who don't want to retire)
*NEW* MINOR LEAGUE LEVEL - seasonal/playoff based (two leagues with two conf's per area, for those not good enough to go Pro yet, or for old timers who don't want to retire)
COLLEGE LEVEL - seasonal/bowl tournament based (many leagues with two conferences in each area - as it is set up right now)
H.S. LEVEL - seasonal/elimination tournament based (even a more vast amount of leagues with two conf's in each area, sort of like the D leagues are right now)
*NEW* Thanks to Bluejay for this concept: The different levels would have a promotion/relegation system within them, so there would constantly be movement up and down the various tiers within the tiers for H.S. and College teams. The various levels would be exactly the same as what we have now, being the best H.S. teams would be in the "A" bracket, the middle of the road teams in the "AA" and "AAA" brackets, and the worst/gutted would fall down to "BBB" bracket level within the various regions. Same for College teams, but the Pros would all be on the same level for each region, simply put, you'd have the best with the best records most likely, and the worst with the worst records. The higher schools get more attention from Pro Scouts and GMs which would put their players in a better position to get noticed and get that ever-elusive Pro contract when their 4 years are up. It's also been suggested that a player could move up one season early to the Pros if he's being recruited already, as an option.
Players would be able to play four seasons of game time in the H.S. and College Level before being forcibly moved upwards to the 'next level'. If they can't hack it when it's time to move up, then the agent would have to make the decision - keep their bench warmer with a lackluster career ahead of him, or retire and start anew. Players who've been 'bumped' would only be eligible to accept contracts and trade offers from teams in that level of play for the duration of the 4 seasons, whether they've played the entire time or not...so if a brand new player is created, he's a High School athlete, and must spend 4 seasons in that level. He can choose to not sign on to any team at all, and just wait it out (why? I don't know), or play as much as he can and get as good as he can for entering into College.
Once in the Pro level, which not very many players would actually get signed onto a team, since the Pro level would have a very few number of teams compared to the other two (this goes for the transition from H.S. to College as well, just as in reality, only a few H.S. kids play college ball, and only a few College guys get signed to the Pros), and forcibly make the Pros the elite class, and something to strive for.
With this idea, I think that if someone wanted to boost, they could...but not 3 times per season, perhaps just once. Or keep it the same. But personally I'd not want to boost until I found out if my player was going to be good enough to go to the College level at least...but again, not boosting would possibly make your player's chances of getting to the pros, and even College, that much more slim.
*NEW* Originally posted by Bluejays4ws
I really like the idea of having a High School, College, and Pro type structure. Where you have to spend a certain number of years at each location. Instead of having players last a certain number of seasons, how bout just have them have a "age".
E.g. you start out High School as a Freshman (so what, 14/15 years old). As you progress through the High School seasons your player gets older, 15, then, 16, then 17 and all during the senior season the College teams could send out scholarships (Here's where the recruiter for college teams come into play). So I guess your player could choose to accept the scholarship to a school or walk-on (As a penalty for walking on a player could have something happen like only can train every 2nd day).
How about having separate "minor" leagues (Like NFL Europe, CFL, Arena League, etc. Of course with different names but you get the point).
These are all very vague ideas, but it's fun just throwing out random ideas
*NEW* Originally posted by kretchfoop
I would say make the cost and structure for Owning look something like this (the numbers can be changed, of course)
-Pro team: base = 1000 FP
-College team: base = 500 FP
-HS: base = 250 FP
Another possible way is to have each team owned by a computer, and each person who wants to be a GM submit their 'application' which could simply be 500 flex points and a button to click on which position they'd like to apply for. General Manager (handles contract negotiations with FAs, re-signings, recruitment, releases, and trades), Offensive Coach (handles offensive tactics and offensive depth), Defensive Coach (handles defensive tactics and defensive depth), Special Teams Coach (handles special teams depth), Financial Advisor (handles all things money), etc etc...then if you were good at your job you'd basically get to keep it. If your team went on a losing streak, the CPU owner would be moe likely to fire some of it's staff, such as if the offense of the team wasn't putting up very good numbers, the Offensive Coach would be fired, and a position would open up (the CPU owner handling basic tactics until it's filled) as an example.
*NEW* Originally posted by kretchfoop
General Manager: base price
OC: base price x .75
DC: base price x .75
Special Teams Coordinator: base price x .25
Financial Advisor: base price x .50
Scout (Talent and Game Plan): base x .25
Of course, with these positions there would need to be clear distinctions/records kept. For example, a financial advisor should have a handful of stats such as team profit/ticket sales/concession sales total and trends, stadium progress, total salary paid out/average level of players, etc.
The way things are right now would still need to be reworked so that losing teams see a bigger hit to ticket sales. This way, everyone has to work together to net a profit. If the GM decides not to spend the money on a big time player, they will save some money but lose fan support and ultimately their job.
IDK, there are still a lot of holes in this system - the CPU-owned teams part, at least.
Originally posted by demonicangel
Most of the pro leagues are full of gutted teams anyways. I agree a huge restruction needs to be done. I think the op has a good idea, but it maybe a bit overboard.
Until GLB can come up with a way that can keep the high level guys up in the pro leagues, it will always be full of gut jobs. And that problems comes from people that want to play with friends and the over abundance of teams out there.
Every idea Bort has come up with people shot it down, and now every league is starting to pay for it. Pretty soon, it will be empty, because it will be to difficult for level 1-4's to find anything out there. Who the hell wants to play the game if they dont get play time. I know that when I finally retire my guys, I have no intentions of creating more, and just sitting their watching them get 10 plays a game, so when the 10th season comes, for them to retire again they will be at like a level 30? If I decide I want to boost them or not.
