User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Forum > Discuss GLB Issues With Catch22 > NOT A BUG - CLOSED > Running Game out of whack with 'reality'
Page:
 
Enkidu98
offline
Link
 
I am of the opinion that the changes to the Offensive sim are really hurting the game as a whole. Right now Running Game is completely out of whack with reality.

Lets look at the NFL:

http://www.nfl.com/stats/categorystats?tabSeq=0&statisticCategory=RUSHING&season=2007&seasonType=REG

Looking at who had the best Yards Per Game, and then the average yards per carry we see a completely different story than what we're seeing in GLB.

Africa Pro: http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?league_id=83&conference_id=0&stat=rushing&sort=rushing_yards/carries&playoffs=0

USA Pro: http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?league_id=1&conference_id=0&stat=rushing&sort=rushing_yards/carries&playoffs=0

Canada pro: http://goallineblitz.com/game/stats.pl?league_id=5&conference_id=0&stat=rushing&sort=rushing_yards/games&playoffs=0

This is really not fun/unrealistic. Essentially you are taking the game and making it so one position has a hugely disproportionate amount of influence on the outcome of the game. That diminishes the play experience for the players at all the other positions and makes for sims that are a little crazy.

One of my teams set for preferring the 'Pass' and we ended up with only 4 passing TD's to 13 Rushing TD's.

Most NFL teams would be happy to get a back who could average 5 yards per carry. The GLB leagues are rife with backs averaging over 10 yards per carry.

Something is wrong.
Last edited Aug 5, 2008 19:32:29
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
I generally don't like comparing this game to "reality," but the point that hits home is the huge imbalance we're seeing between the running game and the passing game.
 
cosmoxl
offline
Link
 
when teams are equal the stats range from realistic to much less than expected.

don't look at stats after only 2 games. some teams have played 2 very weak opponents so far, so stats are inflated.
 
timpjynx
offline
Link
 
personally, i'm begging for more "reality" like sims
 
TCR
offline
Link
 
Since our conception the running game has been our bread and butter.Teams don't run on us either since we have had the league leading defense since we started.Of course we have not neglected basic skills like so many others have.Now people are crying foul and I cannot understand why.Quick build players are now paying a penality for taking shortcuts.In two games so far our defense has only given up 1.5 yards total rushing and only 8 missed tackles over the course of two games.
 
Koncorde
offline
Link
 
And comparing NFL to GLB is a bit inaccurate.

I made the point on the radio show last week that GLB is probably closer to representing flag football, college or even Canadian Football at the moment. The majority of players are not of a "professional" level.
 
Adderfist
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by GO TEXANS
Since our conception the running game has been our bread and butter.Teams don't run on us either since we have had the league leading defense since we started.Of course we have not neglected basic skills like so many others have.Now people are crying foul and I cannot understand why.Quick build players are now paying a penality for taking shortcuts.In two games so far our defense has only given up 1.5 yards total rushing and only 8 missed tackles over the course of two games.


Invalid argument for this discussion. Try again please.
 
DLight03
offline
Link
 
Against similar competition the running game is still your second best offensive option. I wouldn't panic. Wait until you play more teams of similar skill* and level, and it evens out real quick.
 
xeef
offline
Link
 
I think alot of the imbalance might be because of the cruise control feature. I know ours is.
 
Drukman
offline
Link
 
The stats will even out throughout the season once teams start going against real competition.
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
There are huge mismatches. You take the best yards per carry games, then yes-- those are much better than the best one sees in the NFL.

But take the worst, and they're much worse than the worst one sees in the NFL.

It's the games that are close that matter, and those are realistic (finally).
 
Yellow
offline
Link
 
As it stands right now, if you want to win in GLB, you need to have a running-based offense.

The passing game is far too buggy to be effective or reliable right now, so passing teams are suffering. Meanwhile, the already-solid running game got even better now that wrap up tackling isnt as good.

Can you still win games with the passing offense? Yeah. But it's so much of a crapshoot that it's not even worth it to gear your offense that way.
 
ColorChAnGe
offline
Link
 
nah what ive noticed with the new sim is that powerbacks are back too being the dominating force on offense like they were back in season 2 when everyone was low lvls.. players with 70 plus strength and 40 tackling are missing several tackles a game tackling on wrap up against opponents of similar lvls who run straight at them i think this is ridiculous
 
Ken1
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Yellow
As it stands right now, if you want to win in GLB, you need to have a running-based offense.

The passing game is far too buggy to be effective or reliable right now, so passing teams are suffering. Meanwhile, the already-solid running game got even better now that wrap up tackling isnt as good.

Can you still win games with the passing offense? Yeah. But it's so much of a crapshoot that it's not even worth it to gear your offense that way.


There isn't enough difference between yards per pass and yards per rush right now, but part of that is that passing is a bit too weak and a large part of both halves of that is that defenders aren't as strong and as good of tacklers as they'd be if this system had always been in place, and instead are very fast.

People talk about 40 tackling as if it's phenonmenal. Tackling is a LB's central skill. Power runners soft-cap their strength and put their eq there. Even the more realistic LB's don't do that with tackling. Now, if they do that, they'll stop the power runners but, with less speed, have trouble with the fast guys running around end on them.

That's the kind of tradeoff that people need to have to make.
 
RAPB
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Ken1
Originally posted by Yellow

As it stands right now, if you want to win in GLB, you need to have a running-based offense.

The passing game is far too buggy to be effective or reliable right now, so passing teams are suffering. Meanwhile, the already-solid running game got even better now that wrap up tackling isnt as good.

Can you still win games with the passing offense? Yeah. But it's so much of a crapshoot that it's not even worth it to gear your offense that way.


There isn't enough difference between yards per pass and yards per rush right now, but part of that is that passing is a bit too weak and a large part of both halves of that is that defenders aren't as strong and as good of tacklers as they'd be if this system had always been in place, and instead are very fast.

People talk about 40 tackling as if it's phenonmenal. Tackling is a LB's central skill. Power runners soft-cap their strength and put their eq there. Even the more realistic LB's don't do that with tackling. Now, if they do that, they'll stop the power runners but, with less speed, have trouble with the fast guys running around end on them.

That's the kind of tradeoff that people need to have to make.


I agree. Players need to be adjusted to season 4 changes. That incluses more run defense focus and less pass defense focus on defensive side.

The run seems to be "overpowered" right now - but only because defenses focussed on pass defending skills (such as incredible speed - even for LBs) and kept strength and tackling rather low.

It needs to change - otherwise the running game should produce great results. It's your choice if you focus your defense on the pass - but don't whine about offenses running the ball down your throat then.

After all: give it a little time to adjust and work out. And do your best to adjust players and tactics too!
Last edited Aug 6, 2008 05:30:39
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.