User Pass
Home Sign Up Contact Log In
Page:
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Bort can you please look at the Blue Jays game vs Toronto?

I think there is a huge bug that hit our game. Our team is 5 to 6 levels above these guys and we missed them like they were made of butter. Our team has never missed this many tackles in our previous 8 games combined. Our Def has been stellar and very solid game to game but this week they looked like a high school team.

And before all you nay sayers jump in and say AI shit, it aint as we used the same tactics last week and destroyed the number 1 offensive team in the league with it and this team we played this week plays the same style.
 
Bort
Admin
offline
Link
 
Just appears to be a platoon of power backs. They can break some tackles, especially with good carrying and strength.

Something like 70 strength vs a 30-40 tackling should break at least a few per game.
 
DaRealest
offline
Link
 
Being 5 - 6 levels above another team doesn't mean shit if your players aren't built right. Most users created players with a focus on just speed and no balance. Linebackers, for instance, need Strength and Tackling to make tackles. Higher tackling only means less missed tackles, but if he's got high strength to go with that he's in pretty good shape.
 
j10er
offline
Link
 
15 missed tackles spread over 4 RBs is not many.

6 of your missed tackles were from members of your secondary, who should miss some tackles. This looks completely normal when playing a power-run team.

Considering they racked up 400+ yards, I bet fatigue was a factor also.
 
nittany2b
offline
Link
 
Also, whatever you had done in the 8 games before that means nothing. Bort said that wrap-up tackling was not going to be perfect anymore, and it's a very good thing for this game.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by Bort
Just appears to be a platoon of power backs. They can break some tackles, especially with good carrying and strength.

Something like 70 strength vs a 30-40 tackling should break at least a few per game.




Generic answer Bort, wish you would look into it for real and see what is up because there is no in game matter that could produce a turn out like this on a team so over matched despite what a lot of people think around here. If we had been a poor team or even if they were a good team I wouldn't stop to question it but given what information is out there for me to see there is no way in hell a team that low should dominate a team much higher then them with solid builds that have produced against much better and higher level teams in the past.

This isnt also about sour grapes over the loss. I can handle losses when there is a legit reason for them. Upsets are part of the game but there needs top be some rhyme and reason to it. If our QB had come into the game and played the bad under or over throwing everything and tossing a few interceptions fine. If our LG was beaten inside/outside or if our HB had fumblitist then it is something that is can be accepted in the event of a loss. But to have your entire defence, thats the entire defence not just a guy or 2, regardless of how well build they are all miss multiple tackles against a weaker team is not a good way to have them lose as it is not probable to happen. Again, if this team had put up any type of game last season against any good team I wouldnt be here trying to get you to look into this. I honestly beleive something went amoke in this game and should be looked into a bit more.


To answer a few other questions or statements

Energy isn't an issue nor is stamina
Our builds are very solid and have performed well over the last 2 years giving us a record of 27-15
Its not the AI as we left it the same as last game playing a stronger team and missed only 2 tackles
The players we played against are the same ones last year
The players also put broken tackles in our game that nearly doubles their career totals.
I don't want the game replayed and can live with the loss
We have played some really good power back teams and stymied them
Our rush defense has been one of the best in the league the last 2 seasons and has gotten better not worse


All I am asking Bort is for you to actually look into this and see if there was something a mist.






 
Ogallagher13
offline
Link
 
http://goallineblitz.com/game/game.pl?game_id=102059

Granted this was a D-League game but it seemed a bit ridiculous.
 
coach
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Wolf

The players we played against are the same ones last year

All I am asking Bort is for you to actually look into this and see if there was something a mist.


First, lol at "something a mist".

Second, 15 broken tackles really isn't that many. Was it a bug last season when your RBs broke 18 against that team?

