What the title says. Anyone else seeing this? Needs to be looked at.
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Insane number of deflected passes being caught.
Koncorde
offline
offline
I do tend to think perhaps if a CB does get his hand to it, its unclear what attribute declares where the ball is deflected and/or what chance the WR has of catching it still.
Seems to me that if the CB gets a deflection, he gets a delay to trying to catch it. Whereas if the WR gets adeflection - he automatically adjusts to try and catch it. Maybe the same delay needs to be applied to WR? Though that would result in more dropped passes.
Alternatively the ability of CB's to hold onto the ball - or a more explicit/obvious reasoning as to what makes a good "swat" would be nice.
For instance I have a CB with 9 in swat ball. But I can't say I've noticed a particular drop in the number of PD's that are caught? But then it never seemed to be an issue with him previously.
Seems to me that if the CB gets a deflection, he gets a delay to trying to catch it. Whereas if the WR gets adeflection - he automatically adjusts to try and catch it. Maybe the same delay needs to be applied to WR? Though that would result in more dropped passes.
Alternatively the ability of CB's to hold onto the ball - or a more explicit/obvious reasoning as to what makes a good "swat" would be nice.
For instance I have a CB with 9 in swat ball. But I can't say I've noticed a particular drop in the number of PD's that are caught? But then it never seemed to be an issue with him previously.
JeffSteele
offline
offline
INSANE NUMBER! what is the number? i dont know!
yeah i'm seeing it a bit more too, but i think it's because QBs get to throw bullet passes all the time. slightly tipped passes that used to deflect away are now thrown so hard they still get into the catching radius of the WR.
QB bullet --> more tipped catches.
yeah i'm seeing it a bit more too, but i think it's because QBs get to throw bullet passes all the time. slightly tipped passes that used to deflect away are now thrown so hard they still get into the catching radius of the WR.
QB bullet --> more tipped catches.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Some are, but the point is - some CB's are that good too and is it representative.
I'm not sure what the percentages are - or what improves the odds of a PD being deflected away from the WR and thereby the WR not being able to control it. Where currently it appears any PD has a (seemingly) 90% chance of being caught afterwards.
Questions that need answering are things like:
1 - Do PD's qualify as interception attempts?
A - if so, catching is key.
2 - What controls the direction of the PD? Is it random?
3 - What effect does Swat Ball have? Does it increase the odds of the ball being moved away from the WR?
4 - What effect does a PD have on the WR catching the ball?
5 - Does the CB have the "delay" effect?
6 - Does the WR have a similar delay effect?
I'm not sure what the percentages are - or what improves the odds of a PD being deflected away from the WR and thereby the WR not being able to control it. Where currently it appears any PD has a (seemingly) 90% chance of being caught afterwards.
Questions that need answering are things like:
1 - Do PD's qualify as interception attempts?
A - if so, catching is key.
2 - What controls the direction of the PD? Is it random?
3 - What effect does Swat Ball have? Does it increase the odds of the ball being moved away from the WR?
4 - What effect does a PD have on the WR catching the ball?
5 - Does the CB have the "delay" effect?
6 - Does the WR have a similar delay effect?
JeffSteele
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
Some are, but the point is - some CB's are that good too and is it representative.
I'm not sure what the percentages are - or what improves the odds of a PD being deflected away from the WR and thereby the WR not being able to control it. Where currently it appears any PD has a (seemingly) 90% chance of being caught afterwards.
Questions that need answering are things like:
1 - Do PD's qualify as interception attempts?
A - if so, catching is key.
2 - What controls the direction of the PD? Is it random?
3 - What effect does Swat Ball have? Does it increase the odds of the ball being moved away from the WR?
4 - What effect does a PD have on the WR catching the ball?
5 - Does the CB have the "delay" effect?
6 - Does the WR have a similar delay effect?and all six questions (except maybe the first one) would all be questions that would divulge the super specifics of the game. plus they're probably ridiculously random.
Some are, but the point is - some CB's are that good too and is it representative.
I'm not sure what the percentages are - or what improves the odds of a PD being deflected away from the WR and thereby the WR not being able to control it. Where currently it appears any PD has a (seemingly) 90% chance of being caught afterwards.
Questions that need answering are things like:
1 - Do PD's qualify as interception attempts?
A - if so, catching is key.
2 - What controls the direction of the PD? Is it random?
3 - What effect does Swat Ball have? Does it increase the odds of the ball being moved away from the WR?
4 - What effect does a PD have on the WR catching the ball?
5 - Does the CB have the "delay" effect?
6 - Does the WR have a similar delay effect?and all six questions (except maybe the first one) would all be questions that would divulge the super specifics of the game. plus they're probably ridiculously random.
Koncorde
offline
offline
No, most of the answers would be similar to those we'd already received and identified as issues under the CB coverage bugs. 5 and 6 "are" part of the same issue and indeed were introduced by Bort during the Coverage Bug thread - and may have, as a result, caused more PD's to be caught by the WR instead of the CB.
Other stuff meanwhile maybe Bort needs to question that perhaps there are too many influences on PD's making them unfeasibly easy.
Really they're questions that "need to be asked" so Bort can go away and check everything is working as it should be, rather than "need answering" for our own benefit. In the process Bort may find Swat Ball is underpowered, or not having the required effect, or that PD's are too random and the delay effect gives too much of an advantage to the WR in all situations.
Other stuff meanwhile maybe Bort needs to question that perhaps there are too many influences on PD's making them unfeasibly easy.
