User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
GG
offline
Link
 
First read this thread...

http://goallineblitz.com/game/forum_thread.pl?thread_id=82817

This is a question really. But if levels per se are reason for an OL-man getting 21 pancakes in a championship game suddenly out of nowhere tho getting roughly 4 per game in the playoffs, then does that then suggest a level 11 WR against a level 6 CB mean that WR would/could/should get 21 TDs receiving? Or a level 11 FB up against a DL/LB corp of level 6 mean that FB could/would/should get 50 broken tackles in a game?

If this is the case, then it's like no trading should be allowed between leagues where a level 12 Center could be brought into a team where the rest of the conference/league are level 5. That leagues should be classes then, like boxing weight divisions.

That's not do-able because at all times people/owners should be allowed to create new players for their team. Meaning players will start at level 1 in a league thats 2 or 4 seasons old where everyone is level 15 or 18.

Imo, this whole issue needs to be discussed, addressed. IF levels/skills matter that much that can cause obscene stats like 21 pancakes. Then a) where are all the WRs with 20 TDs per game? b) how can leagues several seasons old co-exist fairly then if at all times new players are being created which will start off 10+ levels behind most other players in the league.

 
GG
offline
Link
 
Levels and skills then should be re-worked to ensure that the difference between a level 1 player and a level 11 player is not much difference at all. Otherwise the whole structure of global leagues, mass trading, XPs, newly created players in leagues/teams that are seasons old, etc etc, falls apart.

Level 1 vs level 11 should not be like a 10 year old boy vs an Orlando Pace. It should be like a college player vs a 10 year NFL veteran. You dont see rookies in the NFL being burned for 20 TDs at CB, unable to make tackles, unable to block, allowing 20 sacks a game, etc. What you see is roughly an equal skill set. Often you even see rookies who are better than the vets or can hold their own.

Therefore, the whole levels/skills thing needs to completely overhauled. Allowing level 1 players and level 11 players to be basically equally matched pretty much from the get-go.

Last edited Apr 20, 2008 18:56:21
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
It was only 21 pancakes man.

Bolstersam had his center get 51 in a game this season. That was against a USA pro DL. He probably put most of those SP into a good spot on the last couple of levels. And a low leveled dline will do that. Plus ive seen DEs and DT's go way heavy in speed and agility and forget strength.

Lots of things could have happened but i really dont think its a bug.

PS we will wait for the 20 TD and 20 sack thing if/when that happens.
 
MentalMisfit
offline
Link
 
why is this in the bug section?? And no a lvl 11 shouldnt be equal to a lvl 1.. The game is still fairly new in time the leagues will kind of separate having a their own lvl system just give it time.
 
domenick2x
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by bigtisme
It was only 21 pancakes man.

Bolstersam had his center get 51 in a game this season. That was against a USA pro DL. He probably put most of those SP into a good spot on the last couple of levels. And a low leveled dline will do that. Plus ive seen DEs and DT's go way heavy in speed and agility and forget strength.

Lots of things could have happened but i really dont think its a bug.

PS we will wait for the 20 TD and 20 sack thing if/when that happens.



51 pancakes in one game?

That's not reasonable under any stat set. Unless the DL he was up against was a 175 lb CB pretending to play DT...
 
GG
offline
Link
 
My point is that it should never happen. Things like 20-50 pancakes (or broken tackles, TDs, INTs) a game should never happen DUE to a level/skill difference. Otherwise the very fabric of GLB mmorpg collapses. Think ahead to season 4, when players are like level 20 or 24. And all the time new players are being created, brought into leagues, teams where everyone is level 20. First....they'll never get a game or game time if owners have cause to be concerned about giving up 20-50 of something per game. How is that level 1 player ever gonna get game time then. So they leave GLB due to all this.

What ends up having to happen is one of two things...1) all leagues are separated based on skill/level. Like boxing classes, which is ok, but it doesnt then help when someone wants to create a new player (level 1) to come into that team)....or....2) the whole skill/level thing needs to be re-worked so that the difference between level 1 and level 20 even is not much, like a rookie out of college vs a 10 year vet. Just some minor skill difference that is still crucial but not obscenely so. Instead of possible 50 pancakes or broken tackles, maybe just a couple crucial plays.

Long-term the skills/levels is gonna be a huge problem. How can anyone introduce new level 1 players if the sim considers them to be 10 year old boys when pitted against level 11 or 20 players?
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
There will be level caps in the future to avoid this issue of level 30s against level 1s.
 
domenick2x
offline
Link
 
The solution to bringing in a new player is clearly to stick with like-levelled players, build steadily, eventually get traded to the team you want.

Think of it like this - a great player wouldn't bring in his kid brother without having the proper training/experience. Think of Michael Vick and his brother - younger brother has some raw skill, but didn't get the work in college to take advantage of it, and thus couldn't hack it in the NFL.

