User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Please don't let this thread become an emotional rant. I am trying to gather and present hard numbers specific to the WR and CB secondary problems.

*****************
OK Bort,

Some stats from our last game.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=104437

I am focusing on AllDay McRae who is probablly our best Corner. I matched him up generally against their best receiver.

AllDay looks like this (not saying he is all world, but he is a pretty decent 27th CB):

Strength: 16.08 Blocking: 8
Speed: 71.74 Tackling: 19.58
Agility: 55.69 Throwing: 8
Jumping: 30.01 Catching: 29.45
Stamina: 35.02 Carrying: 20.85
Vision: 44.07 Kicking: 10
Confidence: 27.63 Punting: 7

Specials are:
3 Swat Ball, 4 sticky Hands, 6 Super Vision, 2 Smooth Operator, and 3 shutdown coverage
1 First step, 2 change direction, 2 return spec, 1 Blitz, and 2 closing speed

The guys he covered were Tom Cruise Level 27 WR, and Jrue Holiday level 21 WR. There were 16 passes thrown to the guys he was covering, and 14 were completed, 2 were not. There were no PDs, nor interceptions.

AllDay was in Pass focus, Man to Man – Close coverage stick to your man like glue, and loose coverage style, play it safe and don’t get beat. Since you stated in a different thread that “Aggressive – go for interception even if you may get beat will give the defender a negative on the “catch” roll, I thought I’d try the loose hoping it might balance out. I expect that it doesn't.

The success rate for the offense when throwing the ball in his direction was 87.5%, a far cry from your 50-65% on even matchups. Remember please, he went against a good 27th WR, and a 21st WR, both caught most everything thrown to them.

This is the basis for my dissatisfaction with the current defensive secondary model. Even if the 27th WR is MUCH better trained, I’d be hard pressed to believe the level 21 is.

I’m willing to gather information in the next few games if you wish?

PinTBC
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Pin,

Not sure you can base a theory or an assumption on one game, I would probably monitor the next 4-5 games, OR go back 3-4 games and do the same thing.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
To be fair, you should add the SA Defense General your MLB provides and if/when this CB happened to miss any tackles. Destroyed in-game morale might play a role.
 
ky1732
offline
Link
 
your cb has low strength so he probably got out muscled
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by sjmay
Pin,

Not sure you can base a theory or an assumption on one game, I would probably monitor the next 4-5 games, OR go back 3-4 games and do the same thing.


Oh, I agree, but in one game out of 46ish passes, 16 went his way, and 14 were complete. That is why I am planning on posting the same information for our next few games also.

He missed a single tackle about 1/2 way through the game, and our MLB/NTs have around 4 each in the appropriate stat.

Oh, we won that game also.

PinTBC
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Pin - playing loose, in my opinion, is meant to keep the play in front of you, or at least that is how I read it. Basically, I feel that it means you will give up more passes in the short / medium length but should rarely if ever get beat for a deep ball.

Medium to me means you play tighter to the receiver, esp. when you have help over the top. When you have help, you'll make a break for the ball and try to pick it off. When you don't, you'll still be closer to the WR but won't break for it, but might be able to get a hand on it at times. You'll also run a higher risk of getting beat deep.

Aggressively going for the INT means if you miss the INT roll, you have less of a chance to bat the ball down, and there are lots of chances for WR's to have big catches, esp. when you go for the INT with no help over the top. It is a complete risk/reward system.

I'd try playing your CB on medium next game and see if anything changes -- I think it should. And, as always, if you set your individual guys up based on what you think the other teams offense will do / is capable of, I think that makes a huge difference.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
But then there's a game like this, just played today, where we contained the opposition very well, both in the air and on the ground; and they contained us well, also.

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=104605

Neither of us got close to the 6.9 NFL yards per pass attempt, nor to the 4.0 NFL yards per rush. We held them under even a 50% completion rate.

It seemed like we were deflecting passes extremely well all game as well.

The thing is, last season, this would have been a high offense game by the season's standards. This season it was, as it should be, a good day for the defenses to hold opponents to such numbers.

For a game like the one I played to happen is fine. I fear there are those who truly think that any game with more offense than the game I linked to is automatically off-- and that's where they are wrong.

A lot of that was due to letting the Season 3 sim stay in play all season, and people getting used to low-offense games, when the in real life average NFL team gains well over 300 yards per game and scores over 21 points.

Oh, and in looking at a pasing attack, don't forget to account for the QB. High Vision is supposed to allow a QB to "thread the needle" to receivers in traffic, among other things.

Last edited Aug 17, 2008 16:19:38
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
Pin - playing loose, in my opinion, is meant to keep the play in front of you, or at least that is how I read it. Basically, I feel that it means you will give up more passes in the short / medium length but should rarely if ever get beat for a deep ball.

Medium to me means you play tighter to the receiver, esp. when you have help over the top. When you have help, you'll make a break for the ball and try to pick it off. When you don't, you'll still be closer to the WR but won't break for it, but might be able to get a hand on it at times. You'll also run a higher risk of getting beat deep.

Aggressively going for the INT means if you miss the INT roll, you have less of a chance to bat the ball down, and there are lots of chances for WR's to have big catches, esp. when you go for the INT with no help over the top. It is a complete risk/reward system.


Except that the aggressive and medium settings directly talk about interceptions, which lead me to believe that the setting itself was how often does your CB go for the interception. If that is true, then the loose setting should mean that the guy never goes for the interception, and simply tries to bat the ball instead. That would be supported by the statement Bort made about the aggressive style being a large negative in the "catch" roll. If there is a large negative modifier, there certainly should be an offsetting positive one, no?

