Please don't let this thread become an emotional rant. I am trying to gather and present hard numbers specific to the WR and CB secondary problems.
*****************
OK Bort,
Some stats from our last game.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=104437
I am focusing on AllDay McRae who is probablly our best Corner. I matched him up generally against their best receiver.
AllDay looks like this (not saying he is all world, but he is a pretty decent 27th CB):
Strength: 16.08 Blocking: 8
Speed: 71.74 Tackling: 19.58
Agility: 55.69 Throwing: 8
Jumping: 30.01 Catching: 29.45
Stamina: 35.02 Carrying: 20.85
Vision: 44.07 Kicking: 10
Confidence: 27.63 Punting: 7
Specials are:
3 Swat Ball, 4 sticky Hands, 6 Super Vision, 2 Smooth Operator, and 3 shutdown coverage
1 First step, 2 change direction, 2 return spec, 1 Blitz, and 2 closing speed
The guys he covered were Tom Cruise Level 27 WR, and Jrue Holiday level 21 WR. There were 16 passes thrown to the guys he was covering, and 14 were completed, 2 were not. There were no PDs, nor interceptions.
AllDay was in Pass focus, Man to Man – Close coverage stick to your man like glue, and loose coverage style, play it safe and don’t get beat. Since you stated in a different thread that “Aggressive – go for interception even if you may get beat will give the defender a negative on the “catch” roll, I thought I’d try the loose hoping it might balance out. I expect that it doesn't.
The success rate for the offense when throwing the ball in his direction was 87.5%, a far cry from your 50-65% on even matchups. Remember please, he went against a good 27th WR, and a 21st WR, both caught most everything thrown to them.
This is the basis for my dissatisfaction with the current defensive secondary model. Even if the 27th WR is MUCH better trained, I’d be hard pressed to believe the level 21 is.
I’m willing to gather information in the next few games if you wish?
PinTBC
*****************
OK Bort,
Some stats from our last game.
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=104437
I am focusing on AllDay McRae who is probablly our best Corner. I matched him up generally against their best receiver.
AllDay looks like this (not saying he is all world, but he is a pretty decent 27th CB):
Strength: 16.08 Blocking: 8
Speed: 71.74 Tackling: 19.58
Agility: 55.69 Throwing: 8
Jumping: 30.01 Catching: 29.45
Stamina: 35.02 Carrying: 20.85
Vision: 44.07 Kicking: 10
Confidence: 27.63 Punting: 7
Specials are:
3 Swat Ball, 4 sticky Hands, 6 Super Vision, 2 Smooth Operator, and 3 shutdown coverage
1 First step, 2 change direction, 2 return spec, 1 Blitz, and 2 closing speed
The guys he covered were Tom Cruise Level 27 WR, and Jrue Holiday level 21 WR. There were 16 passes thrown to the guys he was covering, and 14 were completed, 2 were not. There were no PDs, nor interceptions.
AllDay was in Pass focus, Man to Man – Close coverage stick to your man like glue, and loose coverage style, play it safe and don’t get beat. Since you stated in a different thread that “Aggressive – go for interception even if you may get beat will give the defender a negative on the “catch” roll, I thought I’d try the loose hoping it might balance out. I expect that it doesn't.
The success rate for the offense when throwing the ball in his direction was 87.5%, a far cry from your 50-65% on even matchups. Remember please, he went against a good 27th WR, and a 21st WR, both caught most everything thrown to them.
This is the basis for my dissatisfaction with the current defensive secondary model. Even if the 27th WR is MUCH better trained, I’d be hard pressed to believe the level 21 is.
I’m willing to gather information in the next few games if you wish?
PinTBC






























