User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > USA AAA Leagues > USA AAA #2 > WEEK 4 POWER RANKINGS
Page:
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Pre-game rankings from day 8:

EAST: TEAM RATING
1 New Jersey Generals 93.9
2 Cincinnati Who Dey 93.6
3 Dallas Vaqueros 93.0
4 Green Bay Maulers 92.2
5 Richmond Razorbacks 91.8
6 ***Official*** Footballguys 90.3
7 Cincinnati Shockers 89.9
8 Extreme Pipe Layers 89.7
9 Las Vegas Aces (Rename) 88.4
10 Illinois Enforcers 88.4
11 Capital Punishment 84.9
12 Pocatello Punishers 83.6
13 Buffalo Bearcats 82.0
14 Chilton Roughnecks 75.7
15 Barstow Worker Bees 43.2
16 Brooklyn Legacy 14.1

WEST: TEAM RATING
1 Tucson Turtles 97.1
2 Anchorage Penguins 92.1
3 San Francisco Fire (Rename) 91.8
4 Jacksonville Barracudas 91.6
5 Richmond Rebel Yell 90.9
6 Cincinnati Owls 90.7
7 Omaha Dragons 90.0
8 San Francisco Montanas 88.7
9 Texas Twisters 87.8
10 Fairfax Fireskins 86.4
11 Metropolis Men of Steel 83.8
12 Hawaii Five-0s (Rename) 83.4
13 Grand Junction Silverbacks 80.1
14 Dallas Destroyers (Rename) 75.3
15 Springfield Atoms 67.2
16 New York Murderers' Row 67.1
Last edited Aug 9, 2008 04:46:54
 
mavsman
offline
Link
 
What is this bias! We dropped from one to five???? Racism is back.
 
Mornacale
offline
Link
 
Well, hey, all we did was win 56-6. Giving up that bullshit last-second TD due to our defense playing on relaxed did double our points against for the year.

I'm worried about those #2 Jacksonville Barracudas, though. They look real tough.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
No bias its all numbers based. Of course the numbers may hate the Rebel Yell, everyone else does.
 
Reggie Smash
offline
Link
 
I hope this week's power rankings thread is as fun as last week's. It's off to a great start!
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
As I've said before, I'm keeping detailed records of how teams have performed relative to what the rankings indicated, in all four leagues where I'm doing ratings this year. Right now I haven't gotten data from week 1 or 2 of either AAA league into the spreadsheet, and I didn't calculate ratings at all for week one of USA Pro. Here's how data looks for the 112 games I do have in my spreadsheet so far though (all 3 weeks of Canada Pro, weeks 2 and 3 of USA Pro, and week 3 only for Canada AAA#2 and USA AAA#2):

In 112 games, the favorite has covered the spread 50 times (44.6%) and won outright 81 times (72.3%). The correlation coefficient between adjusted rating differential and result is 0.906 (the correlation between raw roster rating differential and result is only 0.892, so the adjustments ARE increasing the accuracy of the rankings, though not by a huge margin). The correlation between other key rating differentials and results are:
Offense: 0.840 (WR = 0.752, TE = 0.677, OT = 0.655, HB = 0.628, FB = 0.618, G = 0.591, C = 0.555, QB = 0.477)
Defense: 0.873 (CB = 0.723, LB = 0.709, DE = 0.686, DT = 0.681, FS = 0.680, SS = 0.556)
Sp. Teams: 0.687 (K = 0.614, P = 0.418)
Chemistry: 0.477

As for favorites only covering the spread 44.6% of the time, it appears to be primarily due to blowout games, where the linear formula I use to predict the spread breaks down in the face of the blowout prevention adjustments Bort made this year. There were 7 games in the sample with a spread of 100+, and if you exclude those (where the favorite only covered once), then in the other 105 games the favorite covered 49 times (46.7%), and won outright 74 times (70.5%). There were an additional 9 games with spreads between 60 and 99, where the favorite only covered 3 times, and excluding those as well leaves us with a 96 game sample in which the favorite covered 46 times (47.9%) while winning outright 65 times (67.7%). There were another 12 games where the spread was in the 30-59 range, in which the favorite only covered thrice, so in the 84 games where the spread was less than 30 points the faves actually covered 43 times (51.2%), though they only won 54 (64.3%) of those games.

It's also worth noting that the correlation between rating difference and result is somewhat inflated by those games with huge spreads. As the spread drops, so does the correlation; and in the process the difference between the adjusted and non-adjusted ratings also grows. As I said, in the entire 112 game sample, the correlation between rating difference and result is 0.892 unadjusted or 0.906 adjusted. In the 105 games with spreads <100, the correlation is only 0.809 unadjusted or 0.839 adjusted. In the 96 games with spreads <96, the correlation drops to 0.638 unadjusted or 0.695 adjusted. In the 84 games with spreads <30, the correlation is 0.454 unadjusted or 0.562 adjusted.

This basically just tells us what was already obvious, which is that while these rankings do have some predictive merit they aren't telling the entire story, and they particularly don't do too well at distinguishing between teams of relatively similar talent levels. The adjustments, however, even after just a couple of weeks, do seem to be significantly increasing the accuracy of the ratings at predicting games involving teams ranked within ~10 points of each other, so there is reason to expect that after another several weeks worth of adjustments these rankings will begin to become much more accurate. The system does appear to be working, albeit slowly.
 
Yeremiah
offline
Link
 
You can explain all you want BJJ, some ppl will still bitch. The rest of us appreciate the effort though.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yeremiah
You can explain all you want BJJ, some ppl will still bitch. The rest of us appreciate the effort though.


Oh I've figured that out already. The explanations are meant to be additional information for the people that do appreciate it. I've given up on trying to convince the doubters
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Rankings updated for game day.
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
One other interesting stat regarding the results so far. In 112 games, the median rating difference is 5. In exactly half the games, one team has been rated 5 or more points higher than their opponent, which translates to a 14+ point spread. The favorite has won 51 of those 56 games, or 91%. In the other half of games, where the spread was less than 14, the favorite is 30-26 (54%). Basically, teams that are rated within 5 points of each other (such as the #1 and #8 teams in the East, where anyone could take home the title) are within the margin of error where levels are too close to decide things, and it comes down to builds and tactics. Outside that range, the favorite generally has the underdog outleveled by too much for builds, tactics, or even luck to matter (except in very rare cases).
 
Zach Morris
offline
Link
 
How many spots will the Rebel Yell move up if we get your dick sucked?

How many more sports if we get your dick sucked by A.C. Slater
 
BobJoeJim
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zach Morris
How many spots will the Rebel Yell move up if we get your dick sucked?

How many more sports if we get your dick sucked by A.C. Slater


Zero, and negative eleven, respectively.

On the other hand, if you beat the San Francisco Fire by 22 or more today (as 2.5 point underdogs) you'll earn a 1.2+ point adjustment that, if rosters were to stay the same, would move you from 5th to 2nd.
 
awculero
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Zach Morris
How many spots will the Rebel Yell move up if we get your dick sucked?

How many more sports if we get your dick sucked by A.C. Slater


A queer bullfighter linebacker - who knew?
 
joemiken
offline
Link
 
Thanks for the rankings. The Razorbacks being ranked over us is a bit puzzling since we blanked them 30-0 a couple of games ago.

I'm afraid to see what'll happen if we somehow beat Jersey. lol
 
Warpriest
offline
Link
 
I have one question about the rankings you haven't explained yet. What's with the (Rename) after certain teams?
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.