User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Stamina/Energy is just random this season
SCACE
offline
Link
 
I have some players with no stamina who have no issues staying above 70 after a game.

And I have others that that despite putting all my equipment on stamina are losing 35-36 from a game on normal intensity, even when playing 40 or less plays per game.

I understand that playing 40+ plays on hard should be impossible to do without enough points in stamina. But even playing on normal is just variable.

HB...playing on normal....37 plays (17 rushes)...36 lost stamina....23.62 in stamina

DE...playing on hard.....47 plays (2 tackles, 1 hurry)...33 lost stamina....26.21 in stamina

This type of thing really didn't happen at all to any of my players last season, so the changes are having a pretty big effect. I'm not against them, it seems more realistic to need to put points into stamina. What I don't get is how variable energy can be from game to game and player to player, seemingly regardless of what you do to try and avoid energy drain.

Bort - maybe we can get a bit more clarification on what the biggest drains on energy are (we know special teams is a killer for whatever reason, still not fixed, but what else is).

And someone who has the time, knowledge and experience -- maybe an updated chart on a stamina range for each position at different levels.
 
RIP Al Davis
offline
Link
 
I put the settings for 79/86 at a position and the starter got 30 plays and the backup got 60 plays. They both ended with 80 energy and if you think about it for a long time I suppose it might be working as intended, but IMO a backup should NEVER get more snaps than the starter whether he has 100 energy 100 stamina and plays on relaxed or has 50 energy 10 stamina and plays on hard. Perhaps my opinion is ill conceived and I'm just sad we lost?
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 18:45:42
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
For SCACE's point - I can't say because only Bort has the formulas.. but from what I've seen - things look fine. Admittedly I only have access to the energy of one team + 2 Players... which is a pretty limited view.

Originally posted by Kira
I put the settings for 79/86 at a position and the starter got 30 plays and the backup got 60 plays. They both ended with 80 energy and if you think about it for a long time I suppose it might be working as intended, but IMO a backup should NEVER get more snaps than the starter whether he has 100 energy 100 stamina and plays on relaxed or has 50 energy 10 stamina and plays on hard. Perhaps my opinion is ill conceived and I'm just sad we lost?


I believe that the way the sim works is that it checks a player for breath vs energy settings; if the Player fails - then it goes to the next player.. unless there isn't another player then it just plays this one. That's why it isn't hard to get backups that play more than the starter if the starter has very low stamina and keeps having to sub out... I could be wrong in how it works though... I keep planning on testing this - but because of the lack of "throwaway games" available to a team, it's hard to test things like this.

As for whether Backups should EVER get more plays in a game than a Starter - I 100% disagree with you, when you state it as an absolute like this. One day injuries will be added to the sim, and if injuries don't lead to atleast some subbing - then there really isn't any point in adding them to the game, now is there? If for no other reason - injuries should lead to a situation where a backup plays more than a starter. Beyond injuries though - I would say that in general, Starters should get more plays. Of course backups often play STs or backup multiple positions - so it gets more complex than just comparing one starter to one backup.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Xiong -- the thing that got me with my HB is that I added +8 to his stamina bar before the last game and played less than the game before (less plays + less rushing yardage + less carries) and I ended up losing either the same or more energy than the previous game.

Increasing stamina + decreasing workload should not give me the same energy loss...can't say that is working as intended. I could go through my list of players and find some guys that are having stamina issues and others that have none, despite similar stamina settings, level, # of plays and play intensity.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
not to mention one of my guys didn't get energy back from training two nights ago, and with no response from support I'll go into a game at 91 instead of 100
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.