PinTBC
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by PinTBC
Originally posted by SCACE

Pin - playing loose, in my opinion, is meant to keep the play in front of you, or at least that is how I read it. Basically, I feel that it means you will give up more passes in the short / medium length but should rarely if ever get beat for a deep ball.

Medium to me means you play tighter to the receiver, esp. when you have help over the top. When you have help, you'll make a break for the ball and try to pick it off. When you don't, you'll still be closer to the WR but won't break for it, but might be able to get a hand on it at times. You'll also run a higher risk of getting beat deep.

Aggressively going for the INT means if you miss the INT roll, you have less of a chance to bat the ball down, and there are lots of chances for WR's to have big catches, esp. when you go for the INT with no help over the top. It is a complete risk/reward system.


Except that the aggressive and medium settings directly talk about interceptions, which lead me to believe that the setting itself was how often does your CB go for the interception. If that is true, then the loose setting should mean that the guy never goes for the interception, and simply tries to bat the ball instead. That would be supported by the statement Bort made about the aggressive style being a large negative in the "catch" roll. If there is a large negative modifier, there certainly should be an offsetting positive one, no?

PinTBC


For what it's worth, I took what he said the same way.
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
These are the stats from our previous game. Again I had my CB set to guard the other team's #1 WR. He ended up covering a level 28 receiver, and a level 25 receiver. in 40 passes, 4 were thrown in his direction, 3 were completed, and one dropped. All but one of those were to the level 25 WR. The QB in that game is one that lead the league last year in yardage and TDs, so he isn't completely useless.

AllDay's settings were close man to man, and loose on the coverage style. The sample size is too small in that game to get a real good read, but I offer the data because I was tracking it.

By the way, a small nit. The Man to Man should dictate the coverage distance. Close medium or loose shows how the CB is covering the receiver. If he is close, he should stand a decent chance to get beat if the WR or QB can fake him out and he fails his vision/agility check. Medium should be harder to fake him out, but give a lower chance that he is "right there" when the ball gets there, and loose means he is playing back so he doesn't get beat deep.

The coverage style should be how aggressive is he in going after the ball when it is thrown. Aggressive says he is going for the interception and not playing the man. This should get beat pretty easily. Medium means he is average, but if he has another defender there he will go for the int, and loose should mean he isn't going for the interception, he is however going to stop the ball from getting to the man. They should each have pluses and minuses in that elusive "catch" roll.

Those different pull downs should be reworded to accurately spell out what each setting means. The way loose coverage style is described on the pull down, you would expect it to be part of the man to man coverage style.

PinTBC
 
PinTBC
offline
Link
 
In the scrimmage we played against a friendly team

http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=124981

The stats are 48 attempted passes, with 5 going in his direction. 1 was incomplete, 1 was deflected by another CB in the crowd that was covering the WR, and 3 were complete. One of the completions was a deep throw over his head for a TD. I know the WR very well on that play, and he is not a well rounded WR. He is trained very specifically to exploit speed and vision.

AllDay's settings were again close man to man, and loose coverage style. Again, this game didn't offer a lot of passes thrown in his region, which at the time made sense to me. He is covering close, and not going for the interception, which means the receiver should be pretty much blanketted. He won't make any big plays, but should certainly force the QB to look somewhere else to throw the ball.

PinTBC
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Thank you for some actual intelligent discussion instead of "OMG EVERYTHING IS BROKENZZ THIS GAME SUXXORZ," Pin.

Playing loose doesn't mean you'll always go for the bat down. Playing loose means you're just trying to keep the guy in front of you and are not going to try and go straight for the ball when it's thrown. Medium is more of the "bat down" setting, while aggressive is the "try to get the INT every time" setting.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Thank you for some actual intelligent discussion instead of "OMG EVERYTHING IS BROKENZZ THIS GAME SUXXORZ," Pin.

Playing loose doesn't mean you'll always go for the bat down. Playing loose means you're just trying to keep the guy in front of you and are not going to try and go straight for the ball when it's thrown. Medium is more of the "bat down" setting, while aggressive is the "try to get the INT every time" setting.


That's good to know.

That information is not intuitive at all.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Thank you for some actual intelligent discussion instead of "OMG EVERYTHING IS BROKENZZ THIS GAME SUXXORZ," Pin.

Playing loose doesn't mean you'll always go for the bat down. Playing loose means you're just trying to keep the guy in front of you and are not going to try and go straight for the ball when it's thrown. Medium is more of the "bat down" setting, while aggressive is the "try to get the INT every time" setting.


I agree - very nice post Pin.

Interesting information here. There's definitely a time for all three settings, with Medium being the most common, as it should be. Also, the risks of all three settings all seem appropriate, from what I've seen.

This is a much better passing situation than last season, when every single CB was on close/aggressive.
 
tremele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Thank you for some actual intelligent discussion instead of "OMG EVERYTHING IS BROKENZZ THIS GAME SUXXORZ," Pin.

Playing loose doesn't mean you'll always go for the bat down. Playing loose means you're just trying to keep the guy in front of you and are not going to try and go straight for the ball when it's thrown. Medium is more of the "bat down" setting, while aggressive is the "try to get the INT every time" setting.


Bort, I really support this game, and will continue paying while you improve it. Why post only to "intelligent discussions" instead of seeing real plays being screwed up? One that is killing me is a level 1 HB breaking tackles on two level 21+ DTs on one play, which we haven't heard a word on yet.
Last edited Aug 17, 2008 23:26:55
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.