This is in response to the "Nerf WR's back somewhat" thread. Personally, I don't think that's the problem so much as Bort nerfing the DBs too much (over correcting seems to be a problem in every walk of life). Now, against good WRs, it's like the DBs' only purpose is to make TKLs, as they get eaten alive by good WRs, even when the WRs are blanketted in double coverage. I just think Bort took the nerf too far and everything would be about right if he shot for around the 1/2 way point between where they were and where they are now. For teams with good WRs, it's almost foolish to even run.
Forum > Suggestions > Boost DBs back to 40-50% of what they were before the nerf
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by PP
This is in response to the "Nerf WR's back somewhat" thread. Personally, I don't think that's the problem so much as Bort nerfing the DBs too much (over correcting seems to be a problem in every walk of life). Now, against good WRs, it's like the DBs' only purpose is to make TKLs, as they get eaten alive by good WRs, even when the WRs are blanketted in double coverage. I just think Bort took the nerf too far and everything would be about right if he shot for around the 1/2 way point between where they were and where they are now. For teams with good WRs, it's almost foolish to even run.
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
This is in response to the "Nerf WR's back somewhat" thread. Personally, I don't think that's the problem so much as Bort nerfing the DBs too much (over correcting seems to be a problem in every walk of life). Now, against good WRs, it's like the DBs' only purpose is to make TKLs, as they get eaten alive by good WRs, even when the WRs are blanketted in double coverage. I just think Bort took the nerf too far and everything would be about right if he shot for around the 1/2 way point between where they were and where they are now. For teams with good WRs, it's almost foolish to even run.
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
SCACE
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by PP
This is in response to the "Nerf WR's back somewhat" thread. Personally, I don't think that's the problem so much as Bort nerfing the DBs too much (over correcting seems to be a problem in every walk of life). Now, against good WRs, it's like the DBs' only purpose is to make TKLs, as they get eaten alive by good WRs, even when the WRs are blanketted in double coverage. I just think Bort took the nerf too far and everything would be about right if he shot for around the 1/2 way point between where they were and where they are now. For teams with good WRs, it's almost foolish to even run.
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
exactly...in games where the teams are evenly matched, numbers are just about realistic now
Originally posted by PP
This is in response to the "Nerf WR's back somewhat" thread. Personally, I don't think that's the problem so much as Bort nerfing the DBs too much (over correcting seems to be a problem in every walk of life). Now, against good WRs, it's like the DBs' only purpose is to make TKLs, as they get eaten alive by good WRs, even when the WRs are blanketted in double coverage. I just think Bort took the nerf too far and everything would be about right if he shot for around the 1/2 way point between where they were and where they are now. For teams with good WRs, it's almost foolish to even run.
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
exactly...in games where the teams are evenly matched, numbers are just about realistic now
Magnitude
offline
offline
So...basically what you mean is
"OMG I'M GETTIN' MOSSED, COS I CANNOT MAKE A DECENT DB!"
"OMG I'M GETTIN' MOSSED, COS I CANNOT MAKE A DECENT DB!"
TCR
offline
offline
This debate is really starting to get funny....you can tell who has QB,s and WR,s along with who has CB's.On the serious side the nerfing went to far, all we hear about is how agents building CB's ignored base skills.Well guess what so did the agents building WR's and trust me I know cause I own both.My WR has no catching skills yet he eats CB's alive and this should not be so.The WR was built as a return specialist that we have put into a receivers role because the passing game is to simple to ignore.
Vagrant God
offline
offline
Holy numbers of players. Not even going to count them, took me minute to scroll down to a DB.
TreMetal
offline
offline
I think part of the problem is that the O-Line is too good during passing plays, but that is probably for another thread.
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by Magnitude
So...basically what you mean is
"OMG I'M GETTIN' MOSSED, COS I CANNOT MAKE A DECENT DB!"
Oh, great come back. Between my 7 DBs and the 4 other teams I work with (one I'm not a GM of), we have every conceivable CB build out there. We have speed guys, we have balanced, we have high catch and jump, ton in shutdown and swat ball, some with super vision that Superman would envy and so on, yet every time any of them come up against a good WR they get absolutely owned? You're right....Since they all are getting absolutely toasted since the nerf, none of the 20 or so agents is capable of making a decent DB. I think after you get out of grade school, you may want to look into becoming a rocket scientist or brain surgeon. I knew I'd get ripped for this post, and I'm OK with that, but at least be somewhat original in it instead of dragging out the same old tired shit that comes with every thread involving a suggestion for builds.
So...basically what you mean is
"OMG I'M GETTIN' MOSSED, COS I CANNOT MAKE A DECENT DB!"
Oh, great come back. Between my 7 DBs and the 4 other teams I work with (one I'm not a GM of), we have every conceivable CB build out there. We have speed guys, we have balanced, we have high catch and jump, ton in shutdown and swat ball, some with super vision that Superman would envy and so on, yet every time any of them come up against a good WR they get absolutely owned? You're right....Since they all are getting absolutely toasted since the nerf, none of the 20 or so agents is capable of making a decent DB. I think after you get out of grade school, you may want to look into becoming a rocket scientist or brain surgeon. I knew I'd get ripped for this post, and I'm OK with that, but at least be somewhat original in it instead of dragging out the same old tired shit that comes with every thread involving a suggestion for builds.
