User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Suggestions > Getting coverage more realistic
Page:
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Since many coverage issues have been adressed lately, it might be time for some serious discussion about how coverage should work.

A reasonable balance in the game is needed. CBs shutting down WRs on "close" coverage setting almost all the time are unrealistic i.m.h.o. (that's what season 3 was like). On the other hand, WRs catching the majority of throws even in tight coverage or double coverage are unrealistic too.

So it's time to discuss coverage issues:

- how should receivers get separation?
- how should receivers not based on getting separation (high jumping/catching) get catches too?
- how should coverage work and provide a way to defend both types of receivers?


One idea that came to my mind:

Maybe provide different ways of coverage settings and have each have bonus and penalties?

Right now, there are only 3 Man Coverage Distances:

- close: stick to your man like glue ("problem": you shouldn`t be able to play that without the WR getting open A LOT when facing equal "running" attributes; so that should be only an option to superior CBs)

- medium: stay a couple of yards back so you don't get beat deep (problem: this setting allowes the WR to get open all the time right now and you need to have great agility to deflect the ball even a couple of times - so this setting is not really an reasonable option to defend the pass)

- far: keep about 5 yard cushion between you and your man (a setting for outmatched CBs, just preventing the deep TD pass and giving up everything else)


So maybe have a more precise setting like:

coverage cushion:

5yd
4yd
3yd
2yd
1yd
as close as you can

preferred reaction

bite on every move (the defender will react on every head or body motion the receiver shows, this getting him a great advantage of defending short passes and simple routes)

play it reasonable (the defender will not react on the first head or body motion the receiver shows, this preventing him more of getting faked and getting beaten deep afterwards)

play it safe (the defender will let the receiver make his turn first and follow him after he's sure that it isn't a fake)

in-game adjustment (this requires remembering how the CB played the specific receiver in the game before)

play it safe (the defender will adjust his coverage settings as soon as he's beaten once)

don't mind occasionally problems (the defender will stick to his settings and adjust as he happens to get beaten a couple of times; he will get back to the original settings as he's giving up catches)

stick to the plan (the defender will very slowly adjust to getting beaten)


Such settings would also provide a better way of gameplanning and give the agents of defenders much more to do.

Any ideas welcome!
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
This is a great idea...

and could be used for almost every position. It would give the individual players a bit of 'intelligence factor' of sorts, adjusting to the way they're being played against that particular game. If the Coaches get the gameplan wrong, the player can adjust himself to try and get the one-up on his man - offensively OR defensively.

This is one of the best ideas I've seen yet
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
I think you have a basis for something very good here. I'm a big fan of setting the cushion down to the yard.

I have mixed feelings about the other settings, but they could work.

The "preferred reaction" setting needs a disadvantage to "play it reasonable." Maybe it's just that it would work as it would normally, whereas "play it safe" is a disadvantage if there's no fake but a big advantage if there is one, where "bite" means that there's no hesitation on a legitimate move but a significantly higher chance to be faked out.

It all works if it's balanced.

The "in-game adjustment" might be too much of an advantage, at least on fakes. It would be the only player setting that had adjustments. However, maybe on coverage cushion it could work like auto-adjust, as it would seem a bit unfair if someone who provided no cushion got constantly beaten on deep routes.

One other thing is that there has to be room for zones, meaning man coverage needs to be tough enough to play well that some teams play mostly zone coverage (at least in some matchups). That might mean further weakening man coverage but also improving zone coverage, both in the AI and in its intended reaction.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Oh, and on

Originally posted by RAPB
- how should receivers not based on getting separation (high jumping/catching) get catches too?


People would need to get used to the better possession receivers making great catches, even when the defender is right on top of them. Maybe the PbP could say "Great catch by Receiver Name!" to indicate that it was a catch based on catching ability despite very good coverage.

All receivers would have some chance at the "Great catch..."es, as it would compare the relevant stats (and just how well covered) to a random number, and anyone would win at times. But someone with 60 Catching should get many more "great" catches than someone with 30 Catching; and not only double, but many more than double.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
...The "preferred reaction" setting needs a disadvantage to "play it reasonable." Maybe it's just that it would work as it would normally, whereas "play it safe" is a disadvantage if there's no fake but a big advantage if there is one, where "bite" means that there's no hesitation on a legitimate move but a significantly higher chance to be faked out.

It all works if it's balanced.


That was the idea. If a defender don't bite on the first thing he notices, the WR will get a good advantage on shorter routes. The "reaction time" of the CB will be longer- this preventing him from falling for fakes, but providing more separation for the WR.

The "play it reasonable" (I'm not happy with this name, but I'm not a native speaker) setting should be a balanced setting, allowing all kinds of routes and providing some support to all kind of routes too. The defender should get faked out on great QB / WR- fakes and have a slightly higher reaction time - so a quick cutting WR will break away for sure.

"Play it safe" should prevent fakes (huge bonus), but allow more separation on well run routes.



Originally posted by Ken1
...The "in-game adjustment" might be too much of an advantage, at least on fakes. It would be the only player setting that had adjustments. However, maybe on coverage cushion it could work like auto-adjust, as it would seem a bit unfair if someone who provided no cushion got constantly beaten on deep routes.

One other thing is that there has to be room for zones, meaning man coverage needs to be tough enough to play well that some teams play mostly zone coverage (at least in some matchups). That might mean further weakening man coverage but also improving zone coverage, both in the AI and in its intended reaction.


My idea is to cover that both. Bort had a "remind your play" function for CBs, but it ended up in giving the WR LOTS of cushion when the CB was beaten deep once. That caused a lot of problems.

Basically, it should work like auto-adjust - but both ways. So you can choose if you want to get back to your original setting soon or stay with the adjusted setting.