Really they're questions that "need to be asked" so Bort can go away and check everything is working as it should be, rather than "need answering" for our own benefit. In the process Bort may find Swat Ball is underpowered, or not having the required effect, or that PD's are too random and the delay effect gives too much of an advantage to the WR in all situations.
SCACE
offline
offline
id guess, to be honest, that there aren't a lot of high jumping, catching, strength DB's out there...a deflection could mean a lot of things...off the fingertips and not really changing the direction of the pass all the way to a ball slammed down into the ground.
I'd guess with the CB builds we have now, there are a lot more of the former deflections compared to the latter.
I'd guess with the CB builds we have now, there are a lot more of the former deflections compared to the latter.
SCACE
offline
offline
one other thing - bort said the majority of CB's are playing on aggressive...and when they miss the INT their chances of deflection = incomplete pass goes down, chance of WR catch goes up, because they took the risk, risk vs. reward.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by SCACE
one other thing - bort said the majority of CB's are playing on aggressive...and when they miss the INT their chances of deflection = incomplete pass goes down, chance of WR catch goes up, because they took the risk, risk vs. reward.
Cheers, I missed the official comment on that one, but I kinda knew it from experience
one other thing - bort said the majority of CB's are playing on aggressive...and when they miss the INT their chances of deflection = incomplete pass goes down, chance of WR catch goes up, because they took the risk, risk vs. reward.
Cheers, I missed the official comment on that one, but I kinda knew it from experience

Yellow
offline
offline
Honestly it doesnt really seem like it's any different than it was in season 1 or 2. What's probably happening is more and more WRs are focusing on Catching now that theyre maxed on speed and agility, and it's making it harder for CBs to swat the ball completely away.
I'm sure Strength, or the Swat Ball SA, or Jumping, or even Catching for the CBs would help with this. I definitely dont think it's a bug at all.
I'm sure Strength, or the Swat Ball SA, or Jumping, or even Catching for the CBs would help with this. I definitely dont think it's a bug at all.
Koncorde
offline
offline
No I wouldn't call it a bug, just there's a big grey area around some of the changes and what knock on effects they've had.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by Koncorde
No I wouldn't call it a bug, just there's a big grey area around some of the changes and what knock on effects they've had.
Realistic passing stats, is the effect-- which must not be changed.
Bort indicated a willingness to consider eventually making CB's more effective at batting when in great coverage, in return for making it harder for CB's to be in such great coverage.
That's a tradeoff I'd be happy with, as tight man coverage is far too easy to play effectively.
No I wouldn't call it a bug, just there's a big grey area around some of the changes and what knock on effects they've had.
Realistic passing stats, is the effect-- which must not be changed.
Bort indicated a willingness to consider eventually making CB's more effective at batting when in great coverage, in return for making it harder for CB's to be in such great coverage.
That's a tradeoff I'd be happy with, as tight man coverage is far too easy to play effectively.
whoshotjr
offline
offline
Originally posted by Yellow
Honestly it doesnt really seem like it's any different than it was in season 1 or 2. What's probably happening is more and more WRs are focusing on Catching now that theyre maxed on speed and agility, and it's making it harder for CBs to swat the ball completely away.
I'm sure Strength, or the Swat Ball SA, or Jumping, or even Catching for the CBs would help with this. I definitely dont think it's a bug at all.
I agree with this. It seems similar to past seasons where:
- Ball deflected by the CB in front of the WR is caught fairly often by the WR.
- Ball deflected by the WR in front of the CB is intercepted a fair amount.
I just say this as in the past, there were games where I was in good position coverage wise but would give up some fairly long catches on deflections. Likewise, there were times when the WR was wide open, only to have the balls deflect to my guy a couple yards behind.
Honestly it doesnt really seem like it's any different than it was in season 1 or 2. What's probably happening is more and more WRs are focusing on Catching now that theyre maxed on speed and agility, and it's making it harder for CBs to swat the ball completely away.
I'm sure Strength, or the Swat Ball SA, or Jumping, or even Catching for the CBs would help with this. I definitely dont think it's a bug at all.
I agree with this. It seems similar to past seasons where:
- Ball deflected by the CB in front of the WR is caught fairly often by the WR.
- Ball deflected by the WR in front of the CB is intercepted a fair amount.
I just say this as in the past, there were games where I was in good position coverage wise but would give up some fairly long catches on deflections. Likewise, there were times when the WR was wide open, only to have the balls deflect to my guy a couple yards behind.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Koncorde
No I wouldn't call it a bug, just there's a big grey area around some of the changes and what knock on effects they've had.
Realistic passing stats, is the effect-- which must not be changed.
Bort indicated a willingness to consider eventually making CB's more effective at batting when in great coverage, in return for making it harder for CB's to be in such great coverage.
That's a tradeoff I'd be happy with, as tight man coverage is far too easy to play effectively.
Some realistic, others kinda gaudy.
Don't get me wrong - I support the changes wholeheartedly. I'm just now looking at the next level at what might or might not be out of kilter.
Originally posted by Koncorde
No I wouldn't call it a bug, just there's a big grey area around some of the changes and what knock on effects they've had.
Realistic passing stats, is the effect-- which must not be changed.
Bort indicated a willingness to consider eventually making CB's more effective at batting when in great coverage, in return for making it harder for CB's to be in such great coverage.
That's a tradeoff I'd be happy with, as tight man coverage is far too easy to play effectively.
Some realistic, others kinda gaudy.
Don't get me wrong - I support the changes wholeheartedly. I'm just now looking at the next level at what might or might not be out of kilter.
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.





