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by GO TEXANS
This debate is really starting to get funny....you can tell who has QB,s and WR,s along with who has CB's.On the serious side the nerfing went to far, all we hear about is how agents building CB's ignored base skills.Well guess what so did the agents building WR's and trust me I know cause I own both.My WR has no catching skills yet he eats CB's alive and this should not be so.The WR was built as a return specialist that we have put into a receivers role because the passing game is to simple to ignore.
I've got them all. Because of that, I have a very impartial view of this. I have no desire for WRs, HBs, QBs, OLmen, TEs, DLmen, LBs or DBs to suck. I'd just like to see it balanced. I have no doubt that anyone arguing that the WR/DB battle hasn't gone too one sided has yet to play a team with good WRs that know how to use them. Talk all you want about the feared "power backs," but any team with good WRs is a fool right now to pass anything less than 90%.
This debate is really starting to get funny....you can tell who has QB,s and WR,s along with who has CB's.On the serious side the nerfing went to far, all we hear about is how agents building CB's ignored base skills.Well guess what so did the agents building WR's and trust me I know cause I own both.My WR has no catching skills yet he eats CB's alive and this should not be so.The WR was built as a return specialist that we have put into a receivers role because the passing game is to simple to ignore.
I've got them all. Because of that, I have a very impartial view of this. I have no desire for WRs, HBs, QBs, OLmen, TEs, DLmen, LBs or DBs to suck. I'd just like to see it balanced. I have no doubt that anyone arguing that the WR/DB battle hasn't gone too one sided has yet to play a team with good WRs that know how to use them. Talk all you want about the feared "power backs," but any team with good WRs is a fool right now to pass anything less than 90%.
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 14:01:47
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
I could post play after play after play of WRs either drapped by a CB or blanketted in double coverage. A handful of plays like that mean nothing, but, when the good WRs are winning 80-90% of those, I'm sorry, that's not a "realistic level" even on Mars.
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
I could post play after play after play of WRs either drapped by a CB or blanketted in double coverage. A handful of plays like that mean nothing, but, when the good WRs are winning 80-90% of those, I'm sorry, that's not a "realistic level" even on Mars.
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by TreMetal
I think part of the problem is that the O-Line is too good during passing plays, but that is probably for another thread.
I don't think there is a significant overall problem, but on the other hand I agree that pass protection seems a little too good overall.
As to what PP is saying, that's why I like to pull out real life stats, as those need to be the guide for ideal outcomes.
I think he sees...
Originally posted by PP
we have every conceivable CB build out there. We have speed guys, we have balanced, we have high catch and jump, ton in shutdown and swat ball, some with super vision that Superman would envy and so on, yet every time any of them come up against a good WR they get absolutely owned?
..."absolutely owned" through the lens of "actually gives up some completions," because that was what it used to be like: A really good CB could effectively take a very good receiver away for a game. Now the DB's are human too, and it feels like they're "absolutely owned" even when a realistic 40% of passes aren't complete.
I'd agree with turning up the pass rush a bit (but improving QB Vision when not being rushed, if so), and I agreed with someone else that ideally it would be easier to get open in tight man to man coverage and if so then when the receiver didn't get open-- especially double covered-- the coverage would be more effective.
That would help balance man coverage with zone.
But the overall balance is realistic, and it mostly drives people crazy because they got used to an unrealistic level of DB dominance.
And if you disagree with what's realistic in terms of outcomes, you'll force me to get my stats back out....
I think part of the problem is that the O-Line is too good during passing plays, but that is probably for another thread.
I don't think there is a significant overall problem, but on the other hand I agree that pass protection seems a little too good overall.
As to what PP is saying, that's why I like to pull out real life stats, as those need to be the guide for ideal outcomes.
I think he sees...
Originally posted by PP
we have every conceivable CB build out there. We have speed guys, we have balanced, we have high catch and jump, ton in shutdown and swat ball, some with super vision that Superman would envy and so on, yet every time any of them come up against a good WR they get absolutely owned?
..."absolutely owned" through the lens of "actually gives up some completions," because that was what it used to be like: A really good CB could effectively take a very good receiver away for a game. Now the DB's are human too, and it feels like they're "absolutely owned" even when a realistic 40% of passes aren't complete.
I'd agree with turning up the pass rush a bit (but improving QB Vision when not being rushed, if so), and I agreed with someone else that ideally it would be easier to get open in tight man to man coverage and if so then when the receiver didn't get open-- especially double covered-- the coverage would be more effective.
That would help balance man coverage with zone.
But the overall balance is realistic, and it mostly drives people crazy because they got used to an unrealistic level of DB dominance.
And if you disagree with what's realistic in terms of outcomes, you'll force me to get my stats back out....
Ken1
offline
offline
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Ken1
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
I could post play after play after play of WRs either drapped by a CB or blanketted in double coverage. A handful of plays like that mean nothing, but, when the good WRs are winning 80-90% of those, I'm sorry, that's not a "realistic level" even on Mars.
