User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > I understand bringing sacks down, just not against poor opponents.
CRich
offline
Link
 
Well, here is the problem. The past few seasons there have been some DEs that have been crazy good and ended the season with 25-35 sacks. Of course this isn't realistic. The problem is that the majority of the sacks are against poor opponents. The opposing team either didn't build correctly or they didn't bring in higher level talent to fight off the beasts.

Now that Bort has tweaked the DEs, it made it where DEs are almost non-existent. We are being for having stud players and recruiting our butts off with poor games. Of course if a OT is well built and close to the level of a DE, he should hold him off, it makes sense. If a team just didn't care to recruit properly or the players are garbage builds, then let them be dominated.

 
tarlyn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by CRich
Well, here is the problem. The past few seasons there have been some DEs that have been crazy good and ended the season with 25-35 sacks. Of course this isn't realistic. The problem is that the majority of the sacks are against poor opponents. The opposing team either didn't build correctly or they didn't bring in higher level talent to fight off the beasts.

Now that Bort has tweaked the DEs, it made it where DEs are almost non-existent. We are being for having stud players and recruiting our butts off with poor games. Of course if a OT is well built and close to the level of a DE, he should hold him off, it makes sense. If a team just didn't care to recruit properly or the players are garbage builds, then let them be dominated.



Amazing how the excuse for a QB throwing 13 picks in one game was because there are so many games each day that you are bound to have something like that happen here and there.....if thats ok then why is it not ok to have a couple freak DE's getting 25 sacks a season.....that means the "good" de's will get an 10-12 sacks which is more the norm.....right now it looks like they want the freak DE's to get 10-12 sacks which means the good DE's will get 2-5?

RB's are running for 400 yards a game and QB's are passing for 600 yards a game so why are the DE's being picked on?
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
This is a great thread to state this in: Cry More.

Seriously.. whether DE's are getting 5 or 50, as long as the same formulas are used for ALL DE's, then it doesn't affect game balance at all. The only thing that changed was removing the 0. Assuming that everything you guys state is FACT... and even assuming that the implication is correct (that offenses are now better than defenses), this STILL doesn't affect game balance.

Season 3 was balanced, just a lot of people felt that the games were decided by Defense + Kicker.. That didn't mean that the teams were given any unfair advantage - all teams faced the same recruiting/playing choices... Same with this season.. but now the pendulum is swinging the other direction with Offenses being stronger. Part of this swing comes from the changes in the effectiveness of different skills (tackling was worthless last season, now it is important - hence runningbacks getting 400 yards per game).. Part of the swing comes from underlying game mechanics being tweaked - including your precious ability to sack every 3 downs.

Game balance between teams is unchanged - some positions aren't the key positions this season, that they were last season.

EDIT - the ironic thing here is: the comparison between QB/WR and DEs... QB/WR's cost 300 FP and DEs cost 200 FPs ... SPECIFICALLY because QBs and WRs are supposed to be the playmakers.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 18:38:52
 
CRich
offline
Link
 
Why, the highest total in my conference is 6 sacks and hurries are not much better. Pass rush is the key to defensive football, and the game is not allowing it to be realistic.

Ok, so lets go with your idea, keep the well built high level DEs (26+) not be able to get pressure on the QB b/c he might get to much pressure. Lets reward the teams that didn't try to improve their team, that makes sense. A guy has a level 19 OT against a well built level 26 DE, and he stops him 98% of the game, not realistic.
 
tarlyn
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Xiong Yoshi
This is a great thread to state this in: Cry More.

Seriously.. whether DE's are getting 5 or 50, as long as the same formulas are used for ALL DE's, then it doesn't affect game balance at all. The only thing that changed was removing the 0. Assuming that everything you guys state is FACT... and even assuming that the implication is correct (that offenses are now better than defenses), this STILL doesn't affect game balance.

Season 3 was balanced, just a lot of people felt that the games were decided by Defense + Kicker.. That didn't mean that the teams were given any unfair advantage - all teams faced the same recruiting/playing choices... Same with this season.. but now the pendulum is swinging the other direction with Offenses being stronger. Part of this swing comes from the changes in the effectiveness of different skills (tackling was worthless last season, now it is important - hence runningbacks getting 400 yards per game).. Part of the swing comes from underlying game mechanics being tweaked - including your precious ability to sack every 3 downs.

Game balance between teams is unchanged - some positions aren't the key positions this season, that they were last season.

EDIT - the ironic thing here is: the comparison between QB/WR and DEs... QB/WR's cost 300 FP and DEs cost 200 FPs ... SPECIFICALLY because QBs and WRs are supposed to be the playmakers.


Of course everyone is on the same playing field......if QB's are were physically unable to throw a pass I guess that would be fine too since everyone would have the same problem....lets try that.

Just because everyone has to deal with it equally doesnt mean its right.

DE's are the playmakers on defense....whats your point...you spend more flex so you should get more stats to make you justify the extra flex...what kind of arguement is that.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 23:01:38
 
AUS
offline
Link
 
Yeah my level 22 DE is being manhandled by lower level players with inferior stats and it's rather sad how he won tons of tropies last season to now running weakly straigt into blockers that he can easily out quick and speed.
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
That's odd... my team's top DE piled up three sacks today against an equally-levelled opponent. Our first sacks of the season, too...
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
your league is a very small sample size...look around at other leagues and you'll see some guys with ridiculous sack numbers.
 
Amyrlin
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by SCACE
your league is a very small sample size...look around at other leagues and you'll see some guys with ridiculous sack numbers.


I know that, I was talking about today's post-tweak games. I found it odd that DEs on my team had no sacks on the season (having played one game against a much weaker opponent), there's a tweak that supposedly makes DEs less effective, and suddenly we have 4 sacks (a very realistic number) in a game against an evenly-matched opponent.

In other words I'm saying that from early results, the tweak seems good :-)
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
wasn't directed at you hehe

was directed at OP and his 6 sack league
 
manx
offline
Link
 
league leader with 6 sacks after 4 games? thats 24 sacks at end of season... still a crapton of sacks.
 
Superman6464
offline
Link
 
Just because some of you or other in your league have got sacks, doesn't mean it's resolved. There where some that got sacks before the new pass rushing tactic was added or Bort even begin working on it. So until Bort says he is done adjusting it and it's implemented in all leagues then it's still a work in progress.
 
RMiller517
offline
Link
 
Thread locked by moderator.
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.