Its so easy to sit and think about the now, but what happens with the future rolls around and all your high guys are gone, and your forced to compete with a level 30 in a basement league, and your not getting any play time.
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Yes, something needs to be done. Here is my problem with the lack of systems thinking going on here:
We don't even know what is going to really happen to players when they hit their 11th season. Will they decline drastically? Will they be able to play several more years? Who will take their place? Most likely a season 9 or 10 (as they will be the highest level). Then they will be replaced by a season 9 or 10 guy. Ultimately, if you are lucky enough, you will get 2 seasons in the pros. Even then, the odds are against you. I know adding more teams is not the way to go. It has entirely become a watered-down version of the football experience.
That is why I support the OP's idea (with arena leagues). You basically would have season caps for leagues. If you end your highschool career without boosting, you will end up in a low-end, shitty college division. Then, after 4 seasons there, you will end up going to some crappy arena league team. You still get to play, but you don't get the rewards associated with paying to play (making it to the Pros for the big money and the limelight).
To take it a step further, add a short attention grabber at the top of each player's page for pro-league highlights. Click on the link and see the day's results. Give them a reason to try and make it to that level.
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by demonicangel
Sounds like your talking about a non booster team and leagues. That wont happen. But Bort needs to grow a set of balls, and say ya know what this friend thing is killing the game. WE NEED TO MAKE SURE WE KEEP A ABUNDANT SUPPLY OF LEVEL1-4'S. Without them this game will be tanked very very very fast. If there is a cap, people will bitch and cry, but I doubt that they will have invested so much money, and then just turn around and leave. I say call their bluff.
I see what you man about the non-booster leagues. Perhaps it needs to be set up so that the "arena" leagues do not have the same perks as the pro leagues. If there was a real drawback to being in the arean league, more people would be encouraged to boost. IDK what the drawback could be...that is where you guys could definately help out.
Originally posted by Schaffer05
I don't mind that so much, The one thing I don't think many will like is the owning of a team portion. Who gets what teams? How are new players delivered to the new teams (drafting or what?) You know what I mean, will it come down to a popularity contest, or will it come down to perfomance and stat wise? If that's the case what happens when an actually really good player ends up on a pretty good team but only gets decent stats because he plays against good competition as well. Same token, what happens when a mediocre player ends up on a shitty team in HS and college, but puts up great stats because he plays shitty players.
I am not too clear on what he meant by the CPU-owned teams with the different positions you could apply for and pay flex. I am still unsure if I like that. It would be next to impossible to implement fairly.
As far as players getting onto the pro teams, I think that is why turner wanted the CPU owned teams. Less BS of letting friends on their teams - if you lose too much, you get fired.
Perhaps, the owners that win the premier bowl games are put on a list to own a pro team. If they win 2 years in a row, they are bumped up the list. 3 years, etc. When a pro team opens, they can buy it and drop their old team. The same would be true for high school leagues. People could always decline the offer if they do not want to move up. They can then bring any of their good players up, if they want to. A sort of natural farming system bond would be built between certain teams in the different levels...like a team the favors drafting from a certain college.
I like the following post, and the thread linked within towards the end. It describes exactly WHY this is needed so badly:
Originally posted by rivergato
turnerhero---See it similar to you. Maybe you can take something from my dead thread to add to your ideas. BTW, I like a random degeneration beginning in 7th player season (maybe anywhere to 11th)...
http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=821914
Originally posted by kretchfoop
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Yea I think the years in each league need to be adjusted, or the 10 season decline needs to be adjusted for this idea to work.
I was all about 12 years. This would give 4-5 seasons to play in the pros (before a decline...which we are still in the dark as to how long we could last). Keep in mind, the NFL career is 3.5 years on average. You must also realize that the journey would be fun...it is not just about the destination. Dominating in highschool or college would still be awesome. Right now, tearing up the D-Leagues is kind of lame. There is nothing to compare it to. Most people on here played in HS, and some in college. It is an MMORPG after all. It is a virtual way to re-live our lives or make projections about them, imo.
Originally posted by Schaffer05
Originally posted by kretchfoop
OK, I think we are not on the same page, here. I have thrown out the whole CPU owned teams idea. I am for keeping teams together right now.
I guess the most plausible implementation of this idea is to implement it soon, but not force teams to break apart. Redistribute teams into pro/college/HS based on median level of players. Then, within those levels, break them further into tiers.
If you cut someone the season before it is implemented, you cannot sign them again for 2 seasons (to avoid teams trying to get around this and ruining parity)...or add a signing cap for each league/division until it all works out. Make only the gutted teams the HS teams and add some CPU controlled teams (if needed).
Eventually, it will all work out. The issue is, either address it soon and deal with bitching and moaning for a while, or have another reset. Either way, people are not going to be happy. But, you have to imagine that this game is going to grow if you do it right. If you keep it as is, it will die in a few seasons.
I agree with that portion of it... so if you own a HS or College team you'll never move up WITH your team, you'll have to get a new team in a different tier correct? Seems to make sense kind of like a real life Coach type thing. I'd say have it different costs for different levels of competition as well. Say HS is 200 a season to own, 500 to buy in. College is 300 a season to own, 750 to buy in, and Pros are the same as they are now.
So far these are the great debates going on in this thread, for those not willing to read through it all. PLEASE add your input!
Last edited Aug 18, 2008 21:08:26






