Third, maybe their RB who broke the majority of the tackles is simply better than he was the last time you faced him. He's had plenty of time to build up his Power Back specials since then. This wasn't a fluke, it looks like he's breaking tackles against other teams as well.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 15:59:11
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
looks like noone missed more than 2 tackles. Your top tacklers in the game had 8 made to 1 miss, and 7 made to 1 miss.

Do you ever use combo or power tackling for any of your guys? If so, with the changes this season, look out when you face a team of very good power backs.

I've seen games where guys missed 4, 5, 6 tackles and those are questionable, but can generally be explained by using power tackling or possibly combo, along with low tackling numbers.

Your game really doesn't look like there is anything wrong with only 16 missed tackles vs. power backs -- with the way the sim is right now, it fits. Previous seasons, you could get away with under 30 tackling. This season, you need at least 30+ if not 40+ to be a sure tackler, which is how it should be.

Bort has also mentioned that the running game is a bit stronger than he wants, and is tweaking it to find a balance.
 
tautology
offline
Link
 

Taking a look at your results, I'd say they are not extreme at all...you faced some very good powerbacks (they had 23 broken tackles in their previous game, you reduced that number by 30%).

You just need more tackling to handle those guys.

If it's any consolation, the first powerbacks my team faced this year lit us up far worse than that...our MLB had 5 tackles and 5 missed tackles, our SS had 1 tackle and 5 missed tackles.

Your results are not out of line at all, from what I can see. Also, once you miss tackles, your confidence drops and it just gets worse from there...so confidence helps too.

 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Sorry of the last post came off like a whinning sore loser, thats not what I was going for.


Its more the across the board misses that has me thinking something isn't jiving. If it had been one or 2 of our guys its a build problem and I would of told those players to up their tackling but to see that many players miss multiple times when we only missed 2 times total against a better power back and 6 levels higher last game is what has me scratching my head. It wasnt also just one back it was 3 of them running all over us and the backs levels are 22, 21, 15 running over players that are +35 in tackling 60 in strength and are levels 23 to 25. How does a level 25 miss tackle a lvl 15 RB?


Again please don't take this as sour grapes but even with all of what has been posted here none of it makes any sense to how it can happen across the board.

I think the big thing that has me frazzled at this is how the better team of the 2 was contained by our D and the weaker one dominated us. I know the saying about "Any given Sunday" but gee wiz this game was on Monday.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
I guess we will do the old "up the tackle thing", just looking for a reason to why the 2 games were so different with the same game play and variance between the 2 teams we faced already.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
wolf - you aren't giving us enough info to really help.

If any of your guys used combo or power tackling, they upped their chances of missing quite a bit from my experiences in this game. If they had 35+ tackling and used wrap up, the odds of a missed tackle are low, but a few will still happen vs. power backs right now.

Also, as has been mentioned, a very well built lvl 15, if they've put all their points in strength/speed/carrying, for example, could break a tackle vs. a higher level guy who didn't have high enough tackling or was trying to force a fumble.
 
SCACE
offline
Link
 
Originally posted by The Wolf
I guess we will do the old "up the tackle thing", just looking for a reason to why the 2 games were so different with the same game play and variance between the 2 teams we faced already.


The easy answer here is they have completely different players and use different builds/gameplans.
 
The Wolf
offline
Link
 
Most if not all of our guys are always on wrap up or balanced. We do not play on force the fumble.

All of our starters are over 35 tackling, and pushing 40, and they still had missed tackles against a far weaker opponent.

And I disagree with a level 15 properly built RB beating a properly built lvl 26 DT. I do agree a great lvl 15 build could break a tackle against a poor built 23 but the case here as we do have solid builds.

I know its hard for others to digest what I am trying to say but several players in our league from different teams have watched our game and feel that something was definitely wrong with how the game was simmed. One guy even mentioned that maybe the game some how reversed the 2 teams abilities or game plans as it has happened in the past.
Last edited Aug 4, 2008 16:50:59
 
Page:
 


You are not logged in. Please log in if you want to post a reply.