Still, 51 pancakes is ridiculous. I could see the other guy having no effectiveness, but not being pancaked on EVERY play.
 
GG
offline
Link
 
A level 1 player should always be considered to be like a rookie. So he's already athletic, muscular, has skills, etc, that are at least equal to every other nfl vet. Because....they're all human. You dont see a 10 yr vet continuing to grow, to the point where they are superhuman, literally. They dont grow into 800 lbs with 99 speed rating DE's.

The difference between the rookie level 1 and the maximum vet (level 100?) should be like very minimal. That rate of growth is not feasible. Nor when you have new level 1 guys being created every season...from the get-go 20 levels behind and NEVER able to catch-up.

Like I said, if a level 1 vs a level 20 in sim'd game, it should mean something like they give up a crucial play or two at most in a game. But not ALL rookies. Some can come in and be great players straight away. So there needs to be a totally different aspect to GLB than XP and levels allowing skiills to go from 10 to 50 in a couple of seasons, therefore a 50 speed WR vs a 10 speed CB ends up meaning 20 TDs given up in a game.

Imo the PHYSICAL skills categories between level 1 and level 100 should ALL be the same roughly. A level 1 WR should start off with 90 speed. So the maximum a player can ever get is 100 speed AFTER 10 seasons. But FOOTBALL skills are trainable. So a level 1 WR catching could start off at 50, while a 10 season vet could be like maximum 100 by that time. Because the point is that humans/footballers dont CONTINUE to get bigger, faster, stronger to an obscene amount, and rookies arent 10 year olds, but are fairly equally if not equal or better in things like speed, strength. A college DL is gonna be 280 lbs with 4.80 40 time when he enters the NFL. He's not gonna be 280 lbs with a 80.7 40 time. His vision on the field as a rookie is gonna be fairly equal to a veteran. And even skills arent that much different. A rookie WR isnt some guy who drops 20 balls a game. Etc.

Last edited Apr 20, 2008 19:29:15
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Well i think it kills the point of a MMORPG to make everyone equal from the start.

Feel free to discuss your thoughts. But this is not a bug...there has to be some line and here is where it is for now. If you dont get 51 versus a terrible DL then you NEVER see a pancake when they are even. Even matched players will give realistic stats and outcomes....if a player is really overmatched this game shows that as well.
 
randomguymike
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
A level 1 player should always be considered to be like a rookie. So he's already athletic, muscular, has skills, etc, that are at least equal to every other nfl vet. Because....they're all human.



I disagree with your assesment. Lvl 1 is me walking onto a football field. Put me up against an average D2 college player (level 11), I'll get my ass handed to me. Get me and 10 of my buddies out against an App state, and they'll put up 72, no problem.
 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Also a number of plays on the dline were by CPU players
Last edited Apr 20, 2008 19:36:42
 
GG
offline
Link
 
Simply...level 1 should = rookie standard human being and football skilled player.

Able to immediately be of equal physical and football standard/skills to a veteran. Just very minimal differences. Gives up a play or two in a game. Drops a clutch TD maybe 3 or 4 times in a whole season. Gives up like 15 sacks in a year. As a CB gives up a few more big yardage plays than a vet would per game/season.

I dont think a level cap in a league would work. I as owner should have the ability to create a new player for my team at level 1 and have him able to play against level 20 guys in season 5 because my starting OT got traded/released and I needed someone to come in. Or to allow people across the whole GLB to trade back and forth with each other. Maybe I want all my friends to come play for my team, so all these level 1 guys come into a team in a league full of level 20 players. Or if I've spent 4 seasons developing a great player for my team to suddenly be told he cannot play for my team anymore because he's now level 20 and must be released from my AAAA league team and join the pro-league.

 
Serenity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GG
Simply...level 1 should = rookie standard human being and football skilled player.

Able to immediately be of equal physical and football standard/skills to a veteran. Just very minimal differences. Gives up a play or two in a game. Drops a clutch TD maybe 3 or 4 times in a whole season. Gives up like 15 sacks in a year. As a CB gives up a few more big yardage plays than a vet would per game/season.

I dont think a level cap in a league would work. I as owner should have the ability to create a new player for my team at level 1 and have him able to play against level 20 guys in season 5 because my starting OT got traded/released and I needed someone to come in. Or to allow people across the whole GLB to trade back and forth with each other. Maybe I want all my friends to come play for my team, so all these level 1 guys come into a team in a league full of level 20 players. Or if I've spent 4 seasons developing a great player for my team to suddenly be told he cannot play for my team anymore because he's now level 20 and must be released from my AAAA league team and join the pro-league.



lollers
 
bigtisme
offline
Link
 
Serenity dont laugh. You know that you should be able to create a level 1 that is equal to the level 45 you will have in a few seasons!!!
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.