User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Season 4 changes ARE going to cost this game alot of dedicated players.
Page:
 
jebby69
offline
Link
 
I get so frustrated every time a new game sims this season because it is just another installment of a disaster. I am the GM of a team and we had built a successful team based on the "OLD" rules of the game. We had built players that were successful in the specific aspect of the game they were asked to perform.

This season our offense is completely broken. We cant pass to save our ass and can for some reason the AI wont run the rock even when we ask it to. We have gone as far as 80/20 rushing and still had just as many passes as runs. This is for a team that last season was one of the top 5 in passing yards and had the leading rusher in the league.

I am all for making the game better, but how can you (Bort) make such drastic changes midway into something that completely breaks everything. I know everyone is going to bitch about us having bad builds, but they werent according to the rules we used to have to follow and I would argue that they still aren't. Now the rules change and we are all in the mid 20's level wise and there just isn't any way to try to react, we level about every 5 games and obviously we need a bunch of some magic skill to make us better. Changes seem to be made on the hour to try to compensate, but it just feels like we are trying to adjust to a moving target which is no good since once skill points are allocated there is no getting them back. While all of these changes are going on would there be something wrong with allowing people to reallocate their skills say once a season??

I know I am not alone in this frustration because I have spoken to several other successful owners whose teams have been brought to their knees this season. The problem is the majority of the players out there that do all the talking are the ones who were saved by these changes and all of the people who were screwed are scrambling to try to find a quick solution to be competitive again.

At times it feels like the developers of this game want everyone to have "cookie cutter" type builds where everyone is pretty much the same because they are forcing so many skills be at high levels to be even adequate at particuar aspects of the game. What is the fun if everyone is built the same?
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 13:43:47
 
Rezlov
offline
Link
 
I can't say I agree cookie cutter is the idea at all.

No matter what, players are going to be only so effective with certain attributes. A super fast WR wouldn't be anything without great hands or great agility. A great QB would be Ryan Leaf if it wasn't for confidence or vision. The point is, regardless of how "cookie cutter" people want to think it is, it's straight fact. Whether the game is based on the NFL or not, you have to have certain skill sets no matter what.

I can't say I like the changes mid season but it's that or sit out an entire season OR play a whole season littered with bugs.
 
sjmay
offline
Link
 
Yea,

I read this, and my one continual thought was, how can you convince yourself that all you need is speed to be succesful in ANY position?

How do you build a player to do ONE thing, when you know for a fact in the real game, you need to be good at SEVERAL things,

So yea, don't really buy this argument all too well, especially considering we started approximately at the same time. And the 3 teams I GM, and the one I own are doing ok all things considered.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.

If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.

Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.
 
snowman
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jebby69
What is the fun if everyone is built the same?
I find this line funny as you just described how your team must be built if you are struggling this season.

 
Bigdawg_56
offline
Link
 
My team was full of balanced builds last year and didn't believe in the speed kills theory. We went 13-3. This year were 3-0 so far. Following your logic, we had "bad builds" last season since we didn't go all speed. We also don't have cookie cutter builds. Players can be built for their position. A RDE is needs to be built for pass rushing, LDE for run stopping, You can have a pass catching TE and a blocking TE.
 
GwennA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by jebby69
I get so frustrated every time a new game sims this season because it is just another installment of a disaster. I am the GM of a team and we had built a successful team based on the "OLD" rules of the game. We had built players that were successful in the specific aspect of the game they were asked to perform.

This season our offense is completely broken. We cant pass to save our ass and can for some reason the AI wont run the rock even when we ask it to. We have gone as far as 80/20 rushing and still had just as many passes as runs. This is for a team that last season was one of the top 5 in passing yards and had the leading rusher in the league.

I am all for making the game better, but how can you (Bort) make such drastic changes midway into something that completely breaks everything. I know everyone is going to bitch about us having bad builds, but they werent according to the rules we used to have to follow and I would argue that they still aren't. Now the rules change and we are all in the mid 20's level wise and there just isn't any way to try to react, we level about every 5 games and obviously we need a bunch of some magic skill to make us better. Changes seem to be made on the hour to try to compensate, but it just feels like we are trying to adjust to a moving target which is no good since once skill points are allocated there is no getting them back. While all of these changes are going on would there be something wrong with allowing people to reallocate their skills say once a season??

I know I am not alone in this frustration because I have spoken to several other successful owners whose teams have been brought to their knees this season. The problem is the majority of the players out there that do all the talking are the ones who were saved by these changes and all of the people who were screwed are scrambling to try to find a quick solution to be competitive again.

