User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=86662&mode=pbp

I have read a lot of threads that debate whether coverage is fixed or not etc. I present this game and our passing attack as a prime example of the problems present. This is a good test case to me. My team has several level 20 range WRs. The no. 1 and 2 are 27 and 26. The opposing defense had a level 22 CB and a bunch of level 9 CBs. Watch our passing game and you will see we were able to abuse the level 22 CB and had success there but teh level 9 guys on the other side held us down. Sometimes the QB threw as the Level 9 was loosing coverage but this seems to highlight the issue. I post this not in hopes of engaging in a long debate with many noted scholars. I think this one is a good one for the trouble shooters like Bort to look at since the wide divergence in CB skills is present from one side of the field to the other and because our WRs are all similary skilled in a general sense. This game should help sort out buggy issues with coverage and you can compare contrast what the CBs are doing.
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
that was the most confusing block of text i've ever read. is this supposed to be a "test case"? you know most coders do that to their own code while nothing else is simming right?
Last edited Aug 15, 2008 12:16:50
 
dberner30
offline
Link
 
no. my point is simple. There have been lots of posts talking about screwed up coverage and i thought this game would be a good one for someone to look at to identify the bug.

1. My WR1 and WR2 are similar within a range (lvl 26 and lvl 27)
2. The opponent had a level 22 CB on one side and a level 9 CB on the other.
3. The level 9 CB (and his other level 9 CBs that spelled the CB2 guy) did a better job in coverage all game than the level 22 CB.

We dont usually see games where the opponent CBs are so far apart. The outcome for this game should have been the Level 9 CB being toasted all day long while the level 22 CB did a decent job. So in a nutshell, a level 9 CB effectively shut down high level WRs while the same general WR was able to have success against the level 22.

hope that clears up my point in putting this sample forward for review by those with knowledge. This isnt a test case but an example for review.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Build does not make any difference anymore for CBs.

The passing game mechanic is entirely random.

The CBs do not react to anything, regardless of their level or build. They simply stay near (and sometimes not so near) the WR, and the game rolls whether the WR drops the ball or not. That is what pass coverage has been reduced to.
 
thunderdoozer
offline
Link
 
Like this crap: http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=92461&pbp_id=3559854

which is so entirely unrealistic, it makes we want to vomit.
 
Buzzkill
offline
Link
 
If they arent reacting to anything, you mind explaining to me what exactly happened here?

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=93340&pbp_id=3844342

Its obvious that our CB read the QBs mind, and ran to where the ball would end up. The problem is he forgot there would be a WR incoming to catch the ball before it got there. No way ANY CB has he vision to read a pass that far in advance.

I totally agree that CB coverage has become a joke, as all of a sudden my once league leading secondary is now giving up 10-20 yard plays at will, but i think over-reacting needs added in on our list
 
Link
 
What's really sad is even if you are right and the CB "knew" where the ball was gonna wind up, he still couldn't stop it. That just goes to show how bad the CB position is F'ed right now.
 
Link
 
Yeah the CB/WR thing is getting out of hand. It's like every pass is caught, even when it is deflected by the CBs. It seems to have only gotten worse as the season has progressed.

Love the avatar, Johnny.
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnny_Johnson
What's really sad is even if you are right and the CB "knew" where the ball was gonna wind up, he still couldn't stop it. That just goes to show how bad the CB position is F'ed right now.


+1
 
GreyFoxTBC
offline
Link
 
Boy do they have to work on the coverage and tips. I give you this play as a perfect
example. Since we were scrimmaging friends I had excess to the actual numbers of the
CB and WR. Chris Silvas (22 WR) is being covered by Randy McSwatter (26 CB). As you can
see there is a 4 level difference, McSwatter is 10 points faster, 13 points more vision,
2 points more jump, and 11 points more strength. Silvas has 4 points more agility 11 points more catch .

a)When in this play was Silvas open, other than standing at the line before the hike?
b)How did he catch the deflection?
c) What QB would ever throw into that coverage?

(And yes I know that the dots are just close approximations to where the players are.)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=124981&pbp_id=3794324

During that game there were 8 deflected passes and 5 were caught. Sounds WAY high.
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 18:13:38
 
NWWarrior
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GreyFoxTBC
Boy do they have to work on the coverage and tips. I give you this play as a perfect
example. Since we were scrimmaging friends I had excess to the actual numbers of the
CB and WR. Chris Silvas (22 WR) is being covered by Randy McSwatter (26 CB). As you can
see there is a 4 level difference, McSwatter is 10 points faster, 13 points more vision,
2 points more jump, and 11 points more strength. Silvas has 4 points more agility 11 points more catch .

a)When in this play was Silvas open, other than standing at the line before the hike?
b)How did he catch the deflection?
c) What QB would ever throw into that coverage?

(And yes I know that the dots are just close approximations to where the players are.)

http://goallineblitz.com/game/replay.pl?game_id=124981&pbp_id=3794324

During that game there were 8 deflected passes and 5 were caught. Sounds WAY high.


Nice post...hope Bort explains it well since that is one of hundreds of examples like that!
 
Vlad Dracul
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Johnny_Johnson
What's really sad is even if you are right and the CB "knew" where the ball was gonna wind up, he still couldn't stop it. That just goes to show how bad the CB position is F'ed right now.


+1
 
rjdriver
offline
Link
 
We have 3 Lvl 23+ CBs and opponents are averaging 70% comp pct...
 
dpell
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks
Yeah the CB/WR thing is getting out of hand. It's like every pass is caught, even when it is deflected by the CBs. It seems to have only gotten worse as the season has progressed.

Love the avatar, Johnny.


Yes, the game isn't perfect right now. WR's seem to make too many catches in traffic and I'd argue that CB's still react too quickly. They should get fooled a little more, and when they're on top of the WR the WR shouldn't make as many catches.

However, WR's are getting better because they are finally putting SP into catching which they never did or had to before. I've got a CB on my team with 10+ interceptions and 4 of them for TD's. Maybe a CB should have more than 20 catching too if you want him to get interceptions?
Last edited Aug 16, 2008 18:54:04
 
JeffSteele
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by dpell
Originally posted by Punk Rock Jocks

Yeah the CB/WR thing is getting out of hand. It's like every pass is caught, even when it is deflected by the CBs. It seems to have only gotten worse as the season has progressed.

Love the avatar, Johnny.


Yes, the game isn't perfect right now. WR's seem to make too many catches in traffic and I'd argue that CB's still react too quickly. They should get fooled a little more, and when they're on top of the WR the WR shouldn't make as many catches.

However, WR's are getting better because they are finally putting SP into catching which they never did or had to before. I've got a CB on my team with 10+ interceptions and 4 of them for TD's. Maybe a CB should have more than 20 catching too if you want him to get interceptions?
that's not what we want. we want PDs. and for some reason every time i see my guy Christian Cage try to play loose coverage, he gives a 5 yard cushion to the WR. it happened during the entire last drive and prevented us from getting the ball back.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.