User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
wdb
offline
Link
 
Due to the use of energy to decide on who's in, any starting D league punter that can stand up will get 6 or so punts before the second punter gets any. On a human controlled team this may make sense. On a CPU developmental team this makes no sense. Counting the 0 punts my guy got this game, he's had three punts in the last three games. He's a level 7. Our recently hired starter (he went from one D league to another and is now level 8) had just short of 20 in the same time period. The net effect is the second team punter won't develop in a timely manner. Oddly enough, this problem doesn't seem to apply to kickers, just punters. Perhaps you could adjust the settings.

wdb
Last edited Aug 17, 2008 10:18:00
 
oldskool
offline
Link
 
Agreed. Special teams need to alternate kicks regardless of energy levels, the backups just don't see the field otherwise.
 
diro
offline
Link
 
Happend to kickers to. Posted this and wrot to suport.

The answer was:

"This is a known issue when there are multiple kickers on one d-league team. Over the course of a few games the plays should even out for both players.
-Thorn"

But nothing is getting better. Still a bug.
 
wdb
offline
Link
 
In the five games since the CPU team hired the other guy (my guy was level 6 then)

My guy: 4 punts including the last two games with no punts

Other guy: 31 punts, including 8 punts in the last game.

He is now two levels ahead instead of one.

It is not getting better! Nor will my guy with 0 XP in the last two games and a total of 273 (not counting training) in the last five games.
 
ipstaff
offline
Link
 
I remember similar frustrations when my punter was in the D-league.

That said - if you really want to make yourself a player who will be valued and get lots of PT, retire your punter, and use those FP to make an offensive lineman. The way punter works with XP, the better the team you're on is, the worse off you'll be over the long run - as bad teams have to punt a lot, while good teams sometimes have entire games where you'll go without punting.

Further complicating the frustration with being a punter is the fact that punters don't appear to be able to actually go for coffin-corner punts, angling kicks out of bounds near the goal line. As it is now, the only way you pin a team inside the 10 is if the ball magically settles there.

For the same FP, an o-lineman will be much more involved, have at least one tactical choice to make (how to focus blocking), and grow more quickly. I made an OT a season after my P and his growth has been much faster and play more satisfying.
 
wdb
offline
Link
 
Thanks, but I'm happy with a punter. And he is not my only player.
 
Darkus Black
FFA Mod
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by ipstaff
I remember similar frustrations when my punter was in the D-league.

That said - if you really want to make yourself a player who will be valued and get lots of PT, retire your punter, and use those FP to make an offensive lineman. The way punter works with XP, the better the team you're on is, the worse off you'll be over the long run - as bad teams have to punt a lot, while good teams sometimes have entire games where you'll go without punting.

Further complicating the frustration with being a punter is the fact that punters don't appear to be able to actually go for coffin-corner punts, angling kicks out of bounds near the goal line. As it is now, the only way you pin a team inside the 10 is if the ball magically settles there.

For the same FP, an o-lineman will be much more involved, have at least one tactical choice to make (how to focus blocking), and grow more quickly. I made an OT a season after my P and his growth has been much faster and play more satisfying.


Stop hating on the punters.

 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.