You might have planned vs. the long pass, but the opponent plays short passes and your defenders suck. Now they would adjust - quickly (risk of getting the long pass then) or slowly (still giving up much on short passes). Either way: having a player adjust based on "things went wrong" should not be as effective as well run zone defense. It's still a one-on-one situation and the DB will suffer quite a bit due to all the catches on him (in-game morale).

Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by RAPB

- how should receivers not based on getting separation (high jumping/catching) get catches too?


People would need to get used to the better possession receivers making great catches, even when the defender is right on top of them. Maybe the PbP could say "Great catch by Receiver Name!" to indicate that it was a catch based on catching ability despite very good coverage.

All receivers would have some chance at the "Great catch..."es, as it would compare the relevant stats (and just how well covered) to a random number, and anyone would win at times. But someone with 60 Catching should get many more "great" catches than someone with 30 Catching; and not only double, but many more than double.


... another way: possession guys require more accurate throws - so the QBs needs to be build in order to do so. A well covered guy should be harder to hit i.m.h.o.; at the same time, you could provide a bonus to his further movement. I see WRs stop A LOT to catch the ball. Maybe possession guys could just pick up the ball while maintaining full speed? So even a little separation (which they get unless the CB is set on "bite on everything") will result in a complete pass and even some extra yards after catch?

I generally disagree with receivers making the majority of catches even in "perfect" coverage. If the defender is all over the receiver, he can not only deflect the ball before the receiver even gets a chance to catch. He can also swat the ball out of the hands before the pass is complete. So high jumping/catching should not guarantee a completed pass - for you sure got a hand on the ball, but you need to hold on afterwards.




 
bamaplaya1
offline
Link
 
very nice, get a few more suggestions in here and put it all in 1 quote and ill add it to the ultimate suggestion thread
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
I noticed your so-called ultimate suggestion thread had no mention of GG's thread post about player advanced tactics. He, I and a few other agents went over almost every single position and came up with a ton of ideas for adv. tactics for them, to go along with the new QB tactics and pass rush tactics on defense...pretty good collection. Maybe it's already a sticky and I haven't noticed yet...either way, it's one of the best ones around.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
I like where this is going. Good ideas, guys.

Everyone should take a note: Suggestions of how you would improve what you don't like, rather than just complaints about how you don't like it and it sucks, go a long way to helping to improve the thing you're not happy with.
Last edited Aug 17, 2008 22:18:37
 
G.O.D Turner
offline
Link
 
Awesome!
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
The trick to this though is there are two ways maybe three for a receiver to get open, and they can be justified with attributes and/or special abilities.

1) There should be a check on any sudden cut, which rolls against the agility of the player making the cut and determines his new top speed as a percentage of his old speed. This roll should go against BOTH the CB and WR. Vision could add in for either of them to recognize it is simply a stick your foot down, pivot and run, and it definately does add in for the QB to recognize his guy is open.

2) The second method involves the WR outrunning the CB, where you have agility versus speed with vision tacked in for the CB to recognize the WR is going long.

3) A third method could be a broken coverage where say a SS gets in the CB's way or something like that.

Since Bort figures motion with vectors, this then presents the vectors (assuming the ball is thrown there), the WR, the CB, and the ball. There should be an accuracy roll for the QB, factoring in vector motion, distance, strength, vision, throwing, and "openness" of the target. The "catch" roll can then be determined from the distance between the WR and CB, the catching skills, jumping skills, special skills, and pass settings to determine if the pass is caught.

BUT the end result should be dictated by the attributes, special abilites, and settings, not some misguided notion that because the NFL has a certain yard per pass average, GLB must have the same thing.

Bort in a different thread said he was shooting for 50 - 65% completion rates given equal CB and WR, and I think that would be about perfect.

I'm not however seeing that right now.

PinTBC


 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by tarlyn
I just dont want to see that many deflections getting caught.....if a DB deflects the ball it rarely if ever gets caught......a caught deflection should be a highlight reel catch not happening 10 times a game.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Landon06
Originally posted by tarlyn

I just dont want to see that many deflections getting caught.....if a DB deflects the ball it rarely if ever gets caught......a caught deflection should be a highlight reel catch not happening 10 times a game.


Absolutely agree with this. Tipped passes that are still caught happens WAY too much in this game. Either make the deflections uncaught or just have less deflections and let the WR's catch more untouched balls.

 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
the problem is that CB's can get to the ball for a deflection too often. You don't see as many deflections on average in a game as you see in GLB, mainly because good CB's can play tight too easily. However, they don't have the upgraded secondary/tertiary attributes to actually slam the ball down, a true deflected pass, so some get caught.

Again, the defn. of deflected pass in this sim, like a "missed tackle" is literal -- if a guy even got a finger on the ball and didn't chance the passes direction, still a deflected pass. If a guy gets a finger on a ball carrier, still a missed tackle.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Originally posted by dpell

CB's need to be nerfed back even more, but when they do get a hand on the ball or are in position to make a play the WR shouldn't be making the catches like they are.


I don't think nerfing is the right word here, too much negativity there, and they don't need to be made less effective...the effectiveness right now is pretty accurate to RL.

Bort just needs to tweak it so that it is harder to play tight coverage, thus less pass deflections, but as you said, when a pass is deflected it shouldn't be a catch most of the time. It will get there, patience is a virtue.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by drunkenmonkey
I think a "Bump and run" option needs to be added to the Cbs! Preferably in the AI settings for defensive plays or in players advanced tactics. The bump and run is such a huge part of the coverage and blitzing game in real football. It should be implemented here. The corners should have the ability to jam up the WRs at the LOS

 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.