At times it feels like the developers of this game want everyone to have "cookie cutter" type builds where everyone is pretty much the same because they are forcing so many skills be at high levels to be even adequate at particuar aspects of the game. What is the fun if everyone is built the same?


I'd argue that the people who were all built the same were mostly the ones who followed the same cookie cutter recipe to easy success.
Everyone had the same amount of warning about the most drastic changes that were coming. Everyone had the same chance to use last season to build for them.

Those who didn't, their reward was getting to dominate last season over the teams who built players with a variety of skills.

Not everyone with success has the same builds. Some actual strategies are actually working now, and a lot more players are looking like real football players with some variance in their skillsets - not like the whole team are track stars, aside from the o-line who needed nothing but to be immovable walls.
 
GwennA
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.

If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.

Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.


Thanks, Bort. A lot of us, at least, applaud the move to greater realism in the game.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
First, this isn't close to a bug report, so it's in the wrong forum.

But secondly, these changes will gain GLB players in the long run because realism is so important to keeping players happy.

If Bort hadn't promised in Season 3 that this was the direction he planned to move, I wouldn't have bought any more FP's.

Now, people who build realistic football players are the ones rewarded. Now, we don't have extreme defensive games when two evenly matched teams meet. And yes, now those who built players who should be running track instead of playing football got hurt. But in the long run, for the good of the game, it had to be done.

This is not cookie cutter builds; it's realistic tradeoffs. Make the guy faster to defend passes and catch up to runners, or give him more tackling to make the tackle if he can reach the guy? That sort-- the realistic differences between players.

Season 3 led to cookie cutter builds: Put it all into Speed was the cookie cutter. Now it's multifaceted and we have a much richer game.
 
markhehe
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.

If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.

Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.


i like the updates and the way the game is playing. i dont know if its builds or strategy problems, but unless the game treats everyone different, i dont see the problem. passing is a little less effective, but not to a degree that it bothers me.
 
glaity
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.

If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.

Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.


you mean can't fix broken things and not change things at the same time, I for one am appalled --- Must be taking too much time for sleeping and eating and such...

I personally would rather the game go forward and deal with changes as they come (the grown up way of doing things) - minus my little hissy yesterday regarding energy/stamina - but HE is but 1 man with a dream / a little bit of code and a server to put it on ...




 
Robbnva
offline
Link
 
the people with bad builds need to retire and start over again and this time follow the guidlines set and not try and break the system. those are the guys who are screwed.

all of my players are performing as they were last season, only one i didn't know was my kicker but he was 2/2 in 40+ FGs. this was his 1st game kicking FGs because my team owner had it set for go for it on 4th down every time.

 
Rychyrd
offline
Link
 
Its not like the changes come out of the Blue...If you do your homework and listen to what is being said by those in the know I.E. Bort, then the problems some are having would have never happened.

On " Cookie Cutters "
Why is it that everyone claims that having to have multiple Attributes to have a successful players is a cookie cutter build when those type builds will have far more variants than a All Speed and a few crumbs else where build.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Same argument seen over and over - I'm damned if I do and I'm damned if I don't.

If I make no updates everyone complains about how this is broken or that is broken.
If I fix the broken stuff everyone complains about how things are changing on them.

Sorry, but I'm not going to let the game go forward with a broken sim just because some users don't want any changes. It's the core of the game, and it has to improve or it will cost us a lot more dedicated players.


Bort, thank you!

When I was upset in Season 3 about lack of realism, you let me know that your intent was to bring realism to the game. You've lived up to your word.

It's still imperfect, of course; but it's much closer to what's right and now seems like a game I'll want to play for many real life years.

I still think you could use some help so you could get more done, but this season's version is so much better than what preceded it, I'm extremely grateful and happy.
Last edited Aug 7, 2008 13:54:21
 
Xiong Yoshi
offline
Link
 
You have two issues:

1) Your players aren't as good as they were before because the sim is using different balances for which attributes/skills are important. Too bad, tbh - this is a relatively new BETA game and the time for making these sorts of changes is right now. If you aren't interested in the rollercoaster ride that early Beta Testing represents, then you should probably hit the door right now.

2) You are unable to use the Advanced Tactics in an effective way. Bort has already mentioned an idea to "fix" this issue, though I doubt all that many people saw his post. Bort is a computer programmer and the Tactics are laid out much in the same manner that a computer program is developed. While it makes complete sense to me, it's kinda like derivatives and even basic Algebra: some people get it, some people don't - it's just the way our brains are wired. The idea that Bort has mentioned was for him to design a number of Playbooks which are already available for GMs to use. I can't really see this happening until the OC is developed more.. but down the line, this should help people who know what style of playing they want - but can't translate that into the Advanced Tactics.
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.