They aren't winning 80-90% of those, as QB's are completing no more than 60%.
Originally posted by Ken1
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
I could post play after play after play of WRs either drapped by a CB or blanketted in double coverage. A handful of plays like that mean nothing, but, when the good WRs are winning 80-90% of those, I'm sorry, that's not a "realistic level" even on Mars.
They aren't winning 80-90% of those, as QB's are completing no more than 60%.
Koncorde
offline
offline
Some QB complete more, but that's just rewards for the fact they've been shafted for 2 years by a game engine not representing their WR skills.
CB's are not there to shut teams down, they're damage limitation. Last year the issue was that 1CB on every team was a lockdown receiver, and the other 2CB's (depending on how good they were) would rack up endless interceptions and/or tackles.
Not CB1 can get beat sometimes, and CB2 can get beat sometimes, and the QB can actually find his man with a pass sometimes.
CB's are not there to shut teams down, they're damage limitation. Last year the issue was that 1CB on every team was a lockdown receiver, and the other 2CB's (depending on how good they were) would rack up endless interceptions and/or tackles.
Not CB1 can get beat sometimes, and CB2 can get beat sometimes, and the QB can actually find his man with a pass sometimes.
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
..."absolutely owned" through the lens of "actually gives up some completions," because that was what it used to be like: A really good CB could effectively take a very good receiver away for a game. Now the DB's are human too, and it feels like they're "absolutely owned" even when a realistic 40% of passes aren't complete.
No, That's not what I mean at all. I agree 100% that it was too much before, and that caused the speed craze with WRs. The only way they could consistently catch balls was to be 5 yards out fron of the DBs before (exaggeration, but not that much of one). I just see this situation as being the same in reverse. I'd like to see it somewhere near the middle. The last thing I'd like to see is the WRs get nerfed. I agree that they're finally about right.
As far as stats goes, I don't think that applies to GLB at all. In pro ball, everyone is good. In GLB, some lvl 27s are good, some are great and some are horrible (more fall in this group than any other, IMO). Because of that, the stats aren't nearly as true of a representation than watching a good DB go against a good or great WR. That's when you see how well the builds are or aren't balanced, IMO.
..."absolutely owned" through the lens of "actually gives up some completions," because that was what it used to be like: A really good CB could effectively take a very good receiver away for a game. Now the DB's are human too, and it feels like they're "absolutely owned" even when a realistic 40% of passes aren't complete.
No, That's not what I mean at all. I agree 100% that it was too much before, and that caused the speed craze with WRs. The only way they could consistently catch balls was to be 5 yards out fron of the DBs before (exaggeration, but not that much of one). I just see this situation as being the same in reverse. I'd like to see it somewhere near the middle. The last thing I'd like to see is the WRs get nerfed. I agree that they're finally about right.
As far as stats goes, I don't think that applies to GLB at all. In pro ball, everyone is good. In GLB, some lvl 27s are good, some are great and some are horrible (more fall in this group than any other, IMO). Because of that, the stats aren't nearly as true of a representation than watching a good DB go against a good or great WR. That's when you see how well the builds are or aren't balanced, IMO.
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 14:23:02
PP
offline
offline
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Ken1
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
I could post play after play after play of WRs either drapped by a CB or blanketted in double coverage. A handful of plays like that mean nothing, but, when the good WRs are winning 80-90% of those, I'm sorry, that's not a "realistic level" even on Mars.
They aren't winning 80-90% of those, as QB's are completing no more than 60%.
I'm talking good or great WRs, not decent, marginal or poor ones AND when the pass appears to be decent. Some passes still appear to be extremely off the mark...subtract those and I believe that good WRs are winning the battle on 80-90% of seemingly catchable balls, even when drapped in double coverage. There are a shit ton of bad WRs out there, just like bad QBs, HBs, CBs, and every other position. That makes the stats balance out. Now, you certainly could argue whether good (not even great, just good) players need to absolutely dominate to bring the stats of the poorly built players up, but that's another debate.
Originally posted by PP
Originally posted by Ken1
No it wouldn't, as the passing offense would not be at the realistic level it finally is.
I could post play after play after play of WRs either drapped by a CB or blanketted in double coverage. A handful of plays like that mean nothing, but, when the good WRs are winning 80-90% of those, I'm sorry, that's not a "realistic level" even on Mars.
They aren't winning 80-90% of those, as QB's are completing no more than 60%.
I'm talking good or great WRs, not decent, marginal or poor ones AND when the pass appears to be decent. Some passes still appear to be extremely off the mark...subtract those and I believe that good WRs are winning the battle on 80-90% of seemingly catchable balls, even when drapped in double coverage. There are a shit ton of bad WRs out there, just like bad QBs, HBs, CBs, and every other position. That makes the stats balance out. Now, you certainly could argue whether good (not even great, just good) players need to absolutely dominate to bring the stats of the poorly built players up, but that's another debate.
Last edited Aug 12, 2008 14:30:35
You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.






























